Note to self: Make the next guy put both hands ON the table.

In reply to my solicitation for questions, the esteemable Andrew Cory asks the question of high import:

Han shoots second: what implications does this have for the character of Han Solo?


My answer is: None whatsoever. This change, made for the Special Edition of Star Wars in 1997, does nothing to affect Han’s characterization, George Lucas’s claims to the contrary. Apparently Lucas decided that Han wouldn’t actually shoot Greedo in what appears to be cold-blood, so he altered the film so that Greedo shoots first, and then Han shoots in return. The general criticism of this scene is that this change totally changes Han’s character, blunting his rogueish nature and making him “softer”. I don’t think it does this at all, really.

What do we learn of Han Solo in this scene? We learn that he owes money to Jabba the Hutt, we learn that Jabba has enforcers out looking to collect the debt, we learn that Han is pretty cool in such a crisis, we learn that Han’s general approach to such problems is to blast his way out of them, and we learn that Han is a very good shot with the blaster, a weapon that Obi Wan Kenobi has already characterized as “clumsy” and “random”. I’d say that in the Special Edition version of this scene, we still learn all of that.

As for Han not being one to shoot first, well, Lucas is flat-out wrong. (And I’m a steadfast defender of Lucas, so for me to say he’s wrong is quite a thing.) Consider that in just about each tight spot in the films, Han’s initial preference is to fight. He wants to fight his way out when the Millennium Falcon is caught by the tractor beam; he wants to fight when Luke complains that Chewbacca is howling too loudly; when a cadre of stormtroopers comes across the heroes in a Death Star hallway, Han blasts the guy in front and charges after them. In The Empire Strikes Back, Han’s blaster is in his hand instantly when the door opens on Cloud City to reveal Vader. So on and so forth. Han’s more than willing to shoot first if he feels the need to do so, and he feels that need quite a bit over the course of the films. In fact, I’d say that his reliance on subterfuge on Endor in Return of the Jedi constitutes an overlooked bit of character growth on Han’s part. (Many fans think that Han is just “along for the ride” in ROTJ, but he has a very real character arc that plays out fairly subtly.)

The fact is this: if the altered Greedo scene really hurts Han’s character, then we can expect that Han’s subsequent actions would not be consistent with that scene. I don’t think that this claim can plausibly be made. He’s cool under pressure, he gets his weapon at the ready, and when the moment comes, he pulls the trigger without hesitation. So I don’t think that having Greedo shoot first harms the characterization of Han Solo at all.

What Greedo shooting first hurts, then, is actually the scene itself. In the original, it’s a very funny scene; here it’s less so, because the scene has a different flow to it (better in the DVD version, which was altered again to make it work better than it did in 1997), and because as the scene exists, Greedo has no reason at all to shoot when he does. There’s no logic to Greedo shooting at all, unless Han makes some kind of move that startles him, or if Han says something that articularly enrages Greedo, or so on. As it is, the scene goes from being a funny scene that also establishes Han’s character to being a scene that is less funny because, although it still establishes Han’s character, it makes less sense. It’s the equivalent of a joke that is told masterfully until the punchline, which the joke-teller muffs.

The other major addition to this part of Star Wars is the scene between Han and Jabba himself, originally filmed with a stand-in actor playing Jabba but never finished because the effects couldn’t be done. (Incidentally, Jabba wasn’t even designed until his appearance in Return of the Jedi, so presumably the Jabba originally intended for A New Hope would have been very different from what eventually showed up.) I don’t object that the scene repeats quite a bit of the dialogue in the Greedo scene. The final line, though — Han saying “Jabba, you’re a wonderful human being” — is just horrible. In the original script, the line was “Jabba, I’ll pay you because it’s my pleasure”. That would have worked a lot better. As it is now, I’m wondering why Han is calling this big-ass slug thing a “wonderful human being”. Is he making fun of Jabba, because he’s so fat and Han’s thin and can walk around and stuff? What is he saying here?

Anyway, there’s my answer to that question. Does anyone have any others? Post ’em in comments at the link above, or even here. Test me, folks! Challenge me! This is your chance to make me talk about something goofy (or something).

Share This Post

Sunday Burst of Weirdness

I’ve complained before about the prevalence of advertising these days, and the apparent belief that a moment in which we are not somehow pitched a product or made aware of a brand name is a moment wasted. I’ve always used, as my ultimate example, the presence of advertising on that little plastic rod you put on the conveyor belt in grocery stores to separate your order from the next person’s, but I’ve just seen this one supplanted. If there’s a context in life that should be advertising-free, surely that would be the one.

(via Mr. Sun.)

Share This Post

Three items of “Oy”.

WARNING: Politics here! Move on if you’d rather not see leftism on display.

Here are three things I read this morning that have me saying, “Oy”.

:: Via Thousand Yard Glare I find that in addition to industrial pollution, we also need to worry about military pollution. Stories here and here. Oy.

:: Via John Scalzi I see that back before the Iraq invasion, planning for the post-war Iraq wasn’t just lacking but utterly nonexistent. Oy. I’m not sure when “Que sera, sera” became a viable approach to war planning, but I’m not liking the results.

:: Via Matthew Yglesias I see a rather disturbing account of just how supremely confident in his own instinct George W. Bush is. The degree to which this President is so convinced of his own righteousness just scares me. Oy.

:: Why stop at three? Via Darth Swank I see that the Bush Administration is just so darned serious about fighting terrorism that they finally got round to freezing the assets of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, a terrorist who’s been making all kinds of headaches in Iraq since the invasion. Oy. Who knows, maybe the “Everything changed after 9-11” Administration will actually pull the trigger now, if they ever get another good chance to kill Zarqawi. Remember, they didn’t before.

OK, that’s all out of my system. Back to normal stuff.

Share This Post

Untitled Post

OK, here’s something those weirdo LiveJournalers are doing, and I figure, since it’s halftime of the Bills game, I can toss this one off in a few minutes. (Some language adapted from the LJ version, since we in Blogistan don’t have “Friends lists”. We have blogrolls. That’s because we’re generally cooler people. Score!)

Name a CD you own that no one else on your friends list does.

Probably quite a few, given that I have a large CD collection and my tastes are mainly in classical, film and Celtic music, genres that aren’t exactly the “heavy hitters” of music these days (sadly enough). I’ll just settle on Live at O’Lacy’s, a disc of Celtic and Irish tunes by Western New York’s own Kilbrannan. This is one of the most entertaining CDs I’ve ever heard.

Name a book you own that no one else on your friends list does.

At first glance this seems easy, but I have some pretty literate people on my blogroll, and it wouldn’t surprise me if any title I named turned up on the shelves of people I link — Jason Streed or Will Duquette, for example. But for my purposes, I’ll assume that nobody owns a copy of Richard Halliburton’s Complete Book of Marvels.

Name a movie on DVD/VHS/whatever that on one else on your friends list does.

Anybody got a copy of Flash Gordon (the 1980 version with music by Queen)? No? Ha!

Name a place that you have visited that no one else on your friends list has.

Tough one, this. I’ll try Cannon Beach in Oregon. (Chime in, folks, if anyone’s been there. I’ll revise accordingly.)

Name a Piece of clothing that no one else on your friends list has.

Well, philosophically speaking, isn’t every article of clothing I own an article of clothing no one on my blogroll has? If not, you people need to get out of my closet!

Anyway, since they seem to be my photographic theme here, I’ll go with my overalls. Again, correct me if I’m wrong.

Name an occupation that you’ve had that no one else on your friends list has had.

I don’t know if anyone I currently link has ever been a helper on a beer deliver truck, so I’ll go with that. I did that for four days. It sucked.

Share This Post

Exploring the CD Collection, #7

Film Music of Lee Holdridge

London Symphony Orchestra

Charles Gerhardt, conductor

This is a good CD to talk about on two levels. First there is the conductor, Charles Gerhardt, who is most famous for his long career of championing film music and the art of music recording. Gerhardt recorded a fine series of film music compilation albums for RCA; his recordings – – undertaken with the assistance of George Korngold, the son of the great film composer Erich Wolfgang Korngold – – that are staples in the collection of any serious lover of film music. Gerhardt died in 1999 while he still might have had years of music in him. A bio of Gerhardt’s career can be read here, while an article specifically on Gerhardt’s film music recordings can be read here.

RCA’s decision to abandon Gerhardt’s film music series is a particularly frustrating one for film music fans. Since we are used to seeing worthy recording projects go undone because of commercial concerns, it’s doubly annoying when projects like Gerhardt’s recordings are terminated despite their commercial success. Anyhow, the recordings of Charles Gerhardt for years represented the only real way for film music lovers to explore the work of “Golden Age” composers like Herrmann, Korngold, Steiner and Rozsa. And even though many classic film scores have over the last decade at last been issued on CD, both with the original music tracks or in re-recordings, Charles Gerhardt’s CDs are still worthwhile interpretations of film music’s underexplored byways.

This particular CD was not part of the RCA series; rather, it was issued on Citadel Records in 1985, exhibiting the work of composer Lee Holdridge. Holdridge is one of those film composers who, like Bruce Broughton or Basil Poledouris, always gets mentioned by film music fans as a composer who just doesn’t get the high-profile projects that he deserves. His music is always very melodic and memorable, even though his filmography includes relatively few films that many people will have seen. He gets a lot of work, but he never seems to get that big project that could catapult him into the rarefied air where people like James Horner and Howard Shore hold forth. This is especially frustrating in light of all the “cookie cutter” film music being churned out these days by guys like Hans Zimmer (whose music, to be fair, I do enjoy at least somewhat) and his Media Ventures disciples.

Holdridge’s most “famous” efforts — if that word can even really be applied — include his score to The Beastmaster (is that movie still on TBS something like every nine days?), his love theme to the early Tom Hanks movie Splash, his themes to the TV series Moonlighting and Beauty and the Beast (a show which also received fine music from Don Davis, who went on to score the Matrix trilogy), and his very fine score to the recent TV movie The Mists of Avalon. (This last might have been one of the most memorable scores of the year 2001, had it not been for a TV project and had it not been completely overshadowed by Howard Shore’s work for The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring.) And the theme of Holdridge’s that is most likely to be very familiar to mainstream audiences is his East of Eden theme (limited-time sample here), which is probably better known because it was used prominently by magician David Copperfield in his “flying” illusion than because of its use in the East of Eden TV film.

This is one of the very best CDs in my film music collection. Lee Holdridge is a composer who deserves more attention, and Charles Gerhardt was in many ways film music’s greatest evangelist. Here you get both.

Share This Post

“You can eat your fill of all the food you bring yourself….”

As I noted in my One Hundred (plus) Things About Me post, I went to college in Iowa, which was in some ways quite a change from my experiences in Western New York. To wit, it took some time getting used to a place where the nearest cities of major size (Buffalo-sized and up) were at least three hours away (Des Moines and the Twin Cities, respectively), where there were no hills to speak of (although Iowa’s flatness tends to be overstated, especially in the Mississippi River region, which is frankly a stunningly beautiful region that gets nowhere near enough recognition as one of this country’s most scenic locales), where every town had its water-tower, where the roads are for the most part disturbingly straight, and where trees existed pretty much in small stands to punctuate the corn-fields.

But that was all first-impression stuff, really. If you spend long enough in Iowa — say, an hour or so — the place’s charms start to work on you. The way that entire towns are “off the main drag”, half a mile or so away from one of the state highways as opposed to actually being on the state highways, seems odd at first until you realize that the towns were built where the trains either used to run or still run, and anyway, having the town not centered right on the state highway certainly makes for safer traffic patterns in a state where any consideration of “traffic” has to take large vehicles built by John Deere into account. The flatness of the land strikes at first, but then one’s sense of topography adjusts, and you find yourself realizing where very slight grades exists, and you discover that in its own way pumping a bicycle up a one-percent grade over five miles is harder than it looks, even if you’re used to five-percent grades over much shorter distances. It takes a while longer getting used to the lack of urban areas, but you discover the places of quiet beauty with greater ease.

And in Iowa you meet one smart person after another. Not that you expect these people ot be dumb, by any means, but you figure that they’ll be pretty much as smart as the people back home and they’ll just have some different takes on things. And yes, they do have different takes on things, but you’re surprised to learn just how often they’re smarter than the people you know back home. And they’re just plain sensible, really. Iowa’s just a place where things make sense. I mean, where else could Captain Kirk come from?

Why am I babbling on about all this? Because yesterday I stopped in a store to buy something, and in my change was an Iowa quarter. This was the first time I’ve seen it, and for my money, Iowa’s Statehood Quarter is the best of the series yet, from the standpoint of managing to catch the character of the state on the back of a coin. Vermont came closest, prior to this, but Iowa takes the prize thus far.

(I still think that if they wanted to capture the character of the states, then New Jersey‘s should be a car in gridlock on the New Jersey Turnpike, with the driver offering an extended middle finger to the guy in the toll-booth.)

Share This Post

Come on, without….

In comments to the “Ask Me Questions” post (which, by the way, is still active — ask me questions, people!), Simon asks to hear more about the “new addition”. Assuming he’s talking about little Quinn, I aim to please, so here’s what’s up. (This isn’t an entirely happy post, by the way.)

To go back to the beginning, what happened is that in either the latter stages of my wife’s pregnancy or during the birth process, the oxygen levels in Quinn’s blood became compromised. The blood gases taken from the blood in the umbilical cord right at birth were very low, and as I sat beside my wife during the C-section, I looked over to the table to where the docs and nurses were cleaning Quinn up, and I saw something that I knew I should not see: they were intubating him. Minutes later they whisked him upstairs to the NICU. When next we spoke to a doctor, nearly two hours later, we were informed that the level of oxygen was sufficiently low that there was certain to be organ damage in Quinn’s body. The good news was that every organ in the human body, save one, has the ability to heal and regenerate in the event of such an injury. The bad news was that the one organ without the ability to regenerate is the brain.

We then suffered through a long period of uncertainty (which has, in many ways, not yet ended). Quinn spent a total of nearly six weeks in the hospital. During the first week, he was on a ventilator machine; two early attempts to extract the breathing tube ended in collapsed lungs. Luckily, the last attempt to extubate proved permanent (save for the brief period when he was re-intubated for surgery — more on that below), but his EEG and MRI suggested significant abnormality of brain function. The doctors believed that he was likely to suffer significant disability later in life, including cerebral palsy and likely mental retardation.

One by one, Quinn’s organs healed — first his kidneys, then his lungs. His breathing was sufficiently strong that he was off the respirator for good. The problem now was in his secretions of mucus and saliva, because he didn’t seem to have any ability to swallow at all. The worry now was that he would need to have a G-tube in his stomach for feeding, and a tracheostomy for breathing. Luckily, he began to swallow, so he never had to have the trache, but he still doesn’t have a strong enough gag reflex or “suckling instinct” to feed normally. So he went into another hospital, this time for surgery to put in a G-tube.

This surgery went very well, and his recovery from this was, if anything, quicker than the doctors expected. A week after the operation, we were allowed to bring Quinn home. Now we feed him through his G-tube every four hours, and life is adjusting to a rhythm that doesn’t involve hospitals and monitors and alarms and complete lack of privacy. He still has a boatload of doctor appointments in the future, with a number of different specialists. But he’s home, and he’s ours.

The latest medical news comes from a neurologist, who examined little Quinn yesterday and said that we can be “cautiously optimistic” that any future disability will be “mild”. Quinn does see and hear, although we don’t know how well yet. His body and muscles tend to be very stiff, but he’s progressed in that regard (for example, he no longer clutches his hands in an incredibly-tight fist). He lifts his head, looks around, and seems to be figuring out that crying gets him attention. That last is, in itself, a particularly hoped-for development. Quinn did not cry at all until he was nearly five weeks old. Now he has a full-throated cry, and in all honesty, I have not yet tired of hearing it. (Unlike his older sister, whose cry drove me crazy at about Day Five.)

So there we are, with more doctor visits in store. A repeat EEG — his third — is scheduled, and it still feels weird to pour his feedings into a tube in his stomach. But again, he’s home and he’s ours.

By the way, I posted news about Quinn’s arrival to the message forums over at Bright Weavings (the official site for Guy Gavriel Kay, and one whose message forums are home to a very fine community of GGK fans and generally intelligent people), and in the course of the resulting thread (to which GGK himself posted) some enterprising soul came up with this response. Yeah, that song’s been on my mind a lot lately, but not quite in this version. I’ll take it, most gratefully.

And I’ll close now with yet another annoying photo of the little guy, in the arms of the follically-blessed writer-in-residence in our home. No, it’s not really my intention to turn Byzantium’s Shores into a goofy photoblog about an infant, but hey, it’s not my intention to not do so, either. And besides, that’s why the blog scrolls.

Onward and upward!

Share This Post

My eye! My eyes! I can’t take the cuteness!

Sean posts pictures of his kids, here, here, here, and here. He’s got a nice looking family. That son of his sure looks like he’ll one day be sitting in a collegiate philosophy class, munching a toasted bagel and saying things like “Maybe truth doesn’t exist, maybe truth subsists.” (No, I didn’t understand him, either.) His daughter, on the other hand, looks like she’ll be singing soprano, writing poems in a leather-backed journal, and perhaps riding a hot-pink Harley.

(BTW, Sean reports not yet owning a digital camera. This isn’t totally strange, since I don’t own one either, but Sean’s a lot more into tech stuff than I am. I’ll bet he’s waiting for Google to come out with its own digital camera!)

Share This Post

How to Tell if you’re Freaking Tired At Work

Here’s a sign that by the end of the week, with five consecutive nights of six or fewer hours of sleep (due to staying up late to feed Quinn and then get up early the next day for work), the mind isn’t at its usual peak of sharpness.

Today there was company at The Store: the current patriarch of the family whom The Store is named visited, along with (I think) his wife and a couple of district managers. At one point during the visit, our own district manager turned and specifically greeted me by name, which impressed me immensely because this was, as far as I can recall, the first time the man has ever addressed me at all. (Not that he’s mean or aloof or anything; I’m just one face in a very large organization.)

So when I went to one of the other store managers and had the following conversation:

ME: Wow, the DM just greeted me by name! I had no idea that he even knew who I was.

MANAGER DUDE: You’re wearing a nametag.

(beat)

ME: Oh. Well that explains that, then.


Shortly thereafter I went to the coffee bar and had a frozen cappucino drink with a double shot of espresso. Because, you know, you can’t be too careful.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓