Christmas Music, revisited

After listing some of my favorite CDs of Christmas music the other day, I see a couple of newer posts about Blogistan about Christmas tunes: Lynn Sislo and John Scalzi opine about certain Christmas tunes. Lynn likes “Carol of the Bells”, which I detest, and John detests Jose Feliciano’s “Feliz Navidad”, which I like a whole lot. Go figure.

My favorite Christmas song, generally speaking, is “Little Drummer Boy”. This one seems pretty darned hard to mess up; I’ve heard some indifferent renditions of it, but thus far none that have me screaming, “Make it stop!” And for my money, the Bing Crosby and David Bowie duet on this song is my favorite Christmas song, ever.

In his post, John poses this hypothetical:

Your Christmas gift is the ability to expunge one highly annoying yet popular Christmas song from the history of the world. Which one is it?


Strangely, I wouldn’t choose “Carol of the Bells”, even though I can’t stand it. There are a lot of Christmas tunes I hate more. In fact, there are too many Christmas tunes I hate more. Lots more. There’s one that received incessant airplay a couple of years ago, even though I haven’t heard it a single time this year, something about Christmas wishes coming true, in which some guy sings a verse or two of some syrupy Christmas ballad, with little kids reciting their oh-so-precious wishes from Santa in between the verses. Gack. It takes a lot to redline my “Sentiment” meter, but that one blows the needle right out the back of a gauge.

And then there’s that f***ing song with Alvin and the rest of the Annoying Rodents Chipmonks. I’m sure this was cute once. But that was before I was born. The window of opportunity is up, and the Chipmonks should probably be silenced for all eternity.

But that one isn’t even my pick for a Christmas Song whose memory I would banish to the lowest depth of Hell, a song that would send me to its writer’s grave that I might dig up his bones and salt the earth about his grave for a one-mile radius. That song would be “All I Want For Christmas Is My Two Front Teeth”, a song that fails to be cute, fails to be funny, fails to be interesting. The only thing this song doesn’t fail to do is make me vomit.

Well, that was sure cathartic! And what’s Christmas, if not a season for some well-timed venting of the spleen?

Share This Post

A Musical Follow-up

In comments to my post yesterday about musical keys and their supposed emotional characters, Will Duquette says this in response to my suggestion that a piece in one key be transposed to another key, so that we might decide if the piece’s emotional character changes significantly by virtue of the key change alone (with all the melodies and harmonies remaining the same, relative to the new key signature):

It’s perfectly possible to transpose music from one key to another without changing it’s character; it’s no big deal, really, it’s all about the tonal range of your target instruments or voices. We are much better at perceiving musical intervals than we are at perceiving specific tones, and transposing a piece preserves the intervals.


Of course he’s right; transposing is a trivial musical matter. Well, it’s fairly trivial, anyway. A professional trumpet player, for example, is required to know how to transpose music from one key to another, and on sight at that. This is because trumpet parts are usually written by the composers for trumpets keyed in whatever the tonic of the work in question happens to be — thus a Symphony in D will call for trumpets in D. The problem this poses to the modern trumpet player is that few trumpeters today actually own trumpets in all the keys that might be required by the composer. Thus the trumpeter must transpose his or her parts on the spot, literally playing a note on the trumpet that is different from the note on the page, in order to actually produce the tone the composer requires.

(For those who are totally baffled by this, certain instruments aren’t actually pitched in C, which is to say, that when the instrument’s tonic note is played — what is considered to be C on that instrument, with no valves pressed or keys closed — the instrument is actually sounding some other note, as struck on the piano. On the trumpet as played by most high school and college trumpeters, this is B-flat. Thus, the parts that are printed for the trumpets will actually display a different key signature than the parts of the same work printed for, say, the flutes, which are pitched in C. Most professional orchestral trumpeters actually use trumpets that are pitched in C, but this does not mean they don’t have to transpose.)

So of course, it wouldn’t be too much of a musical problem to transpose Mozart’s Symphony No. 40 from G-minor to E-minor; all it would take is someone to do the transposing. What I was wondering was if one could come up with a computer doohickey to do it for us, so one might stick a CD of the symphony in and have it play in E-minor as opposed to G-minor.

Which brings me to another question: do CDs reproduce pitch exactly, when played? When I listen to a disc of Beethoven’s Eroica, are those opening chords actually E-flat major chords, or am I hearing them as merely major chords that may or may not have been reproduced specifically as E-flat major chords?

Share This Post

Great Love Dialogue, #3

Moving along in my sporadic series in which I single out bits of dialogue centering on love from movies, TV, or books (previous installment here — I’ll add a sidebar section for this series one of these days), I turn to what I think is the better of the two “Scotland epics” of 1995 (even though the other one, Braveheart, was the more acclaimed): Rob Roy.

The scene I quote here takes place toward the film’s end. Robert MacGregor (Liam Neeson) is a Scots clansman who has become an outlaw through no misdeeds of his own; he has borrowed money from the Marquis of Montrose (John Hurt), whose nephew, Cunningham (Tim Roth), has stolen the money and left MacGregor in debt. The Marquis does suspect that his nephew is behind the whole thing, but preserving his own rank is more important to him, so he allows MacGregor to be pursued across Scotland, entrusting this very task to the vile Cunningham, who at one point goes so far as to rape MacGregor’s wife, Mary (Jessica Lange). So, by the end of the film when MacGregor has arranged to settle all in a duel to the death with Cunningham, Mary is pregnant with a child that may either be Robert’s, or Cunningham’s. The following scene of farewell takes place just before Robert leaves with the Duke of Argyle for the duel.

ROBERT: So, boys! Have you heard there’s going to be another addition to the family?

Robert’s two sons look at Mary, who glances in turn at Robert, surprise in her eyes.

ROBERT: Show them where it’s hid, Mary.

Mary remains still.

ROBERT’S SON: Is it inside you?

Mary nods.

ROBERT’S SON: How does it get out?

Mary and Robert exchange glances, and Roy smiles.

ROBERT: The same road it got in.

Robert grabs his jacket and heads outside, where the Duke of Argyle and his party await him. Mary comes running to him from behind.

MARY: Robert…Robert…what if you don’t–

ROBERT: Shhhh.

MARY: No. I cannot.

She pulls his tartan up onto his shouler.

MARY: What if–

Robert puts a finger to her lips.

MARY: I cannot. What if you do not return to us?

Robert smiles.

ROBERT: If it’s a boy, call him Robert. (beat) If a lass, name her for my love, Mary McGregor.

Robert departs.


Of course, the scene is helped by the pitch-perfect acting of Neeson and Lange, and by Carter Burwell’s gorgeous score (which, by the way, is a fascinatingly “minimalist” score that eschews the heavy-handed gestures common in such melodramatic films). The duel that follows between Robert and Cunningham is one of the best such action sequences ever filmed, driven as it is almost entirely by character concerns as opposed to plot machinery. And Tim Roth’s performance is quite simply one of the best portrayals of a villain ever.

But the scene above is why I love Rob Roy. The film establishes Robert MacGregor as a man of honor and integrity, a man for whom doing the right thing and holding his word is more important than anything. His unquestioning acceptance of the child who may be Cunningham’s — and the film, wisely, never provides a conclusive answer to this question, or even raises it again — is the best example of it.

(Another good bit of love dialogue from this film is Robert’s single line, which he repeats several times to his wife: “Mary MacGregor, do you know how fine you are to me?”)

Share This Post

Of Keys, Colors, Emotions, and Musical Purity (in short, a light post)

Terry Teachout had an interesting post the other day about musical keys and their emotional characters, and Fred Himebaugh responds (after initially writing about the topic here). The idea is that D-minor, for example, has a different emotional “feel” than, say, F-major.

I confess that I know very little about the internal theory behind this idea, but I’ve always been slightly skeptical about it: with the exception of people who suffer from synesthesia, I’ve never believed that people perceive musical tones in the same way that they perceive colors, and even then, colors themselves don’t seem to me to do much at all emotionally if they are presented to the eye devoid of context. This seems to partly be Fred’s point, as he wonders if people with “perfect pitch” would fare well when presented tones that are synthesized, i.e., totally divorced from the physical characteristics of an instrument. That would be an interesting experiment to perform. I once owned an electric metronome that also would sound, for tuning purposes, an A at 440. This latter feature was not nearly as useful as I originally thought it might be, because the machine’s tuning note was a very harsh electronic sound that I found unsuited to the task of tuning my trumpet.

Another experiment might be to digitally “transpose”, if such a thing were possible, an musical work into another key entirely. Everything would be the same about the work — tempo, instrumentation, et cetera — except for the key. Say, lower the entirety of Mozart’s Symphony No. 40 by a minor third, so that instead of being heard in G-minor, it would be heard in E-minor. Would the resulting version of Mozart’s symphony have the same character? I don’t think it would, but as Fred notes, is that because the melodies would sound different, being pitched in a key where the tones sound different than the ones we’re accustomed to hearing, or is that because E-minor actually does have a different “emotional character” than G-minor?

Anyway, it seems to me that it would be perfectly possible for a composer to take D-minor, that “saddest” of keys, and write a perfectly happy little minuet in it. But I might be wrong.

On a related note, Greg Sandow makes some interesting points about early music and our knowledge of early-music performance practices. It’s interesting stuff, although I have to admit that I’ve never really been one to get worked up about whether a piece is being performed in a way that the composer him or herself, at whatever time in which they worked, would recognize it. I own very few “original instruments” recordings — a full cycle of Beethoven and Berlioz symphonies, and a few Bach works — and I’m perfectly happy with my recording of Handel’s Messiah in which Sir Thomas Beecham commands musical forces that Handel himself would probably blush to hear. I’m not really a purist, so I’ve never really considered Sandow’s point: that “purism” might just be an impossible proposition in the first place.

Share This Post

Catchin’ the Fever!

I’m going to write my usual post-Buffalo Bills game report today, since I’m not sure if I’ll have much opportunity to post tomorrow. Today saw the Bills travel to Cincinnati to take on the Bengals, a team which used to have so permanent a status at the cellar of the AFC standings that I figured it would take an Act of Congress to lift them out of it. But that franchise has finally started turning it around, and of the Bills’ three games remaining before today, I thought that this one — on the road against a team in similar rebuilding position, also struggling for its very playoff existence — posed the biggest threat. Especially after the Bills have been so hot lately; if ever they were due to suffer a let-down, this seemed to me to be the game when it would happen.

Final score: Bills 33, Bengals 17. And it wasn’t even that close, since the Bengals fell behind 21-7 early in the third quarter, and didn’t get their score to 17 points until very late in the fourth, when the outcome was no longer in doubt.

The Bills didn’t get much offensive production today, but they didn’t really need it, as their defense and special teams themselves contributed 14 points directly (by interception return and by blocked punt return, respectively). They created more turnovers, and they held a pretty respectable offensive team to a pretty low number of total yards. And they did it on the road, which seemed like an absurd thing to suggest they’d ever be able to do just two months ago. They did surrender a one-hundred yard rusher, but the big chunk of that came on a busted-play 31-yard run by Rudi Johnson late in the fourth quarter.

So the Bills opened their season 0-4, and since then have gone 8-2. That’s pretty good. They’re still on the outside of the playoff picture looking in (unless they get a lot of help), but I’m amazed that the Bills have now equaled the total number of wins I predicted they’d get before the season started, and the number that I decided they had no chance at all of attaining after the sixth week. It appears that even with a completely new roster since the Bills’ heyday of the 1990s, they are still unmatched in their ability to circle the wagons.

Share This Post

If a blog falls over in the woods….

Huh. I hadn’t intended to take a four-day hiatus; I just did it. Oh well. How strange. No real reason, beyond the usual stuff: lots of stuff to do in PhysicalSpace, thus draining from my reserves of available time for BlogSpace, coupled with a relative lack of things to say. Anyway, I’m back for now, although I must note that I will probably be posting fairly lightly this entire week. Apparently there’s some Holy Day coming up that I need to prepare for. (I’d mention it by name, except I don’t want a bunch of libruls named Adlai to come chasing after me.)

In other news, Buffalo just got its first major shot of Canadian air for the winter. What’s notable about these is the lake effect snow they bring (a few inches today, which have stopped now), and the fact that one goes to bed when it’s 30 degrees out and gets up the next morning when it’s 11 degrees out. Gotta love winter!

(My favorite bit of meteorological terminology, by the way, is the name given to the “big blast of incredibly cold air from Canada coming down to put us all into carbon freeze” phenomenon in the Midwest: the “Alberta Clipper”. It just sounds like a big, long train rumbling along the tracks across the Canadian tundra, doesn’t it? I’m not sure why I bring that up just now, but there it is.)

Share This Post

Diary of a Ring (part one)

AHHHHHHHH!

“I’m cooling off now. Man, that volcano sure is hot. I’m glad to get out of there. That guy with the funky helmet is sure looking forward to wearing me, and I gotta say, he should be! Look at me! Look at how gracefully I can tumble up and down through the air, and check out these fire-runes! ‘One Ring to rule them all’! You’d better believe it, baby! And we’ll start with those Nine the Men are wearing. Nitwits. And I’m saving that jerk-off from Angmar for last. Heh.

…Master’s putting me on. I guess a bunch of men and elves are attacking. What a bunch of wankers. Oh well, Master will kill them pretty easily. I mean, that mace of his kills twenty guys with one shot! Take that, you bunch of pansies. And that! And that! Hmmm…what’s Master doing? Why does he give a crap about this one guy? He already broke the guy’s sword, why bother? Master, what are you doing? Uh-oh…look out, that broken blade still looks pretty sharp, and oh shit, Master’s leading with his finger! Shit! Master, don’t! Pull your hand back, he’s gonna — AGGGHHHHHH!….what the hell was that? Where’s Master? Now this dorky guy is holding me. What’s this crap all over me? Ash? Is that Master’s finger?! Did Master die? Oh, man, I gotta think fast, now. I’ll start by shrinking so I fit this guy’s finger. Unh…errgghh….unnnnhhh! Man, that’s hard to do. But there I go. Oh, I’d better hide those fire-runes while I’m at it. That’s it, that’s nice. Hey, buddy, what’s your name? Isildur, eh? Huh…goofy name. Not masculine, like ‘Sauron’. But OK. I’m yours, buddy! Rule the world!

Oh, shit, now what? Who the hell is that elf? Oh, crap, is that Elrond? Damned meddler…he wants Master to go…oh, no! Not there! That’ll ruin everything! I’d better start chanting now: Don’t listen to him, Isildur! Don’t do it, Isildur! I can be yours! You can have my power! No one will stand against you! Don’t do what he says, and the whole world is yours! Disobey him! Disobey him!

Ha! Take that, Elrond! You stupid goodie-two-shoes elf! Heh! You thought he’d throw me in there, and he didn’t! He didn’t destroy me. I knew he wouldn’t. Isildur’s good people, I tell ya. Bye now! Ta-ta! Have a nice thousand years in that Homely House of yours!”

Some while later…

“OK, this Isildur guy is getting boring. He wears me around his neck, for Morgoth’s sake. I’m a ring, damn it! I’m not a stupid pendant. Never heard of a ‘necklace of power’, did you? Or a ‘great anklet’? Of course not! That does it. I’m out of here. O for a distraction, like a random band of attacking orcs…hey, check it out! Attacking orcs! Well, I’ll be! Ah, he’s putting me on his finger. Let’s see, this should be easy…hmmmmm…whoa, he’s getting pretty close to the river, there. Is he going to…blessed Master, he’s in the water! Isildur’s in the water! This is too easy! I just grow again, a tiny bit, enough to slip off…unh…ergg…So long, sucker! Oh, that arrow in the back has gotta hurt. Oh well, sucks to be him. Floatin’ on down the river. Serves him right, for killing the Master. Guess I’ll just flow with current for a while. I wonder where it will take me?”

Some while later…

“Still in the pond. Big fish tried me, spit me out. Stupid fish.”

Some centuries later…

“The big fish died, but there was another big fish. Fish have no fingers. I am so screwed.”

Some centuries later…

“My, the fish in this pond are really big. Doesn’t anybody eat fish anymore?”

Some centuries later…

“Note to self: Turtles can’t be warped by my power either. Shit.”

Some centuries later…

“I am going to go CRAZY if I don’t get out of this f***ing pond soon! It’s taking all my power to keep myself from getting buried in sediment. Doesn’t ANYBODY ever fish here? That one that keeps swimming over me is begging to be fileted.”

Some while later…

“Oh look, here comes that same fish again. I’d make faces at him, if I had a face. Jerk. But what’s that in his mouth? Looks like a hook…and a line? Morgoth’s blood, is that a boat? WHOA! What is that? A child? No, it’s a…well, he’s short. Maybe he’ll see me…gotta catch a glint of sun…come on…I think he saw me…he’s getting closer…did he see me? He’s reaching…oh yes oh yes oh yes! He’s picking me up! I get a breath of fresh air! Damn that’s good stuff! Wow, I’m covered with shit. I hope he rinses me off.

“Hi there, buddy! Your name’s Deagol, right? Nice guy! Thanks for getting me out of there! Now, let’s see, we should have introductions…oh, who is this? What is his problem? Liar! It is not his birthday! Don’t let him touch me, Deagol. He’s a creepy bastard. Why are you fishing with him? Yeesh! Whoa, he’s getting pissed! Fight him off! Fight him, Deagol! You can do it! You can…oh, shit. Deagol’s a freakin’ wuss. He just got strangled by this little shit, Smeagol? The way he smells, it should be Flea-gol. Well, fine. I’ll go with him, I guess. Maybe I can warp him? I wonder if I still have what it takes…been a while since Isildur…”

Months later…

“Wow, that sure worked. This guy’s got problems. What the hell is in his throat, anyway? He keeps hacking. What kind of noise is ‘gollum’, anyway? And Morgoth’s blood, I didn’t mean to destroy his damned taste buds! He’s eating fish raw! Yeeccchhhh! Isildur didn’t even do that! Show some pride, will you? Cook the damn thing? OK, maybe not. They’re gonna blame me for how this guy is turning out, but if you ask me, he had some issues before I ever came along. Oh well, what’re you gonna do? I sure like being called ‘Precious’, even if he takes six minutes just to say two syllables. All right, the villagers have had enough of his crap, so I guess we’re out of here….oooooooh, he’s taking me into the Misty Mountains! I think the Master is hanging out somewhere in the south of Mirkwood. Maybe my new buddy, Gollum, will take me there…what’s this? We’re going into a cave? What on Earth for? Don’t take me down here! I just got out of the mud at the bottom of that river!”

Years later…

“This cave sucks. Gollum sucks. This whole thing sucks. I just wanna be out of here, you know? This guy eats nothing but the blind fish who live in the underground lake and the occasional goblin who wanders down here. (Goblins smell worse than dead fish, let me tell you.) Gollum doesn’t even wear me anymore, I wonder if he even knows he put me down. Does he even know what ‘My Precious’ is, anymore? Hey, it’s me, Dumb-ass! Stupid Gollum. I hope somebody comes down here and kills him with an elf-sword.

Hhheeyyy! Here comes somebody, with an elf-sword! He’s gonna kill Gollum! Yay me! Let me get a look at him…oh, shit. He’s one of those short shits like Gollum was to begin with! Morgoth’s blood, I hate these little guys. Uh-oh, he just found me! Stupid confounded luck! But maybe he’ll get me out of here. What’s your name, little guy? ‘Bilbo Baggins’? Man, these hobbits sure do have dumb names. Sauron: that’s a name. That’s a guy who’s going places. ‘Bilbo’ is a guy who milks your cows. I’m the One Ring! I’m supposed to Rule Them All! Why do I keep falling in with these lackwit farmer-types?! Ugh! Well, he’ll just kill Gollum and be done with it…wait, they’re just talking. What are they saying? Gotta listen…hmmm…riddles? They’re playing a game of riddles?! AGGGHHH! Stupid fat hobbit, stupid slimy bastard! Riddles, my ass!

And hey! Bilbo’s cheating! ‘What have I got in my pocket’ is not a riddle! Come on, Gollum, call him on the rules! Challenge it! Why aren’t you challenging it! This Bilbo character’s gonna screw you, Gollum, you idiot! It’s me in his pocket! I’m the answer! Say it! Say it!

Shit, he didn’t say it. Dumb ass! And now Bilbo’s pulling me out – oh shit, he’s gonna put me on! Gollum, you stupid bastard, I told you to keep me in a box! Bilbo’s putting me on! Blessed Master, he’s got fat fingers. Gotta grow a bit. All right, here we go. OK. You’re invisible, you little shit. You’re lucky my Master hasn’t returned to full power yet, or he’d have his eye on you right now. Heh. What’s Gollum doing? He’s searching for Bilbo. Oh, now he’s screaming about his Precious. Yeah, you put me down and forgot about me, didn’t ya? And now someone else found me, didn’t he? Serves you right, you slimy twit. And he’s following you right up out of the cave! Ha! The joke’s on you! Ohhhh, here we go! Sunlight after all these years! Air that doesn’t smell of water and fish! I’m free! Yay! Yippee!

You know, I think I’ll wait a while before I warp this Bilbo guy. I mean, he did do me a favor. Maybe the best thing right now would be for me to just act like a nice Invisibility Ring for a while. Then maybe he’ll keep me. Gotta be careful now. Apparently these hobbits don’t take well to being ring-warped. So here we go.

Hmmmm, I can still hear Gollum screaming. See ya later, Dumb-ass! Eat some fish for me! I hope I never hear his ugly voice again. But he’s still screaming about how much he hates Baggins. Morgoth, is he pissed. Oh well, I’m sure I’m done with him. How much more trouble can a guy named Gollum be, anyway? Doo de doo de doo….

A couple of weeks later…

“Morgoth’s blood, this is all getting embarrassing. I’m the One Ring! What am I doing, being used by some fat little hobbit to get in and out of tight spots while he helps some smelly, hairy dwarves to kill a dragon and steal their treasure back. It’s a disgrace. What have I got against this Smaug fellow? Dragons are good people. Just give them a pile of money to sleep on, toss in a live villager once in a while to feed them, and they’re fine. What is it with these smelly dwarves and their mountains and mines and rock and all that? Just the other night I heard one of ’em – Balin, I think – talking about how nice it would be if someone went and reopened Moria. I don’t think they heard me laugh at that, but I couldn’t help myself. Yeah, you short fat dirt-crawling mithril fiend, just go and start poking around Moria again. There‘s a good idea. Heh! Indeed!”

“Well, that was some battle, there. Five armies, and then some big-ass shapeshifter guy. I guess goblins are still idiots. Kind of like orcs, only stupider. Oh, look, that Thorin guy is dead, and now I’m off with Bilbo again. We’re going to a place called ‘Shire’. Pansy name, if you ask me. Orodruin, the Mountain of Fire – now there’s a place you don’t muck with! Who’s gonna take seriously a place called ‘Hobbiton’?”

“Oh, and Gandalf has absolutely no idea what I am. He’s a bit out of his usual self. I have a feeling that Saruman will kick his ass in pretty short order, once he finishes turning to the Dark Side. (No, I don’t know “the Dark Side” of what. It just sounded cool.)

“Bilbo keeps me on his mantelpiece. Weird. Shouldn’t he, you know, wear me, once in a while? It’s hard for me to warp him like this, when all he ever does is use me to avoid some ugly-ass relatives of his. I mean, those Sackville-Bagginses are some creepy folks, let me tell you. And I don’t trust that nephew of Bilbo’s, either. Frodo, his name is. I have a feeling he’s gonna be a pain in my ass before long. And what’s with that fat one he’s hanging out with all the time? And those other two idiots? Man, I gotta get back to Sauron. I wish he’d get back to Mordor and start looking for me again…”

To be continued…

(Actually, this never continued. The joke wouldn’t have kept working.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓