Music, in words

It’s always terribly hard to capture, in words, the essence of a musical work. To paraphrase Leonard Bernstein, “If the composer could say in words what he wanted to say, why would he use music at all?” Stirling Newberry, though, gives it a go with this essay about Beethoven’s Symphony #7.

The Seventh is often cited as Beethoven’s greatest work, and there’s a hell of a lot of reason why. For me, my tastes tend to embrace the Ninth more — not surprisingly, given my predilection for works of massive apocalyptic glory — but the Seventh is, and always will be, utterly amazing. What always strikes me about the Seventh is its inevitability, the way every single note seems to naturally spring from the one immediately before it.

Share This Post

Kerry/Clinton?!

Matthew Yglesias points out an article suggesting that John Kerry make a Clinton his running mate — and not the junior Senator from New York, either, but that other famous Clinton. The one who’s been unemployed since noon on January 20, 2001.

Now, you’re thinking that the Constitution probably forbids such a thing, and you’re probably right, as Matthew describes; one Amendment says that “No person shall be elected President twice”, but then, another says that “No person ineligible to be President shall be Vice President”, although this might actually refer to the age and “natural born citizen” stuff, as opposed to the stuff about eligibility for mere election.

But really, the idea’s just dumb, anyway. If a Kerry/Clinton ticket were even legal (and Matthew is right that surely it wouldn’t be a good idea to have a ticket whose very legality would be a major issue), what of it? If Kerry/Clinton were elected, and Kerry died and thus re-elevated Bill Clinton to the Presidency, he’d be an instant lame duck. This would do the Democratic Party no good at all, since they’d have an incumbent ineligible to run again and thus would have to immediately start searching for yet another nominee; and it seems to me that the repercussions of such a transition from VP to President would be worse the closer one gets to the next election. If President Kerry were to die in, say, March of 2008, and VP Clinton ascended the Presidency but couldn’t run again, the country would be in the position of having no fewer than three different Presidents in a period of less than one year. (Kerry, then Clinton, then the 2008 winner upon the 2009 Inauguration.)

So, even if the Supreme Court were to decide that Clinton could be Vice President, I don’t think it would be a good idea. Now, I do think that a case can be made for allowing former Presidents who have had two terms to run again after a certain period of time — say, two or three full terms — given that lifespans are getting longer all the time. But even if such an Amendment to the Constitution ever comes to pass, I’m certain the language would “grandfather” Bill Clinton out of eligibility.

Bill Clinton, like him or hate him, is a compelling figure, and an important voice in America today. But he won’t be President again.

Share This Post

Overzealous Ushers

This morning, I attended a performance of a stage version of Charlotte’s Web with the kid, as an outing organized by her preschool group. The performance was at Shea’s Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Buffalo, which is in turn the city’s main locale for big productions and such. Since there were a lot of different school groups attending this play, the theater seating was sectioned off by school group, so the ushers could — theoretically — direct incomers to their appropriate seating area. Fair enough.

Except, they also wanted to pack in as many seats as possible, so since we were actually the first people from the kid’s group to enter the theater, our usher — a cranky little old lady with a button the size of a dinner plate reading “I’M A VOLUNTEER!” — tried getting us to take a couple of empty seats in the middle of the school group in front of ours! This woman actually expected a four-year-old kid to understand her anal reasoning for not allowing her to sit with her friends, who started filing in moments later.

Luckily for her (the kid), I dug deep into my soul and found that part of me that refuses to respect authority. (Actually, it didn’t require digging all that deep.) As I directed the kid to the seat beside one of her best friends, I could hear THE VOLUNTEER! behind me, grousing something along the lines of, “Well, that’s not the way we do it.”

The performance itself was pretty faithful, although I’m not entirely sure my daughter realized the sadness of Charlotte’s Web‘s ending. She seemed to have a good time, though.

(BTW, a note to theater groups: Please make sure your sound equipment is properly tested before you give your performance, OK? Especially if one of your speakers is prone to emitting sudden and deafening bursts of static with no warning. This is generally not welcomed by a theater full of kids ranging from preschool to second grade.)

Share This Post

Dummmm, dee dee da da doo da dum dee-da dum….MAKE IT STOP!

The other day, in speculating that the fair lass who married Aaron is, in fact, a vampire, I also reported that I absolutely loathe Maurice Ravel’s Bolero. In comments, Sean expressed surprise, so I should probably attempt to explain why I hate this piece.

Very simply, it boils down to a single reason: Bolero is nothing more than a single melody, repeated in its entirety something like twenty times, each time played by a different instrument or group of instruments and each time getting louder until, at the end, what started as a single pianissimo snare drum and a flute has become the entire orchestra blasting that melody until the paint peels from the concert hall’s walls. And admittedly, the orchestration is pretty damned amazing — Ravel gets some pretty startling sounds out of the standard orchestra, and you should probably hear the thing just once for that reason alone. I got to play it once, and I enjoyed the trumpet parts, when I got to play; but the rest of it was counting measures to the next entrance. And poor Aaron’s wife had to play the damned snare drum part, probably the most thankless task in all classical music after being the poor slob who has to play the bass line in Pachelbel’s Canon in D.

Cool orchestration, yeah. But it’s that damned melody, see — all Ravel does with it is repeat it. Literally, he does nothing but repeat it. It never develops, it never opens up into other melodic or rhythmic possibilities, it never goes anywhere except louder and somewhere else in the orchestra. And really, it’s not even that interesting of a melody in the first place, sounding to me like someone attempting to improvise a melody who isn’t confident enough to move beyond the confinesof the scale. (Hum it, if you don’t believe me — the entire melody is almost completely stepwise.)

True, Dimitri Shostakovich uses a very similar device in his Symphony No. 7 (the “Leningrad”), but I like Shosty’s melody more, he doesn’t call the crescendo-by-repetition device an entire piece, and it makes sense in that work’s programmatic context as representing the long, slow march toward Leningrad of the Nazi siege army.

I have the obligatory recording of Bolero on my shelf, since it was coupled with a recording of Ravel’s infinitely more-interesting Daphnis et Chloe Suite #2 and La Valse. Once every two years or so, I’ll put Bolero in the stereo, thinking that maybe I’ll have finally opened up to it, or, failing that, at least it’ll be over in fifteen minutes. And never once have I made it past the eight minute mark before hitting “Stop”. Lots of people, it seems, listen to Bolero and hear hypnotic sensualism; I listen to it and hear naught but boring repetition. Ears of the beholder, I guess.

Share This Post

What a stupid question.

I may have been reading the wrong political blogs the last day or two, because I only learn today — via Kevin Drum, who is apparently behind the curve himself — that some journalist posed this question to John Kerry at the most recent Democratic debate: “Is God on America’s side?” James Lileks thinks this is just incredibly clever, although it doesn’t seem all that brilliant to me, since there are several obvious replies.

Kerry’s was “Most of the time”, to which Lileks thinks he gets the great trump card, “So, when wasn’t he?” Oh, I dunno — slavery? The resistance to the civil rights struggle? Vietnam? (No, James, to say that God would not have approved of Vietnam does not imply that God therefore supported Communism — but that’s the common rhetoric these days, when “Against this” must necessarily be equivalent to “For that”. But James Lileks, whenever I read him, seems utterly incapable of nuanced thinking whenever he goes into political mode. His every politics-centered Bleat is based on the idea that every issue admits only two possible positions, one right, and one Liberal or Democratic.) You just list a couple such instances, and then you say something like “But God is on our side when we learn from our mistakes, because that’s what he created us to do,” and there you go, question over. Lileks’s idea that this question pins Kerry into discomfort is ludicrous.

But an even better response would be something along the lines of, “I can’t presume to speak for God, but it seems to me we should wonder if America is on God’s side.” Short, direct, and it deflects the questioner’s attempt at moral superiority.

Share This Post

Up From Monkeys!

Lynn Sislo points out (just before linking me; Thanks, Lynn!) a blog called Dispatches from the Culture Wars, which has all the earmarks of a pretty damned good blog. Good stuff on evolution taking place right now.

To return for just a moment to my off-hand comment about homeschooling that engendered a pretty extensive (for these parts) comment thread, I guess my real big problem with homeschooling, in principle, is that I think that we need to have a national debate one of these days on just what we think our kids should be learning. I don’t like the idea of children learning only those things that their parents wish them to learn, and I especially don’t like that idea in a time when science is generally held in very low esteem.

Share This Post

Nope, that’s where we keep the ice cream.

Today I was doing a routine maintenance check of the freezer section of The Store (basically, wandering about with a broom in case someone had dropped a cracker or something). It was apparently a pretty busy “restocking” day for the freezer folks; there were several of the large cargo-carts about laden with product which they had transported from the giant walk-in freezers to the cases. But at this particular moment, the two fellows working the freezer department were not present. They had probably gone off to take their recyclables out, or to the bathroom, or even outside for a cigarette — I don’t know. But even though it seemed patently obvious that there was a restocking-in-progress, some woman still stopped me to ask if we really thought that a cart in the middle of the floor was a suitable place to store ice cream.

My initial impulse — to lean in close and whisper, “You know, that stuff about freezing ice cream is just an urban legend” — was pushed down deep, I’m sorry to say. Oh well.

Share This Post

SCRUBS, anyone?

Do any of my readers watch Scrubs? I’ve loved this show since I watched the very first episode — it’s always incredibly well-written and perfectly acted. So much of the humor on this show is dependent on precision timing that you’d need a watch made in Switzerland to measure, and yet, the show is hilarious each and every time out.

But right now, I’m wondering if anyone else was completely blindsided by the ending of last week’s episode. The way Scrubs manages to cross back and forth between poignance and farce never stops amazing me, but last week’s episode was a tour de force, with a twist ending that I literally had no idea was coming and which made the episode resonate emotionally with me in a way that few shows do anymore.

And I guess in this case it’s a good thing that Scrubs isn’t one of NBC’s ratings juggernauts; otherwise, the entire preceding week on NBC would have been awash in promos exhorting us not to miss the last five minutes, since the clods in TV these days are evidently unaware that most of the pleasure of a good surprise ending comes from not knowing the surprise ending is coming in the first place.

Share This Post

Untitled Post

Congratulations to this guy:

The Return of the King Oscar love-fest encourages me, not just because the films are so damned good but because I hope this marks a continuing emergence of fantasy storytelling into the mainstream. I’m sick, sick, sick to death of the idea that only things that are “relevant”, that take place in the “real world”, are to be considered worthy — a trend which is not just annoying but also starkly at odds with the rest of culture, where the fantastic holds sway to an impressive degree. Look at how much Shakespeare depends on fantasy; look at Homer. Imagine what the opera world would be like if you struck down all the operas with fantastic elements.

Congratulations, also, to Howard Shore for winning the Best Original Score and Best Original Song awards. The more I listen to these three scores, the more convinced I become that they are the greatest scores since John Williams’s work on the original Star Wars trilogy. I was nonplused when Shore was originally announced as the composer, way back in 1999 or whenever — like most film music fans, my only exposure to Shore was on films like The Silence of the Lambs and Seven — but man, did he deliver in a huge way.

A couple other observations about the Oscar telecast (of which I didn’t watch much):

:: Say what you will about Michael Moore, I loved that he had enough sense of humor about himself to allow a bit of self-parody. (For those who missed it, they showed a clip of the Battle of the Pellenor Fields from Return of the King, and suddenly, there’s Moore in the middle of it, shouting, “You don’t have to fight, Hobbits! This is a fictitious war fought for a fictitious King!” And then he gets trampled by one of the Mumakil.)

:: I used to watch the entire telecast every year, but I haven’t done this in six or seven years. Nevertheless, I seem to have a weird ability to tune back in at the exact moment they’re about to do the “Tribute to Departed Stars” segment. I’d forgotten all about how many wonderful people died this past year, and I’m glad the Academy thought to include composer Michael Kamen in its tribute.

:: I really think that Billy Crystal is a fine host for this show — I enjoy his schtick a lot more than I enjoy Whoopi Goldberg’s, for example. (Of course, I’m one who thinks that Letterman’s performance wasn’t nearly as bad as its legend has become.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓