Of bumper stickers and lawn signs….

Lynn Sislo links this Stanley Kurtz article about a “culture of fear” that is dissuading good Americans from displaying their Bush-Cheney campaign signs on their lawns and bumper stickers on their cars:

There is a climate of fear. Again and again, Corner readers say they’ve been scared off of posting bumper stickers by visions of having their cars keyed or their windows smashed. A typical comment: “Putting a Bush-Cheney sticker on my car would be like adding a bulls-eye that says, ‘Please vandalize my truck.'” A reader from Arlington, Va., who lives just a few blocks from national Bush-Cheney headquarters, says he was not afraid to use bumper stickers in 1996 or 2000, but wouldn’t do so this year. Bush lawn signs are feared, not only as an invitation to vandalism, but because they might permanently alienate neighbors.


I suspect that this sort of thing happens in just about every election cycle, and for my own small sample size, I do see more Kerry-Edwards signage and stickers than Bush-Cheney ones, but I do see a fair amount of signs expressing Presidential support in the Buffalo area (and Buffalo is a fairly Democratic place — not so much so as, say, New York City, but still Democratic).

(Actually, by far the dominant theme of political signage here is for local races — Congress, State Assembly, judgeships, school boards, et cetera. Very few homes seem to have any Presidential signage at all.)

If this stuff really is going on, yeah, it’s a shame, and yeah, it should stop. That’s all pretty obvious. I’m getting tired of all the implications, on both sides of the aisle, that I shouldn’t even associate with “the enemy”. I know plenty of people who, unlike myself, admire George Bush and think John Kerry is a complete tool, and I even like some of them. Of course, that’s just me.

What bugs me about the article is the complete lack of factual support. It all seems to derive from things like “Readers tell me” and “Someone wrote in to say” and “There are reports of” and so on. I’m sorry, but to take all this at face value seems absurd — it reminds me of the level of factual reporting contained in that TV special Geraldo Rivera did back in the 80s, the one with the message that America was awash in closet Satanists. I’m sorry, but I just don’t believe this is going on, in anything approaching the level of frequency that Kurtz seems to be taking for granted. This is all “a friend of a friend told me…” stuff. It’s the way urban legends become, well, urban legends. It’s the same mechanism by which every college student in the United States believes that if his professor is fifteen minutes late for class, he can leave the room without penalty; or that if his room-mate gets run over by a steamroller and dies, he automatically gets all A’s for that semester.

Kurtz also suggests, oddly, that things like flags on cars and “Support the troops” bumper stickers are proxy-statements for Bush supporters. Maybe, but I find this to be an incredibly odd assertion. What I notice a lot in Buffalo are these magnetic “stickers” in the shape of a yellow ribbon. I mean, these are all over the place. (I don’t have one on my car, but then, I don’t like to put stickers on my car in general.) Does Kurtz believe that these people are mostly Republicans who are too terrified to put Bush stickers on their vehicles? What an odd thing to believe.

Late in the article, Kurtz ponders, “Is the violence really unequal?”, as he ruminates on whether the violence directed at Bush-supporters and their outward displays of Bush-affection are more prevalent than similar violence directed at Kerry supporters. (Gee, I wonder what Kurtz’s answer to that is going to be. Hmmmm, let me think.) Kurtz doesn’t seem to even consider the more basic question here: “Is the violence really happening?”

UPDATE: In comments, Will Duquette says that he hasn’t even heard of any vandalism directed at Kerry supporters or, failing that, vandalism in support of President Bush. Thus, I searched Google News, and found reports of such, here, here, here, here, and here. Granted, many of these articles describe vandalism going both ways, but that’s exactly my point: to the extent that this kind of thing actually is a wide-spread problem, it’s a problem that doesn’t particularly favor one side or the other. Kurtz’s article, frankly, strikes me as more of this “playing of the aggrieved minority” schtick that the right has down pat, even though they are so far as I can see neither aggrieved nor a minority.

Share This Post

Debate: what you put on de hook

Like the first Presidential debate and the Vice Presidential debate, I passed the time during Friday night’s second Presidential debate watching something else. Sure enough, it doesn’t look like I missed a thing: wandering about Blogistan yesterday, I see some people saying that Bush took it by looking Presidential, others saying Bush lost it by yelling and seeming spastic, others saying they both suck but by God they’ll vote for Bush anyway because he’ll keep bombing Arabs or for Kerry because he won’t. Whatever.

But here’s something that caught my eye over on Asymmetrical Information:

The verdict: gosh, I’m too tired to guess. But expectations were so low for Bush, that I almost think not drooling on himself was a win.


Now, I admit to being out of touch with the whole debate thing, since I decided quite a while back that since the debates had zero chance of altering my vote short of both candidates being revealed to be robotic mouthpieces for those one-eyed slobbering space aliens from The Simpsons, but this strikes me as incredibly odd. Sure those were the expectations for George W. Bush in 2000, but how is it even remotely conceivable that we can apparently harbor such expectations about a sitting President of the United States? “Hey, the Leader of the Free World didn’t totally suck!” That doesn’t exactly fill me with the joy of democracy.

Share This Post

Election Predictions

Apparently Matthew Gross wants bloggers to predict the election results; while the prize for winning isn’t even something cool like a set of steak knives with the Bills emblem on the handle, I figure, heck, why not. Since I’m a pretty pessimistic fellow about these things, I’m going to say that it will be a fairly close election, but — unfortunately — we’ll get another term of George W. Bush. I figure a popular vote of 51% to 49% for Kerry, with the Electoral College going something like 289-249. (No, I have not bothered to go through and see if any realistic combination of states can produce that particular electoral result.)

No, it’s not the result I want, but like any good pessimist, I figure that this way, when the worst happens, I’m prepared for it.

(via Scott Spiegelberg)

Share This Post

Iraq and roll….

[Political content here, in which I spout some leftie stuff. Move along, if such things annoy thee!]

Two items I’ve seen around and about in Blogistan the last couple of days have been festering in my brain:

:: Andrew Cory links this SLATE article about the serious problems and struggles being faced by Iraqi police officers. It seems to me that any effective state-making in Iraq is going to hinge upon the success of efforts to create an atmosphere of law and order, which doesn’t seem to exist right now. It’s a pretty interesting article.

But what interests me about Andrew’s post is this comment by Dean Esmay:

“Poorly” has no meaning unless you have some objective criteria against which to measure. The truth is it’s going better than we had a right to expect, is going better than almost any operation of its type ever has gone–and the truth is, it’s childishly easy to say “it’s fucked up” and infinitely more difficult to say “and it won’t be fucked up if we implement the following steps.”

But I’ve been saying this for more th an a year, and I despair of getting anyone to listen.


Those of us who don’t think Iraq is going well are suffering from a lack of “objective criteria”? Well, off the top of my head, here are a few objective measures:

1. The number of casualties in Iraq should go down, and stay down. Casualties reached their highest mark in April (over twice the number of casualties as in March 2003, the month in which the actual war itself began), dropped again, but immediately started climbing. The pace is down so far this month. (Figures here.)

2. Security in Iraqi cities should get better, not worse. Maybe this sounds less objective than the number of casualties, but it is hardly indicative of progress on the security front when all indications are that the Green Zone in Baghdad is a place of decreasing security. See Andrew Sullivan for details.

3. Agencies essential to the functioning of a secure Iraqi state should be fully manned and staffed. We’re not even close.

4. Insurgent attacks should decrease, if we’re really beating the insurgents.

5. So should things like kidnappings and car-bombings.

6. Some meaningful percentage of money intended for Iraqi reconstruction projects should actually be spent on Iraqi reconstruction projects. (By “some meaningful percentage”, I do not mean one-and-a-half percent.)

So there you are, some objective criteria and areas where we might focus some effort if we want things to get better over there. But it seems to me that the lack of substantive effort in these areas and others like them, under the rubric of “staying the course”, is precisely the course of action that is spectacularly unlikely to produce any kind of meaningfully good results, on any time frame. And as has been noted by others, I don’t find the fact that John Kerry doesn’t have wonderful answers to questions like these particularly troubling, because the other guy doesn’t seem to even be willing to admit that these problems even exist.

(And besides, I’m constantly amazed by the apparent belief on the right that “Saddam Hussein in power” constitutes the absolute worst possible scenario in Iraq, and that therefore any Iraqi scenario that involves Saddam being out of power is ipso facto a better scenario — along with the corollary position that any admission that maybe things aren’t better now constitutes a preference for leaving, or restoring, Saddam in or to power.)

:: Also, Michael Lopez paid attention to John Edwards’s choice of words at the VP debate, and came away with a distinct impression of the Kerry-Edwards view on the War on Terror. Noting Edwards’s (apparently) frequent references to “those who attacked us”, Michael says this:

You see, I don’t want a strong leader who will go after the people who attacked us. I don’t want a fierce fellow like John Kerry who will trot out the remains of Los Angeles to the rest of the world and eloquently prove our case for taking out North Korea.

I want Los Angeles to still be there while we’re waging our wars, however unpopular they may be with France and Germany. I don’t want a president who will fight “the people who attacked us.” I want a president who will fight the people who are going to attack us.


This is all well and good, although I don’t think that it’s a reasonable reading of what Kerry and Edwards are saying to interpret as “We will do nothing until we are attacked, but after that, watch out!” Nothing that either Kerry or Edwards has said implies a refusal, in principle, to engage in preemptive war. But they seem to have this weird notion, admittedly common in Democratic circles, that a preemptive war should actually preempt something. Edward’s main point, and I think it is a good one, is that invading Iraq hasn’t preempted a damned thing.

I have seen nothing that would make me believe that Islamic terrorists in general, or al-Qaeda in particular, have been seriously damaged in their efforts by what we’ve done in Iraq. And in fact, there is lots of evidence that diverting attention from Afghanistan (especially after the colossal blunder committed at Tora Bora) actually helped “the terrorists” by allowing their senior leadership to escape into the hills, and by allowing much of that country to return to its former status as a patchwork of small territories controlled by opium-enriched warlords and former Taliban thugs. We could have dealt al-Qaeda a nearly mortal blow; instead we looked elsewhere for action in a country that has had little, if anything, to do with terrorism. And when we looked to that other country, we had several opportunities to take out a very nasty terrorist indeed, and we didn’t. And in that latter case, guess what? The guy’s still living, and still killing. The Bush Administration has had lots of opportunities to kill the bad guys before they attack us. Too bad that they didn’t do so, choosing instead to attack bad guys who had neither plan nor ability to attack us.

I also don’t think that Michael’s hypothetical about North Korea is very apt, considering that the Bush Administration’s general approach on North Korea has been a Homer Simpson-like blinking of the eyes and a gasp of “There’s a North Korea now?”

I saw a pretty nifty formulation of the whole thing on Electablog, via David Trowbridge:

If you are voting for this president, then you have to believe that it is appropriate for us to go to war over the risk that a guy who doesn’t have any weapons of mass destruction will pass them on to those with whom he has no ties.


If there’s somebody out there who does have a nuclear weapon and who might give it to al-Qaeda, we’d damned well better take them out. Nothing John Kerry has said makes me believe that he would not do so (verbiage from the Right to the contrary), and nothing George Bush has said makes me think that he has done so (again, verbiage from the Right to the contrary).

Share This Post

Can’t anybody speak this here language?

Tenser, said the Tensor links a funny news item: a library in California spent $40,000 on a ceramic mural that apparently includes a large variety of historical figures. Problem is, the artist — one Maria Alquilar — misspelled the names of eleven of the historical figures, including Shakespeare, Van Gogh, and Michelangelo. Check out the large photo, and note the spelling of “Einstein”:

The refitting of the mural, in order to get the spellings right, will take $6,000 on top of the original $40,000 spent to build the mural in the first place. And the artist? Is Ms. Alquilar repentant or contrite? Nope:

“The importance of this work is that it is supposed to unite people,” Alquilar said. “They are denigrating my work and the purpose of this work.”


Oh. Random misspelling in this work is a feature, not a bug. Right.

And Alquilar seems a bit defensive, doesn’t she? One wonders how she ever became a professional artist at all, if this is how she reacts to a criticism as basic as, “Hey, isn’t that spelled ‘Einstein’?”

There were plenty of people around during the installation who could and should have seen the missing and misplaced letters, she said.

“Even though I was on my hands and knees laying the installation out, I didn’t see it,” she said.


Um…so? People overlook misspellings all the time. Sometimes it’s because their brains automatically correct for the misspellings; other times it’s because they just don’t know how to spell the words in question. Which is true here? Probably the former, in Ms. Alquilar’s case. But I don’t know.

Either way, misspelled words are misspelled words. That no one noticed for a while doesn’t change this.

The mistakes wouldn’t even register with a true artisan, Alquilar said.

“The people that are into humanities, and are into Blake’s concept of enlightenment, they are not looking at the words,” she said. “In their mind the words register correctly.”


Um…what?! I mean, reall: WHAT?! “People who are into humanities aren’t looking at the words”? Geez, as an aspiring writer, I like to think I’m “into humanities”, but maybe I’m dead wrong. I guess I’m not a “true artisan”.

(BTW, find the mistake in this graf from the news article:

Reached at her Miami studio Wednesday by The Associated Press, Maria Alquilar said she was willing to fix the brightly colored 16-foot-wide circular work, but offered no apologizes for the 11 misspellings among the 175 names.


Funny to see an error like that in a news item about spelling errors, eh?)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓