Ye Gods!

Gregg Easterbrook‘s take on Super Bowl XXXX resembles my own: yes, the referees blew some calls, but those calls are not why the Seahawks lost the game. The Seahawks made too many mental errors and bad coaching decisions to win. Those questionable calls may be enormously frustrating to Seahawks fans, but it just wasn’t their fault. Take it from a guy who knows losing Super Bowls: as a Buffalo Bills fan, I’m an expert. I’ve seen close losses, and I’ve seen blowout losses.

However, in mid-column, Easterbrook feels the need, as he often does, to write about non-football stuff. I usually gloss over this stuff, because it’s usually geeky stuff about geek franchises with which I’m unfamiliar, but here Easterbrook expresses his frustration that Intelligent Design has been co-opted by stealth creationists:

Yours truly thinks the “intelligent design” idea is being given the short
shrift by the mainstream media. Yes, some intelligent design advocates
want to use I.D. as a Trojan horse to put religious doctrine into public
schools — forbidden by the First Amendment, and wisely so in the
opinion of this churchgoer. And some intelligent design advocates
believe young Earth creationism, a nutty idea for which there isn’t one
iota of scientific evidence. But as they mock the notion of intelligent
design, the mainstream media are systematically avoiding a substantial
question mark in evolutionary theory: it does not explain the origin of
life. That organisms evolve in response to changes in their environment
is well-established — anyone who doubts this doesn’t know what he or
she is talking about. But why are there living things in the first
place? Darwin said he had no idea, and to this day science has little
beyond wild guesses about the origin of life. Maybe life had a natural
origin that one day will be discovered. Until such time, higher powers
or the divine cannot be ruled out. Exactly because I think intelligent
design is a more important concept than the mainstream media will admit,
I really wish right-wing screwballs would stop advocating I.D. —
they’re giving the idea a bad name! First, it’s common to hear them say
evolution can be disregarded because it’s “just a theory.”

This is ill-informed. In everyday usage, “theory” can mean a conjectural
or unlikely claim. (“See, I have this theory why Maria Sharapova would
go out with me.”) In science, a theory is an idea that has well-accepted
supporting principles, has been tested successfully and that no one has
falsified; in science the word theory conveys high standing. For
instance, first relativity was an analytical idea, then a hypothesis,
then after many years of testing was acknowledged as a theory. When in
1996 Pope John Paul II called Darwinianism “more than a hypothesis,” he
was choosing words precisely. Many on today’s anti-science right appear
ignorant of such basic precepts as the definition of the word
theory.

The screwball fringe keeps proposing I.D.-related legislation that shows
it doesn’t even understand the limits of evolutionary theory. Two years
ago some science illiterates in Cobb County, Ga., got the local Board of
Education to mandate stickers on biology textbooks reading, “Evolution
is a theory, not a fact, regarding the origin of living things.”
Evolution has nothing to do with the origin of living things. The
core quandary of Darwinian logic is that we can imagine how living
things evolve but cannot imagine how they came into existence in the
first place. Now a know-nothing Utah state representative has proposed this bill that “requires the State Board of Education
to establish curriculum requirements and policies that stress that not
all scientists agree on which theory regarding the origins of life … is
correct.” Hey, Utah state legislature, there are no theories on
the origin of life.
A few biologists have made wild guesses
involving RNA, clay or hot ocean vents, but no scientist has offered
anything nothing remotely near the level of a testable theory. (The details on that point) Given the presence of life is so
mysterious, a creator God may be why we are here. But please, science
illiterates, stop attempting to enact rules about intelligent design;
you are ruining the idea.

Oh, ugh. This is the worst possible justification for ID, and after reading Easterbrook very correctly deride the incorrect use of the word “theory”, it’s so disappointing to see him go off on this lame goose chase. If Easterbrook himself has a testable hypothesis on ID, then by all means, let’s hear it; but it is simply false to state, as Easterbrook does, that science’s current inability to answer a particular question therefore implies a supernatural answer to that question.

And as Easterbrook himself notes, there are hypotheses regarding the origins of life. I’m not sure that his description of these hypotheses as “wild guesses” is at all fair; but how much more of a wild guess would it be for a scientist, faced with a vexing conundrum, to conclude “God did it!”?

Lordy, stick to the football.

Share This Post

Sentential Links #36

It’s time again for some sentential goodness. Click for the context:

:: And anyone who likes to makes jokes about how old they are now, show me you have as nice an ass as Mick Jagger and I might think about listening to you. (I’d give this challenge a try, but I can’t see my ass because my gut keeps getting in the way….)

:: I mean, for God’s sake: a 24-year-old press officer for NASA who sees it as his primary mission to “make the president look good”? Gag me. Can’t we throw him to the largely ignorant Muslim fundamentalists?

:: I seem to remember the Soviet Union being held in contempt for its heavy reliance on “political officers.” President Bush’s close relationship with Russia’s ex-KGB head honcho, Vladimir Putin, is starting to make more sense. (Remember how, in The Hunt for Red October, Captain Ramius’s first act in his plan to defect was to kill his ship’s Political Officer? Hmmm….)

:: My great-grandmother was old enough when she died to have met people who fought in the Civil War. “Multi-tasking” for her at my age would have been playing the phonograph while dancing the Charleston. (“Moriarty” of AICN — real name, Drew McWeeny — has a blog about DVDs. I don’t always agree with Moriarty, but I love his approach to films: he’s not afraid to like whatever he damned well wants to like. Cool. Welcome to blogging, Moriarty!)

:: I’m gearing up for a post wherein I share a current inner dialog about living the dream in my heart, (and why I am on the brink but for some reason holding back) but some explanation may be needed to fully “appreciate” (as in understand, not necessarily enjoy) the different forces and factors in my life. (Jayne’s blog is almost a kind of Zen meditation thing at times. It’s really something.)

:: Of course Gonzales begins his Opening Statement by quoting Osama bin Laden and Zawahri. We used to quote Madison, Jefferson and Lincoln to decide what the principles of our Government are going to be. Now we quote Al Qaeda. The Administration wants Al Qaeda and its speeches to dictate the type of Government we have. It is the centerpiece of everything they do and say.

:: 1. I will hold you, Daniel. (If you read any of these this week, read this one. Via.)

:: So why this sudden burst of enthusiasm for things photographic? It’s a complicated question, but as to what triggered it the answer is clear: I was seduced by the Power of the Dark Side of the Zoom. (Will has a new URL, by the way. Update your blogrolls. This means you. Yeah, you, in the back — the guy in the overalls who is always slow to update his blogroll. Slacker!)

All for now….

Share This Post

Super Bowl 28….er, 40….er, 101000….er, 50

How ’bout them Stillers!

I am happy that the Steelers won the game, but I also note that this is not just the strangest Super Bowl I’ve ever seen, but also one of the strangest football games of any type I’ve ever seen. Here we had a game where the winning quarterback posted a passer rating of 22.6; here we had a game where the team that won the turnover battle lost the game; here we had a game where it seemed like every great play was followed minutes later by a stunningly bad play. What a strange, whacky game.

So, today on the radio, it stands to reason that the major topic of discussion is…the officiating. I mean, that’s got to be the major reason the Steelers won the game, right? The refs were clearly judging the Seahawks more harshly than the Steelers. Clearly the Seahawks were screwed each time out, when every questionable call or seemingly unjustifiable tossing of the yellow flag went against them. The refs saw to it that every time the momentum started to swing toward the Seahawks, it got swung right round again, pronto.

I’m sympathetic to a point. I didn’t see the personal foul called on Matt Hasselbeck, so I can’t comment on that, but the offensive pass interference call that negated a touchdown was a tough one, even if I’m generally fine with it because I suspect that if that exact play gets run a hundred times, the NFL’s refs will throw that flag probably fifty percent of the time. There really are times when officiating is a crapshoot.

Same with Ben Roethlisberger’s touchdown run. To me, it looked pretty evident that he got in: judging by where he was holding his arm as he reached the front edge of the goal line, the ball had to have broken the plane. However, I also suspect that if the line judge had made the opposite call — down at the one-inch line — the instant replay would not have offered the conclusive proof to overturn that call, either; and in any case, I seriously doubt the Seahawks would have been able to turn back the inevitable attempt by the Steelers to pound the ball in there on fourth-and-goal from the one-inch line. So I’m not bothered by that one, either.

The Seahawks suffered seven penalties for 70 yards, versus only three penalties for 20 yards for the Steelers. That seems kind of lopsided, but for a bit of perspective, here are the penalty results from the last few Super Bowls:

SB 40: Steelers 3 (20 yds), Seahawks 7 (70 yds)
SB 39: StuPats 7 (47 yds), Eagles 3 (35 yds)
SB 38: StuPats 8 (60 yds), Panthers 12 (73 yds)
SB 37: Bucs 5 (41 yds), Raiders 7 (51 yds)
SB 36: StuPats 5 (31 yds), StL 6 (39 yds)
SB 35: Ravens 9 (70 yds), Giants 6 (27 yds)
SB 34: Rams 8 (60 yds), Titans 7 (45 yds)

Of the previous six Super Bowls, the winning team was penalized more than the losing team. The average number of penalties for winning and losing teams, including yesterday’s game, since SB 34 break down thusly:

Winners 6.4 (42.6 yds), Losers 6.9 (48.6)

So the Steelers did get penalized about half as much as winners have typically done recently, but the Seahawks weren’t really that far off the pace for losing teams. Does this mean anything? I’m not sure that it does, but it may point to the one reason I think that the Steelers really won the game: composure.

Watching this game was a study in contrasting attitudes on the part of the teams. No one will disagree that Seattle looked fairly sharp in the first quarter, while Pittsburgh could only have looked flatter if they’d actually started turning the ball over from the get-go. However, the Steelers hung in there, eventually getting things moving, albeit never terribly impressively except for a trio of really big plays. But what really stood out, for me, was that each time something bad happened to the Steelers, their team demeanor did not change. Seattle’s, however, did. After every call against them, after every dropped pass and missed field goal and eventually after a crucial interception, the Seahawks looked a little more deflated every time something went wrong. They started out with their heads in the game, and the Steelers did not. But the Steelers got their heads in the game and took maximum advantage of the relatively small number of opportunities they had, while the Seahawks allowed themselves to get disrupted.

Setting aside the penalties and the possible wrong calls, the Seahawks were only down by eleven points in the fourth quarter with eight minutes to go, and yet Shaun Alexander, the NFL MVP who rushed for over 1800 yards this year, only touched the ball one more time after that. In fact, after the Seahawks had scored to close to being only down 14-10 in the third quarter, Shaun Alexander only touched the ball six more times. In the whole game, Alexander only had twenty carries — and while his team trailed the entire second half, the difference was never enough to justify abandoning the run.

Then there were the missed field goals. Yes, kicks from 54 and 50 yards are low-percentage kicks, but both of Josh Brown’s kicks had the distance; he was over 60 percent successful from that range during the regular season; and it’s not like he had weather to contend with — he was kicking indoors. If he makes either of those kicks, or even both of them, then that means that assuming everything else remains the same the Seahawks would have been in an entirely different situation on that last drive. There would have been less panicked urgency, because it would not have been a two-possession game. But the kicks both missed wide.

And that’s not even mentioning the clock-management problems the Seahawks had.

Contrast that with the Steelers, who kept their wits about them. The Steelers didn’t panic when they made bad plays (and a couple of ’em were downright awful plays). They stayed calm and waited for the next opportunity for a big play, which they made each time. They still controlled the tempo of the game. They didn’t play well, but they didn’t need to. They just found ways to make the big plays they needed to make, and Seattle didn’t: as the need to make plays got bigger and bigger for the Seahawks, they strayed farther and farther away from getting the ball to their playmaker.

And that is why the Steelers won this game.

Some random final thoughts:

:: Here’s a scary thought: Ben Roethlisberger is probably still a year or two away from being in his prime.

:: I take this game, and this entire season, as proof of my theory about Bill Cowher: rather than being a guy who could never get over the hump until now, the guy is a brilliant coach who got closer to that hump than he ever should have with the talent he had.

:: I really hope the Seahawks get back to the Super Bowl and win it soon. I like Mike Holmgren a lot (I’ve liked him since his Packers days), and while I wasn’t rooting for them, I don’t dislike them at all. As long as they don’t play the Steelers or Bills next time they’re in the Super Bowl, I’ll root for them.

:: Is the idea of a Super Bowl without Tom Brady present somehow unthinkable now? Having him at the coin toss was just goofy.

:: Why does a fresh ball have to be used for every first-half play? What is the point of that?

:: What on Earth was up with all the newfound reverence for the Vince Lombardi Trophy, with the thing being walked out onto the field for the presentation? As trophies go, I think that the Lombardi is the coolest one aside from the Stanley Cup (which is cool mainly because it’s so friggin’ huge, and because the players actually get to take it home for a while after they win it), but the Ritual Presentation of the Trophy was kind of strange, I thought.

(By the way, check out the Wikipedia entry on the Stanley Cup. There’s a ton of cool Cup lore there, including the factoid that a player once tried drop-kicking the cup — in a smaller incarnation — across a canal. He was unsuccessful.)

:: Was it just me, or after the game was over, did Steelers owner Dan Rooney look like he’d just won a free Coke from McDonald’s? The guy could not possibly have looked less enthusiastic.

:: I know that ABC wanted to get to Grey’s Anatomy (a show which, in my opinion, is now what ER used to be and isn’t close to being anymore), but does the losing team no longer warrant any coverage at all? No interviews with Mike Holmgren or anything.

:: I didn’t bother watching many commercials. I did like the “streaking sheep” one, the Kermit-the-Frog in the Great Outdoors one, and I thought the funniest was the Sharpie Retractible commercial that depicted the trials and tribulations of a theme-park pirate. The Fed Ex dinosaur ad drew a “meh” from me, the Diet Pepsi ads sucked, and if I live to the age of 200 and never see the Whopperettes again, I may get over the mental scarring. That was one weird, creepy-assed ad.

:: OK, the Harrison Ford-channeling-Dr. Seuss thing amused me. What can I say? Harrison Ford can, it seems, still summon up quite a lot of coolness.

:: Thank God for the Winter Olympics…for me, the post-Super Bowl, pre-Spring Training period is the dullest sports time of the year. (I don’t care one whit about college basketball.)

Well, I wonder who the Bills will sign in free agency? And who they’ll draft? Can we start training camp now?

Share This Post

A snapshot of the blog

Lots of folks are doing this: it gives a “word cloud” from the most common words on your blog, as far as I can tell. (Of course, it’s anyone’s guess if they’re actually selling too many of these shirts, as opposed to seeing bloggers just grab the image and post it accordingly.) Anyhow, here’s mine:

Share This Post

IMAGES OF THE WEEK

Apparently two “new” paintings by Caravaggio have been discovered; Alexandra has the goods. Go look at them: I didn’t care for the first one, but the second is kind of haunting in a CSI kind of way, if that makes any sense.

As long as I’m linking Alexandra — whom I haven’t linked in quite a while — she also has a link to this wonderful NYT article about author Harper Lee, who recently came out of reclusion after her one novel — a little volume called To Kill A Mockingbird — to appear at an awards ceremony for a contest involving essays on the subject of Lee’s novel. You know what I thought was the coolest thing about Ms. Lee? She lives with her 94-year old sister, who is a practicing attorney.

I have got to read Mockingbird again one of these days. I haven’t read it since the tenth grade, when I loved it dearly — almost enough to revise my rather negative opinion of that particular English teacher (she’s the one who also made us read Ordinary People while the other classes read Mark Twain).

(And one final thought on what’s becoming a grab-bag post: looking at the photo of Harper Lee, she looks a lot like actress Kathryn Joosten, who played Mrs. Landingham on The West Wing. Not that that has anything to do with, well, anything.)

Share This Post

Our Feline Overlords

Yesterday we took in two new cats. The older of our former two cats, Lilac, passed away a few weeks ago. It had been her time, really: she reached that point that all pets seem to reach if something else doesn’t do them in, when she couldn’t get around very well and she was skinny as a rail and her bowel control had reached the point where our first major project after her passing was to rent a Rug Doctor machine and steam-clean our carpets.

Anyhow, a few months back two healthy cats had been deposited upon my parents’ doorstep. They’d been well-cared for, but there they were — we suspect that someone took good care of them until, for one reason or another, they could no longer, and then they got taken to my parents, who are known in their small town for being cat-lovers. And now we’ve adopted these two lovable felines.

And while they’re certainly friendly and good-natured, so far they’ve annoyed me quite a bit. Some cats are able to pick their way through shelves laden with fragile items because they know precisely how big they are and how much weight they can put on each paw wherever they are, and so on. Not so these two boys (named Lester and Julio — we didn’t pick the names). No, these guys seem to have absolutely no idea how big their own asses are, and this lack of self-awareness is coupled with a fascination with the general concept of “up”.

So after about thirty-six hours or so, we’re down one lamp and one glass picture frame, plus a number of other items that have been knocked or dislodged from their perches. One of them seems to feel the need to scratch in the litter box for approximately thirteen minutes after each bowel movement, and the other spends the night wandering around trilling. (Or it might be the same one. I don’t know, really.)

But anyway, we have two new cats. I hope the third one comes out of hiding soon….

You can see my new feline overlords over at the Flickr photostream, by the way. Just click that Flickr badge thing that’s in the sidebar, just beneath my self-photos.

Share This Post

Time for a “Sorkin Pool”!

Like Erin, I am looking forward to the upcoming Aaron Sorkin-scripted TV show which is to be a backstage show about the production of a fictional SNL-type show. Sorkin does like to set his dramas in locations that are well-suited to rapid-fire dialogue, and this one might be the most “rapid” of them all.

I’m glad to see that Matthew Perry will be in the cast. When he did his first guest-shot in The West Wing, I remember thinking, “Oh, how lucky for Perry, that Friends is ending but now he’ll get to do a Sorkin show!” Of course, Sorkin left TWW very shortly thereafter, and Perry only had one more appearance on the show. So now he does get to be on a Sorkin show.

When the new program premieres, I think we should have a “drinking game” along the lines of drinking whenever a character:

1. Refers to getting “screwed with his/her pants on”
2. Says some variant of “I have to go do a thing”.
3. Says some variant of “I didn’t do that! I did not do that! Only, yes, I did that!”
4. Answers a yes/no question with “Yeah”.
5. Makes a sly reference to a former Sorkin project (such as how episodes of TWW mentioned the “Global Defense Council” and French President D’Astier, both of whom were prominently featured in The American President).

Any other suggestions for a Sorkin drinking game? Alternatively, one could go to any AICN TalkBack for any Sorkin-related AICN story and take a drink every time some TalkBacker whines that Sorkin is a crappy writer while Joss Whedon is God.

Share This Post

Thurman!

This year marked Thurman Thomas’s first year of eligibility for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He didn’t get in.

I’m trying to not be annoyed by this. Really. I’m not being very successful.

The fact is that only a quarter of the guys in the Hall have been voted in on their very first ballots. And that is almost certainly because only six people can be inducted per year, so when you have years like this year’s when the class of newly eligible players is unusually strong, some guys are going to be left out in the cold for another year.

So I get the necessity: not everybody who was eligible this year could go in. That’s the “happy face” that’s being put on Thomas’s exclusion for this year: “Oh, he’ll get in for sure, so don’t worry. We’ll induct six more guys in 2007, and in 2008. Thurman Thomas will get into the Hall. Bet on it.”

I’d be fine with that. Grudgingly, yes, but I’d be fine with it — if not for the condescending “Jim Brown” argument, that roughly states that “Sure, Thomas is a HoF guy, but the first ballot is for the greatest of the great — that’s when you induct Emmitt Smith, Jim Brown, and the very best players ever at their position. Thomas was a great one, but not that great. So he needs to wait a while.” This is complete crap.

First of all, it’s the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of Stats, and as many are saying today, either you are a HoF guy, or you’re not. If you have an unusually rich class for the Hall, and you need to use some kind of yardstick by which to decide which guys to induct and which to make wait another year, that might be OK, but now I’m looking at the guys who actually did get in this year:

Troy Aikman (quarterback)
Harry Carson (linebacker)
John Madden (head coach)
Warren Moon (quarterback)
Reggie White (defensive end)
Rayfield Wright (tackle)

I’ll admit up front that I don’t know anything about Carson and Wright, so it’s possible that they were better at their positions than Thomas was at his. I also won’t quibble one bit with Reggie White, who was an astonishing player. (I liked him a lot less when he turned out to be a homophobic creep, but that has nothing to do with football.) I’m even all for inducting John Madden, who was a very good coach in his day and who I think deserves induction on the basis of his broadcasting work. (My wife hates his voice, but I’ve always kind of liked Madden, and I’ve liked him even more since he’s worked with Al Michaels and stopped using the “Coach’s Clicker”.)

So that leaves this year’s two quarterbacks. Troy Aikman is probably a slam dunk, right? The guy won three Super Bowls in four years, and he was one of the league’s best QBs until his career was cut short by concussions. But Warren Moon?

I liked Warren Moon a lot. So much, even, that I think he should be in the Hall of Fame. But does the logic applied to keeping Thurman Thomas out in his first year of eligibility really imply that Moon should be in, also in his first year of eligibility? Imagine that you walk up to a person who turns out to be a fairly knowledgable football fan, and that you ask this person to list the best running backs they’ve seen, followed by the best quarterbacks they’ve seen. I’d probably bet real money that our knowledgable football fan would mention Thurman Thomas on the running backs list well before they mentioned Warren Moon on the quarterbacks list. If Thurman Thomas doesn’t get in because he wasn’t one of the “Jim Brown”‘s of the sport, how does Warren Moon get in? Does anybody think that Moon is one of the Joe Montana’s of the game?

Obviously, one is either a HoF’er or one is not. Equally obviously, the rules for induction are going to leave guys who should be in out in the cold for longer than they should be. But if one is going to use some kind of half-assed metric to justify one player’s exclusion, they’d better be prepared to explain why they didn’t use that same metric against another player’s induction.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓