Of Returning Kings

Thanks to the generosity of a friend at The Store, I spent more than four hours yesterday watching the Extended Edition of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, and I have some brief impressions (leavened heavily with spoilers, so beware):

:: Now that I’ve seen both versions (theatrical and extended), I’m not sure that either final reckoning with Saruman, as filmed by Peter Jackson, works very well. In the theatrical version, Gandalf just says “Oh well, keep him locked up in his tower, he’s powerless”; in the EE, there’s a brief confrontation before Grima sticks him with a knife. I found interesting how the filmmakers managed to both keep the manner of Saruman’s demise from the books, and yet change it utterly. But it still felt a bit anticlimactic. I can understand Pater Jackson’s reasons for leaving the Scouring of the Shire out of his films, but the biggest problem with that decision is that it leaves Saruman as a giant thread just dangling out there. Alas.

:: Speaking of the Saruman scene, I found it a bit odd that Theoden would try to appeal to Grima’s better nature, after all that had transpired. It was probably necessary, just to make Jackson’s version of the scene work, but I had problems with it. Grima was just as much to blame for what had befallen Rohan as Saruman himself.

:: The drinking game between Legolas and Gimli just struck me as more unfortunate comic relief.

:: Denethor gets more screen time, which makes his storyline work better. But I still don’t like his flaming sprint off the top of Minas Tirith, and I wish the film had revealed (as does the book) that the source of his madness is not so much Boromir’s death but the fact that he’s been using a Palantir. I love how, in the books, Denethor is seeing what Sauron chooses to show him, in order to create a sense of despair that is not yet warranted. This is absent in the film.

:: Faramir’s story, culminating with his union with Eowyn, works a lot better now as well. I’d have liked it just slightly better had the film mentioned how their union brings an end to tension between Gondor and Rohan.

:: Speaking of that: there is apparently no guardrail or anything at the point where Denethor leaps from the highest height of Minas Tirith. So at the end of the film, when seemingly all of Gondor is gathered there, wouldn’t the people standing that far back be slightly nervous? “Stop pushing! I’m a little close here! And I seem to be standing in ash. Who’s burning stuff up here?”

:: The theatrical version’s implication that the distance between Cirith Ungol and Mount Doom is about two miles now works a lot better, with Frodo and Sam’s run-in with an orc company.

:: I’m glad that we finally find out what happens to “Captain Tumor”, the orc chieftain at the Pelennor Fields who looks like a walking cancer growth. I would have liked it better if Gimli had done him in on his own, though. For all the “Lethal Legolas” stuff throughout the films, I wish Gimli had been given chance to really shine with the axe.

:: Every time I watch the charge of Rohan on the Pelennor Fields, that sequence rises another notch in my “Favorite Action Sequences of All Time” list.

:: The film (both versions) really does a great job in suggesting how Frodo’s journey with the Ring is leading him to more and more parallel what happened to Smeagol/Gollum. After the opening scene depicting how Smeagol got the Ring, Gollum has a monologue in which he describes how he forgot the taste of bread, the feeling of sunlight, and his own name. And as the film progresses, somehow Frodo’s eyes become bluer and bluer, more and more lamplike; and as he and Sam approach Mount Doom, Frodo admits that he can’t remember the Shire or the taste of food. The irony is that the Ring, an object of beauty, will ultimately destroy all beauty in the world unless it is destroyed.

And I still like the parallel created by the fight in the Cracks of Doom: the film opens with Deagol fighting Smeagol for the Ring, and the story of the Ring ends with another such fight (Frodo and Gollum).

:: I’ve said this before, but it bears repeating: Howard Shore is an absolute genius, and these three filmscores might mark the emergence of the next giant talent of film music. We’re talking a voice on par with Jerry Goldsmith or John Williams here. I’ll know more once I start listening to more of Shore’s non-LOTR work, which is a priority for me in 2005.

Share This Post

New York Pizza

Over at Buffalo Pundit, Alan provides a handy description of New York City-style pizza. So, if you’re ever about the country and you encounter someone from NYC who pronounces the pizza of your particular locality abyssmal, and you’ve then wondered, “Geez, what’s wrong with our pizza? It tastes pretty good to me!”, this is the Platonic ideal they’re coming from.

Personally, I like NYC-style pizza just fine. But then, I like all styles of pizza just fine, really. Thin, foldable crust? Sure. Deep-dish Chicago-style, with the cheese tiled at the bottom and the tomatoes on top? Great. All styles in between? Bring ’em on.

“There are more pizzas in Heaven and Earth than are dream’t of in our philosophy,” wrote Shakespeare. And he was right. (Although, now that I think of it, I’m not sure the Bard was talking about pizza at all. Hmmmm.)

Share This Post

The Mighty Quinn, an update

A commenter on the next post asks if I’m going to provide any updates on Little Quinn’s condition, so here it is:

First of all, we’ve fired his original pediatrician.

Most of this is due to a high degree of impersonal interaction The Wife experienced when she took Little Quinn to the medical offices where the Original Pediatrician (hereafter designated as “O.P.”) practices. We’re talking things like being left on hold for intervals exceeding ten minutes on routine phone calls merely to schedule appointments; calling the office with questions about Little Quinn’s recent respiratory distress at 10:00 a.m. and finally getting a return call around 2:00 p.m. (you’d think that an infant having trouble breathing would somehow be placed around the top of the priority list); and a general refusal to listen to our concerns and treat the problems that we see on a daily basis. Little Quinn’s feedings of late have been highly difficult, his chest has become highly congested, and worst of all, in the last month he has only gained three ounces.

So, in the course of talking to a woman who works at The Store (who has a grown son with many of the same problems Little Quinn has experienced, so it’s not unlike having a human roadmap), we got the name of a pediatrician who has a lot of experience in dealing with “special needs” infants. After just the first visit with the New Pediatrician (“N.P.”), we have a new medication to use in treating Little Quinn’s reflux issues and a referral to a gastro-intestinal clinic to see if anything else is wrong with his digestion. Here’s hoping that either nothing is wrong and that the new treatments will set things on the right path, or that if something is wrong, it will be fairly easily treated and again put to right. (The cynic in me leans to the latter, obviously.)

(If I might get slightly political here for a moment, our recent struggles have pretty much convinced me that any doctor who whines about malpractice suits and the like being “out of control” can, with all due respect, bite me. Doctors are not divinely-appointed people drawn from some rarefied echelon of super-intelligent or hyper-competent higher beings; they’re people who have chosen a profession. Yes, they have to be intelligent to get there, and yes, they work hard; but I have seen nothing in the last six months that leads me to believe that the medical profession is any more exempt from Sturgeon’s Law than any other. To paraphrase George Carlin, they’re like anyone else: a few winners, and a whole lot of losers. Well, OK, maybe I wouldn’t put it quite that strongly, but mediocrity exists everywhere, the medical field included. When a physician can weigh an infant who is well below the expected weight for an infant that age, and not say a single word about it, I am not encouraged. Yes, getting sued is unpleasant. But so is being on the receiving end of malpractice. End of rant.)

What else about Little Quinn? He is undergoing physical and occupational therapy now (under the auspices of state and county-run health programs), and he is starting to lift his head more when he’s lying on his tummy, he’ll roll over (nothing annoys an infant more than rolling from front to back and then having an excited parent go, “Whoa, that was cool! Do it again!” and then plunking him back in the original position so he’ll do it again), and he’s begun to experiment with “commando crawling”. Oh, and he spits. A lot. I think he’s part camel.

So that’s about where Little Quinn is right now.

Share This Post

Feeble Apologies

Thanks to everyone who has managed to keep traffic here relatively high during the last three days in which I fell silent, largely due to a nasty cold that knocked me for a loop. (For reasons passing understanding, I continued to show up for each shift at The Store, thus resulting in approximately two hundred fifty conversations in three days that started off with other concerned folk telling me, “Wow, you look awful.” By the time I got home each day, the amount of brain power I had available with which to generate posts for Byzantium’s Shores was, shall we say, extremely negligible. But I seem to have finally reached the final stage of my colds — the “nasty cough that sounds terrible, but really does mean that I’m feeling better” phase — so content should start to resemble the Content of Old in these parts.

Oh, and go read Chapter Two of the novel. Just in case you didn’t see the post below this one. And if you missed Chapter One, it’s there, too.

Share This Post

Chapter the Second

As of just a couple of minutes ago, Chapter Two of The Promised King was posted, by me. So it should now be read, by you. Failure to do so will earn you a beating, by a big guy named Vinnie.

Go here for Chapter Two.

(Chapter Three is slated to appear on the first Sunday in February, February 6, to be precise. This date also coincides with a certain annual football game, but fear not — at least this way, the new chapter will give you something to do when the NFC Champion is down by four touchdowns in the third quarter.)

Share This Post

The “Credit Where Due” Department

I tend to look down on the writing of Buffalo News sports columnist Jerry Sullivan, and I tend to bust on him in this space, but I have to admit that the opening graf to his column today drew from me an actual laugh. The rest of the article — a meditation on why the National Football Conference is so much worse than the American Football Conference — is pretty good, too. But that opening is a hoot.

Share This Post

Koufax? Weren’t he one of them Dodgers?

To my immense surprise and gratification, I’ve been nominated for a “Koufax award”, as “Most Deserving of Wider Recognition”. So go and vote for me, even if I’m really a titanic lightweight when it comes to political blogging. I doubt I have much chance of winning this category, given the competition, but you never know.

(BTW, it seems to me that this category should be awarded to more than one winner, but that’s just me. Thanks to whichever kind soul suggested me in the first place!)

Share This Post

Huh-whuh?!

Craig of BUFFALOg presents an interesting letter to The Buffalo News, which in turn refers to a letter that apparently presented a rather odd argument: toll barriers on the thruway are essential because they create jobs. And what jobs are created by toll barriers? What industry is served by the existence of toll barriers? The industry of toll collection, that’s what. Oy.

By way of background here, Interstate 90 is a toll road for most of its length in New York State, and is designated here the New York State Thruway. However, the twenty miles or so of I-90 that traverse the Buffalo region are toll-free: there is a toll plaza at the Hamburg (western) side of the region, and another at Williamsville (the Eastern end). Drivers are free to drive the section of the thruway between these two plazas without paying tolls upon exiting.

The current problem is that the Williamsville toll plaza, where I-90 once again becomes a toll road, comes before one of the region’s busiest interchanges, at Transit Road. This exit leads to several of Buffalo’s wealthiest suburbs (Clarence, East Amherst, Williamsville) as well as a few less wealthy, but still important, ones (Depew and Cheektowaga). So the Williamsville toll plaza poses a substantial annoyance to people commuting to jobs in Buffalo from any of those areas. They either get on I-90 at the Transit Road exit and then have to sit through the Williamsville toll plaza to pay up, or they have to take alternate routes like NYS 33 (itself a very heavily traveled road, given that the Buffalo Niagara International Airport is on it) and deal with slower traffic. Thus a proposal to relocate the Williamsville toll plaza to someplace beyond Transit Road.

There’s been quite a bit of opposition to this plan on the part of people whose backyards would probably be affected by a sudden slowdown of I-90 traffic in the neighborhood, but frankly, the benefit of moving the plaza seems pretty clear to me. And just how it would jeopardize the toll collectors is beyond me — especially with increasing reliance upon things like EZ-Pass and the fact that the Department of Transportation doesn’t even staff all of the collection booths anyway, except for peak times.

Frankly, the toll collection industry is one whose shrinkage would, in all likelihood, serve to help economic development here rather than curtail it. Not every job is a sacrosanct duty that must be preserved. Quite an admission from a liberal like myself, but there it is.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓