Scalzi on Music

For his recent “Reader Suggestion Week”, I posed the following question to John Scalzi:

“Will things like iTunes destroy the way we used to allow songs to ‘grow’ on us, as we tilt toward buying songs that are immediately pleasing? And will the fact that apparently the individual song is increasingly the atomic entity with respect to music distribution, will this kill the idea of the album? And what place classical music in the grand world of downloading, when the paradigm of ‘Hey, bands, just record your music in your basement!’ doesn’t really scale to symphony orchestras?”

He offered the following answer in the middle of a “grab-bag” post of all the questions that didn’t inspire a full-length post of its own:

“Well, it’s not like orchestras ever fit into basements. Didn’t stop hundreds of years of symphonies from being written. And when you have the capability of being able to replicate an entire orchestra from a synth, what’s to stop some ambitious person from composing a symphonic score?

Yes, I think iTunes et al will change how we approach music, but it’ll change it back to what it was, say, in 1903, when most music was sold as songs (through sheet music). Albums are a fairly late development in terms of being the accepted basic unit of musical currency. Also, I think we’ve all always tilted toward songs — it’s why even in the era of albums bands always released singles. I’ve mentioned before that I do think the idea of an album meaning “a set number of songs determined by the physical limitations of the recording media” is going out the door, but I think musically ambitious bands will always release suites of thematically-linked songs. Would it be so bad to live in a world where Radiohead or Wilco could release album-length works and Britney and Justin simply released singles? Digital distribution allows for both.”

I wish I could put my finger on it, but this answer just doesn’t seem right to me, and I’m not sure why. I can cite a number of places where I diverge with John, but I’m not sure they add up to him being wrong. So, I’ll just respond to a few items here.

:: First, I think he totally missed my fear, expressed in the opening of my question, that downloads will hasten the compression of our attention span, which is already alarmingly diminished. If we assume that most people who buy music by the song will only buy those songs whose first few seconds immediately appeal to them, have we lost something as a musical culture? I mean, if you bail out on Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique after the first four minutes, you still won’t even have heard the idee fixe, the theme which ties together the entire work. That’s an extreme example, to be sure, but I think it helps illustrate what I’m getting at.

:: I think John’s a bit flip about dismissing my concerns about classical music in general in the age of downloading. No, composers didn’t write symphonies and record them in their own basements, but there were a lot more orchestras then, as well. And I mean, a lot more orchestras. Every town had its own orchestra, many nobles even had their own orchestras, et cetera. Since the era we’re talking about was mostly the pre-recording era, the premium was on performance, which no longer seems to be the case at all. Live music was music, whereas now recording has become so entrenched that we constantly have to remind ourselves that live music even exists. Some commentators I’ve seen (and I’m not sure if John would fit in this category) seem to think that the demise of Big Recording (assuming the demise of Big Recording) will lead to some grand rebirth of live music, which I’m not at all convinced will be the case. And the problem to classical music, in particular, seems to me to be potentially pernicious: as fewer recordings get made, fewer ensembles will exists in the first place, which means fewer opportunities for the composers to get their works performed at all. And besides, those hundreds of years of symphonies were largely written before the rise of the synth, electric guitar, and drumset.

:: I’m a bit dismayed at John’s suggestion that the synthesizer can replicate a symphony orchestra. Approximate, yes. Replicate, no. I don’t want to dismiss the possibilities of electronic music — a lot of my favorite music is electronic in nature — but I don’t want to downplay its limitations. If we reach a point where there are only a handful of orchestras left, I really can’t imagine that the fact that a synthesizer can simulate one will really inspire too much creation of new symphonic music.

:: John says that the musical culture will revert to that of 1903, when the song was the chief means of musical distribution, in the form of sheet music. This analogy troubles me, because the only point of convergence is in the song-as-musical-atom. Sheet music dominated, firstly, in the era prior to widespread recording; and second, more importantly, sheet music’s popularity depended on widespread musical literacy to a degree that I regret to say I find unlikely to ever exist again. For sheet music to be of any use, someone has to be able to play the piano, and not just plink out a tune or two, but actually play the thing. Song-as-atom or no, music was a participatory thing to the people of 1903. Not so now. The song, back then, was still seen as just a first-step into music. Now, it seems as though the song is the only thing that matters. Witness, today, the track list of a mix CD John made for his daughter. It’s all songs, and rock or pop songs to boot. Not an iota of orchestral music there, no suggestion of longer forms.

:: Finally, John says that digital distribution still allows for the concept of the album. I don’t disagree, but that’s not what I’m getting at. What can be done with digital distribution is one thing; what is likely to be done with it is something else. If Radiohead releases an “album”, in the classic sense of the word, online, but people are able to buy either a song or two from it up to the whole thing, what’s the point of the “album” in the first place? Can the “album” even be said to exist? It seems to me that the idea of artistic context that is inherent in the album concept would suffer dramatically in such a scheme.

(Postscript: I don’t want this to sound like a big attack on John Scalzi, because I love the guy’s blogs in general and his thoughts on writing in particular. But there’s just something that bothers me about today’s music talk: it’s entirely about songs. Song this and song that, and here’s a great song, and here’s the ecletic bunch of songs on my iPod, et cetera. The word “music” now seems to be a singular plural for “songs”. I really do worry that longer forms will no longer exist with any kind of true vibrancy.)

Share This Post

The Tempting of Luke

Wow, that sure worked: lots of good comments to the discussion question below, in which I ask if Luke Skywalker was possibly tempted by the Dark Side of the Force when Ben Kenobi was struck down.

The answers seem to trend largely to “No”, which is why I am sure it will not surprise anyone that my answer is “Yes”. Ha! Take that, Smithers! Er….anyway, my rationale follows.

First, I think it’s important to distinguish that there are varying degrees of “temptation by the Dark Side”. I fully grant that whatever Luke feels at that moment, Dark side-wise, is much, much milder than what he feels in The Empire Strikes Back after his vision of his friends in pain, and not even close to what he feels in the throne room in Return of the Jedi. But I do think he’s tempted: just a tiny bit, perhaps, but tempted nonetheless.

It’s worth noting how Yoda defines the Dark Side in The Empire Strikes Back: “A Jedi’s strength flows from the Force. But beware the Dark Side. Anger, fear, aggression — the Dark Side of the Force are they. Easily they flow, quick to join you in a fight.” (Emphasis mine.)

I’d submit that Luke most definitely feels at least two of those emotions in that moment, as he stands still and starts blasting away at the stormtroopers: anger and aggression. The closest thing he’s ever had to a father figure has been struck down before his eyes, by the very man who (he believes) killed his own father, and in that moment, nothing to him matters except vengeance. He ignores Leia’s cries for him to get aboard the ship, while heeding Han’s helpful advice to blast the shield door controls. Only when he hears Ben’s voice in his mind does he realize that he has momentarily lost perspective.

Now, in comments, Nefarious Neddie notes that not all instances of anger, fear or aggression constitute Dark-Side temptations, and I’d agree, although I’d also point out that in Obi Wan’s duel with Darth Maul in The Phantom Menace, anger and aggression very nearly get Obi Wan killed. There’s a closeup of Obi Wan’s enraged face as he brings down a fierce blow which Maul barely parries, but this leaves Obi Wan open to Maul’s “Force blast” which sends him over the brink of the shaft. The implication is that aggression and anger lead to dolorous ends, even if not always to a Dark-Side conversion.

What really convinces me that Luke’s moment in the Death Star landing bay is a Dark-Side temptation, though, is a parallel moment in Anakin Skywalker’s life in Attack of the Clones. It’s been well-noted that Anakin’s life in the prequel trilogy roughly parallel’s Lukes, but with Luke making the right decisions at the appropriate moments while Anakin keeps making the wrong ones. Consider the two moments I’m talking about: Luke/Anakin witnesses the passing of his closest parental figure, in the company of those responsible (Luke sees Ben fall to Vader, Anakin cradles his mother as she dies in the Tusken camp). And then compare what happens afterward: Each lashes out at the perpetrators (even though Luke can’t really get a good shot at Vader, he dispatches a number of his surrogate Stormtroopers). Each hears, in his mind, the voice of the Jedi who first “discovered” him, warning him away (Luke hears Ben saying “Run, Luke, run!”; Anakin hears Qui Gon saying, “Anakin! Anakin! NO!“).

But — and this is the important part — where Luke heeds the voice he hears, Anakin ignores his — and I think it’s pretty clear that Anakin’s slaying of the Tuskens is his first foray into Darkness. (John Williams, as always, tips us off: when Anakin tells Padme what he’s done, we hear the Emperor’s Theme alternated with Vader’s Theme in the score.) The two moments, in my mind, are closely parallel, which leads me to believe that Luke was, in fact, tempted by the Dark Side at that point. But while Luke turns away from his temptation, Anakin gives in to his.

Share This Post

The Gold Watch

Andrew Cory suggests that when John Kerry debates President Bush this fall, he should explicitly mention the fact that he still has a piece of shrapnel embedded in his posterior. I’m not really sure this is a good idea; in my mind at least, if Kerry did this I would be forced to envision Christopher Walken telling a little boy, “I hid this uncomfortable hunk of metal up my ass for two years….”

Share This Post

Stealing the Government’s Bandwidth

Actually, is it stealing the government’s bandwidth, since I’m a citizen and I pay taxes and all that? Hmmmm….anyway, time for my standard “Too tired to blog, but wanting my posts to take up more space on the front page” trick of swiping a recent Astronomy Picture of the Day. Here are some nebulae:

For more details, go here. Weirdly, the APOD site uses nebulas as the plural of nebula instead of nebulae, which I always thought was correct but which I now see by looking it up that nebulas is an acceptable plural form after all. I don’t know, it all seems pretty nebulous to me.

Bada-BING!

(By the way, I see via Patrick Nielsen Hayden that NASA has recently discovered that politics trumps science in the Bush Administration. Oh, goody.)

Share This Post

Your STAR WARS discussion question

Here’s an experiment for the comment thread: a discussion question. Because, you know, I’m tired and scraping the bottom of an already shallow mental barrel for blog stuff. Here’s the question:

Would it be fair to say that the scene in A New Hope immediately following Ben Kenobi’s death — when Luke is torn between escaping with his friends on the waiting Millennium Falcon and standing his ground against the stormtroopers (and, presumably, Darth Vader) to avenge Ben — constitutes the first time Luke is tempted by the Dark Side of the Force?

Share This Post

A Class Act

Say what you will about Drew Bledsoe’s recent performance with the Bills — 2003 in particular — the fact is that Bledsoe is still a classy guy. Today he agreed to a restructuring of his contract, which as most NFL contracts do these days would have put him into stratospheric heights with respect to the salary cap after this year. Now the Bills are no longer virtually committed to dumping Bledsoe after the 2004 season, which gives them enormous flexibility: if Bledsoe tanks in 2004, they can get rid of him more cheaply and move on to the J.P. Losman era, or if Bledsoe returns to form, they can keep him and give Losman another year of development in 2005. And the money not being spent now on Bledsoe means that the team may be able to pick up an additional free agent or two to plug into whatever holes still need filled.

I personally never viewed Bledsoe as anything more than “the guy to play while they groom the next guy”, but it’s nice that the Bills will have flexibility to really spend their time carefully developing the next guy.

Share This Post

Hmmmm, time for some new posts…..zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz….

Posting here may be a bit light this week due to a rather intensive period at work. The Company has decided to operate a full-blown Garden Center at The Store, which is a sort-of “prototype” operation that will be replicated at other locations next year if we’re successful this year. Last week saw the construction of the Garden Center. This week sees the delivery of plants. Lots and lots and lots of plants. Today I helped unload the first three deliveries, totaling almost a thousand plants (and by “plants”, I also include trees and shrubberies [Ni!]). And when I left for the day, the fourth truck was waiting in the wings. So between all that hefting of plants, wallowing in dirt and potting soil, moving wooden pallets around, and climbing into and out of the backs of semis, I’m really rather tired.

(But hey, I got to drive a forklift. That’s always fun. I haven’t been able to drive a forklift in over ten years. There is no finer macho toy than a forklift, if you’re a guy who doesn’t actually have to drive one on a regular basis.)

Share This Post

Anyone want to run for Congress from Buffalo?

Buffalo Congressman Jack Quinn, a Republican from Hamburg (one of Buffalo’s Southtowns), has announced his retirement this year. This could be a good seat for Democrats to pick up: the district is predominantly Democratic to begin with, and Quinn himself was a political moderate (he spearheaded a move to raise the minimum wage and has been fairly labor-friendly, by Republican standards). I’m excited as a Democrat at the prospect of a pickup here, but Quinn was a good advocate in Congress for Buffalo, and that’s a legacy that needs to stand. This city needs all the help it can get.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓