Memorizing

There’s a fascinating post by Our Girl in Chicago (Terry Teachout’s coblogger, for those not regularly reading About Last Night — speaking of which, why aren’t you?) on the topic of memorizing poetry.

“An art of opening the heart”: this is a nice way of capturing the extra-intellectual aspects of memorizing poetry. To memorize something effectively, you have to expend some interpretive effort on it, and with this effort you wind up in something like a conversation with the text. Grasping at least the literal meaning—not necessarily as easy as you might think, I’ve learned in my teaching—is the most efficient way of mastering a poem, so you can’t help but learn something more than just the words in the process. And the richer the text, the more there is to absorb. It’s sad that such a truly mind-expanding practice has been saddled with a reputation as just the opposite.


My experience with memorizing in school was a bit strange. I never resented having to do it, when it was actually required (which I suspect was not enough). I actually enjoyed having some bit of verse that I could recall to mind, any time I wanted, unless it was a bit of verse I totally hated (like this Godawful thing, which I’m sure will send Nefarious Neddie into convulsions as soon as he clicks the link, because he sat in front of me in that class and he had to do it too).

And as I noted a short while back, I’m trying to do some memorizing of my own: not poems, per se, but songs, which is really part of the same thing. You have to learn a tune, and you have to learn the words, and you have to learn how the words fit into the tune, and to make it all work you have to figure out just what the song’s about in the first place. It doesn’t do any good to learn the words and tune of, say, “I’m Glad I’m Not Young Anymore” from Gigi if you don’t realize just what kind of mischievous dirty old man Honore really is, and what he’s getting at when he sings it. And it’s really fun to just be able to drop little bits of verse and song lyric into idle conversation, once in a while. If you want to sound like you’re an erudite individual, well, here’s a great way to do it. And the best part is that it will actually make you erudite.

The part that I seriously hated about memorizing in school wasn’t the actual memorizing, then. No, it was the fact that teachers felt the insatiable need to couple memorizing with reciting, which I despised as much as is possible to despise anything. Bad enough that you have to stand up in front of your classmates and fumble through a poem, but even worse if every kid in the class is doing the same damned poem, so you’re spending forty-five minutes in a hard-wooden chair listening to the same poem over and over and over and over and over again, while Mrs. Hairbun dutifully takes down notes on each student’s delivery. It always seemed to me that simply giving everyone a piece of paper and requiring them to actually write down the poem would have accomplished the same goal, without being simultaneously boring and nerve-wracking; moreso if the actual goal was to learn a poem as opposed to being expected to put on a bit of performance art (woeful grades to the student who delivered every syllable perfectly, but with a monotone that would make Mr. Spock proud).

Anyway, maybe I will start memorizing poems. It seems a good way to simply exercise the brain a bit, and you never know when the ability to start spouting some Tennyson at length might come in useful.

(Lynn Sislo also comments on this. I actually read her post first, but I would have read OGIC’s sooner or later anyway, since I read About Last Night daily. Did I already mention that?)

Share This Post

Foil’d again….

Want a good example of frustration? It’s going a little online reading while you eat breakfast before work, seeing something hilarious that you just know one particular co-worker of yours will think is just hilarious because it involves a hobby of his, and then discovering that he’s not scheduled to work that day.

So I told someone else, and they got a kick out of it, but the original guy I’d planned on sharing the funny story with would have enjoyed it a lot more.

Oh, and the funny story is this Ebay auction, in which some woman who recently caught her fiance cheating on her put all of his PlayStation games up for bids. (Apparently she paid for them all, so she’s reasoning that they’re technically hers.) Talk about Hell having no fury, and all that jazz.

(via John Scalzi)

Share This Post

Eureka!

Thanks to PZ Myers and Scott Spiegelberg, whose comments to this post I was able to combine in order to make my blockquotes look the way I want them to. (For the really geeky, I went with a color other than blue because I already use blue for links.)

I’m really starting to figure out how things work on what Matthew Yglesias calls “this Interweb thingy”.

Share This Post

Carlos Kleiber 1930-2004

Via Lynn Sislo I see that conductor Carlos Kleiber has died. Like Lynn, I am not terribly familiar with Kleiber’s work, except via one recording. Luckily, that recording was a very fine one indeed; unluckily, I no longer own it (I owned a taped copy from my high school music teacher’s LPs). It was this recording of Carl Maria von Weber’s opera Der Freischutz, which to this day is one of my very favorite operas. It’s full of earthy German choruses, several wonderful arias, and a hair-raising scene involving the Devil (a scene which, being constructed around the tritone, is an important forebear of Wagner’s leitmotif technique).

My current version of Der Freischutz — on CD, of course — is Sir Colin Davis’s (with Staatskapelle Dresden), and while it’s quite good, to this day whenever I listen to it I hear things that I liked better in Kleiber’s version, even though it’s well over ten years since my tapes faded to nothingness.

I also recall Kleiber’s 1992 New Year’s From Vienna concert on PBS, which was enjoyable as always but not as fine as Herbert von Karajan’s 1987 version.

Share This Post

Apropos of Nothing….

When you buy a new desh for your office, and it’s one of those “Put it together yourself” jobs that come in two big, heavy, long flat boxes, and you have ordered the model in cherry wood because that’s the wood you like and that’s what the other people with offices have, you will generally find it good practice to actually crack open the box and confirm that the desk the furniture place has shipped to you actually is cherry wood before you pull everything out of your office and pile it all in the office corridor. Waiting to do so until after you’ve emptied your office is a tempting of fate that is not unlike dangling a bit of string before the eyes of a wakeful kitten.

Share This Post

An HTML question

OK, technophiles, here’s what I want: When I use the “blockquote” tag, the font within the blockquote is smaller than the font of the regular post. Is there a way to change this without resorting to “font size=+1” every time, which seems to me to be something of a kludge? What I’d really like is for blockquotes to appear offset and in blue text, but in the same size as the regular post.

Share This Post

I’za good critic!

For a bit of fascinating yin and yang, check out Alex Ross and Terry Teachout on the subject of a new classical work by Elvis Costello. Now, I haven’t heard the piece in question, so I have no opinion, but it’s always cool to read two articulate and knowledgable critics who stand in disagreement over the same work.

And I also think it’s funny that both make veiled negative references to Paul McCartney’s “cantata” Standing Stone. I borrowed the CD of that work from the library a year or so ago, and I remember thinking as I played it, “This is the most banal damn thing I’ve ever heard!” I’ve never shied from liking stuff that critics don’t (Attack of the Clones is a great movie! Someday you’ll see!), but still, it’s cool to receive vindication once in a while.

Share This Post

IMAGE OF THE WEEK





The hands of composer and pianist Sergei Rachmaninov.

If there were a classical composer who was most likely to ever supplant Hector Berlioz as the leading light of my musical world, it would almost certainly be Sergei Rachmaninov. I’ll write a longer post about Rachmaninov and my appreciation of him another time, but for now I note that in reading a little bit about him recently, I am reminded that apparently his hands were enormous, able to span over an octave-and-a-half on a piano keyboard. This “wingspan” allowed him to pull off feats of pianistic skill that would defy people of, well, smaller hands.

I found the above picture this morning, and it doesn’t quite convey the massive size of Rachmaninov’s hands as well as I was hoping, but you still get the sense of it — look how long those fingers are, for one.

(BTW, Rachmaninov’s three symphonies — the first and third are wonderful, and the second is just transcendent — are available in a budget-priced “two-for-the-price-of-one” set here, performed by the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra and conducted brilliantly by Vladimir Ashkenazy. I own these recordings in their earlier, singly-issued, full-price incarnations — and I’ve never regretted buying them.)

Share This Post

Two provocative quotes

I read two interesting quotes today that I partly agree with. (Or, more accurately, I’m not sure what part I disagree with, or even if I do, or if I’m just mildly uncomfortable with something contained within them, as a foggy sort of cognitive dissonance holds sway.)

:: Michael Blowhard on “adolescence”:

Adulthood now looks sad. Having been crowded off the stage, adulthood mills about disconsolate and lost. Given that we now live in a country whose central values are adolescent, we’ve lost track of even the best adult values — wit, grace, perspective, depth, suaveness, conviction, knowledge. In any sane civilization, these would all be regarded as virtues. In our country these days, such virtues often seem the marks of losers and failures.


I’m very sympathetic to this, but at the same time, I don’t really know. I don’t think it stops at adolescence even; our culture is geared generally toward children to a ridiculous degree. Teens are the “gotta get ’em” demographic, and actual adults aren’t merely ignored as Michael suggests, but actually viewed as mere caretakers for the pre-adolescents. Our role as adults is just to make sure that there are more adolescents in ten years, and that’s about it. The mere thought that maybe, just maybe, the kids aren’t the absolute first priority in our lives is met with a gawking stare. It’s really weird, and I don’t have the solution, unfortunately. But on a practical note, it’s just hard to set aside the Kid in favor of more adult pursuits a lot of the time, on both logistical and financial grounds.

(Allow me to resurrect here my abject hatred for the greatest lie ever foisted on teenagers: “These are the best years of your lives.” God, what vomitous prattle that is. That’s right, kids: not only are we discouraging you from actually looking forward to adulthood, but we want you to actively dread it. And speaking of that, where did this idea ever come from that “adulthood” is somehow wholly incompatible with things like whimsy and lightness?)

:: The Gray Monk on Islam:

It is time to put aside the “All Muslims are Victims” thinking and recognise that Islam must grow up. The problems in the Middle East and elsewhere relating to Islam are generated by the tension created by the fact that Islam is intolerant of any other religious philosophy.


I agree strongly with this idea, the thought that Islam is now roughly where Christianity was before the Renaissance, Reformation and Enlightenment eras all transpired. I’d add, though, that at least here in this country (the Gray Monk is from Britain and writes from the perspective of British politics, a subject on which I know little), the brand of Christianity that at least partially mirrors Islam in its current state is much more ascendent (they dominate the Republican Party); and I’d also add that as much as I may agree with the idea that the Islamic world needs to “grow up”, my problem with recent policy decisions from our end — and I’m talking about the Iraq war — is that I’m far from convinced that “bomb them until they realize how badly they’ve gone off the rails” is really a workable strategy for encouraging such. (This point isn’t exactly in response to anything the Gray Monk has written today; it’s just a thought of mine. Anyway, Gray Monk follows up here.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓