You jump, I jump….

First Michael Lopez wrote about Titanic; then I wrote about Titanic, and then he wrote about Titanic some more. So it only seems right that I proceed to, yes, write a little more about Titanic.

Basically, I just want to respond to the fourth point in Michael’s second post, in which he’s still really hung up over the fact that Rose doesn’t sell the diamond and then live off the money (or something similar), which would make it a lot more feasible to “make every moment count”. The problem I’m having with Michael’s argument here is that he’s attacking Rose for this, but as far as I can see, what she’s doing is putting Jack‘s philosophy into play. Jack has, by the end of the film, been pretty much conclusively established as a guy who would rather be poor than rich, because he knows how to get by. Now, whether that’s realistic or not is open to question, but I don’t think it’s so easy to damn Rose when what she really does after the sinking is start living what was not actually her life, but Jack’s. (Take a good look at those photos on Rose’s shelf, the ones that Michael mentioned in his earlier post: the first one we see has her standing on a horse on a beach, in front of a roller coaster. This is an exact allusion to something Jack had said they would do when they left the ship, early in the film.)

I also think that the film also establishes that Rose would really rather be poor, so I think her decision to do nothing with the diamond is in keeping with her character. She has absolutely no desire to marry just to maintain her family’s station, nor does she want to remain in that “station” at all.

At its heart, the love story of Titanic is another version of Lady and the Tramp, although in this case the Lady decides to become a tramp herself, rather than see the Tramp “rehabilitated” to become a “Gentleman”. I don’t know, I guess from a standpoint of utilitarian ethics I can see the argument that Rose shouldn’t have kept the diamond all those years. But I can’t bring myself to hate Rose.

But then, this could simply be because she’s a ravishing redhead.

(Full disclosure, I suppose: To this day, I still love Titanic, even if the love story really is pretty goofy.)

Share This Post

God, am I a juvenile, or what???

I’m enjoying Alex Ross‘s photo-blogging of the Bayreuth Festival, which is on its third installment. But when he points out that statues of Richard Wagner’s dog are all over town, I can’t help but think it would be funny to walk around and place one of these behind every one of them.

I mean, I love Wagner’s music and all, but statues of his dog?!

UPDATE: Mr. Ross has a bit of new information about the dogs of Wagner. I wasn’t so much “alarmed” as “bemused”; I merely assumed that the canine statuary had been in place pretty much since the Wagner festival began, probably as part of Wagner’s own dictate as to how the Festival should be run. I don’t think that there’s much “whimsy” to be found in Wagner — either in his music or in his character — which is why I assumed the dogs weren’t meant to be whimsical.

But apparently the dogs are meant to be precisely that, and they’re a much more recent phenomenon: it’s an art project designed to make Wagner more accessible. That being the case, I’m reminded of something that happened in these parts, the Herd About Buffalo. This was a “herd” of life-sized fiberglass bison that were individually decorated by local artists and displayed around Buffalo before being auctioned off, one by one. A lot of local businesses and homeowners ended up buying them, so it’s not uncommon to drive around and see this big, stylized fiberglass buffalo sitting on someone’s front lawn.

Anyway, thanks to Mr. Ross for the link.

Share This Post

New at GMR

Incidental stuff: I’ve had a couple of new reviews appear the last two weeks at Green Man Review. One is for Move Under Ground, by Nick Mamatas (a book I liked, but with reservations — Mamatas himself, incidentally, thinks my review is tripe); and Airborn by Kenneth Oppel, which I loved. Check them out. (Ane believe me, if you’re looking for a fun book to read, get Oppel’s. It’s the closest thing I’ve ever read to a fourth Indiana Jones movie.)

More to come at GMR in the next couple of weeks as I clear the decks.

Share This Post

Ahhhh, those Freepers

In comments to this post, Scott (of Archipelapogo) wonders how long until the Freepers (that is, the denizens of Free Republic, a place that makes the denizens of Little Green Footballs look like paragons of centrist moderation) start referring to Barack Obama as “Obama bin Laden”. Scott predicts that Ann Coulter will use that phrase in print within 48 hours, but she’ll be quite behind the curve: the Freepers already had this one in play more than three weeks ago. You’ll also find it in use here (what constitutes a political “moderate” to this person is an exercise best left to the reader).

As of this writing, a Google search for the exact phrase “Obama bin laden” only turns up three pages’ worth of hits, but give it time. I expect that number to do nothing but rise.

Share This Post

Best. Resource. EVER!

I mean, really, this thing is freaking AWESOME.

It’s American Rhetoric, a site that gathers more than 5000 audio and/or video versions of

…. public speeches, sermons, legal proceedings, lectures, debates, interviews, other recorded media events, and a declaration or two.


This thing includes a selection of movie speeches. Want to hear the greatest pep-talk in literary history? This is the place for you!

Man, does Jason Streed ever deserve a giant cookie (with an equally-large glass of milk to go with it) for finding this one!

UPDATE: Lynn Sislo also linked this, via Jason.

Share This Post

A Research Request

I have a question for my female readership (or for my male readers who have females present whom they can ask). This is for a writing project that I’m getting underway. (It’s a screenplay of sorts, freely mined from some of the more absurd aspects of life at The Store. Kind of like Clerks, I guess, only probably not nearly as good. And with more spaceships. [No, not really. Spaceships, that is.])

Anyway, here’s a situation I want to write but I’m not sure about the key detail. My main female character will at some point arrive for work in the morning, but she will have undergone some kind of emotional trauma the night before — maybe a sudden and ugly breakup or some such thing (I haven’t thought much of this out). It’ll be the kind of thing that’s bad enough to make you wish you’d stayed home from work, but not so serious as to make you actually stay home from work.

So my question is: what effect would this sort of thing have on her makeup? I don’t want anything so obvious as streaks of mascara running down her cheeks — maybe she got all her crying done and has enough self-control to keep from bawling on the job, but she still doesn’t want it to be obvious to everyone at work that she’s been crying all night. What does she do, makeup-wise, to accomplish this? And what details would tip someone off? I’m thinking that most people will simply think she looks a tiny bit different from her usual appearance, but I want to have one person who knows just what the tiny shifts (or not so tiny) in her makeup application might mean.

(For some reason, this project is coming to me in the form of disconnected scenes, all over the place. I have no idea how to tie it up as a story, which seems kind of weird to me, since I rarely work this way, if ever.)

Share This Post

Who WAS that masked man?!

Via just about everybody (Darth Swank, Modulatin’ Steve, Kevin Drum), I see that Atrios is no longer anonymous. He’s a guy named Duncan.

So I guess this puts to bed all those Sidney Blumenthal rumors of a while back. And while it’s pretty cool to see the face behind the Eschatonic greatness, part of me is slightly disappointed: it’s as if the “Who Shot JR?” episode of Dallas had revealed that the assassin was merely a night watchman whose gun accidentally discharged.

Anyway, I wonder if PZ Myers thinks that Atrios/Duncan looks like an axe murderer….

(As of this writing, Atrios himself has yet to say anything at all about being “outed”, as far as I can see. Hmmmmmm.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓