Our Partners in Peace

A few moments ago I had cause to reflect on one of the many exchanges from The West Wing that I find particularly memorable, from the episode “Enemies Foreign and Domestic”. During a regular press briefing, C.J. Cregg fields this question and responds thusly:

STEVE: C.J., are you aware of the fire that happened at King Fatah Middle School?

C.J.: Yeah, that’s a tragedy. Chris?

CHRIS: Saudi news is reporting that rescuers were prevented from getting to several female students by religious police.

C.J.: Yeah, I read that too. Steve.

CHRIS: Does the White House have a comment?

C.J.: I literally just got this a minute and a half ago. I haven’t spoken to the President, or Chief of Staff, State or anyone in communications, this is just me.

STEVE: Well, do you have a comment?

C.J.: I don’t, no.

STEVE: I’m sorry, C.J., but you’re not outraged by this?

C.J.: [beat] Outraged? I’m barely surprised. This is a country where women aren’t allowed to drive a car. They’re not allowed to be in the company of any man other than a close relative, they’re required to adhere to a dress code that would make the Maryknoll Nun look like Malibu Barbie. They beheaded 121 people last year for robbery, rape, and drug trafficking, they’ve no free press, no elected government, no political parties, and the royal family allows the religious police to travel in groups of six, carrying nightsticks and they freely and publicly beat women. But “Brutus is an honorable man.” Seventeen schoolgirls were forced to burn alive because they weren’t wearing the proper clothing. Am I outraged? No, Steve. No Chris. No, Mark. That is Saudi Arabia, our partners in peace. Bonnie, then Scott.

SMASH CUT TO: MAIN TITLES.

What made me think of this exchange? Lance Mannion’s post about a woman he calls “everything that’s wonderful about the human spirit”, and whose current status has some disturbing implications about the way we’re currently prosecuting the Global War on Terror.

More here.

Share This Post

Aww man I think the clock is slow….

According to Michele, dissing the names of David Lee Roth or Van Halen is verboten on her blog.

Van Halen is one of my two favorite rock bands of all time (Pink Floyd being the other). Of course, whenever I mention that I love Van Halen, the question immediately follows: Do I prefer the David Lee Roth years, or the Sammy Hagar years? My answer is usually that I love both equally, with the proviso that my very favorite Van Halen songs of all time — “Dreams” and “Right Now” — come from the Hagar years.

Those first six albums, the ones with DLR on vocals, are all terrific listens — great hard rock with a lot of that sense of fun, with the occasional oddity (“Women and Children First”, “Pretty Woman”) thrown in for laughs. If I’m in a serious rocking mood, that’s what I want to hear. I’m not sure if any song recorded before or since rocks quite as hard as “Hot For Teacher”. (And I’m sure Aaron’s just jumping up and down, waiting to tell his story right now….) And there might not be a more fun song anywhere than “Jump”. But as much as I loved DLR’s work with Van Halen, his solo stuff left me cold — first his bizarro “hard rock meets Vegas Lounge Act”, and then that band he put together for the album Eat ‘Em and Smile. (Did no one notice the pun inherent in the title of Van Halen’s next album after that, OU812?) Suddenly we were to believe that Steve Vai was actually a better musician than Edward Van Halen? Uhhhh…sure, Dave.

WIth DLR’s departure and Sammy Hagar’s appearance on 5150, though, the band went through an admitted change, but not a really shocking one. They accomplished the rare feat of staying true to the way they had been in the past, with rocking songs like “Best of Both Worlds” and “Good Enough”, but they also stretched their horizons a bit to include balladry like “Love Walks In” (never mind that the lyrics make absolutely no sense) and that wonderful mixture of hard rock and pop-confection in “Why Can’t This Be Love?” that only Van Halen seems to be able to really pull off. And, frankly, there’s no song in the entire history of rock music that is more likely to pull me out of a bad mood than “Dreams”. That song is, to me, such a perfect musical statement of optimism that I can’t listen to it without getting a supremely goofy grin.

In terms of public persona, there’s really no comparing the two. DLR’s a depressing hack these days, while Hagar moved on to other things with quite a bit more class. I saw an interview with him, shortly after his falling out with the band, when he ruefully acknowledged, “I’ll never make music again that’s as good as what I did with those guys.” That was a classy admission, I thought. I was glad to see him get back with the band, and I hope he’s around to stay, because as Michele rightly notes, the Gary Cherone era really doesn’t deserve to be mentioned. That will surely go down as one of music’s greatest failed experiments, not unlike the 8-track tape and that album Robert James Waller recorded after The Bridges of Madison County became the best selling book since the Bible.

But now I think I’ll put in my copy of Best of Both Worlds: Van Halen’s Greatest Hits, and when “Dreams” comes around, I’ll hit “repeat” for a few times. I listened to that song at least four times a day during the weeks after Little Quinn was born, for reasons you might expect.

We’ll get higher, and higher, straight up we’ll climb!

Share This Post

How come it’s always tremors in the Force? Why not a ripple, or a teensy bump?

The inflatable Mr. Jones has undertaken picking his favorite moments from each Star Wars movie, beginning with A New Hope and proceeding to The Empire Strikes Back. He’s claiming to do this daily, although his Return of the Jedi picks haven’t occurred yet. We’re waiting! I don’t really have much to add to what he’s said at this point, although he does throw down the gauntlet for me to pick out best moments from each score. Well, my last two entries in the “Exploring the CD Collection” series of posts (see the sidebar for links!) delved into the same two films he has so far mentioned, with the remaining four to come. Note to self: get cracking.

By the way, John believes that watching the films in story order may work just fine, while Matt disagrees. I tend to lean toward Matt’s view, as far as a person brand new to the saga goes. I think that A New Hope really provides the ideal introduction to the Star Wars universe, being that it starts fairly small scale and only gradually opens up to epic quality; plus, it’s the one that most strongly kicks off George Lucas’s Campbellian structure for at least the first trilogy. Plus, for someone new to the series, I do think that it is absolutely essential that the Big Secret — Darth Vader being Luke’s father — come as a surprise. In that moment, the entire tenor of the saga changed, and I think that’s a feeling that would be lost if the series is experienced chronologically.

Now, had Lucas elected to actually start with Episode One way back in 1977, it’s a dead certainty that the resulting film would have been almost nothing like The Phantom Menace, and not just from the standpoint of the effects being so much better. For my money, the saga’s emotional resonance is strongest watching it in its production order, because with all of the things Lucas did to make the Prequel Trilogy anticipate the Original Trilogy, the story becomes cyclical in nature — like a yin-yang symbol in cinematic terms.

A chronological viewing wouldn’t be disastrous, I don’t think. But it would be a different experience entirely from what everyone else saw.

(My view here is also colored by my experience in reading long-standing book series, where generally publication order is best as opposed to story order, unless the author specifically notes that the books were not actually written in the order in which they were published. It’s just natural, when turning back the clock to an earlier time in a certain story or fictional world, to put things in that recall the already-published works. Guy Gavriel Kay does this in his Sarantine Mosaic, which is full of little touches that you won’t pick up on unless you’ve read his previously-published novel The Lions of Al-Rassan, which chronologically takes place centuries after Mosaic. That’s just one example. But Lucas does the same thing, really, in the Prequel Trilogy.)

Share This Post

Attend, for the High Priestess of Linkage shall now address you!

I don’t know how she does it, but Lynn again finds a bunch of under-linked and under-appreciated blogs. Check them all out. I especially liked this music theory blog, this fiction blog (whose first entry as of this writing is not safe for work), this culture blog, this culture blog, this ancient-language blog and this alpaca-farming blog.

(Those descriptors aren’t all-inclusive, by the way. There’s more going on within those blogs!)

Share This Post

Cry me a river.

As far as I’m concerned, after reading this, if the Right wants to cry like a bunch of six-year-olds over something mean Howard Dean said, then Howard Dean is doing absolutely the right thing. This is nauseating crap. I note that the Power Line guys are distancing themselves from it, albeit from the stance that there just isn’t enough evidence for the claim (it’s reliant on one of those pesky “anonymous sources” — you know, the kinds who will say anything horrible about a Clinton in order to get money from the Scaife crowd) and not to the point of refusing to run an ad for the book in question in their BlogAds. Gotta make a buck, you know.

(But remember that MoveOn.org removed that infamous “Bush as Hitler” ad? You know, the ad that proves MoveOn’s far-leftist status, despite the fact that it wasn’t actually created by MoveOn but rather was submitted as an entry in a contest by someone else, and removed by MoveOn as soon as they learned about its existence? Yeah, I remember that ad too. I only mention it to offer the readers an exercise in contrast. Heh, indeed.)

Share This Post

The Edible Missile

I saw via Lance Mannion that for reasons passing understanding — and I mean, really passing my understanding — some kind of controversy erupted in Left Blogistan over, of all things, an ad for some kind of upcoming show based on Gilligan’s Island that TBS aired involving, again of all things, a pie fight. (You can see the ad here.) The Daily Kos sported an ad on his blog for the show, as part of his blogads or Google Ads or something similar, and some other people found the ad demeaning, and apparently it all went downhill from there, continuing today.

Now, I’m not that interested in the whole thing surrounding the ad; what interests me is how crappy the ad itself is. I can sort-of see what they’re getting at: they wanted a Ginger versus Mary Ann catfight, since catfights are held to be sexy or something, so they parody a somewhat memorable ad for Miller Lite from a few years back, in which two buxom young women escalate a fight over the classic Miller Lite debate (“Tastes great!” “Less filling!”) into fisticuffs, then water, then a full-out mudfight. The Gilligan ad up now does the same thing, substituting Ginger and Mary Ann for the two women from the Miller Lite ad, and coconut cream pies for the Miller Lite itself. (Coconut cream pies often figured in the slapstick comedy of Gilligan’s Island.) A few pies are exchanged in each others’ faces, and then they’re rolling on a table full of them. No, it’s not particularly sexy or erotic. Coulda been, but isn’t. (Believe me. I’m a believer in the erotic possibilities of such scenarios, and a firm believer that Cool-Whip isn’t just for iced coffee drinks and ice cream sundaes, if you take my meaning. But a pie in the face is, to me, a goofy scenario, not an erotic one, and rolling around on a table of them is of no greater erotic quality than doing the same in a vat of jello, mud, or Cheeze-wiz.)

The problem, as far as the ad goes, isn’t that it’s sexist or demeaning; I’m not sure it’s either of those things, because it’s not thoughtful enough to rise even to that level. The problem is that the Gilligan ad completely ignores the actual concept of that original Miller Lite ad. It wasn’t a beer commercial featuring a catfight, because if you remember that ad, you recall that after the buxom women have been inexplicably fighting for a few minutes, the scene cuts to a bar where two guys are staring dreamily into space while two intelligent women standing beside them look at them like they’re idiots, and one of them says something like, “That is your perfect beer commercial? You guys are idiots!” The Miller Lite ad was using stereotypes to make fun of men, not women; but the Gilligan ad completely omits this punchline, so all we’re left with is a pie fight that happens for no reason under the assumption that it’s sexy or something. Ho hum. To have something erotic happening, you have to have a story behind it, something emotional. There’s no such happening in the Gilligan ad. Nor was there in the Miller Lite ad; but then, there wasn’t supposed to be.

I’m not sure if I have a point here; I just wanted to elucidate why I think the Gilligan ad stinks. And that’s despite my own love of a pie in the face.

(By the way, I’ve been saving this for a Sunday Burst of Weirdness, but I guess it’s relevant here, in a “kinda sorta” way. I suspect that no matter what topic you can come up with, someone out there will have a ranked list for it. Case in point.)

Share This Post

Simple Pleasures

I love burgers. Good, thick burgers on a good bun with fresh lettuce, cheese and tomatoes. Bacon’s nice, and so’s barbecue sauce. Or just basic ketchup, mixed with a bit of yellow mustard. Oh, and sliced onion — yellow or white preferred, but red acceptable in a pinch.

But sometimes I like to go to a really basic formula for a good burger: a slightly-less-than-medium cooked patty on a toasted bun, with the condiments consisting solely of a good slathering of mayonnaise and a generous dusting of freshly-ground black pepper. Man, that makes a fine burger.

Share This Post

BETRAYER MOST FOUL!!!!

OK, folks, I’ve been doing my “Sentential Links” thing on Sunday for about five weeks now, right? Where I just grab some sentence from some post somewhere and link it back to its original source?

Well, look what Kevin Drum just posted!

And note, here’s my introduction to today’s Sentential Links:

This week’s roundup of sentences ripped horribly from their surrounding blog-context.

And here’s Kevin’s introductory post to his version, which he calls “Deep Thoughts”:

Weekend wisdom from the blogosphere, ripped violently out of its native habitat but then hyperlinked back to its source so you have the option of attempting to make sense out of it if you’re so inclined

Coincidence? Or…fraud! You be the judge!

(I’m calling it “coincidence”. But you gotta wonder. Those Orange County folks are a shifty bunch. They’re mostly Republicans, of course, but they rub off on the few Democrats they have out there.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓