Revisions, and the Revisers Who Revise them

In the anticipation of the Star Wars Original Trilogy DVDs, all of the old debates on whether George Lucas should be making more revisions to his films, the first of which was “completed” and released nearly thirty years ago. A lot of this stuff involves a lot of what I call “geekery of the highest order”, in which arguments are advanced that the brief scene between Han Solo and the bounty hunter Greedo is so important to establishing Han’s character that to change it seriously undermines the characterization. Personally, I don’t agree, but I’m more interested in a larger issue about artists and the revisions of their work.

I’m generally forgiving of most of the alterations George Lucas has made, on the basis that they all seem to fall into one of two categories: effects enhancements, in which the visuals Lucas intended back in 1977 (or 1980 or 1983, depending) simply weren’t possible either for technological or financial reasons. A number of the effects shots — not that many, strikingly, but a number of them — simply did not age well, and I have no problem with their replacement, especially since in most cases the new effects are, to my eyes, done tastefully and still in keeping with the general “look” of each film. I’m thinking of some of the individual shots during the final attack on the Death Star, for example.

The other type of revision Lucas is after can be called story enhancements. These are dicier, and I admit that not all of them work quite correctly. But what Lucas seems to be doing is trying to “retrofit” the original films so that their story more closely matches the story begun in the Prequel trilogy. In short, Lucas is trying to make sure that the entire film series tells a single story, and I really don’t fault him for this, even if I may on occasion fault the results.

More interesting to me is the idea that many fans (and non-fans alike, to judge by the vehemence of the online griping and bitching) that a film is like a painting or a sculpture, and that “finishing” a film should be like the moment when an painter lays down the brush for the last time or the sculptor sets aside his chisel. In a number of discussion board threads I’ve followed on the subject, this analogy is brought up again and again, and I’m not sure it holds, for this reason: film is a plastic medium, not a static one. Film bears more resemblance to music or literature than it does to static arts like painting, sculpture and photography. And when I look at the history of literature and music, I find that artists revising their work — sometimes many times over many years — is not without precedent.

Many classical composers revisited, and revised, their earlier works over the years. Berlioz did this, as did Wagner, whose opera Tannhauser actually exists in two distinct versions. Anton Bruckner’s music was so often heavily cut and revised and stitched back together that his scores present scholarship issues. And in literature, revision often occurs: consider how many versions of Leaves of Grass Walt Whitman produced, for example. I’m simply not convinced that the idea of a single, canonical version of a given work, be it a film, a symphony, a novel, a poem, or whatever else is an idea that has as much basis in reality as many seem to believe.

Share This Post

Sunday Burst of Weirdness

I can’t really do it justice, so I’ll just link Dave Thomas‘s LJ post, and you can follow his link. Wow. I don’t even know how to describe my reaction to this — I guess it’s one-half “Cool!”, one-half “Ewwww!”, and one-half “Huh?!” Yeah, I know that’s three halves. That’s part of the problem.

UPDATE: It’s brought to my attention, by a blogger I respect, that I have perhaps wandered into a bit of mean-spiritedness here, and looking things over, I have to plead, mea culpa. Part of it is that I genuinely don’t know what “cosplay” is, and therefore greatly misinterpreted what was going on here. I had assumed something, well, sexual in nature; it turns out that’s not really it. (Turns out that “cosplay” is sort of like when people go to Renaissance Faires dressed up in costume, but instead they dress as anime characters.) But that’s not really an excuse. I do try, as a general rule, to avoid mean-spirited mocking; unfortunately, like everyone, my efforts aren’t always successful.

I’m leaving the original post above, since I don’t believe in redacting my mistakes and deleting posts as if they never happened (it’s always bugged me how members of the US Congress can have stupid things they say stricken from the Congressional Record), but apologies around — especially to the young woman whose picture I obliquely reference above.

Share This Post

9-11-04

I don’t really feel like writing anything new in remembrance of 9-11-01 this year; it seems to me that I’ve said it all before, or more precisely, that I don’t have any new insights to offer. So here are links to what I wrote last year on this date:

Images of the Week, 9-11-03

My story, The City of Dead Works (It’s pretty short, by far the shortest story I’ve ever written.)

Losing 9-11-01 to History

Another fictional work for 9-11-01, by James Morrow (Way better than my own effort)

That’s about it. Rememberances, and the continuation of the lives that remain. That’s what there always is, right?

Share This Post

Who was that masked critic?!

Somehow, in the course of all the stuff that’s been going on, it escaped my notice that Terry Teachout was in my neck of the woods.

But then there’s this guy, who seems to think the idea of spending time in places like Buffalo and Cleveland for a vacation is laughable. One would think that having one’s nose in the air to that extent would leave one subject to nosebleeds.

Buffalo does have a lot of culture to offer, and has made a lot of cultural contributions. Maybe this blogger (of whom I’ve never heard) could take time to educate himself about them. (Maybe he could start by boning up on his grammar.)

Share This Post

Time for some geekery.

Yup, in light of all the heavy stuff that’s been on my brain lately, here’s a post about Star Wars.

The DVD boxed set of the original trilogy comes out in a couple of weeks, but to the chagrin of many fans, these are the “Special Editions”, not the actual versions released in 1977, 1980 and 1983 respectively. Personally, I’m fine with this. But that’s not all: the films have been tweaked yet again, and here’s a rundown of the changes.

Most involve touching up special effects and whatnot, and won’t really be noticeable, with the exception of one shot: the end of Return of the Jedi, when Anakin Skywalker, Obi Wan Kenobi, and Yoda all appear in their “spectral forms” to smile upon Luke after the Rebel victory. Back in the original film, actor Sebastian Shaw — who played Anakin/Vader in the “removal of the breath mask” scene — was filmed for the “spectral form”, but now, Hayden Christensen (who plays Anakin/Vader in Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith) is being inserted into that shot. I’m not sure if I like this. It seems needless, and I suppose that the idea is that a Jedi’s “spectral form” doesn’t change from the second of a Jedi’s death. This would therefore reinforce Obi Wan’s notion that at the moment Anakin became Vader, Anakin actually ceased to exist.

The difficulty, though, is that at the end, when Vader turns back to the good side, wouldn’t Vader therefore likewise cease to exist, and be replaced by Anakin? By this logic, shouldn’t the “spectral form” of Anakin still look like Sebastian Shaw?

Anyway, it’s a tiny point. And if the screenshots in the linked article are accurate, after three different versions of the original Star Wars trilogy, those weird “black blobs” are still visible on the Emperor’s temples in Return of the Jedi. Now that’s weird.

Share This Post

SNORE!!!

So I start glancing around Blogistan this afternoon, and all the political blogs are on about stuff like what fonts were available on typewriters thirty years ago and whether one could produce a superscript “th” on them and stuff that’s right out of an episode of Columbo.

You know what, folks? I’ve managed to find enough reason not to vote for George W. Bush just by watching the stuff he’s done as President, so I’m just not that interested in stuff he did thirty years ago when he was probably too drunk to know who was the President.

So stop the boat. I want to get off.

Share This Post

Sixteen times shall thy prefer’d warriors take the field….

So, it’s that time of year again, when the air is crisp and the kids return to school and stadiums throughout the United States resound with lusty cries of “Go, TEAM!” and “C’mon, ref, what’re ya, blind?!” and “Why oh WHY would you THROW on third-and-one?!”

Yup, the return of football season, which means it’s time for my annual prognostications on the impending NFL year, which will be, as always, both verbose and wrong.

:: So it came to pass that in the year 2004, a new and untested head coach took the reins of the NFL’s proudest franchise, the Buffalo Bills. Mike Mularkey comes here by way of the Pittsburgh Steelers, where he was offensive coordinator, and he brings a slew of offensive coaching talent that is probably the single best reason for any Bills fan to be optimistic about the 2004 campaign. After three years of watching Gregg Williams either mismanage himself, or more often, watch someone else mismanage the team’s offense, it’s hoped that this new staff will be able to do things like, oh, actually establish the running game that’s been the staple of many a pregame Bills press conference but never a staple of an actual Bills game.

And yet, for all that, I’m not particularly optimistic that the 2004 campaign will be much different from the Bills’ 2003 season, which was a 6-10 melange of good defense hampered by bad offense and horrible coaching. The Bills could make a run at the playoffs, and maybe even win 10 or 11 games, but a lot of stuff has to break in their favor for that to happen, and I just don’t see it all happening that way.

Here’s a partial rundown on what the Bills need to happen if they’re to have a good season:

1. Their offensive line, which saw no significant addition of talent (Ruben Brown left, replaced by some guy named Chris Villarial) and has rarely been more than adequate in recent years (and frequently abyssmal), has to suddenly start pass-blocking well enough to keep Drew Bledsoe from getting sacked constantly.

2. Drew Bledsoe, in turn, needs to find his football heart again, play like a competitor, stop looking like he’s just awoken from a coma, and most of all, stop making terrible decisions with the ball.

3. The defensive line, which in the offseason saw no addition of talent, needs to generate more pressure than it has in recent years, which will help in the turnover department.

4. The running back situation here, in which proven starter Travis Henry is apparently splitting duty with former first-round pick Willis McGahee in a textbook case of “This town ain’t big enough for the two of us”, needs to never become a major distraction.

5. The defensive backs, now led by newcomer Troy Vincent, actually need to start intercepting the ball, a performance area in which they have been pretty woeful over the last several years.

6. The receivers need to show more ability to get open, something at which they were not particularly good last year. Granted, Eric Moulds was never at a hundred percent due to groin injuries and somehow people expected Josh Reed to become the second coming of Andre Reed in just his second year, so I think we might be a bit more optimistic on this category.

7. Somebody from the tight-ends group needs to step up and become a productive tight end. The Bills have not been impressive at tight end since Pete Metzelaars retired. (Incidentally, Drew Bledsoe’s best years in the NFL — his first five or six years with the StuPats — coincide with the fact that those are the years he had one of the NFL’s best tight ends, Ben Coates, as a safety valve.)

And there’s more, but those are the biggies. I think that all of those things have to break the Bills’ way for the team to be good this year, and I think that’s too much to ask.

Finally, a note about general manager Tom Donahoe, who has been receiving more and more criticism from fans and media here with each consecutive non-playoff season. I’ve generally been willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, since I could see the logic behind a lot of the moves he has made, even the ones that haven’t panned out well. It’s easy to say “Geez, we coulda drafted Bryant McKinnie insteada Mike Williams”, but a lot of people would have made the exact same pick Donahoe did. And while it’s easy to criticize the selection of Gregg Williams as head coach in 2001 now, the fact is that back then, he was one of the highest-regarded defensive coordinators in the game. Somebody was going to make Williams a head coach; that somebody was the Bills. That it didn’t work out isn’t totally Donahoe’s fault.

But I’m noticing something odd with Donahoe’s general approach. When the Bills were rebuilding after the salary cap purge in 2001, it made sense to me that they drafted “for the future” — in other words, they brought in solid athletes who would need a lot of seasoning. And it made a bit of sense, although I was understandably puzzled, for Donahoe to gamble on Willis McGahee, since if he turns out to be a great player and you had a shot at him, you don’t want to have a bunch of “coulda beens” on your plate. But here the Bills are, three years into Donahoe’s administration, and still, this year the Bills drafted for the future. Lee Evans? Sure, everybody thinks he’ll be a fine receiver, but nobody thinks he’s going to be as good right now as Peerless Price was when he left (and that was when Price himself was in his fourth year), to say nothing of being a Randy Moss or Marvin Harrison. J.P. Losman? Yep, the Bills have their QB of the future (even though he’s injured now). But again, there’s a guy who won’t be ready to play for real until next year (rare is the QB who can step right into the NFL from the college game without some sidelines duty first), and then it’ll probably be a few years until he’s seasoned enough to make his own run.

What it comes down to with Donahoe is this: even when he was with the Steelers, he always seems to be thinking to two seasons from now. That’s great if you’re rebuilding, but if you’re just a handful of players away from being a real contender, as his Steelers often were, that’s when you don’t want to be thinking two seasons down the road. Donahoe, it seems, always makes moves that seem to improve his teams’ long-range prospects, but that’s frustrating when you need to improve this year’s team. This is a subtle point, but it’s one that I’ll wager the GM in New England understands.

So, after all that, what’s my prediction for the Bills? I think that a smarter offensive coaching staff is good enough for one or two extra wins, by themselves. So I’ll pencil the Bills in for an 8-8 season. No playoffs, but maybe hope for 2005. As far as placement in the division, I think they could be anywhere from second to fourth, depending on just how big of a mess the Dolphins are. As for the Jets, well, they’re the Jets and sometimes they catch enough breaks to be third and other times they don’t and wind up fourth. We’ll see.

:: The rest of the league? Here’s my rundown of how I expect the divisions to play out. I should note that I haven’t done my usual homework of studying the NFL rosters, so I’m not entirely sure who has gone where. But based on my feeling from last year or what little I know of the offseason, this is how I expect things to end up.

AFC East: New England Stupid Patriots

AFC North: Cincinnati

AFC South: Tennessee

AFC West: Denver

AFC wildcards: Indianapolis, Baltimore

NFC East: Philadelphia

NFC North: Minnesota

NFC South: Carolina

NFC West: Seattle

NFC wildcards: Dallas, Washington

I don’t really have a good reason for picking Washington to make the playoffs, except that I always liked Mark Brunell and that Gibbs guy who is said to be something of a decent coach. But there are my predictions for the divisions; having laid them out, I expect at least five of them to be wrong.

:: And now the part I’ve been dreading writing, because there’s no way around it. Who do I think will win the Super Bowl? Given that neither of the teams I have picked to win the Super Bowl have even made it to the big game in the two previous years I’ve outlined predictions on Byzantium’s Shores, maybe just the act of writing this will doom these guys. But probably not. Anyway, here it is:

The New England Stupid Patriots will defeat the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl XXXIX.

There, I said it. Ugh. Ugh, ugh, ugh.

Share This Post

…Nor any drop to drink.

What was left of Hurricane Frances arrived in Buffalo starting late yesterday, and those tattered wisps of what was once a powerhouse hurricane still managed to dump several inches of rain here in less than twelve hours, causing flooding in many locales around the Niagara Frontier. Where we live, we were generally spared, since Buffalo generally sits at the bottom of a basin that slopes upward as you travel south from the city, and we live in one of the Southtowns, ergo placing us on “higher ground”. Many folks are not so lucky, though: there were actually a number of schools closed locally due to flooding. School closures…on the second day of the school year. Ye Gods.

(Incidentally, major props to Buffalo’s local NBC affiliate, Channel 2, WGRZ. Their in-studio staff was all over it this morning, running constant tickers with the latest school closings and whatnot. But the Channel 2 web staff was not so attentive. Despite the repeated references by the anchors and on-air reporters to the “School Closing Central” section of WGRZ.com, the actual school closing information was never updated on the Web site as late as 8:30 a.m. I mean, the channel is running tickers saying “Such-and-Such School closed today”, but the Web site reported, “All schools are reported open”. That’s a crack web team there, folks. Yes, I sent them a caustic e-mail on the subject, pointing out that I was able to find the correct school closing information on the Web site of one of their competitors. That should open some eyes, seeing as how every TV station here is in a constant competition to see who “told you first”.)

Share This Post

Purgatory, continue’d….

Today is a fairly big day for little Quinn — a second EEG was scheduled, plus (possibly) the next attempt to remove the breathing tube. This is the day when we need whatever good karma we have to break in our favor. If he has to be intubated again later on, well — I don’t know. But it won’t be pretty.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓