The Internet is made of people

Always remember that, folks: The Internet is made of people. I got that from Warren Ellis, and it’s totally and utterly true. There are good people on the Internet, and bad people; people you’d follow once more unto the breach, and people you’d toss into the breach head-first and then walk away. There are winners and losers, friends and enemies, casual acquaintances and even lovers.

This is about an online friend of mine who went by the moniker “Gumdrops”.

Gumdrops, or “Gummy” for short, was a film music fan. And by “fan”, I mean, “rabid hobbyist”. I’m a gatherer of film music, but Gummy was a collector. He amassed a pretty impressive collection, many of the discs of which were quite rare. His collection includes, to give just one example, a copy of David Shire’s score to Return to Oz. Just try finding a copy of this. You’ll pay through the nose.

Longtime readers will know that before this blog, my main outlet for online blatherings was the Usenet group rec.music.movies. I gradually became disenchanted over there, and when that disenchantment lined up with my discovery of the blogging medium, the writing was on the wall (or the Web), and I departed r.m.m. pretty quickly after launching this blog. For a time, I also posted at the FilmScoreMonthly message boards, and it was there that I met Gummy.

He was a jovial soul, who usually signed off his posts with “Yuk yuk!”. He had a way of disarming many heated discussions with a quip or two, and it might have been tempting at first to not take Gummy very seriously as a film music fan, but one quickly learned otherwise: this guy knew his stuff. He was conversant on many composers and their works, and he knew far more about film than I do. But through it all, he never took it all that seriously — or, more properly, he never took it so seriously that he lost sight of the passion of his film music, and he never forgot what music is for. He looked for music that moved him, that made him feel something. He was the guy who’s constantly coming up to you, discman and earphones held out, grinning wildly and practically tripping over his own feet as he tells you, “Wow, you gotta hear this!!!”

That was Gummy.

When the FSM boards finally became too generically unpleasant for me and some others to stick around there — it happens, you know — we went back to rec.music.movies, which had become pretty much of a wasteland. Posts were rare, and posts that were about film music and not about where we might procure cheap CIAL!$ were rarer still. But we started posting, a tiny little community, and gradually things picked up. Not to the point of r.m.m.’s hey-day back around 1999 or 2000, but we got some nice discussion going. Often the discussions were sparked by Gummy’s thread-launching posts, when he’d throw out single questions or provocative statements.

Gummy also loved to share his music, and he cheerfully made copies of just about any score in his collection that anyone asked for. I was the recipient of more than a few of his mailings. Scores that I now own, thanks to him, include the afore-mentioned Return to Oz, Howard Shore’s Soul of Ultimate Nation and The Last Mimzy, John Williams’s Jane Eyre, and a large number of Japanese filmscores as well. His generosity was stunning, and it often bothered me that my own film music collection is not nearly as extensive as his, not because I was jealous of what he had, but because I couldn’t really return the favor. Some time ago he told me about some items he was looking for, and by sheer miracle, it turned out that I own them. Last week I finally got around to burning copies.

You can probably tell by my use of past tense in this post that he’s never going to hear them.

Gregory — “Gumdrops” — became suddenly ill last week, and by the time he became ill enough to require hospitalization, his fate was set. He finally died today. I never met him in person; to me, he was “only” a set of words on a screen, and an occasionaly envelope in my mailbox. But remember: The Internet is made of people, and Gumdrops was one of them.

Other friends from r.m.m. have been in contact with his wife, and we’ve learned Gregory’s passion for film music was a lonely passion until he first went on the Internet and discovered that there are other such-passionate people around, all over the world. And amidst all the cantankerous discussions that take place in Internet forums on any topic, Gregory was a person motivated solely by the fact that the music, and the act of sharing it, just plain made him happy. His vocation, it turns out, was furnace installation. He loved the Pittsburgh Steelers (he lived in that area), and he lustily cheered their Super Bowl win from two seasons ago. But he didn’t trash-talk a few weeks back when his Steelers tossed my Bills around like rag-dolls. That’s the kind of person he was. He took joy in things, and appeared to have no patience at all for the joyless side of the very same things.

So yeah, I’ll miss him. He was a friend. Tonight I’ll listen to some of the music he shared with me.

Goodbye, Greg. Yuk yuk.

Share This Post

The Road goes on and on

Huzzah!

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The Complete Recordings will be released on November 6 of this year. It will include four CDs (the releases for the previous two films had three each) and a DVD containing the entire score in really good sound (I take their word for this).

At some point in the future, film music expert Doug Adams will have a book out on the subject of these films and their music. I can’t wait for that, either.

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: Howard Shore’s accomplishment on the LOTR films represents one of the towering masterworks of all film music.

Share This Post

Luciano

Alex Ross today:

The finest singers not only hit the notes but erase the difference between notes and words. Singing is most thrilling when it becomes a kind of heightened talking. That’s what happens in Pavarotti’s “Che gelida manina” or “E lucevan le stelle” or “Una furtiva lagrima”: the beauty of the sound envelops you, but you’re not conscious of the artifice of art. It’s as if someone were making conversation in a dialect of dreams.

Bravo, Luciano.

Share This Post

Good thing the Devil didn’t go to Carnegie Hall….

For some reason, the local country station — which I hear occasionally at work — plays “The Devil Went Down to Georgia” daily, which drives me nuts because I consider it to be one of the worst songs in the history of musical expression. And not just human musical expression. Human song, whale song, Vulcan song, Gungan song…”Devil Went Down to Georgia” is worse than all of it.

First of all, the whole idea’s just goofy; second, there’s the sad fact that the fiddle playing in that song is, well, crap. I always break out laughing when I hear what’s supposed to be this astonishing playing by the Devil, which turns out to be this scratchy shit that would get jeered off the stage at just about any place where anyone knows anything about good fiddling or violin playing. Seriously, the Devil is so bad that it’s no surprise that “Johnny” beats him; frankly, the Devil couldn’t even rosin the bow of a Natalie MacMaster or an Alison Krauss or an Eileen Ivers, and Itzhak Perlman could blow the Devil right off the stage just by playing a C-major scale.

Anyway. “Devil Went Down to Georgia” is the worst song ever.

Share This Post

Toonz

Apparently I was tagged the other day by Paul on a quiz-meme thing where I’m supposed to write about between 5 and 10 “songs” (which I loosely interpret as, well, any musical work at all) that have had a large impact on me. Hmmmmm…well, I’ll try to stay away from my “usual suspects”, i.e., works or songs that I’ve waxed poetic about in this space before. With maybe one or two exceptions.

:: “Building the Barn”, by Maurice Jarre, from Witness. OK, Witness is one of my all-time favorite movies. I think it’s damned near flawless. The only faults I personally find with it are that (a) the subplot with Hochleitner’s (Alexander Godunov) jealousy of John Book’s relationship with Rachel is just slightly overplayed, and (b) the score by Maurice Jarre is, with one giant exception, disappointing brooding synthesizer crap.

The one exception, though, is absolutely remarkable: the cue that underscores the wonderful barn-raising set piece. I almost wonder if Jarre intentionally made the rest of his score as nondescript as it is, so this one cue would stand out, but stand out it does. At the outset it sounds almost like a retread of Pachelbel’s Canon in D, but then it goes into its own thing.

On a more personal note, whenever I listen to this track now (a stunning version for full orchestra, as opposed to synth, can be heard on this album), I think back to this day, and the time I spent doing something rather like a barnraising, and at the side of my best friend.

:: “Wonderful World”, by Sam Cooke. Featured in the other great scene from Witness (although in a version not sung by Cooke). I love Sam Cooke, and this is my favorite of his songs.

:: Symphony No. 2 in E minor, by Sergei Rachmaninov. OK, here’s one that I’ve waxed poetic about before, but I can’t help it. I often hear Ravel’s Bolero described as “erotic” or “sensual”, but damned if I can’t ever hear those qualities. But you know what? I was listening to the Rachmaninov Second a week or two back, and, well, I can’t help but use adjectives like that to describe it, the way it constantly ebbs and flows, the epic nature of its emotion. I don’t usually describe music in such stark terms, but in the Rachmaninov Second I hear the distillation of love itself. I don’t know how to say it any other way.

:: Irish Tune from County Derry, by Percy Grainger. This was the first piece we played in band, on the first day of my freshman year of college. I think my love of Celtic music was born here. I love this lush and gorgeous setting, with its ingeniously concealed dissonances.

:: “The Portrait”, by James Horner, from Titanic. Bite me, Titanic haters. I love this movie, and that’s a fact. The music, however, is another story — there’s some awfully good stuff here from Horner, as well as some tremendously lazy stuff, and the “action” writing during the sinking is mostly rhythmic thrashing. While I don’t hate “My Heart Will Go On”, I will certainly admit that it’s been played to death to the point where it’s pretty much a complete cliche of a song. However, the solo piano rendition of that theme, heard during the scene where Jack sketches the nude Rose, is soft, tasteful, and delicately beautiful.

:: “The Grand Finale”, by Danny Elfman, from Edward Scissorhands. I’m not the biggest Elfman fan in the world, but he’s had his moments, and this track contains about nine of them.

:: “Inside Your Heaven”, by Carrie Underwood. The tune’s nothing groundbreaking, and the lyrics are pretty much your standard insipid pop-ballad poetics. And yet, I love this song so. Shoot me. Right now.

:: “I Dreamed a Dream”, from Les Miserables. How I want to see this show, someday, seeing as how I know every note in its score from listening to the complete recordings for so long. “No song unsung, no wine untasted….”

:: “One for my Baby (and One More for the Road)”. Classic song. I love the version by Frank Sinatra off his Only the Lonely album. Can’t listen to that album too much, though. It’s never an easy listen, and these days, it would probably drive me to either suicide or body-piercing. Maybe even a tattoo or something.

OK, that’s all. I guess I’m supposed to tag people now, but I think all the people I’d normally tag have already done this one, so feel free to grab-and-go, folks.

Share This Post

Until its rhythm you have found

I’m not feeling too much like blogging at the moment, so I’m going to take a few days off. Could be the heat; it’s pretty hot in Buffalo right now. Could be something else.

For now, I’ll leave you with a song that’s been haunting me for several weeks now. It’s “Scythe Song”, by Scots great Dougie Maclean. It can be heard here here, the song starts up at about the 1:40 mark. (Don’t worry about the sound at the outset; it clears up before the music starts and for YouTube sound, it’s fine. And don’t worry about watching the video. It’s just an unchanging title card.)

The song is a meditation on the kind of learning that takes place when you undertake a craft that may look simple, but whose mastery eludes everyone but those who work at it alongside a giving teacher. The idea, I think, is that learning is as much a function of someone teaching us as finding the secrets on our own.

The lyrics:

O I still remember when
I first watched him work the blade.
‘Twas down in the Buckney den
my questions tumbled and he said:
“O this is not a thing to learn inside a day!
Stand closely by me and I’ll try to show the way.

You’ve got to hold it right,
feel the distance to the ground.
Move with a touch so light,
until its rhythm you have found.
Then you’ll know what I know.

O wild are the ways we run
when at last untethered out we fly!
Straight into the burning sun;
need no direction, no, not I!
But it is not a thing to learn inside a day….
Stand closely by me and I’ll try to show the way.

You’ve got to hold it right,
feel the distance to the ground.
Move with a touch so light,
until its rhythm you have found.
Then you’ll know what I know.

And so, little dancing girl,
you want to learn to play a tune?
One that your heart can fill
to help you shine under the moon?
Well it is not a thing to learn inside a day!
Stand closely by me and I’ll try to show the way.

You’ve got to hold it right,
feel the distance to the sound….
Move with a touch so light,
until its rhythm you have found.
Then you’ll know what I know.

Then you’ll know…what I know.

I’ll be back soon…but right now, I need to move with a touch so light.

Share This Post

Hector Rules!

Earlier this week Lynn e-mailed me a notice about a comment left on this post over at Serenade in Green, about who the Greatest Composer of All Time might be. The comment (by this blogger) is lengthy and refers to several composers, but the part about Berlioz is quite the shot across my particular bow:

To back up my orchestral music is easy to impress with, consider the example of Hector Berlioz, a name that would never be praised if it wasn’t for his orchestral innovations. Berlioz’s music was almost completely vacuous, and had only smatterings of moments of quality. In fact, Berlioz is one of the only well known composers I’d list below Mozart, and we’ve had the Mozart conversation before [flashes the secret handshake].

I’m actually more irritated by the idea that Mozart is so low in esteem as to only allow one or two composers to be placed beneath him, but this is just another of those “To each his own” sorts of things.

But as for Berlioz, this opinion is hardly uncommon, I must admit. I’m a long-confirmed Berlioz obsessive (look for my series of posts, linked in the sidebar, in honor of his bicentenary), but I’ve also seen first-hand how many people who love classical music just don’t get Berlioz, for whatever reason. I have a friend with whom I occasionally share music; I send him stuff and he sends me stuff in return (actually, he sends me a lot more stuff than I send him because he’s twenty years older than me and it’s thus a major challenge finding stuff that he hasn’t heard already). Some years ago I sent him some Berlioz — Romeo et Juliet, if I recall correctly — and his response was a very polite “Meh”. And this I’ve heard from many others. But I’ve also heard from people who, like me, utterly adore Berlioz. (To this day it irritates me that at the Impressions de France film at Epcot Center’s World Showcase, the film — a series of stunning images of France set to French classical music — includes not a single note of Berlioz.)

It’s generally been my experience that Berlioz gets two responses: “Meh”, and “Oh my God, I’ve just had an orgasm.” (Rachmaninov is in a similar boat, although he gets more of a range of reactions.) This is not new, either. Here is Harold Schonberg, writing in his grand old book The Lives of the Great Composers:

Perhaps Berlioz will always remain the object of veneration by a strong and articulate minority. He could not speak to Everyman. But there is not one piece of his that lacks its incandescent moments. And then Berlioz is seen plain, his eagle beak defiantly thrust at the heavens, glorifying in a kind of tonal magnificence and an ideal of self-expression that make the concept of Romanticism very clear.

And, more recently, David Dubal expresses the same sentiment in his Essential Canon of Classical Music:

Still, it took most of the twentieth century to place Berlioz’s art in perspective. He has always irked many people. He refuses to fit into a convenient niche. His works as a whole are not graceful; they do not have the kind of melodies that stick in the mind. His harmonies can sound primitive, and his content empty. But for those who are temperamentally attuned to him, he is shattering. He has a subtlety of construction that goes beyond technique, and his orchestrations have proved to be models for generations to come.

Whenever I hear any of Berlioz’s music, I think of the poet Heine’s statement: “He is an immense nightingale, a lark as great as an eagle…the music causes me to dream of fabulous empires filled with fabulous sins.”

And there you have it.

(Oh, and the Greatest Composer of All Time? The best historical case can probably be made for Johann Sebastian Bach, but even then, I still believe that the sentence “Bach was the greatest composer” can never be a true statement in the same sense that “Jupiter is the largest planet in our Solar System” can.)

Share This Post

Slava

Tim Page on Mstislav Rostropovich, who died the other day:

Mstislav Rostropovich died this morning in the city he had always considered his home — in Moscow, where he had been flown from Paris by private jet in February after it became apparent that he could not long survive.

“Music and art are a whole spiritual world in Russia,” he once said. “In Russia, when people go to a concert, they don’t go to it as an attraction, as an entertainment, but to feel life.”

I don’t currently own any of Rostropovich’s recordings, but I owned several of him conducting various works back when my music collection was in its LP-and-cassette days. I also performed Leonard Bernstein’s concert overture Slava! one year at music camp, a typically joyous and jazzy Bernstein piece along the lines of his far-more-famous overture to Candide.

For now, here’s something eternal: Rostropovich performing the Prelude to Bach’s Suite No. 1 for Unaccompanied Cello.

Bon voyage, Slava.

Share This Post