Pecos Bill’s Cannon

Lynn Sislo had a small rant the other day about uncredited musical rip-offs — how Pachelbel’s famous Canon in D has now, seemingly, morphed into something called “Christmas Canon”, with no mention at all of poor Pachelbel. (My favorite version of the Canon, by the way, is the Canadian Brass’s version — although I deeply pity that pour soul of a tuba player.)

Anyway, this kind of thing — stealing melodies for newer works, even popular song — has been around for years. Two movie scenes leap to mind: First, the wonderful Mr. Holland’s Opus (which I seem to cite weekly now) has a scene where Mr. Holland decides to take a different approach to trying to get his students interested in music. He starts playing a pop tune called “Lover’s Concerto”, gets them excited, and then informs them that it’s really a Bach minuet. And in the musical Anchors Aweigh! there is a scene where Dimaggio (Frank Sinatra) comes across a pianist (Jose Iturbi, playing himself — it’s a long story) who is playing the famous melody from Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto #1, but to him it’s a pop song that he sings with gusto.

Composers always borrow. It’s what they do. (And if you want to see some freewheeling discussion of musical “borrowing”, just go to any film music discussion forum and ask about James Horner. You’ll get an earful.)

Share This Post

S-E-X!!!

OK. In reading a number of reviews and commentaries on Return of the King in particular and Tolkien in general, a common thread I’ve seen woven into the comments is that Lord of the Rings is “sex-less”. Some simply make that observation, while for others it is an actual criticism, and it’s one that I don’t understand. It puts me in mind of that infamous attack article on the Harry Potter books Harold Bloom wrote some years ago, when he complained about the lack of “sexuality” in Rowling’s books — sexuality, in books about people who are what, twelve? — and now I’m struck again by the apparent belief that a lack of sexuality somehow equals adolescence, and the story is not to be taken as seriously. It’s weird how we’ve taken the idea that “Sex is a theme for mature audiences” and twisted it round so it implies that “Sex is a theme of mature stories”. I don’t get that, I really don’t.

To be honest, I’ve never really needed sex in stories, and I’m perfectly happy when it’s either left out or gracefully alluded to with evocative prose. Here is just such a passage, from William Lindsay Gresham’s 1946 novel Nightmare Alley, in which a young boy walking in the woods comes across two people “in the act”.

Two people were lying on an Indian blanket and with a hot rush Stan knew that one was a man and the other was a woman and this was what men and women did secretly together that everybody stopped talking about when he came around, only some grownups never talked about it at all. Curiosity leaped inside of him at the though os spying on them when they didn’t know he was there. He was seeing it all — all of it — the thing that made babies grow inside of women. He could hardly breathe.

No graphic illustration, no description of this-or-that bit of anatomy, no awkward verbs like “heaving” and “thrusting” and “rolling”; just point-of-view and implication. I tend to simply skim over sex scenes in books, and I tend to wince at them in movies. Maybe it’s prudishness, although I like to think it’s not; it’s simply that eroticism for me is contained much more in the careful, and implied, release of pent-up passion (or the culmination of emotion) than in the actual up-close grinding of bodies. Casablanca would not be improved one whit by a scene in which Rick beds Ilsa. Sex is an adult theme, but it isn’t the only adult theme; and in a story where love and heroism are the main themes, the inclusion of sex can simply overwhelm and distort everything.

Share This Post

That’s how big the playoffs are!

I believe I forgot to mention in my football post the other day how happy I am that a new batch of commercials for the NFL playoffs featuring Don Cheadle are starting up. I got a big kick out of those ads last year. Maybe they can somehow mention the Bills’ Super Bowl run, now that the whole stigma of “They lost four in a row!” is giving way to a mystique of “They went to four in a row!”

(And yes, I’m looking forward to a fresh surge of Google hits from people looking for “Don Cheadle playoff ads”, “Don Cheadle playoff commercials”, “Don Cheadle NFL”, and whatever other formulations there may be!)

Share This Post

Process Failures

Daniel Drezner, the highly respected university professor and conservative blogger, has a fascinating article up at Slate called “The Real Trouble With the President’s Foreign Policy”. It’s a fascinating read, although I think he too quickly breezes over the questions surrounding “foreknowledge” of 9-11-01. On that particular issue I think there tends to be a problem of “degrees”: while I certainly don’t think anyone in the Administration knew specifically when and what was going to occur, I do think that a lot of warning signs were either ignored, misperceived, or simply not followed up. It’s rather like the person who ignores the progress of the odometer on their car, even though it’s been eight thousand miles since the last oil change. Sure, they might not know specifically when the engine’s going to seize up, but they are ignoring actions they could well take to prevent it. It is entirely reasonable to wonder just what warning signs were missed in the nine months between the Inauguration and the attacks (especially since so many on the right insist that a big part of the blame belongs, inexplicably, on the shoulders of Bill Clinton), and one doesn’t need to entertain scenarios involving Fox Mulder and the Cigarette Smoking Man meeting in a DC parking garage after midnight to follow this line of inquiry. I also think Drezner goes a bit far in his implication that the criticisms he is leveling against the President are rising exclusively from the right. But all in all, it’s an excellent article.

Share This Post

First in Flight

As Darth Swank points out, today is the 100th anniversary of the Wright Brothers’ flight at Kitty Hawk. Here is a good resource page on matters historical with regard to flight, including a Brazilian man who might well deserve to share the claim to “first flight”. (Mickey mentioned this a few days ago, btw. It turns out that the distinction of who flew first depends, as often is the case, on definitions: what is a “flight?”)

Also check out this grouping of seven “flights of fancy that fizzled”, although a few toward the end — relating to spaceflight and colonization — are things that I don’t really think it’s fair to characterize as “fizzled” simply because they haven’t happened yet. “If we haven’t done it by now, we’ll never do it” is never a particularly wise thing to believe.

(Speaking of which, I’m often of mixed mind on how the Space Age and the Flight Age intersect. It’s not uncommon to read these articles about the Age of Flight and see how what began at Kitty Hawk naturally leads up to, say, Yuri Gagarin and Neil Armstrong, but this seems to me to completely ignore the development of rocketry, which had its own pioneers — Tsiolkovsky, Goddard — and its own set of problems not related to sustained air flight.)

Anyway, it’s been a fascinating hundred years!

Share This Post

Belated Answers

OK, anyone still struggling with the “Villain Dispatch Lines” quiz of the other day, Sarah has most of the answers right. The ones that she does not have, I am putting comments to this post. Basically, nobody seems to have identified #3, although in comments to the original quiz, Nefarious Neddie correctly identified #7. (He also hit the “James Bond Specific” version of the quiz out of the ballpark, as I knew he would [he and I used to compete in grade school on knowledge of the Bond films, and at times, I’m not ashamed to say that he won]. I should have disqualified him from entry.)

Share This Post

If you join me, you get to kill the English!

In my sickness-induced stupor yesterday I watched the first half of Braveheart, a film which I used to number highly in my list of personal favorites but which I hadn’t seen in quite a while. It still holds up pretty well, although the speech Wallace gives to the Scots army just before the Battle of Stirling still rings hollow in my ears, being as it is a scaled-down version of the greatest pep-talk ever written, King Henry’s speech before Agincourt in Shakespeare’s Henry V. But the battle scenes of Braveheart have proven to be very influential indeed: the tracking shots of armies rushing toward each other, which the “crash” as they collide, the helter-skelter close-ups of combat, and so forth. My favorites are actually the tracking shots of hundreds of arrows as they arc through a blue sky. Those compositions have become commonplace in epic war films since Braveheart; even the arena-battle at the end of Attack of the Clones had stylistic throwbacks to Braveheart.

If memory serves, the second half of the film isn’t as good as the first. I’ll find out maybe this weekend. (No, I don’t watch Braveheart with the kid. My TV viewing choices with her aren’t that outlandish!)

Share This Post

The Prodigal Blogger

Longtime readers will know that I like to measure my success in the TLB Ecosystem by keeping tabs of my ranking versus that of William Burton, who maintained a pretty robust state of evolution despite the fact that he stopped blogging way back in February.

Well, I now need to find a new benchmark, because Mr. Burton is updating again, which frankly makes me quite happy. He’s an outstanding voice of liberal reason.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓