I find Mr. Yglesias’s lack of faith disturbing.

Matthew Yglesias takes a break from all that substantive policy stuff about how bad George Bush is to talk about Star Wars a bit, complaining here and here that since the films pretty clearly establish that about twenty years or so pass between the end of Episode III and the beginning of Episode IV, it seems odd that the Jedi will have gone from well-known throughout the Galaxy to not-very-well-known-at-all.

Matthew is, of course, wrong.

The Jedi aren’t unknown by the time A New Hope dawns. They’re unknown, basically, to one character only: Luke Skywalker, and it’s not hard to see why. He’s grown up on a very distant planet, that is established in the Prequels — even during the Republic’s hey-day, when the Jedi are still in vogue — as not being particularly “up” on the great internal affairs of the Republic. Remember how Qui Gon Jinn tries to apply some Jedi-based muscle on Watto, and how Watto blows him off without too much concern that he’s about to be vivisected-by-lightsaber?

This reaction by Watto seems to indicate that the Jedi, even in the time of the Prequels, aren’t exactly held in reverence by the Galaxy-at-large. The Hutts are also established (in Return of the Jedi) as not giving a shit one way or the other about the Jedi, to the point of being immune to the Force-driven “mind tricks”. Han Solo refers to the Jedi as a “hokey religion”, but he’s a Corellian pirate (a group of people who can’t have terribly long lifespans), and who also very likely never much held the Jedi in particularly high esteem either.

The people didn’t forget the Jedi; they simply never much cared about them in the first place, at least as far as the Prequels go, and it’s also worth noting that Matthew makes a fairly common error that Steven Den Beste also once made: the Jedi at the time of the Prequels have already been in decline for many, many years, and the situation in the Republic has been growing more and more difficult and precarious. To read the Star Wars chronology as implying that the Jedi are magnificent warrior-priests up until a certain event X, after which they are barely remembered, is simply wrong, to say nothing of Matthew’s evident belief that not only have the Jedi been supplanted, or even forgotten, but by the time of Episodes IV, V and VI, they are supposed by many to have never existed at all.

Matthew also makes an odd assertion that there is “no indication in Episodes IV-VI that Anakin’s turn to the dark side was coincidental with the fall of the Republic and Palpatine’s assumption of the office of Emperor”. Well, I guess there isn’t, since you don’t have Ben Kenobi saying specifically something along the lines of “Now, all this stuff I’m talking about happened roughly at the same time”, but it’s never once occured to me to suppose that the fall of the Jedi (which Ben clearly indicates in A New Hope happened partly because of Vader’s actions) didn’t happen at the same time that the Republic fell, since numerous other threads of discussion in the film imply precisely this. Example: “For over a thousand generations the Jedi Knights were the guardians of peace and justice in the Old Republic, before the dark times, before the Empire” (emphasis added). Or the fact that as Episode IV transpires, the Emperor has only now got round to ditching the Senate. And so on. This assertion is simply baffling.

Finally, Matthew says this: “What’s more, Obi-Wan specifically says of Anakin in the original ‘I thought I could train him as well as Yoda. I was wrong.’ This is not a very good description of the events portrayed in Episodes I and II.” Well, no, it’s not, because all of Anakin’s training takes place in the ten-year period that elapses between Episodes I and II. But basically, Qui Gon insists on training Anakin, and Yoda says, “Bad idea”; then Qui Gon dies, and Obi Wan steps up and insists on training Anakin, to which Yoda says, “Still a bad idea, but we’ll give it a shot”. And as Episode I ends, Obi Wan has only just become a full-fledged Jedi Knight, and not by undergoing the traditional Trials but rather for his efforts in the Battle of Naboo. So here’s the newest member of the Jedi Order, insisting on being handed what the Council believes to be the most problematic Force-sensitive person they’ve ever found. In light of that, Obi Wan’s rueful remembrance in Episode VI seems pretty accurate.

But of course, since it’s apparently to be taken as a given that George Lucas is a colossal pinhead who has only managed to blunder into two good Star Wars films by some bizarre miracle, I’m clearly fighting a losing battle here. Kind of like the Jedi in Episode III.

Share This Post

Oh, knock it off!

You know what annoys me? People who set up a poorly-designed, slapdash fan site for some famous person on GeoCities or Tripod or some other such free hosting service, but then decide to render all of the photos on the site useless — even for perusal, much less for copying for my own purposes — by using Photoshop or whatever to put a big “stamp” with the site’s GeoCities or Tripod URL right over the head of the famous person in question. This practice is idiotic, and I see it far too often.

(Yes, I’m trying to do some Move Over Britney! research. It’s a hard life….)

Share This Post

Burst of Weirdness

No, I didn’t abandon the Burst of Weirdness; I merely had other things to mind last week, and thus left it alone. Suffice it to say that there’s still lots of weird stuff out there.

I find it hard to believe I’m about to cite mild-manner music theorist Scott Spiegelberg in a Weekly Burst of Weirdness, but I took one look at this, and realized that I had no choice. That’s really weird.

As an additional Burst, there’s this site that theorizes that something like 160 different television series are part of one, gigantic “multiverse” by virtue of crossovers to St. Elsewhere, a show whose final episode apparently revealed that its entire run had taken place as a dream in the brain of an autistic child, or something like that. For some reason, I couldn’t get the spreadsheets to open successfully. (via MeFi)

Share This Post

Repent Ye, for Thy High Geekerie!

In my slow exploration of the Star Wars DVD package, I’ve noted a couple of intriguing things.

:: First of all — and I posted something about this to the off-topic section of the FSM Message Board — my ear was caught by something odd in a noted gaffe in Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope. During the trash-compactor sequence, Luke tries to contact C-3PO on his commlink, but when we cut to the control room where the droids are hiding, they’ve retreated to a closet as a cadre of stormtroopers bursts into the room. Hilariously, though, as the door slides upward to open, admitting the stormtroopers, the one on the right hits his head on the door as he enters. It’s one of the most famous filming flubs in all of Star Wars.

But on the DVDs, something else happens. The stormtrooper still hits his head, but now the impact is actually accompanied by a metallic bonk noise. When I dug out my old VHS copies of the Special Editions and fast-forwarded to that same scene, sure enough, there was no metallic bonk. Therefore, I surmise that this sound was actually added to the film for the DVD.

According to a respondent on the FSM board, George Lucas actually says in an audio commentary to Attack of the Clones that when Jango Fett hits his head while boarding Slave I, this is an intentional allusion to that gaffe in the original film, since the stormtroopers are all clones of Jango. (I haven’t confirmed this by listening to the commentary myself, but surely I have a reader who might know?)

My supposition now is that this also provides some explanation of why the stormtroopers are all such lousy shots. My guess is that the very reason Jango Fett — and, later, his son Boba — carries all that extra weaponry, like a jet-pack and a flamethrower and cable-ejectors and whatnot, is precisely because he’s such a lousy shot with the blaster. So maybe a large part of why the Empire untimately loses is that the Kaminoans just happened to choose a bad shot as their original template for all those cloned stormtroopers!

(I know, not really, but hey, it’s fun being a geek sometimes.)

:: The scene in The Empire Strikes Back in which Darth Vader confers with a hologram of the Emperor has been changed to include Ian McDiarmid as Palpatine, since the role was originally played by some other guy in the original film. Fair enough; I wasn’t particularly attached to that other Emperor in that one brief scene. But now the dialogue has been changed, with the Emperor saying something like “The Rebel who destroyed the Death Star was the son of Anakin Skywalker”, to which Vader expresses disbelief. The implication is, I think, that this is the first time Vader’s learning that he has a son, or that his son is a Rebel.

But.

Earlier in the film, when the Imperial Fleet receives the transmissions from the probe droid on Hoth, Vader takes one look at the images and announces, with certainty: “That’s it. The Rebels are there, and I’m sure Skywalker is with them.” (Emphasis added.) Undisputably, Vader already knows who Luke Skywalker is. So what’s with the shift of dialogue in the Emperor scene?

I really don’t know. Maybe Vader’s merely feigning ignorance in that scene; maybe he’s actively trying to conceal the fact that he already knew who Luke was. (I mean, he’d have to know who Luke was, since he’s already named him as “Skywalker”. I can’t believe he’d learn that a notable Rebel is named “Skywalker”, and then not make any conclusion beyond, “Heh, isn’t that weird, I used to go by the name Skywalker too! Must be a distant cousin….Anyhoo, about that new Star Destroyer….) Maybe this is the very first inkling of the seeds of the Emperor’s crucial miscalculation that Vader can never be turned away from the Dark Side.

Share This Post

New Month, New Masthead

Yup, it’s that time again, and I’m reasonably close to being on-time with this one, as opposed to the last couple of months. Only two installments remain in this year’s theme for mastheads here, Arthurian-related artworks; then, in January, a new theme will debut. I haven’t completely decided on the new theme yet, but I have some ideas.

In terms of monthly traffic, September rebounded nicely after an August that was my lowest-traffic month since last November. Of course, August also saw a very lengthy hiatus as I awaited the arrival of little Quinn (who knew how that was going to play out, eh?), so it’s good illustration of the idea that if you want your blog to have traffic, you must post regularly. Not that this is a guarantee of anything, in itself (nearly three years of doing this, and my average daily traffic still equals roughly what an average nine minutes of traffic at InstaPundit), but failing to post regularly guarantees that you will not have traffic.

Share This Post

In other news, a tower with a big-ass flaming eye on top was recently erected on site….


In Washington State, Mt. St. Helens emitted some steam today, which is a possible precursor to eruption. I, of course, live on the opposite side of the country from the volcano, but that wasn’t always the case: I lived quite close to it in 1980, when it last erupted.

If it erupts this time — and scientists apparently think it’s likely — it could affect my inlaws, who live in northern Idaho, depending on how the winds blow. Take it from me, folks: shoveling a few inches of snow isn’t nearly as hard as shoveling a single inch of volcanic ash.

Share This Post

You READ it???

In this post on the topic of Banned Book Week (my position on which is, quite simply, this: Anybody who would ban a book is a complete and utter moron), John Scalzi says that books like American Psycho and Madonna’s Sex shouldn’t be banned, but rather simply not read, because they suck. Fair enough, but I gotta ask: who actually read Madonna’s Sex? I had a friend in college who bought it (yes, it was a friend, dammit, not me! Really!), and he brought it to a jazz band rehearsal, whereupon those of us lucky enough to be at the back of the band (the trumpets and the rhythm section, basically) thumbed through it. Believe me, we weren’t reading that book. Hell, I don’t even remember that it had words at all.

Share This Post

Sidebar Tweaks

I’ve just made some changes to the sidebar — some new blogs on the blogroll, a couple of blogs that either ended or that I simply wasn’t reading are gone, as well as the first update in months to my current reading list. Also, the long-stifled “2004 Reading List” has now been replaced…but a “2005 Reading List”, with the same titles. And so it goes.

Share This Post

Risin’ t’ d’ bait

The clear winner of last night’s first Presidential debate were, in my mind, William Petersen and Dennis Franz. This is because instead of watching an event that bears about as much resemblance to Lincoln vs. Douglas as a high-school football game bears to the Super Bowl, we watched the season premiere episodes of CSI and NYPD Blue that we taped last week. It only seemed the right thing to do. Thoughts:

:: Why is it that of the CSI shows, now numbering three, the only one that seems to have a sense of humor is the original?

:: I still enjoy NYPD Blue, but I’m glad this is the last year. Aside from the idea that a former “skel” (or “perp”, depending on the situation) is apparently stalking Det. Sipowicz, it’s the same kind of stuff. Still, I think this show has been generally underrated throughout its run.

:: OK, I did catch the very first minute of the debate, in which Jim Lehrer played the role of the person who reads the instructions to the students at the outset of the SATs, and the opening handshakes. This is because I was getting water out of the fridge at the time. I thought the instructions/rules were ludicrous. Is anyone else disturbed by the implications for Democracy In America that we have to provide a buzzer at the debates, in the event that one of the candidates talks too long? Oy. Anyway, unless something drastic changes, I have no intentions of posting anything more about the debates than this comment, right here. For reactions, check out the folks on my blogroll. (Unless you want to hear that Bush won. For that, you’ll need to find a conservative blogroll. Sorry.)

Share This Post

Blogging: the next generation

I’m noticing the emergence of smaller, singularly-focused blogs, which aren’t necessarily meant, as this one is, to be “open-ended” and keep on going until I either burn out or, well, drop dead. A nifty-looking example is Listen 101, which is devoted to exploring 101 “essential” works of 20th century classical music. This sounds like a fascinating project, especially after perusing the entire list. We often think of “20th Century classical music” as being weird, cacophonous post-Modern stuff (think of John Cage), but this list of just 101 works provides a very different picture, which I assume will become even clearer over the course of the blog.

(via Scott Spiegelberg)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓