Let Bartlet Be Bartlet

Via Cliff I learn that The West Wing will end this year. This comes as no surprise at all, really, given that NBC this year moved TWW to a really bad time slot on Sunday nights that pretty much forced me to give up the show. (The eight o’clock hour pretty much gets ignored in our home, TV-wise, because of things like bathtime, homework time, and bedtime for The Daughter.) I have seen a handful of episodes this year, and the show’s been doing pretty well. So, to NBC, I say, in the immortal words of Joey Lucas: thbbppppt!

The big question about TWW is just what will be done about the untimely death of John Spencer, who played Leo McGarry on the show. I figure they can either pretend he’s still there and just not show him (and hell, since they’re positing a Vice President figure with a history of nasty heart trouble, they might as well take the next step and posit his ensconcement in a “secure, undisclosed location”), or they can have Leo die on the show and then have Democratic candidate Matt Santos scramble to name a new running mate. I’ve seen some online speculation that Sam Seaborn could come back and fill that role, but personally, I think it would be cool if Toby Ziegler’s ex-wife (a Representative from Maryland) got the nod.

(And it’s worth noting that it isn’t like TWW lacks for precedent in just having characters disappear with no explanation whatsoever — they could have Leo just go off to wherever it is that Season One’s Mandy, a fingernails-on-the-chalkboard character if ever there was one, vanished to on the very night of the assassination attempt on President Bartlet.)

TWW was a favorite show of mine for most of its run, even if I think that the much-derided Season Five was better than most thought at the time and even if I think that Aaron Sorkin started to lose steam early in Season Four (aside from “Twenty Hours in America”, the Bartlet re-election campaign was a snoozer of a storyline). Thus far I only own the first two seasons on DVD, owing to a massive price markdown on them last fall, but I expect I’ll at least pick up the remaining Sorkin seasons at some point, if I find them cheaply.

Anyhow, here’s to The West Wing, which will be missed as NBC starts lurching for something, anything, with ratings.

(You can read about my favorite TWW episodes here, by the way.)

Share This Post

They must be dropping leaflets while flying over Flyover Country

Last month, I noted with puzzlement Steven Den Beste’s strange obsession with Brokeback Mountain* and his great hope that the film tanks at the box office, so that maybe Leftist Hollywood would get the message and stop making those pesky, pro-gay, anti-Christian movies. (Which is a pretty bizarre argument to find originating from an atheist who has long professed to be pro-gay rights, I must admit.) One of SDB’s money-quotes back then was this:

Peoria and Nashville and Des Moines just aren’t interested in LGBT-themed films.

I guess the idea here is that even if Brokeback Mountain somehow manages to have a respectable showing at the box office, it’ll be because of the liberal enclaves on the coasts and not because of Middle America, where people would much rather see explicitly Christian stuff.

Oops:

This weekend the Focus Features film, which stars Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal as hunky star-crossed lovers, will move to about 1,200 screens (up from 684) and reach even more suburban markets. But don’t necessarily expect Brokeback, which has a fairly explicit sex scene with the two men, to ignite widespread heartland protests. So far it has played relatively well outside the traditional coastal city areas where somber indie hits usually rise and fall. Producer James Schamus explains: “What’s driving the gross now is the gigantic numbers from the small and medium-sized cities, not New York and Los Angeles.” He attributes its success to lots of advance, Internet-driven buzz and near-universal critical acclaim.

The article notes the film’s enthusiastic reception in such locales as Salt Lake City, UT; Mason City, IA; and Scottsdale, AZ.

Seeing SDB march in lockstep with the Religious Right is fairly disconcerting — what’s next, advocating the teaching of Intelligent Design? — but it’s pretty clear that he’s chosen the wrong horse here.

* SDB is currently offline, and before he departed, he sounded pretty non-committal about going back online.

Share This Post

Lo! and the Four shall become Two….

It’s Championship Sunday in the NFL! Yup, up for grabs today are the two berths in Super Bowl XL. As a Bills fan, I have a special fondness for Championship Sunday, because it used to be that this was when we’d see our beloved Bills play their best football. (Would that they had saved some football in the tank for those next games….) I liked it better when the NFL had the games around noon and four o’clock, as opposed to around three and one in primetime, but that’s not much to complain about, I suppose.

Some brief football-related ruminations:

:: People often refer to “home field” as being an advantage, but clearly it isn’t. In fact, in thirteen seasons since 1992 (including 1992), AFC teams have only managed to convert a top-seed status into a Super Bowl appearance four times. The NFC has fared a bit better, doing it eight times in the same span, but that’s not a commanding difference. Of course, this year’s AFC top seed is already out, while the NFC’s (Seattle) is still standing. And there hasn’t been a year in which the Super Bowl featured the top seeds of both conferences since 1993 (the second of the two Buffalo-Dallas matchups).

:: The NFC has never sent a wild-card team to the Super Bowl. All 39 NFC champions to date have been division champs. Contrast with the AFC, which just since 1992 has sent four wildcard teams to the Super Bowl, two of which won it (1997 Broncos, 2000 Ravens), one of which came oh-so-close to winning it (1999 Titans), and one of which didn’t come anywhere near winning it (1992 Bills).

:: The last time the Super Bowl featured the road teams from Championship Sunday was in 1997, when Denver beat Pittsburgh at Three Rivers and Green Bay beat the 49ers at Candlestick/3Com before meeting each other in the Super Bowl.

:: Since 1997, the Super Bowl has been won five times by a team that, to that point in its franchise history, had never won a Super Bowl before.

What does any of this mean? Hell, I don’t know. I just think it’s pretty cool trivia.

Here’s something else: in talking to football fans this past week or two, I’ve discovered that a lot of people just loathe Bill Cowher. Now, I don’t know if that’s a bit of residual Buffalo anger there or not (see, there was a power-struggle in the Steelers about six years ago that basically boiled down to either Cowher or then-Steelers GM Tom Donahoe staying and the other being fired, and it was Cowher who won, leading to Donahoe’s coming to the Bills and basically running the ship aground), but it’s there and it always strikes me as a little weird. I like Cowher’s fiery persona, and here’s a guy who gets to watch his roster get shuffled massively seemingly every offseason, and yet with the occasional bad year every four years or so, he just keeps on being competitive and getting to the playoffs.

Cowher coaches today in his sixth AFC Championship Game, and that run is spread out over the last twelve years. Critics point to the fact that despite all those Championship Sunday appearances, Cowher has only managed to make it to one single Super Bowl (a loss to Dallas in 1995), and thus he is tagged as one of those “can’t win the big one” guys. I look at it another way, though: looking at some of the talent he’s had to work with, it’s damned miraculous that he got to those title games at all. Here’s a guy who took Neil O’Donnell to the Super Bowl. Here’s a guy who twice reached the AFC Championship Game with Kordell Stewart under center. If Cowher loses today and then walked away from coaching, I think he’d be mentioned along with Marv Levy and Bud Grant as the greatest coaches who never won the Super Bowl, and he’d probably be inducted into the Hall of Fame.

But of course he’s not going to walk away from coaching after today — win or lose — and right now he’s got the best quarterback he’s ever had, and that guy is only going to get better.

I heard a caller to a Buffalo sports-talk station the other day refer to Cowher as “Billy the Chin”. Well, I’d take Billy the Chin to walk the Bills’ sidelines any day. He’s earned it.

:: OK, I don’t usually make predictions, but what the heck? It’s pretty obvious by now that I’m rooting for the Steelers today, but then, I always root for the Steelers unless they’re playing the Bills (or a Steeler win would impact the Bills adversely in some important way). But I’m not sure I’d predict the Steelers to win.

The problem is that of the four possible Super Bowl matchups that will emerge from today’s games, none strikes me as significantly more probable than the others. Picking Denver and Seattle to both advance is probably safe, but it’s not overwhelmingly safe, and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if when the dust settles we’re watching the Steelers and Panthers heading for Detroit. So I’ll go with my gut and pick the Steelers and Seahawks.

Of course, that’s the same gut that picked the Arizona Cardinals to make the playoffs this year, so I wouldn’t bet the house on my say-so here.

Share This Post

Huh-WHUH??!!

As I’ve noted before, Spiderman is my favorite superhero, by far. I always loved the way this powerful superhero could use the niftiest set of powers ever to defeat the most powerful supervillains, and yet still have a personal life that was always a complete trainwreck. That’s the aspect of the Spiderman/Peter Parker character that the two movies made thus far have best captured — but now, after reading this AICN article, my Spider-sense is tingling.

Why? Because Spiderman 3 will add Gwen Stacy to the mix.

For some reason, Harry Knowles is going ape over the addition of this character:

When Avi Arad called me this morning to discuss the HULK sequel – he let slip that he was intent on calling me today anyway to drop this megabomb of coolnews. He knew that I would friggin love this like no tomorrow! For me, Gwen Stacy is the very embodiment of YOUNG LOVE. She is that teenage girl that dreamt of all those tomorrows that she’d never live. She was the damsel that wasn’t saved. Right when Spidey was getting cocky about web-slinging and soul-saving… he lost another. This one, within his own soul. For serious comics fans, the Gwen Stacy story is sacred text. It is, along with the coming of Galactus – the single greatest Superhero arc of the Silver Age. And it was the exact opposite of that story. FF 48, 49 and 50 were about the story cosmic, this was about the story intimate.

Now, I’ve never been a huge “purist” when it comes to movie versions of books or comics or whatever taking liberties with the original material. I don’t think that Peter Jackson committed a big error by omitting the Scouring of the Shire, and I don’t get too worked up that Mel Gibson basically told a story only slightly tangentially related to history in Braveheart. But this is really problematic for me.

And it didn’t bug me in the first Spiderman movie when Gwen Stacy was not included, and Mary Jane Watson was established right up front as Peter Parker’s first love. What did bug me about that film, though, was the filmmakers’ efforts to have their cake and eat it too. As I wrote at the time:

I conceded above that films of comic book stories have to make hard decisions about which things from the mythology to include and which ones to leave out. In the comics, while Peter did know Mary Jane for years, his first true love was Gwen Stacy, and it was Gwen whom the Green Goblin dangled off the Brooklyn Bridge. However, in the comic, Spiderman failed to save her. The Goblin drops her from the height, and Spiderman snags her with a web, breaking her fall, but she dies in the effort (if she was alive to begin with). This was Peter Parker’s second great life lesson: not just that “With great power comes great responsibility”, but that “Sometimes great power just isn’t enough”. The death of Gwen Stacy was just as important to the Spiderman character as the death of Uncle Ben, and as such to see the events of her death replayed in the film — but with Mary Jane, this time, and with Spiderman saving the girl — created in me a sort of “cognitive dissonance” that I just couldn’t get around. I can understand why the filmmakers would omit Gwen Stacy from their story of Peter Parker’s life, just as I can understand why the filmmakers of Superman would omit Lana Lang, but Gwen Stacy is far more important to Spiderman than Lana Lang is to Superman. I might have been able to accept a Spiderman who was never in love with Gwen Stacy, but in giving me Gwen’s death without Gwen and without the death, the film basically kept reminding me of her. For me, it was the Big White Elephant in the room. Under some circumstances, I can be made to ignore it — but not if you’re going to point my chair at the elephant and have the beast nuzzle me with its trunk.

They wanted the dramatic tension of the dilemma Peter Parker faced just before Gwen’s death, but without actually killing anyone, which was bad enough. As we now know from watching the movies, Peter Parker is with Mary Jane Watson. So what purpose will Gwen Stacy serve in the new film? We’ve had two movies of Peter and MJ; how can we possibly buy, in a single film (in which MJ will also appear), Peter’s love for Gwen? How can Gwen’s death possibly be as dramatically potent as it was in the comics?

Of course, it’s possible that Gwen won’t die in the movie, which would quite frankly piss me off too — or maybe the filmmakers plan a role-reversal of sorts, and have Mary Jane die despite Peter Parker’s efforts to save her. But I frankly can’t imagine how either one of those options would be anything other than a big cheat.

Maybe it can work. Maybe. But I’m not feeling good about it. Some things you can get away with; some things you can’t. This will almost certainly have the same feel to me that the X-Factor comic had when it “revealed” that Jean Grey had never died because that hadn’t been her that committed suicide on the Moon after all.

Yeah, my Spider sense is tingling, all right.

Share This Post

The Internet is made of people

That’s become one of my very favorite aphorisms (coined, I believe, by Warren Ellis), and last night I got to meet a bunch of the people behind the screens. It was the second meeting of citizens from the Buffalo Prefecture of Blogistan, and after missing the first incarnation, I am supremely happy to have made the second. I hope it’s not as long until the next one, folks!

I would try to link everyone I met last night, but in truth I lost track a little bit and I know I’d miss some one (“Hey! He doesn’t remember meeting me?! DAMN HIM!”), so if you check Alan’s or Jen’s rundowns (hey, Jen — the link to your comments threads, minus the part of the URL that says “#comments”, is your permalink, if that helps!), I met all those folks. And they’re great people, every one.

What was funny was to note that people do actually sound like their blogs! Erin talked a bit about Arrested Development; Jen talked about a relationship she’s in that started with the advent of the 2005 NFL season, which has her nervous what they’ll talk about once the Super Bowl is over; Alan talked about parking lots and diesel cars and The Amazing Race and why it’s stupid to pay thousands in rent in the “cool kids” cities when you can get a house for that in Buffalo; Cliff — whom I had never before met, and whose blog I had to Google this morning — riffed on so much pop-culture stuff that I frequently lost track (but I cheered inwardly when he endorsed my positive view of The Phantom Menace; Kevin and Val are just a great, great couple. (Although when they walked in, I thought, “Why are Christopher Lloyd and Bonnie Raitt here?” Oooooh, that one’s gonna get me in trouble — but seriously, I could listen to them talk all night. At the mere mention of the fact that they got married in Vegas by an Elvis who spoke in a tenor, I was hooked.) And despite listening to WGR-550 sports radio on the drive into downtown, I actually learned that the Bills had talked to Dom Capers about their head coaching vacancy from the BFLOBlog guys (one of whom I now owe one beer — I’ll make good on that next time, Kevin).

Special kudos to Jen, who not only greeted me on sight as soon as I emerged from the stairs, but who was also apparently quite concerned about the possibility that I might show up for such an event wearing something other than overalls. Well, perish that thought! (Photos of everyone here.) Although I should warn folks that if we have a summer meet-up, I’ll most likely wear boring, regular shorts. Summer is too hot for overalls.

If I regret anything about last night, it’s that I didn’t quite block out enough time and that I didn’t get to talk to everyone. Next time I’ll try to stay later. It would also be nice if I’m not nursing a sinus headache next time out — that’s pretty much why I stayed rooted to a single spot. Damned sinuses! Oh, and next time I’ll actually use the digital camera that I brought, instead of forgetting that I had it with me at all. Oops. There it sat, in my coat pocket the entire night.

Like many folks, I have some blogroll updating to do this weekend. Meeting everyone was a great experience, and I can’t wait for the next one! (Maybe I should start scouting out a Southtowns location for one of these….)

UPDATE: In comments, LCScotty suggests a summer blog picnic at Chestnut Ridge or someplace similar. I like that idea — we could do a “potluck” kind of thing. Shall we pencil that in for an August or early September get-together?

UPDATE II (Saturday, 21 January): The other night, whilst discussing various pop-culture items with Cliff (whose curse it is to discuss such things), he insisted that he was NOT hallucinating when he was channel-surfing one day and found some kind of Care Bears show on which the bears were discussing “acid reflux”. Well, a bit of Googling bears him out (no pun intended):

THE CARE BEARS BIG WISH MOVIE, not rated, 2005, $19.98 VHS and DVD; age 2-4.

This film succeeds in bringing new faces to the Care Bear family. Wish Bear is the niece of Wish-a-Lot Bear and is also a lucky bear. She has direct access to making her wishes come true, thanks to her friend Twinkers. Wish Bear ends up taking advantage of this genie-like pal while trying to impress a trio of new friends, Too-Loud Bear, Me Bear and Messy Bear, who exhibit the traits described in their names and mistakenly believe wishing can replace working. Equilibrium is restored with cute scenes and musical numbers.

The movie falls short because attempts to appeal to older viewers—such as with a joke about acid reflux—don’t work. (emphasis added)

Oh, and I was just digging a bit through the archives at Cliff’s blog, and I found this item:

Western boots and hats and shirts will never take off in Blue States, especially when the consensus is that the Red States are entirely to blame for our current situation. Dressing like a Hee Haw extra is the equivelent of saying “they won,” and will be dealt with accordingly…

I’m trying to figure out if I should stand up for people who dress like Hee Haw extras, or if I should try to insist somehow that I don’t dress like a Hee Haw extra, the overalls notwithstanding. (I mean, you don’t see anybody on Hee Haw wearing them over sweaters or the like — it’s all-flannel, all-the-time on that show, and to my knowledge I have never owned anything flannel.)

Share This Post

Arcs

John takes exception to something somebody said somewhere (actually, it was a producer from 24, in a Slate interview) about the popularity of serialization and ongoing storylines on TV series these days. John lists, as evidence, the most popular dramas on TV and notes the lack of story arcs or serialization on them.

Now, I haven’t watched all of these shows, but I do have to point out that the CSI series, while generally self-contained from episode to episode, actually do feature story arcs on a regular basis. Those series tend to keep their story arcs well in the background (and wisely so, avoiding the mistake many such shows make when they allow the soap opera to overwhelm), but the arcs are most definitely there: Gil Grissom’s struggle against deafness; Catherine Willow’s coming to terms with her own past; and others. CSI: New York seems to have the least, in terms of story arcs, but there are a few percolating away once in a while; and that show is offset by CSI: Miami, which has tons of arcs going all the time, including one giant set of arcs, potentially constituting three “trilogies” that will each unfold over three seasons each, about the past of Horatio Caine.

Sitcoms of today also tend to involve continuity, if not actual serialization and story arcs. Frasier and Friends led the way — maybe even led by Cheers — and that torch is carried on by Joey, Scrubs, Will & Grace, and more.

It’s certainly overstating the case to say that every show these days involves story arcs and serialization, but it’s a most definite trend. (I haven’t watched Without a Trace, Cold Case, NCIS, or Criminal Minds, so I can’t comment on whether or not those series blend arcs with their self-contained procedurals.)

Share This Post

The Rev.

In comments to my post yesterday about NOLA mayor Ray Nagin, Will Duquette makes the point that nobody takes Pat Robertson seriously anymore. I certainly agree that Robertson is nowhere near in stature what he was in the early 1990s, when his Christian Coalition basically provided the engine that gave the Republicans the control of Congress for the first time in forty years, but he’s not just some weirdo shouting into the wind, either.

Matthew Yglesias made the same point some months back:

Robertson is far less influential than he once was, and isn’t in a position to pull strings among conservative elites in Washington, but he’s good a big audience and can’t just be written off as meaningless. Certainly in a world where rightwingers seem to think it’s fair to attribute Michael Moore’s movies to the leadership of the Democratic Party, it’s worth being a bit concerned about the Rev. Robinson’s views. It should also be noted that the leaders whose star has risen as Robertson’s has fallen aren’t exactly paragons of good sense themselves. Take a look around the website of James Dobson’s slick and hyper-influential Focus on the Family and you’ll see what I mean.

Matthew also links an essay by Byron York, that illuminates this. I found this interesting:

According to Nielsen Media Research, The 700 Club, aired each weekday, has averaged 863,000 viewers in the last year. While that is not enough to call it a popular program, it is still a significant audience. It is, for example, more than the average primetime audience for CNN last month — 713,000 viewers — or MSNBC, which averaged 280,000 viewers in prime time. It is also greater than the viewership of CNBC and Headline News.

The guy may not be driving policy and political discussion, but he’s not just some harmless flake saying stuff that everybody by consensus agrees to be stupid.

Share This Post

Tristan and Isolde

I saw this film with The Wife last weekend. I was a bit apprehensive about it, owing to the largely negative reviews it has received, but Ebert and a few other critics I like recommended it, and I was in the mood for a “chick-flick for the LOTR set”, so there we were.

And now I’m wondering if the negative critics saw the same movie I did. I loved it.

Now, this isn’t a great movie, by any means; if you approach this film intending to judge how well it tells the ancient story of Tristan and Isolde with Wagner’s titanic opera Tristan und Isolde as your benchmark, well, let me save you the time. It’s just a basic, good old fashioned medieval tragic romance with characters locked into their required actions by their station but also unable to resist the passions that should be beneath them.

Most of the reviews I’ve read pan the film’s acting, but I couldn’t find a bad performance here. The mood tends to be fairly subdued, but never boring, and I for one had no difficulty at all believing that Tristan was in love with Isolde and she with him, or that King Mark was a good man caught in the middle of a terrible triangle, and so on.

The film keeps a fairly tight and intimate focus. Despite lots of court intrigue, the “courts” tend to be very small affairs, and locations named in the film as “castles” look more like tiny villages clustered around small keeps. This tight focus keeps the relatively small cast front and center, with the result that the film’s intrigues are complex and yet never hard to follow. Even better is the fact that the film’s characters all act in ways that are logical to them, with no one just being evil for the sake of being evil. Unintended betrayals occur because they can’t be stopped; intended betrayals backfire horribly; characters find themselves in bad situations and strive to get out of them, only to find things getting worse despite their best efforts.

I found the film’s overall look very fine indeed, as lush locations are photographed in a washed-out fashion to enhance the cold atmosphere of post-Roman Britain, and I even liked the score by Anne Dudley, which utilizes an intimate approach that eschews the large brassy fanfares and sweeping themes of typical epic fare for a more subdued tone, often utilizing solo violins and winds, and also underplaying the Celtic sounds one might otherwise expect from a film with this subject matter. Dudley’s score takes an approach that is closer to Carter Burwell’s effort on Rob Roy than, say, James Horner’s approach to scoring Braveheart, and it’s nowhere near the kind of epic score Howard Shore wrote for The Lord of the Rings.

In the case of Tristan and Isolde, I am truly mystified by the critical response, and I wonder if many critics aren’t simply predisposed against this kind of movie. It is, as I said above, a chick-flick for the LOTR set, but I like the occasional chick-flick and I’m certainly a member of the LOTR set, so I’m good.

Share This Post

A non-cautionary cautionary tale

Craig reports that Ray Nagin, Mayor of New Orleans, said something really stupid about Hurricane Katrina being a punishment sent by God. Since Pat Robertson made a similar statement at the time the hurricane struck, Craig predicts that this will be yet another example of the liberal “Mainstream Media” (MSM) trumpeting something stupid said by a conservative but ignoring something stupid said by a liberal.

Well, setting aside the obvious fact that Pat Robertson is a tad more important a national figure than Ray Nagin and is thus a lot more likely to make the news when he says something colossally stupid (and since now he basically says that God will punish anyone who disagrees with him — Pat, that is, not God — any time anybody anywhere disagrees with Pat), I just did a tiny bit of Googling and found that Craig’s crickets were, in fact, not chirping after all: the Houston Chronicle, the New York Daily News, the LA Times, the Washington Post, the CNN, and BET.

They’re giving Nagin just about all the attention he deserves. More so, even.

(And here’s one of the more prominent liberal blogs blasting away at Nagin:

Nagin told the crowd that he also asked, “Why is black-on-black crime such an issue? Why do our young men hate each other so much that they look their brother in the face and they will take a gun and kill him in cold blood?”

Good question, Ray. Not that you — or Kathleen Blanco — were doing anything to really tackle these problems in New Orleans before Katrina, with its corrupt police, terrible schools, and a disproportionately poor and underemployed population that made it a toxic social gumbo. These are complex problems that have no easy answer, but it’s clear nothing serious had been done for years.

Anyone that thought Nagin wants to deal with the issue of the underprivileged in his city post-Katrina is smoking something. Too many on the Left gave him a pass during the hurricane — the bottom line is that the mayor couldn’t identify with someone that couldn’t get a ride out of town because of classism and incompetence.

I really don’t think that Ray Nagin’s ineptitude is a secret that the MSM is trying to keep hidden.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓