By any other name….

Via TBogg, I see — for the second time in three days — that some right-wing clod has tossed out a statement of unimaginable stupidity. Behold:

Today’s New York Times details a Japanese scientific on earwax and body odor in Asians vs. Europeans and Africans. There is actually an “earwax gene” in DNA that determines this.

But the paper glosses over the most important finding. The study found that Europeans and Africans tend to have wet ear wax, sweat more, and have more under arm body odor than Asians, who have dry ear wax and don’t sweat much. But the study also found that “Native” Americans have dry ear wax and body odor similar to Asians, proving they migrated here from Asia.

So whom did THEY steal the land from? Somebody else, obviously. Yet, no “Dances With Wolves” and “Into the West” from Hollywood about that.

Hoo-boy.

What’s funnier is that Ms. Schlussel is really upset that a bunch of “liberals” are stampeding over there to call her dumb in comments, so at the top of her post she appends a follow-up:

To all the liberal idiots who’ve left dumb, insulting comments on this entry, as directed by similarly intellectually-challenged lefty websites, I’m well aware Indians came here over the Bering Strait, which you’d realize if you actually bothered to read what I wrote below in this entry. I simply quoted the NYTimes that this was yet more proof. Yet, there is no proof they were the first here. And even if they were, this is yet more proof that they originated in ASIA. Hello? . . . This is yet more evidence that we did NOT steal THEIR land. It means it was not THEIRS to begin with.

The mind boggles in so many ways:

First there is the embarrassment of Ms. Schlussel’s grasp of the science involved. While it’s true that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, the truth is that — so far as I know — there is no evidence whatsoever of any civilizations of humans, or human ancestors, on the American continents prior to the emigration of the Asian peoples who eventually became the Native Americans. Ms. Schlussel is attempting to construct some kind of moral argument based on a hypothetical entity for which she has no evidence to justify supposing its existence. Her “argument” hinges on just making up stuff that sounds like it might work. It’s the equivalent of all those times on Star Trek: The Next Generation when, with ten minutes left in the show and the Enterprise facing certain destruction, either Data or Wesley Crusher would start babbling about how they could save the day by using whatever sub-nucleic particle they’d been reading about earlier that morning.

But then there’s Ms. Schlussel’s moral argument, which fares even more poorly. Even if there was “someone else” here, and even if that “civilization” was displaced by the onrushing hordes of Asian invaders (maybe they were led by a distant ancestor of Genghis Khan) — a supposition which, we’ll again note, has utterly no backing in any anthropological science of which I know — since we’re talking about events that would have happened thousands of years ago. That means that those arriving Asians would have had millennia to establish civilizations that were in some cases nomadic (think of the Plains tribes of North America), and some that were distinctly city-based (think of the Anasazi, Olmec, and Aztecs). Therefore, the question becomes: even if the land wasn’t “theirs to begin with”, would it not still be the case that the land became “theirs” at some point?

And more importantly, does that even matter?

Let’s perform a thought experiment here. Imagine a swing set on a school playground. There are no kids on the playground, and no kids on the swings. Out comes young Calvin, ready to swing to his heart’s content. And Calvin comes over, sees nobody on the swings or even on the playground, and hops on the swing. So there’s Calvin, just a-swingin’ away, fantasizing about Spaceman Spiff and planning his revenge on Suzy and wondering how he’ll get into the house without getting pummeled by Hobbes.

And then, along comes Moe.

Moe’s our schoolyard bully, the kid with the beady eyes and the forearms the size of Calvin’s torso. Moe could play on one of the other swings, and he could skip the swings entirely and head for the slides or the dodgeball court, but no! Moe wants the very swing that Calvin occupies. And the following transpires:

MOE: Get off the swing!

CALVIN: No! I was here first. It’s mine.

Moe simply shoves Calvin off the swing and takes it over.

By Ms. Schlussel’s moral logic, Calvin has absolutely no moral standing here to resist Moe. After all, the swing never belonged to him in the first place. He has no standing at all, according to Ms. Schlussel. I suppose that in her world, things belong only to those who are strong enough to take them, and that’s that.

(And note that this moral argument of Ms. Schlussel’s is unaffected by whether or not there were any pre-Indians here at all. All that is mere chimera; it has no bearing whatever on the moral logic at all. Such as it is.)

What’s worse, though, is that Ms. Schlussel’s “argument” doesn’t just deny the Indians their moral stance; it affords a positive moral stance to aggression. If the “We were here first” argument is of no worth, and if ownership of land can only be ascribed to the very first people who were ever on the scene in the entire course of history, then why should aggression ever be opposed? If there was nothing whatsoever objectionable to the United States’s treatment of the American Indians, then what can we say of other acts of aggression in history? Did the victims of all those wars of territory really have no moral standing at all? I’m sure that will come as news to the Jews — after all, Israel wasn’t theirs to begin with. And I suppose that the United States was wrong to oppose Saddam Hussein in 1991; after all, it’s not like Kuwait was the Kuwaitis’ to begin with.

Does any of that make sense? I suppose it all does to Ms. Schlussel.

Share This Post

Sentential Links #35

In addition to the normal linkage, I’ll have some links to blogs nominated for “Most Deserving of Wider Recognition” Koufaxes. There are so many nominees for that award that I can’t possibly link them all in a single post, so I’ll attempt to link a bunch of them each week for a while.

:: While airports have a lot more glamor than bus lines and can probably get a lot more dollars too (maybe even $24 million of them,) I’d suggest that the NFTA stick to its mission and stop trying to get some more pork for an unneeded second airport. (Craig has been blogging the hell out of issues surrounding the Niagara Falls International Airport.)

:: It won’t come as a shock to anyone that we don’t think much of Democratic elected officials. (Koufax nominee)

:: So the contributions to Democrats from the Abramoff represented tribes would probably have gone there anyway. This is all legal, by the way. To equate it with the illegal contributions (or “bribes”) coming from Abramoff is, at best, highly misleading. (Koufax nominee)

:: Here’s the problem with adventure journalism more generally: it’s not written by experts or beat reporters, and therefore only infrequently rises above the usual combination of local color, exoticism, florid prose, and received opinion back home. (Koufax nominee)

:: We’re so used to today’s Hollywood smile that we’re not much bothered by the fact that they’re fake. We are so distracted by the dazzling expanse of perfect white teeth, we hardly notice the eyes. (I know people who smile entirely with their eyes. You can’t fake that.)

:: I will also say that having a nice industry job offer in your back pocket makes these things much less stressful. (Yeah, already having a job makes the search for a new job a lot less terrifying! Koufax nominee.)

:: With 400 posts under my belt I finally feel a bit like a blogger. But I still despise the word “blog.” I want to suggest something more dignified like “combo.” (“Combo”?! Koufax nominee.)

:: Heavy, heavy sigh. (Go see what she’s talking about. Yipes, that’s sad.)

:: But is that what Christianity is about? Is it about power, and authority, and controlling the discussion, and framing the issues, and winning the debate? Or is it about what St. Francis supposedly said: “Preach the gospel to all the world and, if necessary, use words.” (Koufax nominee)

:: Today, I am a man. I’ve received my first hate e-mail. (Geez, I’ve never received hate e-mail! Guess I have some red-meat blogging to do, then. Koufax nominee.)

:: The background animals on the other hand… I just have this vision of the harried BBC wardrobe mistress going to her assistant and saying “go raid the pantomime costumes or something, just get me more animal costumes!” (OK, she wrote this post a month ago, but I’ve been forgetting to link it for that long. Remember when Letterman used to have a bit called “Can A Guy In A Bear Suit…”, in which he’d literally send a guy in a bear suit out into the streets of NYC to do funny things? That’s what I thought of when I read Sarah’s post.)

All for this week on the main links, although I may return to Sentential Links more often as I try to get through the Koufax nominees. But I’m not going to try to have them done by the time the awards are done; I’m just going to try to throw them some linkage as I can. Enjoy!

Share This Post

IMAGES OF THE WEEK

This has been quite the weekend for anniversaries. In order of how recent:

I was a sophomore in college when the Buffalo Bills lost Super Bowl XXV by a single point. It’s a pretty mundane anniversary, I know, but the Bills were a major link I had with my home when I was in college, 800 miles away. I’d watch games from Rich Stadium and think, “That’s home”. (And two years later, it killed me to see all these Iowans, who had always struck me as sensible types, come out as closet Dallas Cowboys
fans. What the hell was that about?!)

I was in ninth grade when Challenger was destroyed in flight. A friend told me about it in the hall, between classes. It seems odd now, but in those pre-Web and pre-cable everywhere days, and in rural Western New York, I didn’t hear a single thing more about the disaster until I got home and watched the endlessly repeating footage on the network newscasts. What I most remember is that, when they played the tape of the entire flight, after the explosion, some NASA person just calmly went on reading the telemetry data or some such thing that was on his screen. It seemed like forever until someone said something like, “Obviously a major malfunction has occurred.”

And then, of course, there’s the sublime. I doubt the Bills will be remembered by anyone other than a scholar or two studying the sports of the late 20th century two hundred fifty years hence. The Challenger astronauts will also be known primarily to historians. But surely Mozart at 500 will still be alive in the most important sense, right?

Share This Post

More Wolfgang (and then some other stuff)

Be sure to check out Sounds and Fury, where ACD has been doing yeoman duty celebrating the 250th birthday of Mozart. Lots of quotes from Mozart’s letters, and quotes from writers about Mozart, and general goodness relating to Wolfgang A. I especially enjoyed this post, where ACD reports on listening to a broadcast of the “official” Mozart 250th performance from Salzburg:

I was entirely unprepared, however, for the ringing of the church bells of all Salzburg’s churches at precisely 8:00 PM (2:00 PM EST) — the official time of Mozart’s birth as noted by his proud papa — and the frisson of emotion and surprise on hearing them literally made the hair rise up on the back of my neck.

One thing I’ve longed for years to experience is an old-world European city when all the church bells are ringing. Here in America, church bells always sound incongruous and out of place, and when I’ve lived in a place where church bells could regularly be heard — always from a single church — I would occasionally hear complaints from the locals.

Imagine the joyous din of hundreds of such bells, pealing such that individual pitches can barely be made out and only one giant din, marked by the percussion of impact from the bells nearest the listener. I’d love to hear that, just once.

As long as I’ve got ACD on the brain, though, I note with some amusement that he is, as ever, annoyed with the onward march of “pop culture”, now as evidenced by the segments on CBS Sunday Morning. Now, I’ve not watched this show in over a year, since I’ve started attending church services at the exact moment the show is on, so I can’t confirm for myself whether classical music has received significantly less coverage than it used to. That certainly sounds likely, however, given the general and saddening trend away from classical music these days. And Sunday Morning‘s failure to note Mozart’s 250th constitutes a major gaffe for a show that has always celebrated culture. That cannot be disputed.

But what amused me was the roster of segments on today’s program that, for ACD, constitute an unacceptable level of “pop culture” focus:

Consider today’s Sunday Morning culture segments, for instance. They were on the turn-of-the-century Viennese painter, Egon Schiele; on C&W singer, Rosanne Cash, daughter of the late Johnny Cash (a regular chip off the ol’ block, she is, with the difference that, unlike her papa, she can actually sing somewhat); on a 10-year-old, Oakland, California Black kid who’s become a big hit in Oakland’s Chinatown singing in his Chinatown elementary school’s productions of Chinese opera; and not a word, not so much as a fleeting mention, of the 250th anniversary of the birth of one, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart.

Now, admittedly, Roseanne Cash is a fairly large name in country music, but she’s not that big a name, and she is, so far as I can tell, following a line in country music that’s more about the folk-art aspects of the genre than the “rockabilly” stuff that dominates the country airwaves these days (think Shania Twain and the like). But a Viennese painter who lived from 1890 to 1918? Some kid who sings Chinese opera? Is this what ACD takes for “pop culture”?

If so, I can only surmise that ACD defines “pop culture” as “that with which ACD is not interested or doesn’t like”. I don’t deny the existence of “pop culture”, and I certainly don’t share ACD’s loathing of it, but I do have a pretty good idea of what “pop culture” is and these subjects ain’t it.

Oh, and Johnny Cash most definitely could sing. That man did things with his voice that no one else could have done, and he was, as far as I am concerned, a great American artist.

(Hell, as long as I’m now quibbling with ACD, I figure that I should also note that I’ve never cared for Wynton Marsalis’s playing. He has always sounded to me like a guy whose very tone conveys a “brute force” approach to the instrument, especially in the classical repertoire. [I think Marsalis a far better jazz musician than a classical one, even though it took me years to warm up to his jazz work, and even now I’ve generally conceded that my ear for jazz is never likely to develop much beyond “bare familiarity”. Marsalis’s best “classical” album, in my opinion, is his disc of cornet virtuoso showpieces that he recorded with the Eastman Wind Ensemble. It’s an incredibly corny record, of course, but as virtuosity-for-virtuosity’s sake, it’s a lot of fun.]

For the Sunday Morning fanfare, I much prefer the way one of the trumpeters from the Canadian Brass performed it on one of their albums; for general baroque playing, Maurice Andre‘s level of finesse is far superior to Marsalis’s; for contemporary trumpet repertoire, I’ll take Hakan Hardenberger. And for orchestral playing — a totally different animal, of course, as far as the requirements of the performer but worth mentioning — I will forever worship at the altar of Adolph Herseth.)

Share This Post

A query for the craft-minded

In my newfound fascination with tie-dying, I find I’m getting to that point in a new hobby when one has enough rudimentary skill with the process to start thinking of new stuff to try.

For instance: what would happen if I took a pair of stiff blue jeans of dark blue denim and, after tying them in various ways, dipped them into a strong solution of bleach and water? Would this result in a kind of “negative” effect on the jeans? Would the same occur if I did this with a heavy black sweatshirt? And is it possible to tie-dye a down comforter?

(I’m not serious about the down comforter. But the bleach idea intrigues me.)

Share This Post

Bush sucks.

As if I needed another reason to think that our President is a complete tool, here he comes with the State of the Union on Tuesday night. He couldn’t do it on damn Monday, when all I’d miss is CSI: Miami. No, he’s got to pre-empt Scrubs and House.

Commander in chief? More like the “Doofus in Chief”.

(But somehow the Prez managed to not pre-empt American Idol, which means I get to go from watching Simon Cowell being mean to watching the President of the United States. What a jolt that will be! Hey, Democrats — why not get Simon Cowell to do the Democratic Response? He’d sure be a lot more interesting than whatever Blandy McBland we’re about to put up there on Tuesday night.)

Share This Post

Those who have gone before

Shortly before she left for work, The Wife asked me to look about online for a certain song that she discovered a week or so ago. A bit of Googling later, I found the song, posted on a blog called Punkin Toes. This blog is no longer updated, being as it is allowed to sit fallow in memory of one of the bloggers involved and apparently some other people who passed away. It’s a terribly sad read.

(Oh, and the song is called “Held”, by an artist named Natalie Grant, with whom I am totally unfamiliar. I’ve just downloaded the MP3 from the link given in this post, and dammit if that song didn’t start up my waterworks.)

And on top of all that, this morning’s church service featured one of the songs that was performed at Little Quinn’s funeral as well as a baptism. I know that life has to go on, but does life have to beat us up and steal our lunch money too? I’m just asking.

Share This Post

With Jonah’s buoyancy, rest assured.

Oh, man. I don’t often run into Jonah Goldberg’s blatherings, because whenever I do, they are invariably stupid. But this is abnormally stupid. We’re talking, dropping-jaws stupid, stupid that makes you literally gasp aloud “Huh-whuh?”, stupid that makes you marvel at the idea that the human brain can even entertain the train of thought in question. He’s talking about the Titanic, and specifically, objects that might better have been used for flotation:

Rather than deck chairs, I thought all of those lovely sideboards filled with fine china would work very well, particularly if you filled them up with life jackets and lashed them to each other. It would be a pain getting them up on the deck, but fear of death and ample time would have made it quite doable. Also, going into the kitchen and smearing-up your body with lard might be a good idea too. Those English Channel swimmers do that. Still, the wisest course of action would have been to either A) not hit an iceberg or B) not build a ship that was guaranteed to sink if it did (please: emails on the superior craftsmanship of the Titanic should be kept to a minimum).

Wow. Just…wow.

This all follows some kind of “conversation” between Goldberg and John Derbyshire in which the general subtext is, “Stupid Titanic victims — they were on a ship with all that wood around, and we all know that wood floats, so why didn’t they just huck as much wood as possible into the water and cling to it until the Carpathia arrived?” The number of ways in which this is all unbelievably stupid are too many to number, but let’s give it a shot anyway:

1. Goldberg says that heading to the Titanic galley to grab some lard would have helped to insulate the victim’s bodies. “Those English Channel swimmers do that,” Jonah helpfully notes. Those English Channel swimmers also do their swimming in a body of water that’s a bit more temperate than the North Atlantic waters that are outside of the Gulf Stream, and as this Channel swimmer notes, the slathering of lard on the body is not for insulation, but for protection from chafing due to the hours of repetitive motion inherent in swimming such a distance. A simple Google search would have helped Goldberg realize how wrong he is; but then, Goldberg is always asking his readers to do his Googling for him.

2. The afore-linked Channel swimmer notes that a number of former training partners of his suffered symptoms of hypothermia after just an hour in water that was warmer than that of the night the Titanic sank. And those are people who presumably are in far better condition than your average person who went into the water when Titanic sank. ONE hour. Carpathia arrived in four.

3. Why didn’t they just chuck all the wood into the water and float around on it? Because it wouldn’t have done any damn good, Jonah. Not all wood floats, and even if a particular kind of wood does float nicely, there are other factors at play here. If they tossed, say, a dresser into the sea and then clung to it, it is still highly unlikely that the dresser would have floated in such a way as to allow the person clinging to it to get out of the water. Canoes do not float in a useful way because of what they are made of; they float because of how they are made. A non-watertight wooden bureau would probably “float” in the sense that it would bob about very near the surface of the water, but the human body will do that. What was needed were ways to get people completely out of the water. (Witness the way that mantelpiece or whatever it was, in the movie Titanic, nearly flipped over when Jack tried to climb on after Rose. Things that are not designed to float may still float, but they will almost certainly do so in unpredictable ways.)

There is no reason to suppose those “nice sideboards” would have remained upright if placed in the water as a lifeboat; there is no reason to assume that they wouldn’t have taken on water quickly (especially if they were bolted down, and would have had to be ripped up); and there is no reason to assume that the people on board the quickly-sinking ship would have been able to get enough of these sideboards ripped out of the walls, up the stairs, and into the water in time to be useful to more than a handful of victims. (The ship sank in just over two and a half hours.) Had the people on the Titanic followed Jonah’s advice, the Carpathia would have found lots of lard-smeared dead bodies clinging to scraps of useless wood.

God, the Corner is a den of idiots. I can’t believe these people get paid to poorly write such stupid stuff.

(Oh, and here’s Derb, a little ways down the page:

Jonah: My gloom is vast, cosmic, and existential. It does not encompass, nor even concern itself with, the trivialities of personal survival. Placed on a sticky wicket, I will swing my bat with a will. Asked about the fate of Western civ, I’ll tell you it’s going to the dogs. Which is where it’s going.

Oh for a black turtleneck and a cigarette, eh?)

UPDATE: Oops, forgot to attribute the original link to TBogg. And I now recall that Derb is the guy who wrote a while back that women stop being attractive to men for a few years after puberty. Yeah, that’s the guy I want beside me on a sinking ship.

Share This Post

Wolfgang and Me

I never really “discovered” Mozart. He just kind of gradually moved into my life, first via my sister, then via school, and then via a movie, and finally by invitation. And now the guy won’t go away. But that’s fine with me.

My sister is six years older than I am, and she took piano lessons for years in her own youth. Therefore she ended up giving me my first exposure to an awful lot of classical music: the three B’s, of course, but also guys like Tchaikovsky and Chopin and Clementi and Mozart. He wasn’t my thing at that time (I’m not even sure I actually had a “thing” at that time), but there he was, a little more demonstrative than Bach but a little less stormy than Beethoven. Or so I thought.

When it came time for me to take piano lessons myself, I took on the first movement of that C-Major Sonata after a few years. I didn’t do very well with it, since my musical instincts at the age of fifteen were that of an undisciplined slob, but I got through it all right. My piano teacher offered up an interesting quote when I started working on the piece: “Playing Mozart is like taking a musical bath: it cleanses you of bad habits.” If only I could have realized what my bad habits even were, but that takes time.

Along about this time Amadeus came out. My mother took me to see it when it came, not so much because it was about Mozart and I needed some culture, but because it was tremendously acclaimed and she really, really, really wanted to see it. This, of course, was in a small town in the Southern Tier of Western New York, and at that time our town had only six movie screens. I remember going to see something else a few months earlier, and my mother asked the manager if Amadeus would be playing our town, and his curt reply of “No”. Of course, a bunch of Oscar nominations changed that. Off to Amadeus we went. And I did pretty well, for a young person who hadn’t yet caught the bug of classical music but wasn’t completely turned off by it, either: I hated the interminable opera sequences, but I enjoyed the story and was moved by poor Mozart’s various dilemmas and ultimate fate.

A year or two later, I chose to rent Amadeus from the local video store. (This was when you had to pay to join video stores, and this one didn’t bother alphabetizing its shelves.) I don’t recall why I wanted to see the film again, but I did, and this time those opera scenes didn’t bother me as much. One cinematic joke — the harping of Stanzi’s mother being the inspiration for the Queen of the Night’s coloratura fireworks in The Magic Flute — had completely escaped me at the theater, but now I got it.

That was all well and good, but I didn’t really start to grok Mozart until I took up the reading of orchestral scores. I taught myself score-reading with the Symphonie fantastique by Berlioz, but a few months later I found a score of Mozart’s Symphony No. 40 in G-minor. Looking at the first page, I was struck by the sparsity of the orchestra (when Berlioz is your orchestral template, even a Mozart symphony looks like chamber music by comparison). Even with my fairly untrained eye, I could tell that there was a contrast going on between a quick, but legato, melodic line and a pulsing staccato accompaniment; and what struck me most of all was the total lack of introduction. With this work, you get one bar and then you’re into the melody. I wasn’t used to that.

The first opera I saw was one of Mozart’s — The Magic Flute. It was a performance at Artpark in Lewiston, NY. I haven’t been to many operas since, but that memory is one of my most enduring.

There’s never been a real moment when I suddenly “got” Mozart, no moment of incandescent discovery like that scene in Amadeus when Salieri looks at Mozart’s scores and realizes the depth of the man’s musical gift. He’s just been a presence, always there, always growing.

I’ve never much liked the cliche about Mozart that he “took dictation from God”, because I don’t like the idea that Mozart’s music sprang from some angelic realm, untainted and pure. Rather, Mozart represents the pinnacle (or a pinnacle) of human musical creation. Mozart reminds me, in times of darkness, that humans can create things that are timeless and worthwhile, things that do not require the endorsement of the angels to be worthy.

Figaro, The Magic Flute, Symphonies 40 and 41, the Sinfonia Concertante for violin and viola, the Requiem, the piano sonatas, the clarinet concerto, the piano concertos…all the work of a human genius. I don’t think that we are all capable of creating what Mozart created — that would be absurd — but we should all be capable of seeing the greatness in Mozart’s creation, and it gives comfort in a cold universe to know that there exists a species capable of producing from its numbers, over hundred and even thousands of years, a Mozart.

I guess that’s why I love so much the idea that the Universe is teeming with life and with civilizations, even if many of them are already long dead. I’d hate to think that out of this entire Universe of ours, there’s only been one Mozart.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓