Of Matters Canonical

I read Jane Galt nearly every day, so I’m not sure how I missed this post of hers in which she talks about literature and why some lit survives and other lit does not. (By “survive”, I mean that people still read it fifty, a hundred, two hundred years down the road.) Steven Den Beste also comments on her post, which is how I caught her post in the first place.

(Aside: Is it proper to refer to Jane Galt as “Jane”, or by her real name, Megan McArdle? Or should I give up and simply refer to her as “That goofy libertarian lass”? Decisions….)

Anyhoo, I somehow missed this post entirely, which defies explanation since as noted above I check Asymmetrical Information nearly daily and it’s a nice, long post. I generally agree with her points, although I don’t scoff at the idea that Bill Clinton’s list of favorite books (which has been making the rounds of Blogistan over the week I’ve been gone) actually constitutes favorites. Maybe I’m just naïve here, but I see little reason to believe that Clinton’s lying when he says that he loves TS Eliot or W.B. Yeats. (Not that anybody’s really calling him a “liar” here.) Six billion people on this earth, so it stands to reason that somebody is going to claim those two fellows for favorites. By all accounts, Bill Clinton is a voracious reader, one of those folks who motors through multiple books at a time (I do this too, although not at nearly so impressive a pace and I tend to miss a lot of stuff in the course of doing so), and it seems perfectly conceivable to me that he really does dig all of the books on his list. My own list of favorite books today would be very different from my list of faves from five years ago, and from the list I’ll make five years hence.

Jane goes on to note that “we seem to be producing very little indeed in the way of lasting literature these days”. I’m not really sure that’s the case, unless she’s equating “literature” with “the stuff kept in the Literature section at Borders”. I guess Dave Eggers, Michael Chabon, Margaret Atwood, Joyce Carol Oates and others are the kinds of writers Jane is referring to here. If Jane means “literature” as a genre, then she may be right – but she may be colossally wrong, too. The problem with the “Test of Time” is that one actually has to let the time pass, and time is really quite capricious. We don’t know what people are going to be reading from our time a hundred years from now. We really have no idea. The history of nearly every art is replete with examples of practitioners revered in their time who lapsed into obscurity (Salieri in music), of practitioners hailed at the time and who never really faded (Beethoven), and of practitioners who were underappreciated for many years until “arriving” (Mozart, Bach, Berlioz). The fact that readers now aren’t responding to the current crop of “literary” writers the same way they respond to, say, Stephen King really isn’t indicative at all of what future audiences are likely to judge worthy. So I think that trying to decide what works will survive is a futile effort, and I think that when people try to judge what’s going to last what they’re really doing is listing the works that they hope will last.

I do, though, disagree to a point with Jane/Megan and Steven’s views of language and its relation to storytelling. (But only to a point.) It’s true that most readers read for story alone, and thus the “literary” writing that works wonders with language tend not to appeal to such readers. But that’s not to say that such works won’t be appreciated by future generations. Language is a tool of storytelling – for writers it is the tool. (Other storytelling tools are available to comics creators and filmmakers, of course.) SDB is right to note that in a great novel we can be swept away into another time and place, but this happens because of language, not in spite of it. Stories tend to work because of their use of language, in the same way that a chair works because the wooden slats and nails fit together correctly. I’ve seen many a banal story elevated by language, but I’ve yet to see a great story succeed in spite of bad language. Dr. Asimov put it thusly:

“If your spelling and grammar are rotten, you won’t be writing a great and gorgeous story. Someone who can’t use a saw and hammer doesn’t turn out stately furniture.”

Language is everything to the storyteller. Language is what you use to create and depict your characters; language is what you use to have them do things. I do agree that today’s “great writers of the future” will be judged so because of their narratives – but their narratives will survive because of their language. You can’t separate the two. No story can take flight unless the language allows it to do so. Now, it’s true that in a well-written story the language will “disappear” to a certain extent, in the sense of SDB’s “vanishing tools” idea (which always makes me think of his proverbial disappearing pants!). But a lot of readers, especially those who also write themselves, are going to actively notice the language, and it’s not really a detriment that they do so, anymore than it is a detriment when a carpenter looks a bit closer at a finely-made chair.

The other point I’d make is that it’s important to realize the difference between today’s audiences and those of a century from now and a century ago. The average person you’ll meet in the bookstore perusing Stephen King and Dean Koontz and Anne Rice probably won’t be too interested in suggestions that they also read Bram Stoker or Mary Shelley or Poe. The reader picking up the latest John Grisham probably won’t be too keen on perusing Faulkner. The person trying to figure out which Robert Jordan book they haven’t read yet isn’t likely to be interested in Lord Dunsany, and someone perusing the latest David Weber “Honor Harrington” novel will probably strongly resist the idea that they should also read H.G. Wells. But a smaller subset of such readers are interested in those writers, and not merely because they told good stories but because they inspired earlier audiences and made today’s storytellers possible.

Jane quotes a snippet from some writer from yesteryear whose work she still admires, even though he’s lapsed into somewhat-obscurity, saying that reading the type of thing this guy wrote is an acquired taste. But really, so is Shakespeare, and so is Twain, and so is, well, anyone. And a hundred years from now, Stephen King will be an acquired taste. In 2103, someone picking up a copy of The Shining will be doing so not for the same reason that your average reader today might pick up that same book, but for the same reason that we pick up a copy of Dracula or Frankenstein. And their reason for doing so won’t be simply to get “swept away” in narrative; it will be for that timeless insight conveyed within the language, to uncover the influences earlier writers have for latter ones, et cetera. All this might come under the rubric of “relevance”, which I don’t use here in the same sense which Jane disparages (and rightly so — writers who strive too hard for “relevance” to a specific audience run the risk of limiting their appeal to any other audience).

Ultimately, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with reading to rejoice in language. That’s a great deal of why I read Guy Gavriel Kay and JRR Tolkien, to name just two examples. Yes, getting swept away in the narrative is important, but it’s not the only thing.

(I’d also note that I think that today’s genre books, which are almost totally ignored by today’s literary “establishment”, are in fact most likely to survive, in my view. I could write a whole post about that, but luckily, Alex Frantz already wrote it.)

Share This Post

The Zimmernator

Last Tuesday saw the release of the score CD to The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King, which made me quite happy save for one thing: I thought it was coming out on Monday, the day before, and thus I left three different record stores empty-handed that day before I realized my error. Fortunately, I did find a bit of a treasure on Monday: a cheap used copy of the score to The Last Samurai, which struck me as odd since the film hasn’t even come out yet. Upon further review, the CD was actually a promotional disc issued by the recording company, which the lucky recipient dumped on the used-CD store despite the big label embossed right on top of Tom Cruise’s face on the booklet’s front: “FOR PROMOTIONAL USE ONLY! MUST BE RETURNED TO THE RECORD COMPANY UPON REQUEST!” Yeah, good luck with that, guys. I ain’t giving it back.

The music for this one is by Hans Zimmer, who has managed to become the “Flavor of the Month” in Hollywood music circles, for good or ill. Zimmer tends to be the bette noire of film-music fandom, although there are small pockets of fandom for the guy. Mostly, though, filmscore folks are ambivalent toward Zimmer at best and outright hate him at worst. This is because Zimmer heads up a company called “Media Ventures”, which is basically a corral of second-tier composers who tend to turn out very similar-sounding filmscores for all those very similar movies these days. We’re talking names like Harry Gregson-Williams, Klaus Badelt, and others. They’re the folks who dole out those throbbing, synthesizer-laden scores with lots of booming percussion, generic melodies and ordinary orchestration. (MV scores tend to accompany just about every movie Jerry Bruckheimer does, for example – a notable example earlier this year was Pirates of the Caribbean. Or, if you really want to take that brand new bottle of Excedrin for a test-run, there’s the Armageddon score.)

It’s interesting about filmscore folks: they tend to be really defensive about classical music people looking down their nose at film music, but then within their own little field the filmscore people tend to be just as provincial at times. Just find any thread of decent length on any film-music discussion forum that’s devoted to Hans Zimmer and you’re guaranteed to find some derisive comment about someone “jerking off on a synthesizer and calling it music”. It’s very odd. Synthesizers are just like any other musical instrument: wondrous in the hands of a fine musician, dull as ditchwater in the hands of a mere mortal. So, where does that leave me with Hans Zimmer?

Well, I’m of mixed mind on the guy. I hated what I’ve heard of Gladiator (which is not the whole thing, though). A lot of his action music really is pounding, headache-inducing stuff with dull, simplistic themes, and sometimes his tendency to “sex up” the orchestra with synthesized goodness is odd – does Zimmer have that little faith in the traditional orchestra? I can understand a lot of the complaints about Hans Zimmer; really, I can. But not all of them, because the guy is gifted, and he’s turned in some really good stuff. His incidental music for The Lion King is quite good; even better is his work for The Prince of Egypt (that film’s opening song is outstanding); I liked his work for the comedy As Good As It Gets; he did a hauntingly evocative score for Beyond Rangoon. Zimmer’s no John Williams, and he doesn’t bring the goods with nearly as much consistency as I might like, but he does bring the goods.

So anyway, how does Zimmer fare in The Last Samurai? I have to admit to being surprised at how much I liked this score. Now, in a lot of ways this is not a surprising score at all. If you ask your typical filmscore fan to imagine a Hans Zimmer score for a movie about Samurai warriors in Japan, they’d very likely imagine what Zimmer has concocted here. But there’s good stuff anyway: it’s a lot more meditative than I would have expected, with some very delicate passages that contrast wonderfully with the inevitable “bring the house down” music that Zimmer offers. Which, in this case, involve a lot of wonderful Japanese Taiko drums and in one really nifty passage apparently includes actual shouting warriors!

The score doesn’t have quite as much Japanese flavor as I would have hoped. It uses Japanese instruments like those drums and the Shakuhachi flutes in service of a Western idea of Japanese-sounding music, which given the film’s subject matter is probably appropriate. But it doesn’t have the Japanese feel that a Joe Hisaishi or a Toru Takemitsu might have brought to bear. (Well, when Takemitsu was alive, anyway.) That’s a minor quibble, though. I enjoyed this score a lot more than most Zimmer/MediaVentures scores I’ve heard. It’s a very fine listen overall, and if you’re looking for a filmscore CD with digital sound to show off your kick-ass stereo, well, this is a prime candidate.

Share This Post

PHNEH

There’s been some comment lately about Blogistan about some bit of political correctness in which the terms “Master” and “Slave” should no longer be used in tech contexts, because they’re racially-charged terms or something. Most commenters, such as Kevin Drum and Jeff Kahane, think this is taking linguistic sensitivity too far, and I agree.

(BTW, is Jeff Kahane a new commenter over at Highered Intelligence? What’s up with that? Not that it’s a problem. I think. Hmmmm…)

Anyway, in one of the comments to his own post, Kevin says this: “It just encourages people to look for things to be offended by, a behavior that is distressingly common among all groups these days (including white males, I might add).” This reminds me of a weird tale from my college years, which still befuddles me whenever I think about it.

In my senior year I took a class in Analytic Philosophy, which very heavily involves matters of language and how language works and what metaphysical relation, if any, exists between words and objects. In particular, we spent some time on the work of Saul Kripke, a philosopher who held that “Names” actually pick out the same object in all possible worlds. If memory serves, a thought-experiment we delved into in this class went like this: “If a meteor had demolished life on Earth such that humans had never evolved, and thus the English language had never existed, would the word cat still refer to cats?”

(You begin to see just why I’m currently unemployed.)

So, one day after spending this class debating whether or not words had “absolute” meanings, a friend and I decided that it would be neat if there was a word that had literally no meaning whatsoever. It was a word devoid of meaning: it would not even have meaning if you used it in any particular context. And the word we cooked up to serve this position was this:

Phneh.

(You begin to detect now the roots of my sense of humor, I hope.)

So we kept this joke around, mainly as a bit of philosophical goofiness: a word with no meaning! None at all! What could be more harmless than this? Well, I was about to find out, because during the subsequent semester, I was spreading the joke of Phneh to some of the cooler folks in the music department, where I liked to hang out. And then I scrawled Phneh on a piece of paper and stuck it on the bulletin board in the student lounge of the music building, and then I pretty much forgot about it.

Until a week or so later, when some other guy was sitting in the lounge and suddenly announced, “I’m taking that sign down. It’s bothering me.”

I, of course, was completely baffled: This guy was claiming to be offended by a sign bearing a single word that he could not possibly have ever seen before, since the word hadn’t even existed until my philosophy buddy and I had coined it in the first place. I thought nothing of it, although I did get a bit nonplused when he in fact did remove the sign. So I, striking a blow for All Good Things, made another such sign and stuck it right back up. Which he tore down as soon as he saw it. And so on and so forth, except this guy actually decided to make some kind of personal crusade over this. Inevitably, this character used some connection he had with the Administration by serving in the Student Government to “take over” the bulletin board in question. He typed up an Official Notice on a fake college letterhead (and I remember him making a big deal of bringing in his girlfriend’s laptop just so everybody would see him doing this, and this was back when students with laptops were pretty rare) that Bulletin Boards were for Official Use Only, et cetera.

This, of course, annoyed a lot more folks than myself, people who took this to mean they couldn’t put up signs advertising their used textbooks or parties they were hosting that weekend or various things. Another person actually went to the Dean of Student Affairs or whatever on whose authority Mr. Bulletin Board had claimed to be acting, and was informed that no such policy existed. And ultimately, I ended up receiving a stern lecture from the music building secretary, a woman named Ruth, if memory serves (who was the real authority in the building). She basically told me that she shouldn’t have to take time out of her busy day to adjudicate a dispute “over a nonsense word!”, and she was less than amused when I asked why she was getting involved in something that everybody concerned already knew was nonsense.

This stern lecture did afford me one bit of amusement later on, because after she’d finished with me, Ruth tore down Mr. Bulletin Board’s “Official Notice” (which other people had covered with caustic bits of graffiti) and stormed out. Then, later on, Mr. Bulletin Board himself came in and got huffy when he noticed that his “Official Notice” was no longer there. He demanded that I tell him who took it down, because it was, you know, “Official College Business”, which allowed me to tell him: “Ruth took it down, and I suspect she is a better arbiter of what is and is not ‘official’ than you are.”

A few friends told me that I should print up a ton of flyers with Phneh on them and just start putting them up on every campus bulletin board I could find, but by this time I was bored of the whole business and had moved on in my head to other things. There was a coda, though, that I think of anytime some weird PC controversy erupts. When it had all just about died down, someone actually asked Mr. Bulletin Board why he decided to make such a crusade over a word that had no meaning. I have never forgotten his response:

“If it really has no meaning, then I’m free to interpret it as offensive.”

A month or two later, I was relating this whole tale to my philosophy buddy, who had missed it all because he had left our college after the first semester that year. He found the whole thing completely hilarious, and when I told him Mr. Bulletin Board’s idea that he was free to interpret Phneh as “offensive”, my friend rubbed his chin and said, “I don’t get it. Why would you voluntarily offend yourself?”

Well, I’ve been wondering that myself, ever since. Maybe the folks who think that “Master” and “Slave” should be stricken from the OED can answer it. Or the poor guy who once nearly lost his job because he used the word “niggardly” correctly in a sentence.

Share This Post

Untitled Post

Like everyone else on Thanksgiving, I didn’t learn about President Bush’s trip to Baghdad until late in the day. Comment seems to be centering either on that trip being a nice thing to do, or a bald political maneuver. It seems to me that it was both. Somebody probably decided that some new photo-op stuff was needed since that whole aircraft-carrier thing just doesn’t look as good now as it did way back when. And of course, a visit from the Commander-in-Chief is nice and all but it really doesn’t do anything to change the fact that the whole policy-thing is going south in a hurry. So basically I don’t think the trip was the great stroke of political genius the President’s supporters seem to think it is, and I don’t think it was the mistake that the President’s critics seem to think it is. I’m with Atrios: obviously a photo-op, but a pretty good one – and that’s it. And it does kind of speak volumes that the President spent two hours in the country he insisted on “liberating” and yet didn’t speak to a single one of the people he’d “liberated”.

I’ve also seen some weird theories floating around that this was hastily cobbled together when the White House learned that Senator Hillary Clinton was also traveling to Iraq, but that just seems bizarre to me. Ditto the folks Glenn Reynolds is linking to, the ones who are spouting the “They love Bush and hate Hillary!” crap. Of course they’re going to be more excited about the actual Commander-in-Chief visiting than some Senator, even if that Senator is fairly high-profile. It’s amazing how anything Bush does can reduce so many people on both sides into acting like sputtering doofuses.

(The only news coverage I caught of the President’s Iraq visit was on The Today Show, which seemed to go out of its way to emphasize the staggering bravery of this whole thing, which I’m really not sure I buy. I mean, yeah, it was mildly risky, but NBC had a computer animation of Air Force One touching down in complete darkness, and then they showed a bit of the news footage some French reporters had of some insurgents shooting a rocket at a cargo plane, as if to say, “These insurgents could have brought down the President’s plane, had he attempted his landing in daylight and had it not been totally secret!” Which, quite frankly, I very much doubt. I know that the President’s plane isn’t quite the piece of military hardware that the Harrison Ford movie depicted, but there is no way a couple of guys with a rocket-launcher could bring it down.)

Share This Post

How I Spent My November Vacation

“Well, I’m back!”

Spending nine days away from the blog was actually a lot easier than I had expected. In fact, for a very brief moment, the thought of simply not returning until I really felt like it flashed across my mind. Luckily, I was able to beat that impulse back down with a very large hammer.

So, what did I do? Well, the usual stuff. First, I read some books:

:: The Sword of Rhainnon, by Leigh Brackett. I’d never read any Brackett before this. Her work is pretty hard to find — I had to get this one from the library, since I’m not sure there is anything by Brackett even in print right now. Brackett is one of those names you’ll see lauded on SF discussion boards which are frequented by people who have read the genre for a long time. Her biggest claim to fame is that she wrote the first draft of the screenplay to The Empire Strikes Back, before her untimely death in 1978 required George Lucas to turn the project over to Lawrence Kasdan.

This particular book is set, as apparently a lot of Brackett books are, on Mars — but it’s not the Mars we know now, not by a longshot. Since the book was written two decades before the Viking landers, this was still in the era when people thought there might be canals up there and that a great civilization might have once prospered on the Red Planet. So basically the book reads like one of those 1950s sci-fi adventure movies. As I read it, I could just see the burly white hero besting a planet-full of Technicolor baddies. The book never quite rose above the anachronisms, but it was still pretty fun.

:: Carrie, Stephen King. I liked this one. Not as much as ‘Salem’s Lot or The Stand, but this one was pretty good. Not all that scary, really, but that could be because I already knew how it ended. What made it compelling for me was that I well remember the equivalent of Carrie in my own school, the kid who was still getting his books knocked out of his hands on the stairs even when he was a senior. Anyone who ever says that “High school is the best four years of your life!” should be kneed in the groin and forced to read Carrie while being force-fed overcooked asparagus.

:: The Postman Always Rings Twice, James M. Cain. This is one of the cornerstones of the noir crime genre, and it’s a good one. Tough and lean prose, a tight focus on a mere handful of characters, a crime that is almost gotten-away with, and it’s short. I read this one in a day, and I think that noir novels might become my genre of choice whenever I’m tired of longer, more florid works.

:: Bushwhacked, Molly Ivins and Lou Dubose. A fascinating, if depressing, look into the policies of the Bush Administration.

:: And I’m still truckin’ along on The Iliad. Hector just killed Patroclus. Lots of stuff about the Argives trying to recover the corpse. I have a feeling Achilles is not going to take kindly to this development. (Yeah, I already know how it all plays out. In college we had to read the portion of the poem where Achilles and Hector finally duke it out.)

As for writing, I didn’t get as much work done as I had hoped, but I still got a bit of work done. The novel now stands just shy of 83,000 words, which is in turn just shy of the halfway point. Now I’m in the middle of a couple of chapters which set up the conflicts that play out over the last act of the thing.

In real-life stuff, Thanksgiving was lovely — much food consumed and not a single down of football watched. (A good thing, too — the cognitive dissonance I would have suffered as I tried to figure out which team I wanted to win in the Dallas-Miami game would have been too much.) We caught From Russia With Love on some satellite-network that was doing a Bond marathon (they followed that one up with The Man With the Golden Gun — talk about going from good to, well, not-so-good). And we largely sat around and did nothing.

Friday I did a very small amount of Christmas shopping. I went to Wal-Mart — but in the mid-afternoon, well after all those psychotic people who line up at five in the morning (and who, apparently, will trample anyone in their way) are gone. That’s also a good time to visit stand-alone stores like Media Play and whatnot, because it’s my experience that later in the day is when people descend on the malls. Then I went home. (BTW, hey, Wal-Mart! You’re going to “hold” a DVD player for the woman for when she gets out of the hospital? You can’t give the damn thing to her? Ye Gods….)

And that’s about it. All in all, not a lot went on. Just the way I like it.

Share This Post

I want to see Mountains and Elves again….

OK folks, this is the Final Post. This is IT. No more.

Well, at least for nine days. I’ll be back on the 30th, one week from Sunday. I hope all of my American readers have a lovely, safe, and filling Thanksgiving; I hope all of my non-American readers have a nice regular week. Feel free to check in here a bit, just to keep the traffic from totally nosediving; I have almost two years’ worth of good stuff in the Archives, you know. Newer readers can check out the posts listed under “Notable Dispatches”, as well as the ones I listed here, which was the last time I took a break from posting.

(BTW, Blogger’s permalinks work, but they are thrown off by graphics. I’ve noticed that when I load a permalinked post of mine from the archives, it will go to the right spot at first, but then as the various images and whatnot in other posts from that same week load, the thing gets thrown off. So you’ll have to scroll around a bit. But that’s not a problem to you, is it? Nope, I thought not!)

Also make sure to check out any of the blogs under “Other Journeys” you might not have checked out before. There is a ton of great stuff being produced in Blogistan. I’m not going away or anything, so I’ll be checking in here to do my own daily blog-reading and I’ll be answering e-mails, if anyone needs to contact me. I should also have a few new reviews showing up on GMR this Sunday (but I’m not sure, it depends on when the editors choose to run them).

Finally, I leave you for now with this item from rock critic Lester Bangs’s book Main Lines, Blood Feasts, and Bad Taste: A Lester Bangs Reader. Writing in 1981, Bangs is talking about Jim Morrison (in response to the book No One Here Gets Out Alive, which I really must read), and there’s good food for thought for all artists in this passage.

In a way, Jim Morrison’s life and death could be written off as simply one of the more pathetic episodes in the history of the star system, or that offensive myth we all persist in believing which holds that artists are somehow a race apart and thus entitled to piss on my wife, throw you out the window, smash up the joint, and generally do whatever they want. I’ve seen a lot of this over the years, and what’s most ironic is that it always goes under the assumption that to deny them these outbursts would somehow be curbing their creativity, when the reality, as far as I can see, is that it’s exactly such insane tolerance of another insanity that also contributes to them drying up as artists. Because how can you finally create anything real or beautiful when you have absolutely zero input from the real world, because everyone around you is catering to and sheltering you? You can’t, and this system is I’d submit why we’ve seen almost all our rock ‘n’ roll heroes who, unlike Morrison, did manage to survive the Sixties, end up having nothing to say.

Art is about the world. So is blogging. So get out and, you know, see the world once in a while. Your art and blogging will be better for it.

Happy Thanksgiving (or Thursday), and see you in nine days!

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓