Eye Candy

Here, for no particular reason (and, therefore, in no particular order), are some of my favorite visuals from the Star Wars movies. I’m thinking of individual shots here, mostly, or scenes whose visual flair I found particularly appealing.

1. Sunset on Coruscant, from The Phantom Menace. I know I said no particular order, but this is actually my favorite pure visual from any of the films. Just after young Anakin is quizzed by the Jedi Council, there’s a wipe to a brief series of shots — we’re talking fifteen total seconds of screentime here — depicting dusk on Coruscant. We see the sun’s final edge slip beneath the horizon, then a couple of the tallest buildings falling into dusky shadow. That moment is just pure visual gold.

2. Luke departs Hoth, from The Empire Strikes Back. We get our only real glimpse of the entire Hoth system here, as Luke’s X-Wing fighter rockets away from the planet, and then his four thrusters, each shrouded in red afterglow, as he roars away from the camera. I’ve just always liked that little shot.

3. The “GAHHHH!” Star Destroyer captain from The Empire Strikes Back. As Vader’s fleet moves through the asteroid field, one Star Destroyer’s conning tower is hit dead-on by a particular large asteroid, destroying it; cut to the bridge of Vader’s ship where he’s meeting with his captains via hologram. The one on the left is apparently the captain who’s currently getting a really close look at an asteroid, because he suddenly throws up his arms in terror and then his hologram winks out. Nice touch.

4. The “orchid planet” from Revenge of the Sith. During the Jedi purge, one female Jedi Knight is killed by her accompanying clone troopers on a planet that appears to be the homeworld of three-story tall orchids. I liked that.

5. The binary sunset from A New Hope. An obvious one; an iconic image from the film that started it all.

6. Anakin versus Dooku in Attack of the Clones. I love how Lucas made the set go dark here, so that the only light was the lightsaber blades, and they flash across closeups of the combatants’ faces. I found it an interesting composition, unlike anything else in any of the other lightsaber duels.

7. Shuttle Tyderium versus the Super Star Destroyer in Return of the Jedi. As General Solo’s rebel squad is trying to infiltrate Endor, their stolen Imperial shuttle flies really close by Vader’s Super Star Destroyer, with the Death Star looming beyond. The sense of scale in this scene always impresses me.

8. The Gungan City, in The Phantom Menace. I love it when Jar Jar swims over a rise, and there beyond is this city of golden bubbles.

What are yours?

Share This Post

Arrgghhhh.

You know, folks, I have no problem with people not liking the last three (or even four) Star Wars movies. I really don’t. I defend them vocally because I truly enjoy and admire them, but I’ve never had a problem with mere difference of opinion. I have real reasons for loving the films, and I’ve elucidated some of those reasons many a time in posts here.

What I do have a problem with is all the arrogant condescension people who hate the Prequel Trilogy feel an almost instinctive need to visit upon those of us who love them. I’m sick of being told that I’ve drunk George Lucas’s Kool-Aid. I’m sick of reading reviews like this mean-spirited, “Oh look how clever a snark-king am I” piece by Anthony Lane (a reviewer I admittedly rarely enjoy, because I tend to only enjoy snark when being visited by a Democrat upon Republicans). And when I’m sick of being the subject of comparisons like this:

Phantom was a knife in the gut of Star Wars fandom; the only Star Wars fans who like that film are the science fiction equivalent to the Michael Jackson fans who mill about outside the courtroom of his molestation trial.

No, fuck you.

I am neither stupid nor delusional because I happen to like The Phantom Menace. Nor am I stupid or delusional because I failed to despise Attack of the Clones. Why people in like position to myself have to be insulted by everyone with a negative view of those two films completely escapes me. But at least I don’t have to worry about enduring this kind of shit again in three years’ time.

Share This Post

Oh. My. GOD.

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith is everything I hoped it would be, and far, far more. I am absolutely astonished. More later, of course, but this movie delivered. In spades. With a cherry on top. And coffee after.

UPDATE: OK, I figure I should probably expand my thoughts a bit here. I’m still saving it all for a more in-depth post over the weekend, so suffice it to say that even though I knew what was going to happen in this film (both in the broad sense and in the sense that I really didn’t try to be “spoiler-free”), I was still drawn in emotionally. I still wanted Anakin to make the right decisions, I still wanted everything to turn out right. And I was emotionally drained when the film had ended — so much so that, since I already had tickets to a noon showing today, I turned to the friend with whom I went at midnight and said, “I don’t know how I’m gonna make it through this thing again in ten hours.”

Even as a lover of The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones, I was astonished at George Lucas’s confidence and rock-steady hand in his direction of this film. There was only one or two scenes, really, where the dialogue was openly awkward; and even then, neither scene was anywhere near the level of awkwardness displayed in, say, the Hoth hospital room scene in The Empire Strikes Back. One line that sounded awful in one of the trailers or TV ads sounded perfect in its context.

Best of all, Lucas seems to have backed off his fabled approach to directing actors (“Faster, and more intense!”), by giving them time to deliver their lines and react to one another to a degree he didn’t so much allow in the first two Prequels. And I have to say that I’m not sure if Ian McDiarmid shouldn’t receive the first Oscar nomination for acting in Star Wars history. He was that good in Revenge of the Sith. He alternates moments of blistering evil with moments of almost fatherly concern that I really saw just how Anakin got seduced by him. It was one of McDiarmid’s lines, actually, that first made me start to shift from “Wow, man, I’m watching Star Wars!” to “Oh my God, this is how it all happened.” During a speech of his maybe halfway through, McDiarmid delivers a line that is identical to a line he uttered in Return of the Jedi — and he delivers it in the exact same manner, the exact same tone of voice. That was my first real spine-shiver of the film, and there were so many still to come.

John Williams’s score was brilliant, as expected; even the bits of action score tracked in from his previous prequel efforts worked well. The visuals were obviously outstanding, with the added bonus that the shots were designed so much more artistically this time out.

George Lucas didn’t merely redeem himself or make a decent movie here. He made a great one.

Share This Post

Welcome, ASV readers!

Thanks to Michele for the link. I have indeed been blogging a storm about Star Wars lately, so feel free to look around both on the front page and in the archives. I have a few older Star Wars-related posts permanently linked in my sidebar (see the section labeled “Notable Dispatches”), as well as the most recent two entries in my “Exploring the CD Collection” series and the most recent post in my “Great Love Dialogue” series. I also like this post, in which Emperor Palpatine makes a customer service call. (Fans of The Lord of the Rings may enjoy the post titled “Diary of a Ring”, also linked in the sidebar.)

My general attitude on Star Wars can probably best be summed up thusly: I consider The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones to be good movies. Not guilty pleasures, not bad movies with a few good spots, but actual good movies.

For those new to my blog, my politics are obviously liberal, but this is not a politically-centered blog, not by a long shot. If I’m really in a political mood, the percentage of my postings centering on politics might reach twenty percent; so if you find something that annoys or offends, just keep clicking and scrolling. I really try to not foam at the mouth in this space. There’s also some information about me linked by the photos near the top of the sidebar, if anyone’s wondering. Comments threads here tend to be (a) short, and (b) fun and respectful. Nothing here goes on like what you’ll see on an open thread over at, say, Atrios’s blog. (At least, not that I know of. I haven’t read one of those free-for-alls in months.)

And yes, I’m going to a midnight showing of THE FILM, but before that I’m showering, going to dinner with the family, picking up a friend to go to THE FILM with, and planning war with Guilder, so I’m swamped. This will be today’s final post. I’m not sure what tomorrow will bring, since I have a couple of important errands to run before seeing THE FILM again (yes, I’m seeing it twice in twenty-four hours) and then seeing who wins The Apprentice while taping Quentin Tarantino’s stint directing CSI, so there might not be much activity here tomorrow, either. I may post a brief something about THE FILM, but I’m going to hold off on a big, spoiler-filled posting blowout until I’ve had a few days to digest the plot. (One problem I have with a lot of the anti-Star Wars brigade is that George Lucas’s plots often need a bit of digesting before one realizes how finely constructed they are, and too often they’re just champing at the bit to bitch about stilted dialogue and the like.)

Obviously I fell well short on my hopes of posting on the subject of each Star Wars filmscore by the time of Episode III‘s release, but I will get those done sometime. Star Wars may be done in one sense, but it ain’t going anywhere, folks.

May the Force Be With You!

Share This Post

So that’s where matte painting artists go!

In this post from yesterday in which I kvetched a bit about one of my Daughter’s childrens books, I noted that the book has some really nice artwork (that makes Jesus look like Bo Bice, coincidentally enough). It turns out that the book’s artist is one Frank Ordaz, who used to paint matte paintings for Industrial Light and Magic. You can see Ordaz’s work in such films as, you guessed it, Return of the Jedi.

You know the reactor shaft in the Death Star into which Emperor Palpatine is given an involuntary nudge by his one-time Sith apprentice, Darth Vader, after Vader suddenly realizes that he’s gone perhaps a wee bit too far around the bend with this “Dark Side of the Force” thing? That shaft is a matte painting by Frank Ordaz. So you all know his work. And he had others in the movie as well, such as the landing platform on Endor when the AT-AT comes up alongside it after Darth Vader arrives. Cool, eh?

Matte painting artists don’t really exist anymore, since digital composition has become all the rage. So Frank Ordaz is doing art for children’s books now.

Share This Post

Balanced, all right (with a big thumb on the scale)

Today while at lunch at the Cafe in The Store, I overheard FOX News on the TV overhead doing some kind of segment on Revenge of the Sith, and sure enough, they were referring to the snore-inducing idea that the movie is actually an anti-Bush allegory. And they brought in an expert to discuss this:

(wait for it)

Michael Medved.

Yup, there was good old Medved, smiling that ever-present pompous smile of his as he announced, “Of course the movie is an attack on Bush!” Luckily, the interlocutor FOX News supplied to counter Medved’s idiotic claims said…oh that’s right, FOX didn’t supply anyone else at all. Just Medved.

I think I might need to return my dictionary to the bookstore, on the grounds that “fair” and “balanced” seem to be defined incorrectly therein….

Share This Post

Aww man I think the clock is sslloowww….

Folks, there is nothing that makes the day at work creep by so slowly that I thought The Store might have forgotten to pay the time bill like the prospect of seeing a new Star Wars movie nine hours after the work day ends. Jee-bus, that was a long day at work.

Oh, and here’s another sign of my Star Wars-induced dementia: I spotted the word “Tuscan” on a bottle of something in our Italian foods section, and I actually thought to myself, “Idiots, they misspelled ‘Tusken’.”

Oh, oh man.

Share This Post

O for the subtext-free days of youth….

The Daughter, at bedtime tonight, asked me to read from The Very First Easter, which I didn’t even know she had. We’re about halfway through it, and it’s an OK, straightforward telling of the whole Easter tale. The paintings are really good, even if I find the Jesus of the book disturbingly similar in appearance to Bo Bice of American Idol.

But I found the book’s very first page really odd. I mean, downright strange. The book’s framing device is that a boy’s father is teaching him about Easter, so there are questions-and-answers throughout the book, interspersed throughout the story. Here’s the text of that first page:

Christopher sat at the kitchen table, dyeing Eater eggs. “Mom, I just love this time of year, especially the jelly beans and chocolate bunnies,” he said. “Remember when I used to think that red Easter eggs came from red chickens? Some kids at school told me that was a myth — whatever that is.”

“A myth? Well, that’s like a fairy tale,” said Mom, smiling.

“Oh. But remember, Mom? I don’t like fairy tales anymore,” Chris sighed.

“Oh, that’s right. You only want true stories — like the one I told you about the birth of Jesus.” Mom rescued several eggs from getting dyed to death, then her face brightened with an idea.

“Chris, why don’t we read the true story about the very first Easter?” Mom asked. “It’s much more important than the Easter bunny, colored eggs, or even jelly beans.”

“Splendid idea, dear!” Christopher’s father said as he walked into the kitchen.

“Hi, Dad!” said Chris. “Hey, you used to be a teacher. Maybe you should tell me about Easter instead of Mom.”

“Okey,” Dad agreed as he sat down next to Chris. “Since Easter is next week, let’s read about it tonight.”

That night after supper, they sat down for evening devotions. “Chris, this has been called ‘The Greatest Story Ever Told’,” Dad began. “Do you remember how you and your mom read from the gospel of St. Luke to learn more about the birth of Jesus?”

“Sure! But I read more of it than Mom did!”

“Good for you! Well, let’s continue reading from Luke.”

And so on.

First of all, I know this is a children’s book and it really isn’t the place to get into what myths really are, but did the author have to give an answer to “What is a myth” that was this simplistic?

But what really put me off on this passage were the two little digs at the kid’s mother. Learning about Easter is Mom’s idea, but the kid ditches her the second Dad walks in — “Hey, you should do it instead of Mom!” “Great idea, son!”. (And in the book, this passage is opposite a painting of Dad and the Kid sitting at the table while Mom stands behind the kitchen counter, grinning like June Cleaver.)

And a bit later on, Dad mentions that the Kid and Mom read some of the Gospel of Luke, but the Kid immediately jumps in with, “I read more of it than Mom did!” “Good for you, son!”

I found this all condescending and, well, almost subliminally sexist. Was this really necessary?

Share This Post

Holy Crap.

Via Andrew Sullivan (in turn via Kevin Drum), I see that someone named LaShawn Barber writes this:

Let me clear up one thing. Whether Americans flushed the Koran down the toilet is irrelevant. Newsweek should not have reported it, even if true.

I honestly cannot believe this. It completely staggers me. The press is not to report any facts, any facts at all, that might paint a less-than-favorable picture of America. The only acceptable role of the media to the most vocal members of the Right is that of distributor of pro-American propaganda. Anything else, and they immediately start bleating about “liberal bias”.

You know the old saw, “My country, right or wrong”? That’s not actually the entire thing. The whole thing goes, “Our country, right or wrong. When right, to be kept right; when wrong, to be put right.” We’re a great nation, but we’re not a perfect nation, and to insist on a media that pretends that we are is the height of stupid hubris.

Read the entirety of Sullivan’s post, which makes clear that the Right simply doesn’t care about the facts in any case. The facts, whether accurate in the case of Abu Ghraib or inaccurate in the case of the Newsweek fiasco, just don’t matter. America can never be allowed, in their eyes, to be the villain; never mind the unpleasant reality that since America is an imperfect country run by imperfect people, sometimes America actually is the villain.

Lance Mannion has more. He’s quite a bit more forceful about it.

Share This Post

First learn Chronology, THEN learn Continuity.

Following a series of links from Michelle to Glenn Reynolds* to Professor Bainbridge, who thinks that George Lucas is betraying continuity in the new film in order to “score cheap political points”. (Which, as I pointed out yesterday, Lucas planned to score all along seeing as how they have always been part of his story, from the 1970s when he started writing the damn thing.)

First of all: bad guys have been making the “You’re either with me or against me!” charge in movies for a long, long time. Just because George W. Bush said something very similar in a very important speech a few years back doesn’t make every subsequent appearance of the “you’re with me or against me” thing in a movie a transparent homage, spoof, attack, parody, or pastiche on George W. Bush. OK?

Second of all: Prof. Bainbridge can claim to be inured to Bush-bashing from Hollywood, but (and this is a really minor point) George Lucas is not a Hollywood filmmaker. Lucas moved to Marin County and set up his own shop because he hated Hollywood’s internal politics.

Third of all, and Prof. Bainbridge’s main point: Apparently in Revenge of the Sith, Obi Wan has this line: “Only a Sith thinks in absolutes.” This is, apparently, a betrayal of Lucas’s continuity, since Lucas later establishes Yoda as clearly believing in some kind of absolutes.

OK. Dealing with that, I have several main objections:

1. “Only a Sith thinks in absolutes” does not necessarily imply “Jedi only think in terms of relativism”.

2. Prof. Bainbridge is correct that the sum total of the Star Wars saga is that the Force has a yin-yang aspect which the Jedi and Sith have ignored. But he’s wrong in what happens: Luke isn’t the one who restores balance. Anakin Skywalker is. And that’s an important point, because it establishes that for all of Yoda’s and Obi Wan’s warnings about the Dark Side and how Darth Vader is forever beyond redemption, they are both wrong.

In fact, when you think about it, the Force is restored to balance and everything turns out right despite the fact that the Jedi basically make one blunder after another. They consistently make the wrong prognostications, their wisdom leads them to utter ruin, and then they continue to be wrong. In ROTJ, both Yoda and Obi Wan believe that Luke must kill Vader and the Emperor if things are to be set right. But Obi Wan, if Vader is to be believed in ROTJ, didn’t even always believe that: he specifically says that Obi Wan once thought that he could be turned back to the Good side, a possibility that Vader totally discounts until the actual moment of his turning. Note that: a Sith thinking in absolutes.

And besides: the lines that Prof. Bainbridge cites from Episodes V and VI as being contradictory to what Obi Wan says in Episode III are interesting because they are said over twenty years later, in story terms. Lots of water flows under a lot of bridges in that time, and I can only assume that both Yoda and Obi Wan come to think of things quite a bit differently. Lucas isn’t betraying his own creation; he is depicting characters changing over time, and he is depicting his own characters being stone, cold wrong.

This is no continuity error and no betrayal of key Star Wars philosophy. It’s a blatant misinterpretation of the film on the part of Prof. Bainbridge. But then, he’s in good company; people have been misinterpreting George Lucas for years.

* And I have to note Glenn Reynolds’s timeliness in his choice of news articles to link. That article, about annoyed Latinos watching Star Wars, sounded familiar to me, and sure enough: that article appeared in 2002 at the release of Attack of the Clones, and yours truly posted a rejoinder at the time. Nice to see that Instapundit is right on top of things as always.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓