Evolution, again

Michael Lopez responds to my post from the other day. I have little intention of flogging this subject beyond the point of usefulness, considering that (a) this is just a blog and (b) I’m not a biologist, but Michael does make some points that I feel need addressing.

First he notes some of “the usual suspects”, by which I mean, the standard complaints about evolution theory:

Whatever your opinions of Evolution, there are still serious problems with it. The one that jumps to my mind most quickly is the simple lack of time: our planet is only about four and one half billion years old. That’s really not a lot of time to go from ooze to amino acids to proteins to humans. I’m not saying it’s impossible — but it’s not really 100% convincing. Then there is the problem with “missing links.” Creationists make a LOT of hay about this, but despite their zeal, there’s some sense to the argument. There’s also the question of why single celled organisms still exist… but that’s a slightly less strong argument.


That’s pretty breathtaking: “only” about 4.5 billion years old. Creationists trot this one out with surprising regularity, and yet they somehow are never able to conclusively demonstrate that evolution is impossible in such a “short” amount of time. I personally find 4.5 billion years to be an astonishing amount of time (check out Carl Sagan’s “Cosmic Calendar”, which sets the Big Bang at midnight on January 1st, for an illustration of the time scales involved here.) I’m frankly amazed that Michael wants to just toss this one out there with a “you see, it’s just not 100% convincing”. Whose fault is that? It’s not exactly 100% convincing that light is both a wave and a particle, but no one complains about that. I’m also not sure what to make of Michael’s insistence, also with no backing argument, that “there’s some sense” to the “problem with missing links”. (Perhaps PZ Myers could weigh in here.) As for the bit about why there are still unicellular organisms, so what? It’s never been the contention of evolution theory that all organisms must evolve into organisms of higher complexity over time, but rather that they can, if conditions over time favor them doing so. That’s not just a “less strong argument”; that’s a non-starter.

Michael also takes me to task for comparing theories that actually have been either confirmed or disproved, but he really doesn’t have much to go on here because he keeps assuming that evolution theory is on far less stable ground than it actually is. My contention, and the vast majority of scientists agree, is that evolution is on far more stable ground as a scientific theory than most people think it is. With all due respect to Michael, he appears to be swallowing Creationist and ID “objections” without question. Plausible answers and convincing rebuttals to every one of these objections exist, and yet they keep getting plopped out there, often completely unchanged despite the answers the scientists provide. It’s simply not true that evolution is in a “lot more serious trouble” than, say, plate tectonics. That the evolutionists haven’t convinced everyone is not an indicator of a theory in danger of being debunked, which is just how Michael depicts it.

Michael also still seems to think that the Laws of Thermodynamics are called “laws” because Thermodynamics is on better ground, as a theory, than evolution is. This is flat-out wrong. The Laws are called Laws because they are formulated as such: the Second Law, for example, states that “In any closed system the energy available for work always becomes zero over time.” (There are other formulations, of course.) It’s not called a Law because it’s true, but because it can be reduced to a single sentence in the form of a Law. Importantly, I can do exactly the same thing with Natural Selection; in other words, it can be stated as a Law: “In a world in which species must compete for limited resources to survive, organisms that develop traits that give them decided advantage over others will survive.” (This phrasing stolen from here.)

Additionally, Michael insists that the phrasing on the textbook-sticker in question is fairly neutral. Yeah, maybe it’s “technically true”, but believe me, it really isn’t. One doesn’t pay attention to the evolution vs. creationism “debate” for years without noting that the phrasing “Evolution is a theory, not a fact” does not turn up outside of people trying to advance Creationism. Yes, it is true that “Evolution is a theory”, but I see no reason to ascribe motives of truthfulness to the people insisting that this sticker be applied to this book about this theory alone.

Michael also says this:

Jaq needs to understand that the people who support Creationism aren’t reacting negatively to evolution because they don’t want it to be true. They’re reacting negatively to evolution because it’s directly at odds with what they’ve decided is the truth. It’s a subtle, but important difference. They’re not scared of evolution, but rather convinced of an idea which is inconsistent with it.


Again, with all due respect, I think that Michael is completely wrong here. They are scared of evolution, and they’re scared of it precisely because it’s inconsistent (or, rather, they think that it is inconsistent) with their default positions. That’s a perfectly human way to respond to something, too — but it is not a rational one, nor is it a scientific one. You don’t get to react negatively to something because it’s at odds with what you’ve already believed, and then call your objections “science”. That’s not the way it works. To return to Copernicus, it’s worth noting that initial objection to Copernicus wasn’t based in scientific concerns, but also because it stood at odds with what people had already decided was true. The objections were religious and philosophical in nature, precisely as they are now with respect to evolution. It wasn’t science then to oppose the Copernican model, and it isn’t science now to oppose evolution.

Lastly, Michael seems to be trying to turn things around a bit, accusing me of the same emotional response of which I accused the Creationists in my earlier posts. Well, maybe, but I don’t think so. I’m convinced of evolution because of the amazing amount of evidence in its favor, its explanatory and predictive power, and frankly, its stunning elegance. And since I didn’t come into the debate with a raft of pre-held notions about these things, I don’t see how that accusation holds. Not even close.

It’s also worth noting, in the end, that Michael’s main point of interest here seems to be in the legal matter of whether this particular school board should be allowed to put that sticker on the book. I admit up front, I don’t care one whit about the legalities. I care about the science, and I care that this is clearly just another attempt by the Creationism/ID people to whittle away until their position is in the schools, too. Defending someone’s right to be ignorant is one thing; defending the actual ignorance is something else entirely. It’s the latter on which I am focused. The fact is, there are some things on which I do not want to encourage students to “make up their own mind”. A list of such items would include UFOs, Holocaust denial, Hollow Earth theory…and Creationism.

UPDATE: PZ Myers also comments on the textbook sticker. Warning to my readers: Dr. Myers is far less patient with Creationism than I am.

Share This Post

The how and why of “Red and Blue America”

Kevin Drum digs into why red is used for Republican states and blue for Democratic ones. It’s a mildly interesting analysis, for those interested in such stuff. I always assumed that red got co-opted by the Republicans because Nancy Reagan always wore red. Remember all those 1980s Republicans in their identical navy suits and red ties? That’s where I figured it came from. Of course, it turns out that I’m pretty much dead wrong, which is probably why Kevin’s the paid political blogger and I’m just Joe Blow With A Blog.

Share This Post

I’ve been let down by my readers!

A while back we spent a Saturday wandering around to various garage sales, and at one of these, the Daughter somehow ended up with one of those “Furby” things”. This one had no batteries, but she liked it because she likes goofy-looking fluffy beasties.

Well, this morning the Daughter discovered that I had bought a new pack of AA batteries, and she immediately assumed that I had purchased them for the Furby. I, of course, took pity on her because she’s nursing a nasty cold and loaded four AAs into the fluffy white beastie.

So now there’s this little white thing sitting on the floor, making very weird noises at what appear to be random intervals. It’s the creepiest damn thing, like, ever. Seriously.

Why, O why, did none of my readers warn me of the elemental evil that is the Furby!

Share This Post

The Whistling of the Birds

As long as I’m blathering on a bit about our neighbors to the North, I just wanted to note something interesting I discovered a week ago. This time of year is when you can’t walk outside and look up without seeing a large flock or two of Canadian geese making their southward migration. As anyone who’s seen the geese knows, usually they’re making this surprisingly loud honking sound which can often be heard even before the flock itself moves into one’s sightline.

Well, one day last week as I was arriving at The Store early in the morning, one of the larger flocks I’ve seen flew overhead, and two things struck me: first, they weren’t honking, at all. Not a one of them was honking. And second, they were flying much lower than I am accustomed to seeing geese fly. As they passed directly overhead, I could make out the motions of their muscles as they flexed their wings, up and down, up and down.

But the coolest thing by far was something I’d never known: when the geese are silent and they’re flying low enough, you can hear a pulsating whistling noise that I suppose is the air coursing through their feathers. It was an amazing thing to hear, especially in that setting: a suburban grocery store parking lot, the traffic on the New York State Thruway (Interstate 90) just half-a-mile away, and the whistling of the morning wind on the wings of the Canadian geese.

There are so many times a day that I ache for all the people in this world who go through their days without ever looking up.

Share This Post

Nitwittery on Display

Yesterday two articles about the election ran in The Buffalo News, one relating how happy Bush supporters are about their victory, and the other describing how despondent Kerry supporters are about their narrow defeat.

I wanted to slap the people quoted in both stories.

First, the easy one. One of the Bush supporters in the first story says this:

This country was founded on strong religious values. My father’s family and my mother’s family fought the American Revolution for that. That’s what this country was founded on. If you don’t like it, go somewhere else.


Ah, yes: “Love it or leave it.” Yeah, well, with all due respect to this person’s forebears who took up arms against the Redcoats, screw that. I have ancestors who fought for this country too, and I plan to work hard to advance the agenda in which I believe precisely because this country is my home and I love my country.

Now to the folks on the other side:

On the day after the election, the number of U.S. visitors to Canada’s main immigration Web site jumped from an average of 20,000 to 115,016 – a nearly sixfold increase that practically doubled the previous record.


Look, I have no idea how much of this traffic was brought about by people who are actually considering expatriating to Canada, or just living there until January 20, 2009, or whatever. I admit that I read this Harpers article about the ins-and-outs of ditching one’s country, but I did so because it was linked on MeFi (I can’t find the link right now) and I thought, “Gee, I wonder just what is involved in changing one’s nationality.” You never know when something like this is going to be useful, when you’re a writer-in-waiting.

(And it’s actually a very interesting read. You’d be surprised at the amount of legal stuff that awaits anyone trying to go this route. It really makes me wonder just how much money all those rich folks who renounced their citizenships to evade US taxes spent on the lawyers who had to iron out the details.)

I suspect that a lot of traffic to whatever site this article is referring was of similar variety — i.e., I doubt that the number of people actually thinking about leaving the United States for greener (well, colder, anyway) pastures in Canada is very low. Anyone who hangs around Blogistan for even a short while knows that traffic does not imply support, and I suspect that this site may have been Slashdotted or something similar.

But to anyone who might actually be considering moving to Canada, let me say: You’re nitwits. All of you.

The risk of participating in a democracy — hell, it’s not even a risk, but a guarantee, a mortal lock — is that sometimes you’re not going to win. Sometimes you’re going to want the country to go one way, and fifty-plus percent of the people who vote are going to want to go another. You don’t knock the board on the floor and stomp off to your room; you reset the board and try again. If you do that, you just make it that much harder on those of us who do still hope to win one of these election thingies once in a while.

So, to sum up: Conservatives, your recent victory doesn’t mean that you own America and get to tell the rest of us to get out if we liberals wish to pursue our agenda. And liberals, shut up about moving to Canada, because that’s really an anti-American attitude, and I for one am done listening to people tell me that I am anti-American. I am an American.

(But if you really really must move to Canada, Sarah Jane Elliott has some pointers for you on how to be a Canadian. And before you leave, make sure you stop in Buffalo and spend some money. We need it. Bad.)

Share This Post

Explain this meme, please

I’m seeing a lot of the political blogs I read carrying some kind of disclaimer about being a “proud member of the reality-based community”. Of course, being the lemming-like soul that I am, I’d love to follow along, but my problem is this: I don’t know what “reality-based community” means. Anyone care to let me in on the joke?

Share This Post

“Theories” are not “Conjectures”

I respect Michael Lopez enormously and I love his blog. He always gives me food for thought, and often in the best of ways: he says something that I think that I might disagree with, but I’m often not sure why or how, which gives me cause to explore my own thinking and such. That’s always golden, whether I end up agreeing or disagreeing with him.

But he goes way off the rails in this post about an Evolution vs. Creationism case. The particulars are that some school district wants to slap a PMRC-style warning label on science textbooks to the effect that “This book contains material about evolution!” (Which has me wondering when National Geographic will have to start carrying similar labels about aboriginal breasts.)

Michael commits the all-too-common “It’s only a theory” error when he says this:

Evolution, for all its marvelous explanatory power, has not been proven. Now, it hasn’t been disproved either, but there are enough holes in it to keep its famous moniker “The Theory of Evolution” and not to promote it to the rarefied company of, say, the Laws of Thermodynamics.


This is all very, very wrong, in a number of ways.

First of all, the Laws of Thermodynamics are not things that got “promoted” to “Physical Law-hood” from “Theories”; the Laws of Thermodynamics are theories. A theory, in science, is as close to fact as you get, but to most people, the word “theory” carries with it a connotation that a “theory” is little more than a hypothesis that’s got some evidence going for it. If we’re going to play the “Evolution’s a theory” card as an implication that there are other, perfectly good theories to explain the same stuff, then we have to take similar approaches to other theories: plate tectonics, for one. Or Special Relativity. Or General Relativity. Or universal gravitation. Or Thermodynamics. The Laws of Thermodynamics are the theoretical laws that govern the theory of thermodynamics. They are not theories that have been “proven”.

And this is because theories are never “proven”. Proof is not something that happens in science; what happens is confirmation: the gathering of evidence that either strengthens a theory or either weakens or outright disproves it. Now, Michael cites earlier examples of theories that fell by the wayside, and he’s right: we now know that phlogiston theory is wrong, as is the theory of the luminiferous aether. But this doesn’t imply that evolution is some nice story that has a ton of holes in it, nor does it imply that evolution is just waiting for some intrepid anthropologist or paleontologist or biologist to uncover the smoking gun that reveals it’s all bunk.

Michael also trots out the “critical thinking” bugaboo, accusing scientists of being dogmatic about their insistence upon evolution. I’ve always found this baffling, because no one (outside a few cranks like the Flat Earthers) insists that geologists are somehow going against the grain of science in their current acceptance of plate tectonics. Neither does anyone complain about the fact that you won’t find an astronomer who refuses to toe the Copernican line. Somehow, in all those cases, we’re all willing to admit that the scientists believe these things because they’re true; but when it comes to evolution, it’s suddenly a case of “Whoa, there, scientists! You guys aren’t supposed to be so dogmatic!”

What it all boils down to is that opposition to evolution, or the endorsement of either Creationism or its more handsome younger brother Intelligent Design, isn’t born out of “critical thinking” at all. What it’s born from is the desire on the part of an awful lot of people to have evolution not be the way things are. Why so many people are emotionally invested in evolution’s failure is beyond me, but don’t tell me that they can act this way toward one theory (and I use that word here in its full-blown scientific sense) and no other theory and tell me it’s all about “critical thinking”. Because, hell, while we’re at it we might as well slap a similar sticker on high school physics texts that they contain material about universal gravitation, and then insist that we’re merely encouraging “critical thinking” from students who would never know where to start to look for evidence against universal gravitation even if they wanted to.

This “sticker on the textbook” stuff isn’t about intellectual honesty, or the “true spirit of science”, or any such thing. It’s about encouraging students to believe that one scientific theory that is nearly universally accepted by scientists is false after all, and that’s it. It’s an encouragement of Creationism, and nothing more.

Share This Post

OK, can we have good writing AND continuity now, please?

(West Wing season six spoilers here, for readers in the UK and elsewhere)

Like many people, I found the first couple of West Wing episodes of this season really overwrought, overly downbeat, and dramatically dull. This is, I notice, a general characteristic of John Wells’s shows — ER has always tended toward extreme pathos, and I can’t even watch Third Watch because just from watching the NBC promos for that show it seems like they kill off a major character every third episode. (“This week, on a Third Watch you’ll never forget, one of these treasured characters will breathe their last breath…join us as we all say goodbye, at ten o’clock, after an all-new Vegas in which lots of people gamble and have sex.”)

But the third and fourth episodes of The West Wing got back into something of a groove, approaching the kind of thing Aaron Sorkin used to do: lots of fairly fast storytelling, with complex dialogue, occasional funny lines, and a sense that this “public service” thing doesn’t completely suck. There was a pretty funny scene the other night when, as CJ is just starting her first day as White House Chief of Staff (we’ll say nothing of the awful “super-dramatic heart attack” Leo McGarry suffered), Toby hands in his letter of resignation. It’s early enough in the episode that we think he just might be annoyed over not getting the job himself. And then Josh hands in his letter of resignation, and we still think it might be real. But then President Bartlet enters and tells CJ he‘s resigning too, and everyone cracks up. It was a nice moment, the kind that Sorkin used to do really well and that’s been in short supply since he left. I’d say that the last two episodes have been roughly as good as the average episode in seasons three or four (but still not as good as the first two years, when Sorkin was really at the top of his game on this show).

But now, a geeky continuity complaint. In an episode last year that purported to be a PBS documentary of “A Day in the Life of the White House Press Secretary” made after the Bartlet Administration left office, the narrator says something to the effect that “To this day, CJ Cregg is the only woman to serve as Press Secretary for an entire Administration.” That’s nice, except that the writers have now made CJ White House Chief of Staff, which directly contradicts what was established in that “pseudo-documentary” episode. I remember thinking, at the time, that making a statement like that might be too limiting for the writers in the future, but they appear to have solved this problem by completely ignoring what they did last year. Oops.

Share This Post

Is there a camphor tree anywhere around here???

It seems that Disney/Miramax/Satan Inc. has set another release date for the next round of Studio Ghibli films on DVD: February 22, 2005. The titles to be released are Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind, Porco Rosso, and The Cat Returns. Readers with long memories may note that The Cat Returns was not originally intended for release with these films; My Neighbor Totoro was. Oh well. I’m sure Totoro will get a DVD release at some point, and I’ve never seen The Cat Returns, so I’ll take a movie I haven’t seen at all and live with my crappy VHS of Totoro for a while.

But not forever. I’m watching you, Disney. Just cause Eisner’s leaving doesn’t get you turkeys off the hook.

(Dammit, where’s Song of the South, anyway?!)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓