The silencing of a voice

Michael Lopez is closing down his blog. I can’t argue with his reasons, since they’re personal reasons and you can’t really argue with the personal, but I’ll miss reading him. I didn’t agree with him all that often, but he was a very thoughtful poster who managed to create the best kind of disagreement: the kind where I say to myself, “Self, I disagree with that, but why?”

Michael promises to post something each day for the next week, and then he’ll be pulling the plug — apparently going so far as to delete the blog entirely. Well, I hope he at least saves his archives locally; he’s generated too much material that I think he has every right to be proud of, even if he’s now loathe to have it permanently available as a matter of Internet record.

I also hope that his retirement as an active blogger doesn’t also signal his retirement as an active blog reader. And who knows, blogging can go in any number of directions: witness Steven Den Beste, who hung up his hat as a political blogger and instead went off to blog about nothing but anime. Maybe Michael will be back in some other form, after he’s either recharged the batteries or found some new batteries.

But anyway, spend some time looking through the archives over at Highered Intelligence. There’s a lot of good food for thought over there.

Share This Post

Yup, I like that one too…and that one….I know all the words to that one….crap.

Michele at ASV has a list of the most overrated songs in history, with lengthy commentary after each one. It’s a really fun post to read (as is usually the case with Michele), even if I feel slightly dirty in still liking a lot of these songs. Here are her songs, with a few responses of my own:

1. Led Zeppelin – Stairway to Heaven. Maybe part of why I like this song a lot is due to the fact that I’ve never really been one to study the meanings of lyrics. I just love this song’s structure: you can barely feel the constant upping of the tempo over ten minutes or however long it is. I just think it’s brilliant.

2. Don McLean – American Pie Yeah, it’s self-important, unintelligible gobbledygook. But I still like it, for some reason I’m unable to illuminate. McLean’s other songs make me wince. That one about Vincent Van Gogh is just treacle.

3. Lynyrd Skynyrd – Freebird Believe it or not, I’ve only heard this song a few times in my life. I gotta get out more. I like it, but I don’t know it well enough to form an opinion on whether it’s overrated.

4. Eagles – Hotel California I like this song, but I’m unimpressed when people tell me they know all its words. Sure, the song is eight minutes, but there’s a minute of intro followed by three minutes of lyrics followed by four more minutes of guitar solo that only sounds good on the original recording. (Don’t believe me? Listen to the exact same solo as played on the Hell Freezes Over reunion album. Ick.)

5. Meatloaf – Paradise by the Dashboard Light. Michele closes a lengthy diatribe about this song (which includes some really creepy descriptions of what happens when this song comes on the DJ’s playlist at a wedding reception) with stating that she can’t see anything redeeming about it. And she’s probably right, since its lyrics portray the Artist As Disgusting Emotional Troll. But I guess that’s what I like about it: that Meat Loaf made this gigando-hit out of a song that has him stand up, arena-rock style, and shout for all the world to hear, “I am a complete pig, and how do ya like that!” It’s sort of admirable in that Archie Bunker kind of way, I guess. And I have to like that while other self-important rock acts were making epic songs out of incomprehensible poetry (see above), Meat Loaf is making a nine-minute epic out of a fifteen-year-old’s one-night-stand at Inspiration Point. He’s saying “You guys sing about a bustle in your hedgerow and stabbing things with your steely knives and cryptic shit about plane crashes outside Clearlake, Iowa. I’m gonna sing about the time I got lucky and dumped her the next day.” Redeeming? No. Refreshing? A little.

6. Guns N Roses – November Rain Michele says that bad things happen when you diss GNR, but bring it on: I never once liked GNR. Hated ’em from the first time I heard “Sweet Child of Mine”. Why, you might ask? Well, I think that Slash is a brilliant guitarist; love his work. The drummer and bass player seem OK (although no Alex VH or Michael Anthony). The problem with every GNR song is this: sooner or later Axl Rose starts singing, and at that moment my nerves instantly curl up. Seriously. The man’s nasal delivery, coupled with his metal-esque tendency to blend singing with shouting, is to me the musical equivalent of when a large metal cabinet is dragged across a smooth concrete floor.

For this reason I have never owned a single GNR album, and I never will.

7. The Beatles – Hey Jude God almighty, I hate this song. I’ve never actually been much of a Beatles fan anyway. I tend, with almost no exception that I know of, to like their songs best when they’re performed by anyone else, but as an actual act in themselves I always get this feeling that they’re either a bubble-gum band just treading water until they can get to the business of revolutionizing music forever, or that they’re in full music-revolutionary phase which turns me off anyway. But “Hey Jude” is just an annoying, unending, interminable piece of crap. I hate it well before the four minutes of “Na na na na na na na na na na na na na na” begins, and that part of the song just makes me cringe.

8. Bruce Springsteen – Born to Run in the USA in his Glory Days. I like Bruce. Oh well. I don’t like “Born in the USA” much, delivering its message as it does with all the subtlety of a brick through a plate-glass window, and “Glory Days” suffers from the same back-end fault that afflicts “Hey Jude”, only in Bruce’s case it’s four minutes of “Well ALL RIGHT! Come ON NOW! Well ALL RIGHT! Come ON NOW!” But “Dancing in the Dark” is cool; I liked his song for the movie Philadelphia way more than I actually liked the movie Philadelphia; and I do like that 9-11 themed album he did a few years back (although I suspect Michele hates it). Anyway, I like Springsteen’s voice. I like it when rock stars sing with a voice that sounds like it’s been through too many years of riding a bus and drinking bourbon.

Here are a few additions of my own:

“Spinning Wheel”, Blood Sweat and Tears. I don’t know what I hate more: the insipid lyrics, the awful brass chords that punctuate the song, or the “Carousel band on drugs” that closes the song. The whole thing stinks. I hate it.

“I Swear”, All For One. Ah, yes — summer 1994, when I would work a shift at Pizza Hut and hear this g**damn song at least eight times in the space of a single night. (Yes, I counted once. Eight is accurate.) And if somebody took mercy and changed the radio to the country station, it didn’t matter because some country artist did the same song the same year! Ugh. Anyway, the song is like eating the world’s biggest fresh-baked chocolate chip cookie without any milk at hand to wash it down.

Any song by Aerosmith that had a video starring Alicia Silverstone. Especially whichever one had her rigging up a stuntman gizmo so she could appear to be committing suicide by jumping off a bridge, but then give her boyfriend the finger while she dangles on her safety harness above a busy freeway. Yeah, right. Or the one where she goes off for a night of debauchery with some other chick and steals a farmboy’s pants. I like Alicia Silverstone just fine, but these songs were overwrought crud.

“Losing My Religion”, REM. Now, it’s not a bad song by any means. But did it really warrant airplay on par with Elton John’s “Candle in the Wind — Princess Diana version”? I don’t think so. And all those playings of “Losing My Religion” kept “Everybody Hurts” off the air. (At least in my town.)

“New York, New York”. This song does two things: first, it brings out the inner Sinatra that everybody thinks they have. And the problem with that, of course, is that the song also proves what should be obvious: that nobody actually has an inner Sinatra. That’s why there was only one Sinatra. I tend to really dislike songs that get adopted by every drunk in a given room. Which brings me to….

“Sweet Caroline”, Neil Diamond. Full disclosure: it’s a lot of fun to be in a bar full of drunken patrons when this songs comes up on the jukebox. Equally full disclosure: the song is pedestrian, at best, in any venue where alcohol is not involved. What’s funny, though, is that two generations of drunks singing this song have elevated those three descending brass notes in the chorus to actually being part of the lyrics. No longer does the song go like this:

Sweet caroline
Good times never seemed so good
I’ve been inclined
To believe they never would

No, it now actually goes like this:

Sweet caroline BUM BUM BUMMM!
Good times never seemed so good
I’ve been inclined BUM BUM BUMMM!
To believe they never would

“Brown Eyed Girl”, Van Morrison. I love this song. But it’s most certainly overrated, if its airplay as compared to the airplay of other, better Van Morrison songs is taken into account.

OK, enough of those for now. I’ll leave off, though, with a funny joke I read on the MeFi thread I referenced in this post from yesterday:

Question: What did the Dead Head say when he ran outta dope?

Answer: “What is this crap we’re listening to?”

Bada-bing!

Share This Post

Sentential Links #9

Good sentences from better posts for the week just gone by.

:: Still, no gift, however generous, can possibly make up for the empty feeling with which we say farewell to the kindly men and women who once upon a time helped to show us what we were. (Mr. Teachout, with all due respect, if you’ve got it in you to write like this — and you damned well do — then please oh please, stop wishing you could write as well as James Lileks. It’s Lileks who should be coming to you for pointers.)

:: A secret: I fall a little in love with nearly every woman that I meet. Just a little – sometimes only for five minutes, sometimes forever. (And I thought that I was the only one who did that. This isn’t actually from a blog post, but it is from a blog, so it counts.)

:: I mean we all stop dead in our tracks while walking to grab that piece of paper to write down a great idea, or line, or story, or thing to do, or thing to blog. Or is it just me? I wonder who else will be found guilty! (Guilty as charged. I’m constantly thinking up stuff. Some of it is just observational stuff to use in stories, some of it gets put into blog posts, some stuff just percolates around within my cranium. I think that this practice is one thing that marks one as a Writer-At-Heart.)

:: The authority of evolution is derived not from any edicts, there is no Central Committee, nor is there any Great Man who defines it all for us (concepts which are exceedingly hard to get across to creationists), but instead, it is derived from a great many experiments and observations of the natural world.

:: At approximately 7 pm EDT this evening, I left my office (5 blocks from the White House) to board the subway at Metro Center (2.5 blocks from the White House) to travel 12 minutes to walk 2 blocks to get home. During my journey, I saw not one sniffing dog. Not one meter maid. NOT A SINGLE COP. (Actually, that’s the entire text of Roxanne’s post. I hope she doesn’t mind.)

:: The Home Run Derby has now gotten so out of hand that a crappy post-grunge band, Alter Bridge, a derivative remnant of the highly derivative band Creed, will now perform at the Derby. (How behind the times am I? I’m not sure I’ve ever heard anything by Creed, but all I know is that everyone who has ever mentioned Creed to me has also used the word “sucks” in the same sentence.)

:: The flypaper theory is dead and buried. (New redesign for Demosthenes’s blog, by the way, which happens to be the first liberal political blog I ever read.)

:: There sure are a lot of different versions of Diet Coke these days, aren’t there? (Yup, there are. And once again, the Blogger With Millions o’Hits posts about something that the Blogger With Hundreds o’Hits touched on two weeks ago. I’m just sayin’.)

:: Seriously, can anyone name a film adaptation that was superior to the book? (Yes, I can. The Bridges of Madison County.)

:: Can you tell catfish bother me a little bit? (There were about seven or eight sentences I could have chosen from this post, whose only wrong point is that Mississippi is not in the Midwest. It’s in the South. The Upper Delta region might be termed in the Midwest, ranging as far north as the southeast portion of Missouri and the southern tip of Illinois. But as to that, it’s worth noting that Cairo, Illinois is farther south than Richmond, Virginia. Yes, Cairo’s in the same state as Chicago, which is most definitely a Midwest city, but consider: Buffalo is in the same state as New York City, but Buffalo’s certainly not a Northeast city; we’re a Great Lakes city, and it’s about 293 miles from here to NYC. From Chicago to Cairo is even farther than that: about 348 miles, according to this site. But that’s just a mere quibble. This is a wonderful post. Go read it.)

That’s all for now. Remember, there will be no Sentential Links next week, because I won’t be linking much of anything next week. (By the way, it just occurred to me that with the exception of my two moves, from Buffalo to Syracuse and back again, this will be the first real hiatus since this blog began which shall also involve a period of inconsistent Net access. What on Earth will I do!)

Share This Post

Too young for the long, strange trip.

This MeFi thread commemorates the ten-year anniversary of the last concert played by the Grateful Dead. I was never a Deadhead, having come of age too late to know what that scene was all about, but I remember hearing the news of Jerry Garcia’s death on MTV one day in 1995.

Last week, Buffalo News rock critic Jeff Miers wrote this review of a CD/DVD package from a concert the Dead gave at Buffalo’s Rich Stadium (now Ralph Wilson Stadium) in 1989.

More than just another release from the ample Dead vaults, “Truckin'” celebrates what fans, band members, Dead archivists and historians are calling one of the finest shows the band performed in its last decade together. The release also cements the Dead’s long-held love for upstate New York, a relationship that yielded some now-historic – indeed, mythical – shows in cities such as Albany, Ithaca, Syracuse, Rochester and Buffalo.

“There is no question in my mind that Western New York brought out the best in the Dead,” says the band’s official audio and visual archivist, David Lemieux, speaking to The News from the Dead’s San Francisco office last week.

“There’s a few reasons for this. First, cities like Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and so forth were among the first to embrace the Dead, going all the way back to the beginning. The band always preferred playing these cities to the bigger places like New York City, for example. There was just a rich history of connection with people upstate, and in Western New York in particular.

“Second, how well they played, and how often they played in places like Buffalo created a lasting impact on those areas, a fan base that was incredibly large and incredibly loyal. When you watch the “Truckin” DVD, you can see on all of the band members’ faces how pleased they were with the gig.”

Dennis McNally, longtime Dead publicist and author of the definitive band biography, “Long Strange Trip,” sees other reasons for the undeniable strength of the band’s Rich Stadium performance.

“That particular show is one of the high points from the period immediately following Jerry Garcia’s collapse and his slipping into a diabetic coma, and subsequent miraculous recovery,” McNally says.

“Like any sane person would do, the band members hit their knees – metaphorically, at least, if not literally – and said “Thank you’ to whatever it is that they believe in. There was the very real sense that Jerry was glad to be alive, and the other guys were so relieved that he was still there, that they could still do this together, that it wasn’t all over. As a result, I think they took it very seriously. There was definitely a feeling of, “Let’s be damned good every night.’ So, as you can see and hear from the Rich Stadium show, there was an energy and a joy in the performance. They had a song in their hearts.”

That joy in the collective musical experience was apparent during the Rich Stadium show, from the opening moments of “Bertha,” through a career-high take on “Not Fade Away” and a celebratory encore of “U.S. Blues.”

I may have to look into getting this thing.

Share This Post

The Dole (and not the pineapple company, either)

There’s a blogger from Rome, NY who codifies his frustration with his hometown in his blog’s title, Rome, NY Sucks. He’s a staunch conservative who, while enormously frustrated with the economic morass that is New York State (where, if you’re anywhere outside New York City or Yonkers, the state government is as reluctant to admit your existence as the Department of Defense is to admit that of Area 51), has stuck around and tried to make a go of it. Kudos to him for that, but the lack of jobs in his town has taken its toll, and now he’s very likely applying for public assistance.

Now, given that Romey (sorry, but I got nothing else to call you!) is a conservative who seriously dislikes public assistance stuff, he finds himself in a philosophical quandary:

Here’s some interesting questions. Can you still be conservative and on government assistance? Does your opposition to handouts make you unworthy to receive them? Is it hypocrisy to be one of the people you criticize? I’d tend to say no.

I’d also say no, for all the various reasons, most of which are cited in the comments thread to his post. There’s the “You paid your taxes, so in a way this is your right” argument, which I don’t have a problem with at all. But there’s something else: I also paid my taxes, and this is part of what I have been paying for. So, if you need to do this to get by for now, I have no problem whatsoever with it.

I’ve never been one to feel moral outrage for when people use their public assistance funds to buy anything other than Ramen Noodles and milk or whatever the cheapest subsistence-level stuff available happens to be. (Not including cigarettes and alcohol, of course.) In fact, I feel rather the reverse whenever I’m in a store checkout line and I overhear someone griping about what the person on public assistance is buying: “How can they get away with buying ice cream on Welfare? How dare they?” Well, I don’t know the welfare recipient’s life story, do I? I’m not going to jump to moral outrage without knowing what’s going on. Maybe they’re abusing the system, but in my experience, they’re very likely not. They’re unlucky, in that (a) they are unqualified for what few jobs there are; (b) those jobs don’t pay enough to live on; and (c) they lack the means to either get qualified for whatever good jobs exist (and in these parts there aren’t too many of those, either) or to move to where the better jobs are for which they are qualified.

I tend to find the assumption behind the disdain for people on public assistance to be that getting a good job is like shopping for toothpaste at Target: you just pick the brand that works best for you and off you go. You hear it in the rhetoric: “Learn some skills, dumbass.” “Go to where the jobs are, you slacker.” It just isn’t that easy, and if there’s a tendency by some (fewer, I suspect, than many believe) to use the safety net as a hammock, I find that preferable to allowing every falling person to plummet to the pavement by removing the safety net entirely.

Some evidently think that not only should society not provide a safety net on a moral basis, but that it is also immoral for a person to accept aid from any safety net that exists. I reject this view as well. I myself was on Unemployment for over a year, and without it, my family would have suffered greatly. And Little Quinn receives assistance from Medicaid that covers treatments that our employer-provided health insurance would not: his various therapies, for instance, without which he would be little better than an immobile child with little hope of recovery; or the in-home nursing assistance, which provides a trained medical professional to watch over him while I’m at work. To say that there is a moral fault in accepting this assistance is, to me, absurd; I would claim that it would have been morally negligent for us not to accept it. What were the alternatives? Look around for employers whose insurance plans might provide better coverage? and then work for the usual required year of service before the insurance kicked in, a year during which Little Quinn’s prospects for improvement would have been set back immeasurably? for me (the secondary income) to stop working again? Not in this lifetime. We were stretched thin on a single income with one healthy child. Our heads are above water, and it’s because of the state assistance we’ve accepted.

Do we like dealing with the state, and its mishmash of regulatory agencies and requirements? No. But we had no choice, and in a way, I’m glad, because I’m very wary of trusting the market to help in situations like ours.

I guess I just have trouble faulting individual people who are on public assistance, because they’re people, and I can’t look into their hearts. Nor can they look into mine. And that’s not changing.

Share This Post

What’s this movie about?

Brad DeLong watched Casablanca recently, and notes as follows:

It is a fact that we are nine minutes into the movie “Casablanca” before we first catch sight of Humphrey Bogart. And we are twenty-five minutes into the movie before we catch sight of Ingrid Bergman, or of the third headliner, Paul Henried.

…

Would anything like that happen today? Would anyone in Hollywood today construct a movie in which the female lead is offstage for nearly the first half-hour? Would anyone in Hollywood today construct a movie in which the first ten minutes are starless?

Well, let’s consider a few.

I’m not sure if the original Star Wars counts as “modern”, since it’s twenty-eight years old, but given that first film’s Campbellian structure, it’s notable that we don’t meet our hero, Luke Skywalker, until about twenty minutes into the film. (In fact, this is interesting in that George Lucas originally shoehorned some additional stuff about Luke into the film’s opening act on the advice of his friends and later rejected it because it mucked up his intended story structure. People are always saying of Lucas, “Geez, if he only had someone around to tell him how bad his ideas are.” Well, here’s a case where he was absolutely right to ignore them.)

The same year, we didn’t meet Roy Neary until a similar amount of running time had passed in Close Encounters of the Third Kind.

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring may be a special case, since it opens with some background narration before we meet Frodo. But then, Casablanca also opens with some background narration. And in the Extended Edition, it’s even longer before we meet Frodo: in the theatrical release, we cut from Galadriel’s narration to Frodo sitting against a tree, where in the EE we have Bilbo telling us what Hobbits are.

Going back before Star Wars, there’s Jaws. We meet Chief Brody pretty early on — the first five minutes, I think — but Matt Hooper doesn’t show up until quite a while later, and aside from a brief scene during a town meeting, Quint arrives even later than that.

Twenty minutes or so of running time elapses in Princess Mononoke before we meet the female lead, although the male lead is introduced in the first two minutes of the film.

A special note must be made of Titanic‘s story structure. (And stop laughing, dammit. That movie was freaking brilliant.) We open with some lengthy expository material set in the present day, some of which is grounded by our introduction to the female lead — but eighty years after the film’s main story has taken place. Then we jump backward to 1912, where we meet the heroine at the age of the story. And then five minutes after that we finally meet the male lead, Jack Dawson. (No, the glimpse of his eyes as Old Rose flashbacks to the drawing of her nude sketch doesn’t count.)

And in Amadeus, we don’t actually meet Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart until around fifteen minutes in, after we’ve already become well acquainted with Antonio Salieri. (This might not be a good example, actually, since the main character of Amadeus is actually Salieri and not Mozart.)

Damn, this was a fascinating question on Prof. DeLong’s part!

Share This Post

I should just rename this blog “The Quiz Place” and be done with it.

Yup, here’s another of those damned quiz things I can’t resist for the life of me. I’ve stolen this one from Erin.

10 years ago: Unmarried, working at Pizza Hut, no Internet access, no DVD player. But at least Braveheart and Rob Roy came out that year.

5 years ago: Minus a few months, we moved to Buffalo.

1 year ago: I was supremely worried about whether I could be a decent male role model for a baby boy. Little did I know that this was something I didn’t have to worry about after all.

Yesterday: I consumed a mocha freeze with two shots of espresso at break time, a salad at lunch time, and a burger with steak fries for dinner. Watched an hour or so of The Two Towers.

Today: Got the hair trimmed (don’t worry, just an inch or so to tidy up the ends and shave the back of the neck); went to Target to get a new memory card for the digital camera (128 MB, should hold 100 or so photos); grocery shopping later (very small run this week, since we’ll be gone after Tuesday); a load or two of laundry; hopefully kicking The Daughter outside; watching something tonight on TV; starting a new story; choosing books and CDs for the trip.

Tomorrow: Going to church (outdoor services during July); more laundry; reading the paper; packing. Starting a new temp assignment.

5 snacks I enjoy: Combos. (Thanks for mentioning these, Erin — now I gotta buy some today.) Red licorice. Zapp’s potato chips. Fruit: apples, nectarines, white peaches. Those bulk trail-mixes with M&Ms, peanuts, raisins, chocolate chips and dried fruit.

5 bands that I know the lyrics of MOST of their songs: None that I know that well, sadly, but I’ll name Van Halen, Pink Floyd, Zepellin, Elton John (I know, not a band) and Kilbrannan (my favorite local act; I gotta catch ’em live one of these years).

5 things I would do with $100,000,000: (Note to self: This reminds me of an idea for a post I’ve been knocking around for a while.) Eliminate debt. Buy a home on some land in the Southtowns. Put a chunk away for retirement. Put a chunk away for The Daughter’s college education. Secure the best therapy for Little Quinn that $50,000,000 can buy. Blow the rest on chicks and beer and DVDs and stuff.

5 locations I’d like to run away to: I can’t honestly answer this one, because where I’d want to run would be a function of where certain people were.

5 bad habits I have: Eating too damn much. Not writing enough fiction. Looking at my damn SiteMeter. Using “damn” in every sentence. Overcooking my red meat (but this one will right itself as I get practiced again).

5 things I like doing: Buying and reading books. Buying and watching DVDs. Buying and listening to CDs. Eating. Walking.

5 things I would never wear: Tank tops. Basketball jerseys. Those “low-riding” jeans. Baseball caps (unless required by work). Contact lenses.

5 TV shows I like: Scrubs, The West Wing (Say, didn’t anyone notice how Season Six ends with the Democrats nominating a guy with a history of serious heart trouble for Vice President? Like that would ever happen!), CSI (the original’s my favorite, although I like the others), American Idol (sue me), The Apprentice (ditto).

5 movies I like: Staying away from the obvious ones: Breakfast at Tiffany’s, Captain Blood, The Last of the Mohicans, Princess Mononoke, Schindler’s List (it bugs me how Saving Private Ryan, a vastly inferior film, has overshadowed Schindler’s List in popular opinion).

5 famous people I’d like to meet: Limiting myself to just the living ones: George Lucas, Peter Jackson, Howard Shore, Guy Gavriel Kay, and Bill Clinton.

5 biggest joys at the moment: Sigh…a well-shaped tune, a well-told story, the friend who listens, the friend who talks (sometimes they’re even the same people), my workplace.

5 favorite toys: The computer, the digital camera, the CD player(s), the DVD player (although soon to be replaced), and my pens.

That’s it. No tagging, just grab-and-go if you’re so inclined.

(EDIT: Link fixed. Whoops.)

Share This Post

The happy band of brothers and sisters

Taking stock of a few British bloggers: Jessica Duchen and Dave Thomas are OK, although Dave is right angry now. Warren Ellis was not in London today, but Michael Brooke was (he’s fine, and he was just blocks away from one of the attacks).

As of this writing, The Gray Monk hasn’t posted anything about today’s attacks, and neither has Charles Stross (who lives in Edinburgh, but for all I know might have traveled to London this weekend). Jostein is Norwegian, but his girlfriend is British, so I’m hoping she’s OK. (Didn’t she used to have an LJ of her own? I didn’t see any links in his recent comments threads.)

If I missed anyone, let me know. I think I got all of the British bloggers on my blogroll.

UPDATE: I missed Helen Radice, who was not in London at the time. Also, The Gray Monk finally posts, with news that his childred are all right and with deep, understandable anger. M. Smith of CultureSpace weighs in today, although I’m not sure if Smith is British or not (although Smith refers to living in London in 1997).

Share This Post

What’s he that wishes so?

Al-Qaeda has apparently struck again, this time in London. I’m not exactly sure what they hoped to accomplish, but something makes me thing it’s not going to work.

What makes me think that? Well, I know that terrorism is frightening and all that, but I also know that the British have been on the receiving end of two particular speeches that have me thinking that Al-Qaeda’s choice of targets might have been miscalculated.

The first speech goes like this:

If we are mark’d to die, we are enow
To do our country loss; and if to live,
The fewer men, the greater share of honour.
God’s will! I pray thee, wish not one man more.
By Jove, I am not covetous for gold,
Nor care I who doth feed upon my cost;
It yearns me not if men my garments wear;
Such outward things dwell not in my desires:
But if it be a sin to covet honour,
I am the most offending soul alive.
No, faith, my coz, wish not a man from England:
God’s peace! I would not lose so great an honour
As one man more, methinks, would share from me
For the best hope I have. O, do not wish one more!
Rather proclaim it, Westmoreland, through my host,
That he which hath no stomach to this fight,
Let him depart; his passport shall be made
And crowns for convoy put into his purse:
We would not die in that man’s company
That fears his fellowship to die with us.
This day is called the feast of Crispian:
He that outlives this day, and comes safe home,
Will stand a tip-toe when the day is named,
And rouse him at the name of Crispian.
He that shall live this day, and see old age,
Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbours,
And say ‘To-morrow is Saint Crispian:’
Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars.
And say ‘These wounds I had on Crispin’s day.’
Old men forget: yet all shall be forgot,
But he’ll remember with advantages
What feats he did that day: then shall our names.
Familiar in his mouth as household words
Harry the king, Bedford and Exeter,
Warwick and Talbot, Salisbury and Gloucester,
Be in their flowing cups freshly remember’d.
This story shall the good man teach his son;
And Crispin Crispian shall ne’er go by,
From this day to the ending of the world,
But we in it shall be remember’d;
We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;
For he to-day that sheds his blood with me
Shall be my brother; be he ne’er so vile,
This day shall gentle his condition:
And gentlemen in England now a-bed
Shall think themselves accursed they were not here,
And hold their manhoods cheap whiles any speaks
That fought with us upon Saint Crispin’s day.

–King Henry V addressing the English troops at Agincourt, France, from King Henry V by William Shakespeare, Act IV, Scene III.

And the second goes like this:

On Friday evening last I received from His Majesty the mission to form a new administration. It was the evident will of Parliament and the nation that this should be conceived on the broadest possible basis and that it should include all parties. I have already completed the most important part of this task.

A war cabinet has been formed of five members, representing, with the Labour, Opposition, and Liberals, the unity of the nation. It was necessary that this should be done in one single day on account of the extreme urgency and rigor of events. Other key positions were filled yesterday. I am submitting a further list to the king tonight. I hope to complete the appointment of principal ministers during tomorrow.

The appointment of other ministers usually takes a little longer. I trust when Parliament meets again this part of my task will be completed and that the administration will be complete in all respects. I considered it in the public interest to suggest to the Speaker that the House should be summoned today. At the end of today’s proceedings, the adjournment of the House will be proposed until May 21 with provision for earlier meeting if need be. Business for that will be notified to MPs at the earliest opportunity.

I now invite the House by a resolution to record its approval of the steps taken and declare its confidence in the new government.

The resolution:

“That this House welcomes the formation of a government representing the united and inflexible resolve of the nation to prosecute the war with Germany to a victorious conclusion.”

To form an administration of this scale and complexity is a serious undertaking in itself. But we are in the preliminary phase of one of the greatest battles in history. We are in action at many other points-in Norway and in Holland-and we have to be prepared in the Mediterranean. The air battle is continuing, and many preparations have to be made here at home.

In this crisis I think I may be pardoned if 1 do not address the House at any length today, and I hope that any of my friends and colleagues or former colleagues who are affected by the political reconstruction will make all allowances for any lack of ceremony with which it has been necessary to act.

I say to the House as I said to ministers who have joined this government, I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears, and sweat. We have before us an ordeal of the most grievous kind. We have before us many, many months of struggle and suffering.

You ask, what is our policy? I say it is to wage war by land, sea, and air. War with all our might and with all the strength God has given us, and to wage war against a monstrous tyranny never surpassed in the dark and lamentable catalogue of human crime. That is our policy.

You ask, what is our aim? I can answer in one word. It is victory. Victory at all costs – Victory in spite of all terrors – Victory, however long and hard the road may be, for without victory there is no survival.

Let that be realized. No survival for the British Empire, no survival for all that the British Empire has stood for, no survival for the urge, the impulse of the ages, that mankind shall move forward toward his goal.

I take up my task in buoyancy and hope. I feel sure that our cause will not be suffered to fail among men. I feel entitled at this juncture, at this time, to claim the aid of all and to say, “Come then, let us go forward together with our united strength.”

Winston Churchill – May 13, 1940

Now, I don’t speak Arabic, so maybe Osama Bin Laden’s speeches lose a lot in translation, but from what I’ve heard, he’s got nothing on these fellows. It will take more than your cowardly car-bombs and your appeals to your God to win this, Mr. Bin Laden. What it will take to win is precisely what you don’t have. One day you will learn that.

In the meantime, I express my deepest sorrows and sympathies to the people of Great Britain for what they have suffered this day.

(Links: Henry V, Churchill.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓