Ninety percent of success

Time for a rant, folks.

Last night on the local TV news I saw a story that was packaged as a “feel good” story, but all it did was piss me off. And then I read about it again in today’s paper.

The tale? Some high school senior in Niagara Falls did something really remarkable. She was able to accomplish a feat that’s just so damned amazing that she was awarded by her school district a car. And no, not a used car, and not some old beater with 150000 miles on it that would cost her a lot of money in gas and insurance and repairs but would somehow teach her something about self-reliance or whatnot. No, she got a brand new car. She got a 2005 Ford Focus for accomplishing this stunning feat. And what amazing feat did she accomplish?

Did she win some kind of state sports championship? Did she post a perfect 4.0 for her entire high school career, plus extra credit for AP and college courses? Nope. Maybe she made some kind of surprisingly useful serendipitous discovery in her high school chemistry lab…but no. So what did she do to warrant a car?

She posted perfect attendance this year.

That’s it. And just this year. She didn’t post perfect attendance for all of high school; in fact, she admits that she missed a lot of school in recent years. Nope, she managed to post perfect attendance in her senior year. That’s it. What’s more, she openly admits that she only posted perfect attendance because she knew she might win a car, and she says that now that she’s got the keys, she might maintain her perfect record until the end of the year.

I have no problem with the fact that this student saw an incentive and decided to go for it. I have no problem with her conduct at all. But I’m really astonished that an incentive like this had to be offered in the first place. Talk about lowering the bar, shortening the goal posts, whatever you want to call it. We’ve now reached a point where merely showing up for school when you’re supposed to is done not because it’s what you’re supposed to do, but because there might be Cash! and Prizes! For one of you, an iPod! For another, a laptop! For a couple more, some scholarships! And for a lucky one of you, a grand prize winner, a brand new car!

And just think: you don’t even have to go on Bob Barker’s show and demonstrate your knowledge of whether the Bayer aspirin costs more than the Parkay margarine to do it, either.

I know a lot of people who show up for work every day. And not school, but actual work. People with families, with kids. People who don’t get week-long breaks at Christmas and Easter and in the middle of spring, and people who don’t get off for the entirety of July and August. And those folks don’t get handed free iPods, laptops, or cars just for showing up.

If school administrators want to encourage attendance, maybe they should connect attendance to grades or graduation, and not give the diplomas to kids who miss a lot unless they make up the time somehow. But handing out cars and other prizes? For just physically showing up every day? That’s just crazy.

And you just know that there’s some kid in that same graduating class who maybe only missed time on a single instance due to a death in the family. Or how about a kid who missed a day because that’s the day his Reservist father shipped out for Iraq? I’m not gonna tell that kid that he’s out of the running for the new car.

OK, I’m done. This wasn’t my most coherent post, but as a rule I’m generally wary of coupling behavior that we should be encouraging as a matter of course to incentives that are wildly out of proportion to the accomplishment.

Getting a car for perfect attendance for a single year of grade school. Insane.

(Again, I’m not blaming the student for “playing the game”, so to speak. I think that the game sucks.)

Share This Post

Yup. Them are some pretty good albums, all right.

Via Mr. Jones, I see that a British publication has held a poll-thing to determine the “100 Greatest Albums of All Time”. Of course, we’re only talking rock albums here; don’t look for, say, Georg Solti’s VPO rendition of Der Ring des Nibelungen, or any of the seminal Celtic music albums by the Battlefield Band, or any of the great Charles Gerhardt film music albums, and so on.

Rock music tends to form the smallest portion of my own musical listening, so it’s no surprise that I own less than ten of the one hundred albums so designated (read the entire list here). Of the Top Ten, I only own one (Dark Side of the Moon, and frankly, I like The Wall more anyway). Many of the artists listed are represented in my CD collection by various “Greatest Hits” compilations. I’m glad to see Brothers in Arms by Dire Straits on the list (#46), as I think it’s the best thing I heard in the entire 1980s. I’m surprised that there’s nothing by Van Halen; but then, it is a mainly British list (by that I mean, mainly decided by British rock fans). And I’m stunned that the only country album is by Shania Twain. I’m sorry, folks — Shania Twain’s got a nice voice and she’s, you know, hot and stuff, but her best album is less worthy than Willie Nelson’s worst.

And I may as well admit that I think Alanis Morisette sucks. I find her voice screechy and unpleasant, and her lyrics trite and uninteresting. There, I said it.

Oh well. Maybe I’ll look into this “Oasis” band one of these days. They seem to be somewhat highly regarded. (Seriously. If you held a gun to my head, I still wouldn’t be able to name a single Oasis song. I don’t know shit about them.)

Share This Post

Sentential Links #51

Click ’em while they’re hot, folks:

:: What I really want to say is director Brett Ratner is a club, and the X-Men are a baby seal. (I love it when Mr. Jones dislikes a movie. And one of his sub-points about X3 — his view that it’s overstuffed with characters — is something that’s really got me concerned about the next Spiderman flick, which from what I’ve read will include just about every character who ever appeared in an issue of Spiderman, possibly minus Jean DeWolff.)

:: There was a time when you couldn’t throw a brick in Concord without hitting someone carrying a fresh letter of acceptance from the Atlantic Monthly in their pocket. (I had a hard time picking between two particularly good posts of Mr. Mannion’s this week.)

:: Then there’s the sound of a father shaking out a blanket to spread over the boy and then the noises of a computer ordered to boot itself to the ready and now just the sound of typing. (The hell with it. It’s my blog, so here’s the other of Mr. Mannion’s posts.)

:: To those who object to the use of da Vinci since it’s a prepositional phrase, I have an example for you to consider that might convince you to soften your position. Ready? (I do love a good “Why didn’t I think of that!” moment.)

:: The problem is, these yahoos have managed an ugly trick. They have turned criticism of the policies of Bastards in Suits into criticism of The People in Uniform Getting Shot At. This, of course, is completely wrong, as one can easily tell the difference between the Bastards in Suits and The People in Uniform Getting Shot At. One group is in Suits, and Not Getting Shot At, while another is in Uniform, and Getting Shot At. Please, try to grasp this. Not the same. (via TBogg)

:: And excuse me if this puts you off, Mr. Web 2.0 writer, but could we maybe retire the phrase “former Star Trek actor?” (Geez, that former Stand By Me actor is pretty touchy, isn’t he?)

:: Worse, Ringo has a taste for sex games and fantasies of a sort I really dislike, and after showing a certain amount of restraint in the previous book he lets himself go again here. (Happens every time I get tempted to try a John Ringo book, someone brings this up….)

:: The rain has begun. Out to the deck and the hot tub, to be immersed from all directions. (Ahhh, hot-tubbin’ in the rain. But you know what’s better? Hot-tubbin’ in the snow.)

That’s it for now. Join us next week and stuff.

Share This Post

How to Temporarily Cure Bad Kitties

If your domicile is home to a couple of nice and loving but occasionally very naughty kitties, just find a way to jack the heat and humidity inside way up. It sucks the naughty right out of ’em!

(Upper 80s and humid in Buffalo before June. This weather sucks, folks.)

Share This Post

Tinkering underneath the hood

OK, folks, I’ve just ripped out the code that was powering the old YACCS commenting system. I’d left the old threads available for a while on the off chance anyone wanted to add anything, but it’s been long enough. They’re gone.

And since occasional YACCS outages tended to drag down the loading time of this blog, hopefully regular readers will experience more reliable response in the future.

Share This Post

Sunday Burst of Weirdness Explosive Destruction

Last week saw the demolition of a nuclear power plant’s cooling tower in Oregon. You can watch it here. I found this interesting not just on the “blowing stuff up” account, but because I remember driving by this particular nuke plant when I was a kid and we lived for a time in Portland.

(I frankly don’t get the whole anti-nuclear power vibe, by the way. Surely we can do it safer by now, right? And as scary as Three Mile Island was, we’ve never come close to having a Chernobyl, which wasn’t exactly the best design for a nuke plant in the first place. But then, maybe I’m full of crap and nuke power is still inherently dangerous and I’ve just been lulled by the fact that Homer Simpson’s been working at a nuke plant for years without any ill effects. Well, except for that one time…and that other time…and the time that Homer….)

Share This Post

Operas we’d like to hear

Here’s an illustration of one of the problems with classical music these days. The LA Opera is set to premiere a major new work by composer Elliot Goldenthal, Grendel, which is based on the Beowulf legend but is told from the point-of-view of the monster. Goldenthal is one of the finer voices to emerge from Hollywood film scoring over the last fifteen years. His is a very distinct voice, and he has a gift for orchestration that goes well beyond the traditional. Goldenthal loves to use unusual instruments in unusual combinations, and for a noted film composer to get an assignment such as this, where he’s basically set free of the formal limitations of film scoring, is an exciting prospect.

Too bad it’s likely to be years before I can hear this work, because due to union re-use fees it will simply be too expensive to record Grendel in the United States. So unless I can find a way to travel to a city where Grendel is staged in the future, I’m unlikely to get to hear this work until a recording surfaces. It would probably have to be recorded in Europe, which I suppose might be more likely since Grendel is a major new work being premiered by the opera company of one of America’s largest cities, but how much other new music is never heard much because not only is it already not performed much by orchestras who are in thrall to “the standard repertoire”, but also because union costs preclude recording?

The union cost issue is one I’ve run into a lot in the film music fandom community. Because the union rules require that musicians get paid for their work whenever recordings are issued, it’s often the case that the revenues expected from releasing a film music recording are less than the union costs. This results in lots of film music never getting released. I hadn’t realized that the union costs can harm the cause of the promulgation of new classical music as well.

(On a somewhat related note, I was surprised to read via Alex Ross that John Adams’s famous opera Nixon in China has never been performed by either of New York City’s major opera companies. That doesn’t help the cause, either.)

Share This Post

Links, with Minimal Comment.

Here’s some stuff I’ve found on which I don’t have a whole lot to say in addition:

:: Calvin and Hobbes creator Bill Watterson gave a commencement speech at his alma mater in 1990, and here it is.

Creating a life that reflects your values and satisfies your soul is a rare achievement. In a culture that relentlessly promotes avarice and excess as the good life, a person happy doing his own work is usually considered an eccentric, if not a subversive. Ambition is only understood if it’s to rise to the top of some imaginary ladder of success. Someone who takes an undemanding job because it affords him the time to pursue other interests and activities is considered a flake. A person who abandons a career in order to stay home and raise children is considered not to be living up to his potential-as if a job title and salary are the sole measure of human worth.

Read the whole thing; it’s worth it (even despite a few obvious transcription errors). I have to admit, though, that while I admire Watterson’s ability to keep his creation “pure” and to walk away from it while it was still fresh, I am bothered by the fact that a man with such insight has pretty much chosen to withdraw from a world that desperately needs it. Oh well.

:: Along similar lines, this woman has found fulfillment as a pizza delivery driver. I’ve done that too — never actually as an official driver, but as a shift manager, it was occasionally my responsibility to go out and run some pizzas around, back in the day. I wouldn’t say I found it fulfilling, but it was sometimes a pleasant diversion, getting to drive around and listen to the radio while the restaurant was getting its ass kicked. Of course, there was high annoyance as well — people who would stiff the drivers on the tips, the unpleasantness of running deliveries on hot summer nights when the car’s A/C was on the fritz, running deliveries on Halloween night, realizing too late that I’d gone down West Washington street when my customer lived on East Washington. But if this woman is really happy doing that, then more power to her.

:: Along the lines of comic strips mentioned above, here’s an article which describes some of the approaches academia has taken with regard to Peanuts. Not the most interesting article in the world, but I did learn that Snoopy’s famed battles against the Red Baron only took place in the strip while the Vietnam War was raging.

:: And along the lines of Peanuts, we’ve just this weekend watched the 1969 movie A Boy Named Charlie Brown, which was made way back in 1969. It’s really quite good, and yet it seems to have slipped through the “cultural awareness” cracks. Most kids now only know the Peanuts gang through the Christmas and Halloween/”Great Pumpkin” TV specials. This film is something else. Its story, involving Charlie Brown’s participation in a spelling bee and his upward trip to the National Finals, basically serves as backdrop for a whole lot of Peanuts digression and some really trippy weirdness. For example, there’s a frankly amazing segment that wouldn’t have been out-of-place in the Disney film Fantasia, accompanying Schroder’s playing of Beethoven’s Pathetique piano sonata (second movement). Here’s a review of the film by Drew McWeeny (AICN’s “Moriarty”). It’s quite a film, really. I had no idea it even existed until I read Drew’s review a few months ago, and I spotted the DVD in the bargain bin at The Store yesterday, strangely enough.

:: When I was a kid I briefly dabbled in stamp collecting. It’s a fascinating hobby, and the main reason I never kept up with it was basically that it got crowded out by other interests. Here’s a story about an ultra-rare stamp that was recently “reunited” with the letter whose postage it provided. The letter was a love letter, appropiately enough.

One of the rarest stamps in the world, the Blue Boy sold for $1 million in 1981 and is estimated to be worth many times that now. Still, many wondered why this stamp — an Alexandria postmaster provisional printed on blue paper before U.S. government stamps were commonplace — survived when all others like it were lost or destroyed. If the envelope had been saved for sentimental reasons, did the letter also exist? If so, what did it say?

:: It seems that wiser heads have prevailed at NBC: sitting on Aaron Sorkin’s new Studio 60 at the Sunset Strip show, and noting that the show would get unmercifully clobbered at 9:00 on Thursdays (against CSI and Grey’s Anatomy, they have moved it to Mondays at 10:00 (up against CSI: Miami). This means that I can still execute my original plan of watching CSI and taping Grey’s, and then watching Grey’s at 10:00. Whew.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓