Not what you think….

Steven Den Beste seems less than thrilled that Oliver Stone is making a 9-11 themed movie. Well, if SDB is assuming that Stone’s going to make something along the lines of Fahrenheit 9-11, he can by all accounts stop worrying. Here’s an original press release about the film, and everything I’ve read since bears this out: Stone’s film focuses tightly on one tale of heroism from the World Trade Center attacks: the rescue of two Port Authority policemen who were trapped in the rubble. Maybe not everyone’s cup of tea, but every report I’ve read about this film’s production has gone out of its way to make clear that this will not be Oliver Stone in “left-wing conspiracy theorist” mode.

(Speaking of which, it’s always bothered me when people refer to JFK as advancing a conspiracy theory, because it really doesn’t advance a theory at all. It’s more of a “fantasy on a theme”, with that theme being “conspiracy”. JFK doesn’t so much advance a theory about the Kennedy assassination as it advances all of them — minus the ones involving aliens and UFOs — basically throwing everything up on a wall for all to see. Just watch JFK and try to sum up the film’s “theory”. It can’t be done. Incidentally, JFK is one of my favorite films of all time. I’ve been for years in awe of how much Stone was able to pack into those three hours.)

Share This Post

Declaring War

Via Glenn Greenwald, I see that Glenn Reynolds thinks that the Congressional authorizations of military force in the case of Afghanistan and Iraq constitute “declarations of war”. Reynolds tosses out a whole lot of legalistic stuff to argue that what we’ve got is a declared state of war, but — well, he’s wrong. By way of illustration, let’s look at the actual language used in Congressional declarations of war.

Here are the texts of both joint resolutions of Congress declaring war on Germany and Japan in December, 1941 (World War II):

Germany:

Declaring that a state of war exists between the Government of Germany and the government and the people of the United States and making provision to prosecute the same.

Whereas the Government of Germany has formally declared war against the government and the people of the United States of America:

Therefore, be it Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, that the state of war between the United States and the Government of Germany which has thus been thrust upon the United States is hereby formally declared; and the President is hereby authorized and directed to employ the entire naval and military forces of the government to carry on war against the Government of Germany; and to bring the conflict to a successful termination, all of the resources of the country are hereby pledged by the Congress of the United States.

Japan:

Declaring that a state of war exists between the Imperial Government of Japan and the Government and the people of the United States and making provisions to prosecute the same.

Whereas the Imperial Government of Japan has committed unprovoked acts of war against the Government and the people of the United States of America:

Therefore be it Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

That the state of war between the United States and the Imperial Government of Japan which has thus been thrust upon the United States is hereby formally declared; and the President is hereby authorized and directed to employ the entire naval and military forces of the United States and the resources of the Government to carry on war against the Imperial Government of Japan; and, to bring the conflict to a successful termination, all of the resources of the country are hereby pledged by the Congress of the United States.

Here is the text of the joint resolution of Congress declaring war on Germany in April, 1917 (World War I):

Whereas the Imperial German Government has committed repeated acts of war against the Government and the people of the United States of America; Therefore be it Resolved by the Senate and the House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress Assembled, that the state of war between the United States and the Imperial German Government which has thus been thrust upon the United States is hereby formally declared; and that the President be, and he is hereby, authorized and directed to employ the entire naval and military forces of the United States and the resources of the Government to carry on war against the Imperial German Government; and to bring the conflict to a successful termination all of the resources of the country are hereby pledged by the Congress of the United States. (Emphasis added)

Here is the text of the joint resolution of Congress of war against Spain in 1898 (Spanish-American War):

DECLARATION OF WAR WITH SPAIN

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, First. That war be, and the same is hereby, declared to exist, and that war has existed since the 21st day of April, A. D. 1898, including said day, between the United States of America and the Kingdom of Spain.

Second. That the President of the United States be, and he hereby is, directed and empowered to use the entire land and naval forces of the United States and to call into the actual service of the United States the militia of the several States to such extent as may be necessary to carry this act into effect.

I couldn’t find the text of Congress’s war declaration with Mexico in 1846, but here’s the resolution of Congress declaring war on Great Britain (the War of 1812):

An Act Declaring War Between the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and the Dependencies Thereof and the United States of America and Their Territories.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That war be and the same is hereby declared to exist between the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and the dependencies thereof, and the United States of America and their territories; and that the President of the United States is hereby authorized to use the whole land and naval force of the United States to carry the same into effect, and to issue to private armed vessels of the United States commissions or letters of marque and general reprisal, in such form as he shall think proper, and under the seal of the United States, against the vessels, goods, and effects of the government of the said United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and the subjects thereof.

By contrast, the text of the Congressional resolution authorizing President Bush to use military force against Iraq can be read here. It’s too long for me to quote here, but it’s worth noting that the resolution never uses any of the turns of phrase common to the above declarations: the specific existence of a “state of war”. No “state of war” has been declared to exist between the United States and the government of Iraq.

As Glenn Greenwald points out, this is mainly about a confusion of the difference between a formal declaration of war and an authorization of military force, and about Glenn Reynolds’s insistence that the authorization of force against Iraq actually was a declaration of war.

My problem is with the whole way the Iraq war is being appreciated. In reading a lot of pro-war blogs, I see a lot of wiggle-language in reference to war in general. Specifically, the phrase “this war” is invoked a lot. Sometimes “this war” refers to Iraq; sometimes to Afghanistan; sometimes it refers in a larger, general sense to the entire “war on terror”.

I’m bothered by the difference between “war” in the specific legal sense (World War II) and “war” in the historic sense (say, the Gulf War) and “war” in the metaphorical sense (see just about any major policy focus of the last thirty years — our “wars” on terror, drugs, poverty, you name it). The “Global War on Terror” at times has the strange feel to it, as though it’s being pushed as some kind of substitute for the Cold War (which was itself only a metaphorical entity), and that it will last for decades in some kind of hazy and undeclared state as we bounce from armed conflict to armed conflict, assured by the Glenn Reynoldses of the world that it’s all good, it’s just all part of the War on Terror. Somehow.

Share This Post

Shoulder high, we bring you home

This article about the final homecoming of a Marine from Iraq is long. It’s also profoundly moving.

Inside a limousine parked on the airport tarmac, Katherine Cathey looked out at the clear night sky and felt a kick.

“He’s moving,” she said. “Come feel him. He’s moving.”

Her two best friends leaned forward on the soft leather seats and put their hands on her stomach.

“I felt it,” one of them said. “I felt it.”

Outside, the whine of jet engines swelled.

“Oh, sweetie,” her friend said. “I think this is his plane.”

As the three young women peered through the tinted windows, Katherine squeezed a set of dog tags stamped with the same name as her unborn son:

James J. Cathey.

“He wasn’t supposed to come home this way,” she said, tightening her grip on the tags, which were linked by a necklace to her husband’s wedding ring.

The women looked through the back window. Then the 23-year-old placed her hand on her pregnant belly.

“Everything that made me happy is on that plane,” she said.

They watched as airport workers rolled a conveyor belt to the rear of the plane, followed by six solemn Marines.

Katherine turned from the window and closed her eyes.

“I don’t want it to be dark right now. I wish it was daytime,” she said. “I wish it was daytime for the rest of my life. The night is just too hard.”

Suddenly, the car door opened. A white-gloved hand reached into the limousine from outside – the same hand that had knocked on Katherine’s door in Brighton five days earlier.

The man in the deep blue uniform knelt down to meet her eyes, speaking in a soft, steady voice.

“Katherine,” said Maj. Steve Beck, “it’s time.”

That’s but a tiny portion of the piece. I strongly encourage reading the whole thing.

Share This Post

Sentential Links #46

This week’s links abide:

:: To be sure, the delightful irony of a race that sold Manhattan Island for $24 bucks getting some of its own back from the Budweiser-bloated Bermuda shorts set is not lost on me, but that’s not the sort of city I want to live in. Let the chumps go somewhere else to be fleeced. Let them go to Biloxi, or Davenport. Duluth, or Thackerville. There’s no shortage of places to go to gamble, a fact that speaks volumes about the credulity of the American public– we really don’t need to have it here. (There’s an anti-casino argument I haven’t heard advanced much. To be honest, I don’t see how a casino is going to do anything but hurt things here. Taking city land off the tax rolls, give the city a pittance of slot machine revenue, in all likelihood not spur any significant development that wouldn’t happen anyway, enrich a few Indians but not much else, establish a casino that really won’t be much of a tourist attraction since just about everybody lives within a few hours of a casino anyway no matter where they are — screw the casino.)

:: I know I know, cool is elusive, undefinable. But when your personal style makes the cover of THAT magazine, you got it. (I’ll be keeping an eye on that mag for the “long hair and overalls” look, then! Probably in vain, but you never know….)

:: I dreamed an episode of The Dick Van Dyke show last night. (I just don’t know what to add to that….)

:: Refusing to do any extras whatsoever on a film that made this large a cultural impact is hubris, and it’s that attitude that continues to leave a bad taste in my mouth about the movie. (Interesting criticism of the DVD package of the movie The Passion of the Christ. I watched the film a few weeks ago, and I was surprised that the film actually seemed less visceral than its reputation holds, and that Gibson apparently fell in love with slow-motion at some point, since I’d guess that a quarter of the film is shot that way. As a movie, it didn’t move me one way or the other — it was just kind of “there”. Oh, and I hated the music.)

:: I am going to castrate the developers at Mircosoft and Apple. (Isn’t there a whole club of people who want to do that? They could all get jackets!)

:: Anyhow, I got to thinking about which towns will never, ever have a vehicle model named after them; the kind of towns with a weird name that doesn’t conjure up the kind of imagery that, say, Malibu or Seville does. (Go check out the ones he came up with, and add some yourself. For myself, I’d love to mosey about down behind the wheel of my trusty Tonawanda!)

:: Can oatmeal be consumed during Passover?

:: And poor Judas has been so reviled that no one will even name their dog Judas. He has been portrayed as this evil man, when even the gospels tell of his remorse. He did kill himself over it, after all. I’d say he was pretty damned sorry.

:: I speak to my wife nearly every day while I’m at work. It helps keep the relationship hot and steamy when we make sure to discuss the consistency of our boys’ bowel movements and whether or not the living room furniture has acquired any more permanent stains in the past day.

:: Moreover, I’ve never seen anything supporting the idea that people who don’t go to classical music concerts or who are ignorant of classical music don’t do so because they think it’s elitist or the music of a superior intellectual or culture class. (Exactly!)

:: Lately I’ve been reading of concerns that Lost is being plotted one episode at a time rather than with a long-range story planned. Yet this off-the-cuff creation is celebrated in jazz improvisation. (I stopped watching Lost a few episodes in because it just seemed directionless, but I’m not sure that the jazz metaphor is the best one, since even in jazz the improv is melodically based and revolves pretty strictly around the chart’s chord progressions.)

All for this week. Tune in next week to hear someone say…well, something.

Share This Post

GRRRR!

Sorry for the lack of content, folks, but in addition to some domestic stuff like picking up our sorry excuse for a living room, I had Firefox go belly-up for some strange reason, which forced me to re-download and re-install it. Back tomorrow. Look for “Sentential Links” then.

Share This Post

(moving) IMAGE OF THE WEEK

I linked a QuickTime version of this a while back, but I found it today on YouTube: the classic “Mahna Mahna” skit from The Muppet Show.

To me, this one skit perfectly illustrates the utter genius of Jim Henson and company in the 70s. Here we have two pink muppets who seem female, although there’s not really anything that indicates them as such (unless it’s just that they’re pink and they have giant eyelashes), singing a jazzy little tune — and then in wanders a hippie-looking muppet with a beard, wild-ass hair, and shades for eyes, who tries repeatedly to derail the jazzy tune with something more rock-like, only to be worn down as the two pink ladies just look at each other and shake their heads every time the hippie breaks into his scat singing.

What gets me is that these two pink ladies, aside from being able to flex their mouths for enunciation of their song (whose one word is “doot”), have absolutely no other means of expression or movement. Their arms can’t move, their eyes never waver from a bug-eyed stare — and yet their reactions to the wandering hippie are always clear. It’s all achieved through nothing but the way the muppets are moved by the “muppeteers”. The humor of the sketch is achieved entirely through body language.

Share This Post

Jed: The Final Days

Well, the Bartlet Administration is in its final days as it witnesses its transition period with President-elect Santos, who somehow managed to get elected despite picking an admitted alcoholic and drug addict with a history of heart trouble as his running mate, and then seeing that same running mate dying of a heart attack on Election Day. Luckily, he was able to pull out a squeaker of an election by carrying Texas and defeating a Republican nominee who had somehow won his party’s nomination despite being a pro-choice non-church goer. Well, who ever said that TV needed plausibility? All that stuff is no less plausible than all those times Data or Wesley managed to save the Enterprise by reversing the flow of dekyon particles from the ship’s Bussard collectors*.

Nothing much to say about the show, really, except that it just occurred to me that it would be funny if the very last scene of the last episode had President Santos, on his first day in office, sitting down at the Resolute Desk, taking a deep breath…and then a knock at the door:

SANTOS: Come in!

MANDY walks in, looking dissheveled and holding some kind of incredibly thick report.

MANDY: Mr. President, I know it’s taken a while for me to get this done, but I’ve been working real hard in the basement on it and…I’m sorry, who are you?

Fade out.

Yeah, I know, it’s lame. But then, I’m a guy who came away from the last episode of Happy Days wondering whatever happened to Chuck Cunningham.

* When he got the notice from Starfleet Academy that Wesley was to leave the ship and actually, you know, earn a spot in Starfleet by actually attending the Academy, do you suppose Captain Picard went alone into his ready-room and said to himself, “My God, I gotta fly this thing by myself? We’re all f***ed!”?

Share This Post

Contraceptives for Me, but not for Thee

Another thing I suddenly thought of regarding the whole “Pharamacists versus Morals” thing: I read, a while back, that the Target Corporation was actually going to allow its pharmacists to behave in this moralizing way.

Funny thing is: even while a Target pharmacist could be denying the pill to women, the Target health products section — which is not run by the pharamacists — carries condoms.

Tell me again how this isn’t about punishing women and paternalistic moralizing.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓