A Music Quiz

I saw this quiz on Tosy and Cosh (wasn’t that a Tom Hanks buddy/cop movie from before he hit it big?), and I figured, hey, why not answer the quiz. So here I go. Answering the quiz. Yup.

1. Of all the bands/artists in your CD/record collection, which one do you own the most albums by?

Going by genre: in film music, John Williams dominates. In classical, it’s Berlioz (although, for physical shelf space, all those Wagner operas take up a lot of room). In Celtic, I have a lot of The Chieftains.

2. What was the last song you listened to?

“Song”? Probably Van Halen’s “Dreams” (which might be my favorite rock song of all time). Expanding “song” to mean “any musical selection”, I heard a Debussy piano prelude on my way into work this morning. I didn’t get to hear which prelude it was, though. (It was not “The Girl with the Flaxen Hair”.)

3. What’s in your CD player right now?

I’m not really sure, actually; I have a bad habit of leaving CDs in there when the thing is shut off. It’s probably the Star Wars Episode III score, but it might also be a Blackmore’s Night album.

4. What song would you say sums you up?

No one particular song. But a few that hit close to home are John Denver’s “Looking For Space”, the afore-mentioned “Dreams” by Van Halen, “Stairway to Heaven”, and “Comfortably Numb”. Including classical works, the scores to the Star Wars and Lord of the Rings films, the symphonies of Berlioz and Rachmaninov, and so on.

5. What’s your favorite local band?

Kilbrannan.

6. What was the last show you attended?

I’m very lax about attending live music. I don’t even remember the last time I went to hear something live.

7. What artist do you consider to be very underrated?

Howard Shore and Hector Berlioz.

8. What’s the shittiest band you’ve ever seen in concert?

I’ve never seen an outright shitty band.

Funny story, though: I was a counsellor at a summer music camp during my college years, and one night while at the camp they brought in a local band to play for a dance. It was actually a pretty decent band, but at one point I went outside to watch the moon rising behind the main lodge, and I noticed a brown spot at the edge of the moon. Yup: the moon was eclipsing. As the lunar eclipse reached totality, everybody attending the camp was outside watching, and the poor band was inside rockin’ out for nobody. Ach well, they got paid, didn’t they?

9. What band do you love musically but hate the members of?

Don’t know, really. Wagner was a complete ass, that I know.

10. What is the most musically involved you have ever been?

I majored in music my first two years of college (before switching to philosophy, which probably answers the question “Why are you working in a grocery store?”). I was in the band and in the orchestra, playing the trumpet.

Our band was very good, but I was actually more proud of my work in the orchestra, because the orchestra program was a shambles my freshman year but through the very hard work of our conductor became pretty respectable by the time I graduated. It was exciting to be part of something like that.

11. What show are you looking forward to?

I’ve been living in the wistful hope that Howard Shore’s touring Lord of the Rings Symphony would make a Buffalo stop with our own Philharmonic, but it doesn’t look like that’s coming to pass. Dammit.

12. What is your favorite band shirt?

Ummmm…I have no idea at all.

13. What musician would you like to hang out with for a day?

I would love to have been able to see Leonard Bernstein at work. Or to just sit in the Chicago Symphony’s trumpet section when Adolph Herseth was in his prime.

15. Sabbath or solo Ozzy?

Neither. I never liked Ozzy much.

16. Commodores or solo Lionel Ritchie?

I have no idea. I don’t recall any Commodores tunes, and the only Ritchie song I really ever liked was “Say You Say Me”.

17. Blackjack or solo Michael Bolton?

What is Blackjack? (Seriously.)

18. The Eagles or solo Don Henley?

The Eagles.

19. The Police or solo Sting?

Solo Sting, all the way.

20. Doesn’t emo suck?

What is emo? (Seriously.)

21. Name 4 flawless albums.

Genesis: Invisible Touch; Van Halen: 5150; Dire Straits: Brothers In Arms (the single greatest album of the 80s, as far as I’m concerned); Wagner’s Der Ring des Nibelungen on Decca, Sir Georg Solti conducting the Vienna Philharmonic (the most towering achievement of recorded music, as far as I’m concerned).

22. Did you know that filling out this survey makes you a music geek?

So?

23. What was the greatest decade for music?

1781-1791 (The last ten years of Mozart’s life).

24. How many music-related videos/DVDs do you own?

Only one, and that one I got as a review item from GMR. (It’s Rachel Portman’s opera The Little Prince.)

25. Do you like Journey?

They’re one of those “in one ear and out the other” bands for me. Like Chicago, REO Speedwagon, and Air Supply.

26. What is your favorite movie soundtrack?

Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back.

27. What was your last musical “phase” before you wised up?

Depends on your definition of “wise”. I tried collecting jazz for a while, before I realized that I’m just not that attuned to jazz, which to me is wisdom in action. I did have a “New Age” music phase in college, but some of that stuff I still like (Tangerine Dream in particular), so I’m not sure.

28. What’s the crappiest CD/record/etc you’ve ever bought?

I’m sure I’ve heard worse albums — way worse, even — but the biggest disappointment that I can remember is the CD of Erich Wolfgang Korngold’s film music that Andre Previn conducted a couple of years back. How Previn made the music to The Sea Hawk sound lifeless and plodding will forever vex me.

29. Do you prefer vinyl or Cd’s?

CDs. In fact, I still prefer CDs to moving digital files around, because I’ve heard too many horror stories of hard drives and whatnot going kablooie to want to trust my music to such ephemeral storage schemes. I loved vinyl in the day, but I didn’t love the way it wore out. I do miss 144 square inches of artwork on the LP covers.

30. What is your guilty pleasure CD, that being the CD you love but would be ashamed to admit you have in your collection?

I’m really never one to feel guilty about my pleasures. (Remember: I’m one to stand up proudly and insist that The Phantom Menace is a good movie.) But if I were one to feel guilt about some pleasures, my liking of Yanni would probably fit the bill.

(Lynn Sislo answered some of these, too.)

Share This Post

Geekage Ahoy!

Time for a bit of geekage…surprisingly, not about Star Wars. At least, not all of it.

First, the Star Wars stuff: there’s a reviewer on AICN who goes by the name “Alexandra DuPont”, who hated The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones. I mean, she detested them. So today she gives Revenge of the Sith a highly positive (and spoiler-dense) review:

It actually ties into why I’m in such a good mood about this film overall: It’s actually worth discussing — and not just in those exhausting “did it rock or did it suck?” back-and-forths where everyone’s a loser.

Man, if that’s the case, then am I in for a treat, because I’ve always thought that the first two films were very much worth discussing — if I could find people who were willing to look past surface flaws that I never found all that damning.

In the same review, Ms. DuPont goes on to discuss the Firefly movie, Serenity, which I expect I’ll be seeing at some point. I didn’t read the whole thing, but I did like the opening paragraph of that bit, in which she discusses the fact that so many geek franchises have either ended or are about to end, and I found this sentence particularly clever:

The Wachowskis reduced the “Matrix” audience to the Venn-diagram intersection of philosophy undergrads, S&M aficionados, wuxia geeks and wankers in denial?

She also mentions Star Trek, whose current TV incarnation is about to disappear and whose further cinematic exploits are currently on hiatus. Personally, I’m fairly ambivalent about the end of Trek, which I find surprising even though I pretty much abandoned it halfway through Voyager‘s run and never caught an entire episode of Enterprise. The last Trek movie that I thought was any good was First Contact (btw, see the posts linked in “Notable Dispatches” in the sidebar for my opinions of all the Trek movies), and I thought that Nemesis was not just bad, but an embarrassing disaster of a movie. So basically I think that Star Trek‘s creative well has run completely dry, and if that’s the case, it’s better for it to be gone.

And I don’t expect it to stay gone forever. Sooner or later, everything comes back — witness the current success of the Battlestar Galactica series. What form will Star Trek take when it returns? Who knows?

I just read this Orson Scott Card article about Trek (link via Lynn Sislo), and as seems to be the case just about any time I ever read anything from Card’s pen, I almost disagree completely, and I had to pretty much set the article aside when he referred to the franchise as “badly acted”. Say what you will about the show’s SF-nal quality (and it was never all that great, and at times it was downright awful in that regard), acting is about the last area in which you can accuse Star Trek of being lackluster.

It’s interesting, from a standpoint of being within the SF ghetto, that the films and TV shows that Card cites as proving that filmed SF has finally caught up with written SF — Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Lost — aren’t marketed as SF at all. But anyway, I don’t think that Card’s thesis that Trek‘s popularity was due to its “SF 101” qualities really works. What made Trek popular was never anything to do with SF at all. It was about the drama.

Of course, Card has already ruled that possibility right out of existence, positing that since the show was badly acted and badly written, it must have been popular for some other reason. (When in doubt, just call the audience dumb and call it a day, I suppose.) I fully grant that many of the fans of Trek aren’t familiar with the best SF of the day, but they are probably familiar with other fine writing, and it’s telling that the very best episodes of Trek — episodes like “The Menagerie”, “The Visitor”, “Tapestry”, “Yesterday’s Enterprise”, “The Trouble with Tribbles” — hinge upon compelling drama between the characters, and not great SF. I note that Card lists a bunch of SF writers who were the genre’s leading lights when Trek first debuted, leading off his list with Harlan Ellison — who just happens to have written what many (including myself) think is the very best episode of Star Trek ever, “The City on the Edge of Forever”.

I think that Star Trek was popular only partly because it was SF. It was also popular, partly, because it depicted a very optimistic future in a time when such optimism wasn’t always thought to be warranted. It was also popular because it often showcased very finely written drama, often based on thoughtful, literate themes.

I don’t think that the demise of Star Trek tells us nearly as much about the current state of filmed SF as Card thinks it does. In the end, the demise of Star Trek really only tells us about the current state of Star Trek.

Hailing frequencies closed, Orson.

Share This Post

IMAGE OF THE WEEK

It’s Mother’s Day, otherwise known as Hallmark’s Greatest Marketing Coup Day! But anyway, here’s the local mother, with Little Quinn sacked out on her chest. This photo is from Christmas time, so Little Quinn is quite a bit littler here than he is now. I did a “black and white” thing on it, just because, I thought it would look cool that way.

As President Josiah Bartlet once said to his wife, “Nice job with the, you know, raising of the kids.”

Share This Post

Hector the Humorist

I’ve just started reading Hector Berlioz’s book Evenings with the Orchestra, which I’ve always wanted to read and a review copy of which fell into my hands unexpectedly (God bless GMR!). My copy is Jacques Barzun’s translation. Berlioz’s wit is legendary, and I already found just such an example on the first page, which I quote here:

[The set-up is that Berlioz posits the existence of an opera-house orchestra where the musicians spend their time in performance when they’re not actually playing reading books, talking about the weather, and basically paying no attention at all to what’s going on.]

One man only in this orchestra does not allow himself any such diversion. Wholly intent upon his task, all energy, indefatigable, his eye glued to his notes and his arm in perpetual motion, he would feel dishonored if he were to miss an eighth note or incur censure for his tone quality. By the end of each act he is flushed, perspiring, exhausted; he can hardly breathe, yet he does not dare take advantage of the respite offered by the cessation of musical hostilities to go for a glass of beer at the nearest bar. The fear of missing the first measures of the next act keeps him rooted at his post. Touched by so much zeal, the manager of the opera house once sent him six bottles of wine, “by way of encouragement.” But the artist, “conscious of his responsibilities,” was so far from grateful for the gift that he returned it with the proud words: “I have no need of encouragement.” The reader will have guessed that I am speaking of the man who plays the bass drum.

I love wit in which long, ornate paragraphs that seem to be headed one place suddenly end up someplace completely different.

Share This Post

Sunday Burst of Weirdness

I haven’t linked Mr. Sun in a while, so here’s something creepy: he links a site about Levittown, PA. Great God almighty, that place looks creepy: one looks at the map of Levittown and wonders where the Indoctrination Center is.

And that photo that Mr. Sun depicts is just a hoot: I don’t know whether to laugh at the guy sticking the TV behind a door, the unbelievable crappiness of his carpentry (did the guy get some kind of really good deal on slats of wood with a giant knots in them?), and the fact that the kid on the left is wearing a shirt that makes him look like he’s wearing lederhosen.

Even creepier is the homogeneity of it all, as represented by this quote:

Everybody lives on the same side of the tracks. They have no slums to fret about, no families of conspicuous wealth to envy, no traditional upper crust to whet and thwart their social aspirations.

Jee-bus, that’s insane. And I’ve long been of the mind that I will never live in a place where my lawn needs to meet someone else’s standard of care.

Share This Post

Screw that. I play the Air Timpani.

Michele of ASV wants nominations for “Best Air Guitar Song”. Well, since I had my 80s headbanging phase like anyone else, I do actually have a nomination to make: “Rough Boy”, by ZZ Top.

Yup, you read that right. “Rough Boy” is actually one of my favorite songs from the 80s, period. I’m not entirely sure why, but I find it to be a sad and beautiful rock ballad from about the last group you’d expect to give you a sad and beautiful rock ballad. The guitar work in the song is excellent, and what makes it a good air guitar tune is that you just can’t wiggle the fingers of your left hand up and down your imaginary fingerboard in a sad approximation of Edward Van Halen guitar pyrotechnics; you actually have to put some expression into your air-guitar playing. And that’s not easy. Anybody can play the air guitar. Not anyone can play the air guitar well. And certainly not anyone can do it with the angst of an 80s power ballad!

(BTW, check out Michele’s 404 page. It’s hilarious.)

Share This Post

Dinner rolls, egg rolls, eskimo rolls, blogrolls….

There’s been some discussion about Blogistan lately (see here and here) about whether blogrolls are useful or not. The idea seems to be that since blogroll links tend to be very static, they artificially prop up the blogs that are at the top of such blog ranking services as Technorati and the Truth Laid Bear Ecosystem. And sure, it’s incredibly hard to get one’s traffic to that level, and once up to that level, it’s also incredibly hard to fall off it (witness Steven Den Beste, who’s still on the Technorati Top 100 as of this writing despite the fact that he stopped actively updating his original blog months ago). For a number of months I religiously monitored my status on the TTLB Ecosystem, and once I attained a certain position (“Marauding Marsupial”, with approximately 75 to 80 inbound links), I never much deviated. I dropped when I went on hiatus, I’d jump back up when I returned, and so on.

My personal solution to this particular problem, though, was to simply stop caring. I only check Technorati to see who’s linking me, and I never check my Ecosystem ranking anymore. (OK, I’ve just checked my ranking just now, for the purposes of this post. And guess what? As of this writing, I am still a Marauding Marsupial, with 83 inbound links. Yes, my ranking might well be better than that, since I doubt that every blog that links mine is actually on the Ecosystem, but I’m not bothering to check that.) I pay no heed to my ranking, and the only thing I actively monitor is links and my SiteMeter hits. What makes me happiest about the direction this blog has taken is not my ranking on any system or other, but on these facts:

1. My daily average number of hits has slowly increased to 160+. This varies day-by-day, obviously, but it’s been maintaining that level for a comfortable while now.

2. I used to be able to count on getting at least 100 hits every weekday, but being below 100 on Sundays and well below 100 on Saturdays. Now, however, I am almost always above 100 hits, and have, in fact, dropped below the century mark in daily hits only once in the last month, and once in the month preceding that one. Yes, there are pros and cons to SiteMeter. It tracks every hit, for one thing, so if someone loads the page ten times in one day, that’s ten hits. Does that give me an accurate picture of traffic here? I contend that it does. When I worked in the restaurant business, a sale was a sale, no matter if it came from the guy who came in for breakfast, lunch and dinner in the same day. Nor do I mind all the search engine hits, because maybe, just maybe, someone will stick around a while.

I know that to some bloggers — many bloggers, even — those numbers sound seriously anemic. And it is slightly disheartening, I will readily admit, to see blogs like AMERICAblog start up and reach levels of traffic that blow mine out of the water in less than a year. But that goes with the territory, doesn’t it? You never know. I’m not betting the farm, but maybe tomorrow I get Slashdotted. (Stop laughing. It could happen!)

Of course, I’m not a political blogger by main focus; once in a while I’ll do a political post just because one bubbles out of me, but that’s about it. And I don’t suppose that Blogistan is really looking for an outbreak of Star Wars geekitude right now. I don’t mind the slow growth of this blog, really. In some ways, it’s kind of nice that there still are places in our society where slow growth is welcomed. (If Blogistan were network television, Byzantium’s Shores would almost certainly have been cancelled a mere month or two into its existence.)

That said, what to do about blogrolls? Well, the fact is, the only blogroll I really use for jacking around Blogistan is my own. That’s what it’s there for: it’s a collection of blogs whose content I endorse for one reason or another. It’s not a list of daily reads (some of these blogs are lucky if I get to them once a month, and in truth, the ones that are in that position deserve to be read more often by me, but there just isn’t time in my day to hit ’em all). I rarely use other bloggers’ blogrolls for my own surfing habits, although I have been doing so more often lately, incidentally enough. It’s especially convenient when some bloggers put their blogrolls into categories.

I provide RSS and Atom feeds here, but I don’t use an aggregator. When I read blogs, I click links and read each blog as it loads. I know what aggregators do, but I don’t frankly see why using one to read my blogs would be of any greater use to me than by simply surfing the links in my blogroll. I think that some people who use an RSS readers tend to overassume their level of use by others.

Plus, in terms of raw linkage, a blogroll link is worthwhile to me. I don’t get too worked up about whether someone’s blogroll is abnormally long or incredibly short; since a blogroll is free to maintain and since users are free to consult it or ignore it, I’ve never bought the idea that each additional link on a blogroll somehow dilutes the whole. But if someone puts Byzantium’s Shores on their blogroll, that says to me that somehow, they’ve decided that my content is worthy of inclusion in their own little sector of Blogistan. Yes, it’s even nicer when something I’ve written gets linked specifically, but the fact is, if I don’t have enough time to read every blog on my blogroll, and if I don’t have inclination to base every post of mine here on a post of someone else’s someplace else, I don’t really have the right to expect that of anyone else, either.

So my blogroll is staying put. It’s a resource of mine, intended mainly for me; but if anyone else uses it as a resource, I don’t see where inconveniencing them in favor of helping to break up the “dominant link hierarchy” is a worthwhile trade.

A few more points:

1. Blogrolls aren’t really all that great at driving traffic to other blogs, unless your approach is like Steven Den Beste’s old approach: he maintained a very short blogroll — about ten blogs or so — and he’d switch them out every three months to feature blogs that he felt were deserving of more traffic. (In other words, he didn’t keep the same links to the “usual suspects” of his side of the political fence. No links to Instapundit, Emperor Misha, PowerLine, LGF, or any of those.) Blogrolls serve a more “secondary” purpose. Kind of like, oh, an encyclopedia, I guess. For doing actual research on any topic, you’d be insane to consult an encyclopedia. But no one suggests getting rid of encyclopedias.

2. If driving traffic to blogs is the goal, then the best way to do that is to link them in posts. Frankly, it would be nice if the “big guns” of Liberal Blogistan did this better. For a short while there was a meme circulating called “Subvert the Dominant Link Hierarchy”, in which folks like Matthew Yglesias would link posts on less-traveled blogs, but that seems to have died out completely. Atrios doesn’t seem to link more than a tiny percentage of the people on his blogroll in his actual postings (and half of his posts nowadays seem to be mere placemarkers for open comment threads). (And not to pick on Atrios, who is a daily read of mine, but if you’re going to maintain a blogroll, at least alphabetize the damn thing.) You don’t even have to make a big deal of it — just a post like “This made me laugh”, with a link, will steer traffic where you want it to go.

3. Hand-coded blogrolls load faster than automated ones maintained by services like blogrolling.com. I used to have a blogrolling.com blogroll here, but I dumped it after it reached a sufficient size that it was severely hampering the load time of this blog. If you’re going to use a service like that, consider putting your blogroll not in a righthand sidebar, so the posts load first.

(And as I finish typing this post, I see that PZ Myers has thoughts of his own. He’s put his blogroll on a separate page. And in his staggering wisdom, he’s made me a “Weblog of the Week”. At least he didn’t describe my blog as being written by a guy who looks like an axe-murderer! Man, it’s going to be a shame when our Creationist Overlords haul his ass off to the Tower….)

Share This Post

ELEVEN F***ING DAYS??!!

You know what, folks: I wasn’t even this excited for the impending release of The Phantom Menace back in 1999, and I ended up liking that damn movie, even if the rest of the Universe hated it (my reasons why, here). Part of it is that this is the end; even with a TV series potentially in the offing, Star Wars has always been to me an almost exclusively cinematic thing. Yes, I read a few of the “Extended Universe” novels, but with the exception of Timothy Zahn’s efforts, none of the ones I read were all that great (a space slug was jumped on a motorcycle, I think, when The Courtship of Princess Leia came out). And part of it is that this isn’t just the end of Star Wars, but almost of a kind of geeky golden age. Since 1999 I’ve had the Star Wars prequels and the Lord of the Rings films. Some folks have had the Matrix movies as well. Yes, I dig Spiderman and The X-Men, but neither of those quite hit me in the emotional center where my inner six-year-old still lives. A new Superman might be fun, and I’ll see a new Batman, although without a whole hell of a lot of enthusiasm.

I’m also encouraged by the fact that the film’s critical reception that I’ve seen so far seems pretty unanimous that this film gets either most of it right, or gets enough things right that it’s worth seeing. That makes me happy. So is it the nineteenth yet? Lord, this is a tough wait!

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓