Book Memes, Two.

PZ Myers has three book memes in one post. One of which is The List, which I’ve already discussed, but I’ll take on the other two. First is simple: what are my rules of what constitutes a good story?

I guess I’d lead off by saying that I don’t think there are any “rules” for fiction; better, probably, to try to describe what characteristics are common to stories I love. With that in mind, here I go:

1. Don’t depress me. This is big: I don’t like stories that are just depressing. But this does not rule out sad endings, because “sad” does not equal “depressing”. Likewise, “dark” (or “gothic” or “downbeat”) also do not equal “depressing”. Schindler’s List is a terribly sad movie; Seven is a depressing one. I guess the difference is that sadness can still seem to serve a purpose, whereas depression is without purpose: it’s just there. I don’t want a story in which characters are subjected to just one damn thing after another, with no hope at all for a respite or even a good lesson learned beyond “Life sucks”. If I want “Life sucks”, well, I’ll just look at, you know, life.

2. Engage my emotions. This goes hand-in-hand with “Don’t depress me”. Even though I don’t want to feel depression after reading or viewing a story, I do want to feel something. A story that is the emotional equivalent of an unsalted saltine cracker is not a story for me.

3. Tie up your loose ends. Unless you don’t want to. I tried coming up with a better way to say this, but I can’t. I love both kinds of stories I’m talking about here, really: I love it when everything ties up into a neat little package, and I also love it when a story lets some things stay open, as if to suggest that the story was really just a segment of someone’s life that we’ve just watched. Guy Gavriel Kay does the latter a lot; John Bellairs does the former. Either works.

4. But if you’re gonna tie up your loose ends, be careful about it. Too often, a “no loose ends” book or movie starts to feel like one: about two-thirds or three-quarters of the way through, you start to notice a relentless pace at which one thread is tied up every few pages or minutes or so. And then there’s Neal Stephenson, who leaves everything in the air until the last ten pages, and then whammo! It’s all bundled up with duct tape and baling wire. That’s not satisfying, really.

5. Great stuff along the way will make me forgive a crappy ending. But the stuff along the way had better be really great.

6. Beware the surprise ending, or the shocking revelation. I love being surprised in stories, but the surprises have to arise logically out of the content of the story, so even if I didn’t see it coming, I can still reexamine the story and see the clues and note the construction by which the surprise or revelation comes. A great example of how not to handle this is the movie Basic Instinct, whose final shot reveals whether or not a certain character is the murderer. The way the story has been constructed, it could have gone either way and made equal sense. That’s bad storytelling.

7. Show me something new along the way. Discovery is cool. And it doesn’t have to even be something totally new; it can just be a new way of looking at something really familiar. Don’t be ordinary.

8. The word “said” should comprise at least 97% of your dialogue attributions. And for the love of God, please don’t use “ejaculated” as a verb of dialogue attribution. I can’t read about someone “ejaculating” a sentence without thinking of that one scene in There’s Something About Mary.

Finally, I can probably distill all this into a single, three-part rule: Don’t bore me, don’t make me feel bad for having been told your story, and don’t do anything that breaks the spell you’re trying to weave.

I could probably come up with lots more, but you probably get the idea. You probably also get the idea that I’m a pretty permissive reader. That I am, and I’ve never made any bones about it: I tend to like lots of stories, of different kinds, told in different ways.

Share This Post

Book Memes, One.

There are suddenly a lot of book memes circulating. While I’ll take a pass on the “List the great books you’ve read” one, here’s one via Wil Duquette that I like: listing the ten books that had the biggest impact on my life.

Now, it’s really hard to do this, now that I’ve been thinking of it for a day or two. It’s tough to gauge impact, because I find that books can often lay in the tall grass, so to speak, for many years — I’ll read them, file them away in my brain, and then suddenly discover later on how they moved me in one direction or another. I’ve waffled on a lot of these titles, and who knows, I may come back and change them later. Anyway, here are ten books, some of which won’t be a surprise to longtime readers. (These are in no particular order, and as I tend to do in “List” posts, I cheat. A lot.)

1. Cosmos, Carl Sagan. To this day, this is still the book that has influenced my overall worldview regarding the Universe and our place within it more than any other. I find so much more awe, so much more poetic beauty, so much more reverence in a Universe that is billions of years old and through physical processes eventually gave rise to life and consciousness than I do in the idea of a static Universe popped into being in just six days, six thousand years ago. The science of this book may be out of date, but I don’t care. As far as I am concerned, it is a towering achievement of twentieth century science writing.

2. The Lord of the Rings, J.R.R. Tolkien. It’s pretty obvious why, I think.

3. Salem’s Lot, Stephen King. This is the first out-and-out horror book I read, once I was ready to really delve into the genre.

4. On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft, Stephen King. This book provided the answers to questions I didn’t even know I had.

5. 2001: A Space Odyssey, Arthur C. Clarke. I’m pretty sure I read some science fiction before this, but this one cemented my love of the genre for all time. And not only that, this book showed me what was possible in the genre besides Star Wars space opera and Star Trek “sociological” SF.

6. The Prydain Chronicles, Lloyd Alexander. (Yeah, it’s a five book set, actually. Deal with it.) My first encounter with epic fantasy, two years before Tolkien.

7. Tigana, Guy Gavriel Kay. It’s not my favorite GGK novel, but it’s the first that I read, and in the same way 2001 pushed me beyond my original idea of what SF was, Tigana broadened my horizons of what fantasy can do.

8. The Joy of Music and The Infinite Variety of Music, Leonard Bernstein. I group these together because the content of each — essays, teleplays from Bernstein’s TV programs, interviews — are so similar in style and tone. These two books shaped my love of music more than any others. I always adored Bernstein’s ability to adore and venerate a very wide range of music, and I have always tried to follow his example. (This is a man who would as soon conduct Mozart as he would David Diamond.)

9. Dungeon, Fire and Sword: The Knights Templar in the Crusades, John J. Robinson. A fascinating era of history, engagingly written by a writer who didn’t produce nearly enough books.

10. The Book of Marvels, Richard Halliburton. This man’s travel writings, all of which roughly correspond to the years between the two World Wars, are a clinic on how to convey “sense of wonder”. Track down a copy, and when you read it, try to ignore the obvious anachronisms (like the fairly obvious “white man’s superiority” stuff, which is par for the course for the book’s day).

And, you know, why not a couple of honorable mentions:

11. Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud can teach you a great deal about storytelling, and not just about comics.

12. The follow-up, Reinventing Comics, is less about storytelling and more about the possibilities inherent in a digital age.

13. Adventures in the Screen Trade and Which Lie Did I Tell? More Adventures in the Screen Trade William Goldman. These will also teach you a great deal about storytelling; and for me, they pretty much squashed any idea that I’d ever try to sell a film script. (Not that I could sell the ones I’ve already written, of course, because they’re Star Wars fan-fictions.)

14. The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark, Carl Sagan. Essential reading, really, in this age of belief in UFOs and holeopathic medicine and various other nonsense items.

15. The House with a Clock in its Walls, John Bellairs. Just because Bellairs is a favorite author of mine, and this is the first of his that I read. Gothic fiction for kids. Great stuff.

16. Danny, the Champion of the World by Roald Dahl. Humor, warmth, darkness, cruelty, love, pain, redemption, and the perfect ending. All in one book.

OK, that’s it. For now. (I told you I cheat!)

Share This Post

Man, am I reading the wrong books….

One blog meme which I will not be picking up is the big list of great books that’s going around, the idea being to bold the one’s you’ve read. (You can see the list here, in Lynn Sislo’s version.) I won’t be doing this list because for one thing, I think it’s a pretty odd — it includes Shelley’s Frankenstein, but not Stoker’s Dracula, for example, and I’m not really sure how to count some works. There are things I read in high school to which I have not given a single thought since, so much so that I couldn’t possibly talk intelligently about them beyond saying “Yeah, I read that in high school.” Would that count? And while I haven’t read Pygmalion since high school, does it count that I know My Fair Lady by heart?

But more than that, I prefer to maintain my belief that I am actually a fairly well-read individual, and posting visual evidence that I’ve not read the vast majority of those books would do damage to my self-image. And I’m all about self-image, you know. Uhh….or something like that.

And then there’s Jason’s copy of the list. Man, is he well-read. Yeesh. It reminds me of an exchange in an episode of The West Wing, when Josh Lyman glances over Charlie Young’s shoulder at his school transcripts as Charlie is filling out college applications:

JOSH: Charlie, just how smart are you?

CHARLIE: I got some game.

Jason’s got some game, too.

Share This Post

The Draft (NFL, that is)

One thing I love about the NFL is the way the long, slow offseason is punctuated at about the halfway point by the annual College Draft, when teams select their “players of the future”, and hope for, say, a second-rounder who will become a Hall-of-Famer (Thurman Thomas) while avoiding a first-rounder who flops horribly (Ryan Leaf). The Draft is split over two days, with the first three rounds on Saturday and the last four rounds on Sunday. The Draft gives fans the first inkling of what their team is up to and how things might shape up in the season to come.

First thing’s first, though: Eli Manning.

I can’t stand it when young athletes enter the draft of some professional sport but then whine when they don’t like who drafts them. I never really liked John Elway because he started his career with this kind of crap (the Colts – then of Baltimore – drafted him, but he pitched a fit and got himself traded to Denver), and so did Eric Lindros when he entered the NHL. My belief is that if you do something like enter the NFL draft, you take your chances. It’s no secret at all that the bad teams get the first picks, so if you’re one of the very best college players in the draft, you know you’re going to play for someone who’s rebuilding. And these days, if you really don’t want to play for them, just put in your four initial years and then exercise free agency.

So Eli Manning, who pitched a fit about not going to the Chargers, got his wish and was traded to the Giants about an hour after he was drafted by San Diego. Fine. I don’t blame Manning, really, for not wanting to go to San Diego, seeing as how that team’s front office is only marginally better managed than that of the Arizona Cardinals, but still — they had the first pick, and Manning’s the guy. By pitching a fit, he’s already shown without ever so much as putting on shoulder pads in the NFL that he places himself ahead of the team. So I hope he tears his ACL in his first game and never plays again. Seriously.

(And for some reason, I’ve never been too wild about Eli’s older brother Peyton either, but I don’t know why. I mean, he’s a very good quarterback, but he just bugs me, somehow. Maybe it’s my suspicion that he was named after a soap opera?)

Now for the really important stuff from yesterday’s first three rounds of the NFL Draft (with rounds 4-7 happening today): how did the Buffalo Bills do?

Well, I dunno.

I mean, there’s that metaphysical sense in which I don’t know: you obviously can’t predict the future. Back in 1991 or thereabouts the Indianapolis Colts had the first and second picks in the draft overall, which they used to take defensive end Steve Emtman and linebacker Quentin Coryatt. Those picks, everyone thought, would lay the cornerstone for the Colts to build a defense that would dominate for years. Instead, both guys suffered through short, injury-riddled careers before leaving the game. And then there’s the whole San Diego Chargers’ Ryan Leaf fiasco, which put the Chargers this year into the position of using a top five pick to take a franchise quarterback twice in five years. Ouch. So, I don’t know how the Bills’ picks will pan out, obviously. (And I’ve always had this sneaking suspicion that Mel Kiper has somehow managed to craft a career out of not really knowing anything.)

But in general, I think they did pretty well yesterday, but I was hoping for something slightly different. My belief, before the draft, was that the Bills had to get the following in the first couple of rounds, and hopefully in this order:

1. Defensive Back

2. Quarterback

3. Wide Receiver

What the Bills actually did was to make a trade with Dallas to end up with two first-round picks (and no second round pick), which they used thusly:

1. Wide Receiver (Lee Evans, Wisconsin, 13th pick in the 1st round)

2. Quarterback (J.P. Losman, Tulane, 22nd pick in the 1st round)

3. Defensive Tackle (Tim Anderson, Ohio State, 11th pick in the 3rd round)

So the Bills apparently got the speedy wide receiver they were looking for. I wouldn’t have gone with a first-round pick at this position, since this draft is supposedly rich in WRs, and the Bills aren’t exactly desperate at that position, no matter how the fans might whine. A local sports-radio personality used to maintain that receivers grow on trees, and while I don’t think good ones are quite that common, I don’t think they’re so uncommon that a team with other deficiencies needed to spend its high draft pick on one. But maybe Tom Donahoe was thinking in terms of Eric Moulds’s longevity, after Moulds’s injury-prone 2003 season. I’m also not sure what message this sends to third-year man Josh Reed, who’s a guy who has taken a lot of abuse from fans for what they perceive to be his lackluster second year, even though that second year saw much more production that either Eric Moulds or Peerless Price displayed in their respective second years.

I wanted to see a defensive back drafted this year, badly. The Bills’ secondary is usually pretty decent at tackling, but they haven’t had a real interception threat since Kurt Schulz left the team years ago. They need someone who can pick off the ball once in a while. Maybe they’re thinking that since they signed Troy Vincent, they’re fine in this aspect, but I’m not sure yet. All I know is that the Bills filled out their Draft Day One selections with a defensive tackle. This probably isn’t that bad an idea, since I’ve been harping on their inconsistent pass rush for about two years now. I seriously doubt this guy will step in and start, but well, there it is.

And finally, they needed a quarterback, and they got one in Losman, who is apparently an even better athlete than the guys taken in the draft’s top eleven (according to Len Pasquarelli, an ESPN football writer). This pick is obviously a warning shot across Drew Bledsoe’s bow, but it’s also necessary: nobody really expects the Bills to still have Bledsoe around in a couple of years, so they needed to get their quarterback of the future now, when he could sit on the bench and absorb the game a bit before being anointed the starter. To get Losman, the Bills traded next year’s first-round pick to the Cowboys (along with a second and a fifth-round pick this year), which means that for the second time in three years, the Bills have traded a future first-round pick to get a quarterback. Losman will also be the third “quarterback of the future” for the Bills since Jim Kelly’s retirement (Todd Collins and Rob Johnson were the first two), so here’s hoping Losman’s the third-time charm. I actually don’t mind the Bills trading a bit to get him, since this draft is deep in quarterback prospects, and had they waited another year, the pressure to deliver on a QB would have been that much higher.

So, the Bills ended up addressing two of the three main areas in which I was concerned, and they seem to have done so fairly prudently – i.e., they didn’t give up the farm like the Vikings did when they decided that Herschel Walker was an important enough guy to get that they unloaded enough draft picks on Dallas for the Cowboys to build a dynasty team. As for the rest, I dunno. I can’t predict the future, and anyway, I’m not terribly knowledgeable about the college game to begin with.

My readers are, as always, welcome to opine in comments about their teams’ successes or failures in the draft (even fans of the Stupid Patriots are welcome, although my only interest in the StuPats draft would be if they “drafted” a letter withdrawing from the NFL). And thanks to Sean for tipping me off about the Pasquarelli article linked above.

Share This Post

What if Ozzel hadn’t come out of lightspeed too close to the system?

Last week at the library I found a copy of Star Wars Infinities: The Empire Strikes Back, and I couldn’t resist, even though I’ve generally found Star Wars comics (and the Expanded Universe stuff, in general) to be a very mixed bag. And yes, Infinities: TESB was a mixed bag, but it was an interesting one.

The idea of the Star Wars Infinities comics is a kind of Star Wars alternate history: a small detail is changed in the plot of the movies, and then the resulting story is told from that point on. Apparently their version of A New Hope has Luke’s torpedoes failing to destroy the Death Star, and in The Empire Strikes Back, the point of diversion comes much earlier: Han’s attempt to rescue Luke on the frozen wastelands of Hoth fails. Luke dies, the Empire pretty much crushes the Rebellion, and so forth.

I don’t want to say too much about the plot here, since the delight of such a story rests in a new set of surprises. Much of what happens in the film is reflected in the Infinities version – Yoda, Lando Calrissian, and Boba Fett still appear – but in very different ways. The story’s ending, though, is very much of the “start with a bang, end with a whimper” variety, and it relies on a particular character exhibiting a kind of vulnerability we’d never expect that character to have.

I was also a bit nonplused by the comic’s adherence not just to the main threads of The Empire Strikes Back, but also to The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones. The comic shows Boba Fett and Darth Vader without their helmets, drawn in such a way as to clearly reflect their origins as revealed in the prequels. I found this rather jarring. The original film obviously could not include all of that, and for that kind of material to show up here felt really out of place to me.

Still, the hour I spent reading Star Wars Infinities: TESB was a pretty entertaining hour, so if you’re of a mind to see how it might have turned out differently, give it a try.

Share This Post

“The Chickens of Mars”

PZ Myers – who apparently thinks I look like a deranged chainsaw murderer, which I am not at all sure is not actually a compliment! — has a link that can only elicit the response of “Oyyyyy….”, accompanied by a slow shaking of the head.

Apparently the “Face on Mars!” people have had their thunder stolen by folks who are now poring over the close-up photos of rocks from the Martian Rovers and finding….

(wait for it)

Fossilized bird skeletons.

Oyyyyy….

Share This Post

Feline Indignity

La Gringa brings some awful memories screaming back by linking this. I once had to assist my parents in precisely this operation, and if I ever could select ten memories I’d gladly have removed from my brain, this one might just make the cut.

And I’ve also given baths to plenty of cats in my time, so this kitty’s expression is well known to me:

“Someday, one of my larger brethren will kill you and eat your heart, pathetic human!”

Share This Post

Kegs, pitchers, bottles….it’s all good!

In a corner of the area where we keep the beer, I saw that The Store recently got in a shipment of Leinenkugel’s, which is a small brewery in Wisconsin. I liked this stuff when I had it in college, but I’ve never seen it here, so that’s pretty nifty. (There really is something to be said for Wisconsin, a land where the major food groups are beer, cheese and sausage.)

Now, if only I could find Yuengling’s in Buffalo, I’d truly be happy on the beer front. (And I know I should practice what I preach and taste the locals. I still haven’t got around to drinking any Flying Bison yet. I’m not sure why The Store doesn’t carry it.)

As long as I’m babbling about beer, I should talk about my preferred drinking glasses for the stuff. I have a nice, thick glass engraved with the Killian’s Irish Red logo that I bought at the Coors Brewery; I like that glass a lot, although it’s pretty heavy and the handle is only large enough for me to get three fingers through. Then there’s the authentic German stein that a certain room-mate brought back from college for me, but that one’s just a bit too nice to drink from – the thing’s an actual work of art – so it stays on one of my bookshelves. (That, and when I drank from it, I was always afraid that if I had a few too many, I’d start clunking myself in the face with the stein’s open lid.) My favorite glasses for actual drinking are a pair my sister bought for me. I’m not sure where she got them (some catalog, I imagine), but the handles are wide enough for a good, four-fingered grip; the base is thick and heavy while the glass at the top become pleasantly thin (and with no lip), making for nice balance; and the sides are engraved with the delightful health:

“Fill up the goblet,

Let it swim in foam,

that overlooks the brim;

He that drinks deepest,

Here’s to him!”

I love that. It makes me want to take a long and deep draught, dance a jig, and go beat the crap out of an Englishman.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓