Fun with Objectivists!

Atrios points to a woman named Amber who writes a lot of stuff that relates Ayn Rand to, well, everything. It’s hilarious, really, because you can always tell a Randian by their logic: no matter what topic they are discussing, they follow the exact same train of thought. And I mean, the exact same. There is a Randian on one of the film music message boards I frequent, and that fellow applied that exact train of thought to film music that Amber applies to sexuality (and, really, this is one of the most mind-numbing essays I’ve ever encountered). The Randian train of thought goes like this:

1. A is A. (This is the Law of Identity.)

2. Logic is the Art of Non-contradictory identification.

3. Aristotle was a genius.

4. Nothing else of note happened in Philosophy after Aristotle until the clouds parted and Ayn Rand put pen to paper. (They may take a detour here to mouth-foamingly attack the work of Immanuel Kant.)

5. Because A is A, the X I am talking about right now is X.

6. Therefore, objectively, my opinions about X are true.

If you engage in any dialogue of any length with a Randian, sooner or later these exact points will come up. You could almost set your watch by it.

And for a truly breathtaking example of someone not having the faintest idea of what she is writing about, look at her screed on evolution. (P.Z. Myers might want to take a stiff drink before perusing that one. Ditto Dominion.)

If this woman gets a job writing somewhere, I just may shoot myself. Objectively.

(I’ve linked this article before, but it’s always good to bring it up again: Michael Shermer’s take on Rand’s followers, “The Unlikeliest Cult in History”.)

Share This Post

Upholding the “Sanctity” of Work

If you’re not reading Nathan Newman, you should be. I’ve been lately realizing that in the white heat of international wars and gay marriages and evolution v. creationism and states’ rights and judicial nominations and whatnot, a lot of very important issues are being fought over — and lost — on the side of labor and workers. Today he’s got a pretty depressing example of it: a judicial decision against workers, who were fighting for a somewhat more basic right than health care or decent pay.

Share This Post

Ooooh….say it like you mean it….

Had I not been on “blog vacation” last week, I’d have linked this already: Michelle imagines what it must be sound like when two biological anthropologists get together and talk dirty. I’m reminded of two things: that episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation when Data writes a horrible poem for his cat (read it here), and that scene in When Harry Met Sally… in which Harry expresses his skepticism that carnal relations are possible with a man named Sheldon (the first quote under the movie title here).

Share This Post

Mickey at 75

Somehow I missed this, but apparently Mickey Mouse turned 75 a few weeks ago. But I can never hear of Mickey’s birthday without thinking of George Carlin, who once opined thusly about the noting of Mickey’s birthday:

“No wonder nobody in the world takes our country seriously! We spend valuable television time informing the people of the age of an imaginary rodent!”

Oh well.

Share This Post

Traffic Babbling

November ended up being my third-best month for traffic here, although it barely squeaked past June ’03 for the honor. And that was with taking a nine-day break in posting. Thanks to everyone who has stopped here, especially those who kept the fires burning while I was on hiatus. Onward and upward!

(BTW, I don’t plan any major breaks for a while, although I probably will not post on Christmas Day or the Day After Christmas.)

Share This Post

Oh, come ON!

So I’m blogging this morning over coffee and with The Today Show droning on in the background, because the Kid isn’t up yet. And Today does a segment on last night’s Showtime telecast of that TV movie about Ronald Reagan. Katie Couric says something like this: “After the controversy surrounding The Reagans, the film aired last night. Was it a fair portrayal of the Reagans? We’ll talk to our expert…(oh Lord)…Peggy Noonan!”

Gee, I wonder what Peggy Noonan is going to say about a movie that takes any position on Ronald Reagan other than “the greatest American ever!”. Hmmmm, let me think.

Luckily for me, the unsinkable Peggy was barely ten seconds into her interview before she did that trademark cocking-of-her-head and used the phrase “liberal propaganda”. And with that, my thumb descended upon the “Channel” button on the remote.

Share This Post

And he could…go…all…the…ah, fuhgeddaboudit.

I don’t really have much to say about the Bills game yesterday, even though they managed to beat the Giants pretty handily. It’s just amazing to see what can happen on the few occasions when the Bills actually employ the “Run the ball a lot” strategy, albeit against a team that seemingly couldn’t tackle a cadaver that’s been doused in Superglue. So, the season’s pretty much done and they’re playing for pride. The main observation I have about yesterday’s game is that it was precisely the kind of thing Bills fans expected to be the norm at the beginning of the year, and instead we got pass-wackiness galore. Erk.

And the Colts are off my Christmas card list. Stupid Patriots.

Yeah, it’s a short football post. I wasn’t much in the mood yesterday, apparently.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓