Light posting ahead

Updates to Byzantium’s Shores will be lighter than usual this weekend, as I’m doing stuff with The Family. The Wife has a very rare entire weekend off, so we’ll be taking advantage. Today we’re going to brave the crappy weather in order to perform our annual trip to Pumpkinville (one of those little “fall festivals” that are all over the place this time of year), and then we’re joining my parents for dinner in a bar/restaurant in a small Western New York town. And since tomorrow The Daughter will be staying with the grandparents into Monday, I’ll have a day just to spend with The Wife and Little Quinn. So, writing posts probably won’t be a priority until Monday. (That’s not to say I won’t post at all, however.) In fact, I may end up not watching the Bills-Dolphins game, which is quite a thing given that Bills-Dolphins is always an event in these parts.

(BTW, starting Kelly Holcomb is just a bad idea. We learn by doing, not by sitting on the bench. Losman should be in there. And my football loving friends at The Store and I have reached a consensus: if tomorrow, with Holcomb in there in place of Losman, is the day when the Bills’ coaches finally decide to rush Willis McGahee 35 times, we’re going to personally storm One Bills Drive with torches, tar, and feathers.)

Share This Post

How to Buy Cheap DVDs

Bill Smith, one of the moderators/administrators of the FSM boards, wrote a long post the other day about strategies for bolstering one’s DVD collection for less. You can read it here. Some of this I can vouch for, some of it I can’t, but it’s all interesting.

Share This Post

What’s on?

Over at Tosy and Cosh, John lists the TV shows he watches, by night. And of course, it only seems right that I do the same. So, here’s what I watch when new episodes are in the offing. (During re-run times or if there’s no “special event” programming that I want to watch, I’ll either watch a movie or turn the TV off entirely.) This is also subject to change depending on shifting timeslots and the January returns of American Idol and Scrubs.

Monday: For some reason, I’ve become addicted to Antiques Roadshow, which is on PBS at 8:00. (Even more strangely, The Daughter has also developed a love of this show.) You can really learn a lot watching these shows, and it’s fun to wonder at the stories behind these artefacts and the long-gone businesses that manufactured them. It’s like a game show coupled with a glimpse into an earlier time. At 9:00 we do bedtime, and then I basically watch nothing until 10:00 when I watch CSI: Miami.

Tuesday: At 8:00, I’ve become a serious fan of Nova. Last week’s show about a giant lake that formed millenia ago in upper Idaho and Montana, dammed by a glacier, was terribly interesting, and this week’s show — about the Japanese battleship Yamato, which was the largest battleship ever built and of which I had never heard until Nova came on. At 9:00, I’ve recently watched House and enjoyed it immensely, although I’ve only seen three episodes, and the show is likely off the air until November due to baseball playoff action.

Wednesday: Nothing until 9:00, when I watch The Apprentice: Martha Stewart. (Nope, I don’t watch Lost.) At 10:00 it’s CSI: New York, although I’m not terribly enthusiastic about this link in the CSI franchise.

Thursday: Well, I watch Joey, but not too enthusiastically. (It’s certainly no Friends, although it’s not exactly bad.) Then at 9:00 I tape CSI while watching The Apprentice. And as recent readers know, my 10:00 slot has recently become open. If The Wife still wants to watch ER, I’ll read books or blogs during that time.

Friday: Movie night. Nothing at all is on that interests me.

Saturday: This is slowly turning into “Music Night” in our apartment. Buffalo’s NPR station has two hours of Celtic music starting at 6:00 (coupling Fiona Ritchie’s wonderful Thistle and Shamrock with a local production called Celtic Kaleidoscope), followed by Marian McPartland’s amazing Piano Jazz. (If you’ve never listened to Piano Jazz, and you like the idea of wonderful two-person jazz improv coupled with insightful interviews, track this show down and give it a lesson. It’s just wonderful.) I try to stay up for Saturday Night Live, which is halfway decent again these days (the good sketches are side-splitting, while the bad sketches are cover-your-eyes bad).

Sunday: Football, football, football! Then, The Daughter adores America’s Funniest Videos. At 8:00 is The West Wing (which, so far this year, I’ve found as energetic and good as Aaron Sorkin’s best years, even if the show is a little too dependent on today’s headlines), and then at 9:00 I tape Desperate Housewives, which I then watch with The Wife when she gets home from work. (Yes, I love Desperate Housewives. It is, in my eyes, a terrific blend of soap-opera melodrama and darkly sarcastic humor.)

I follow a lot fewer shows these days, and this year I’ve only picked up one new show , House. (Well, two if you count The Apprentice: Martha Stewart.)

(By the way, a bit of a rant on the contestants on The Apprentice: when are these people going to realize that approaching this show as though it’s Survivor in a business setting is a sure ticket to losing? Every week, the losing Project Manager opts to bring into the final board room meeting those team members he/she is trying to get eliminated, rather than the team members who are directly accountable for the team’s losing that week. For example, last night’s episode of Martha Stewart had the two teams designing a wedding cake and then selling it to couples. One team failed to sell a single cake, and yet, the Project Manager refused to bring in the team members whom he had placed in charge of sales. The contestants make this mistake constantly.)

Share This Post

Beers to you, old amigo!

PSoTD seems to be less than enthusiastic about a new pumpkin-flavored beer from Anheuser-Busch:

Okay, okay, okay, enough with the freakin’ seasonal flavored beers. We get it. You want to sell beer for Halloween parties and Thanksgiving get-togethers. Okay, okay, okay.

What’s next for Anheuser-Busch? Putting toys in the bottom of each case of beer? Making “3-D” bottles so drinkers can see an image inside each Bud? Bottlecap Bingo?

How about just trying to make some good “no special occasion” beer instead of the soulless brews that they currently blanket the market? There’s already a zillion specialty flavored brews out on there. Is AB planning to compete on price? Because I find it hard to believe they will be competitive on flavor…

No word yet on the flavors of the other seasons. Easy suspects for winter: Egg Nog, Candy Cane, New Year’s Day Dry Heave… any other suggestions for the other seasons?

Well, that’s great, because it leaves more beer for me! I had some pumpkin-flavored beer a few years ago, and I liked it a lot. But then, I’m the same guy who thought Pepsi Holiday Spice was just the best-tasting stuff ever, so I’m sure I may well be in a minority here. But I do love the flavor of pumpkin in general; at The Store we have a pumpkin flavored coffee that is just wonderful.

Share This Post

Hooray!

I’m watching this new CBS show Close to Home — and I’m probably not liking it enough to watch it regularly, although you never know — and I saw something cool. The premise of the pilot is that an assistant district attorney (played by Jennifer Finnigan) is returning to work after her maternity leave, whereupon she takes on a case that seems open-and-shut but really isn’t. Nothing really earth-shaking, but the show establishes that this woman has a baby at home, and in an early scene, she is depicted as finishing up with a breastmilk pump while at work.

That was seriously cool. You don’t usually see this kind of thing on TV shows.

Share This Post

A surgeon and a doc, above it all….

John took umbrage to my rant about ER the other day, and wrote a rebuttal on his own blog. Mostly, it’s just differences of opinion, which aren’t terribly interesting in themselves; John still finds the characters interesting, whereas I’m tremendously bored with most of the storylines and characters. I agree, actually, with John that the best stories are the ones involving Pratt and Abby. Pratt has always been well-written, ever since he showed up (although I miss the dynamic between him and Dr. Gallant, whose approach was totally different), while it took the writers a while to stop piling crap on Abby (at least, since I’m not watching the damn show anymore, I won’t have to sit through the next Sally Field cameo).

But I certainly don’t agree on Morris, which just smacks of incompetent storytelling to me. The ER has had its “villains” in the past (Kerry Weaver, Robert Romano), but those characters were (and, in the case of Kerry, since she’s still alive, still are) well-rounded. We know they’re good doctors; we know something of their lives and struggles; they’re not just foils for comic relief or an all-purpose annoyance factor for the other characters. Morris has never been depicted as competent at anything (in fact, in earlier seasons he has both quit med school and been caught sneaking a puff on a joint on the job — good thing for him, I suppose, that a helicopter dropped on Romano’s head before he could fire Morris when that one happened), and yet, now we’re expected to believe that he’s suddenly managed to uncover enough competence to impress people who already know that he sucks enough to promote him to Chief Resident. I’m sorry, but that’s just bad storytelling. It violates the cardinal rule, “Show, don’t tell”. Morris is nothing more than a cartoon character.

I think that Neela vaccilates between interesting and, well, not. She’s all over the map. One episode, she’s lecturing one of her other fellow med students about bedside manner; next episode, she’s demonstrating no bedside manner whatsoever. And I don’t find Sam the nurse interesting in the slightest degree. She’s been dragging the exact same set of problems around with her since her character first walked onto the set. There’s no growth there, no nothing — just the same kind of vaccilating between being warm and incredibly cold depending on the whim of the writers on that particular day. John cites these characters for their consistency, but I don’t see that at all; sometimes they seem to have grown, other times they seem to have not grown at all; sometimes, in the case of Sam, they seem to have regressed.

John also says that the show can remain fresh, theoretically, because the roster of potential medical problems for the ER to face can never be exhausted. Well, maybe not — but the way they can be treated within the constraints of a 44-minute TV show certainly can be exhausted. The med stuff seems to play out roughly the same way, each time out: the bay doors crash open, in comes the gurney with the EMTs rattling off lots of jargon, then into a trauma room where pulse ox is taken and pints of O-neg are strung up and so on. X-rays are fretted over. Maybe a student can’t quite figure it out, so an attending asks leading questions. Maybe the student can answer them (indicating their growing confidence), or maybe they can’t (indicating their still-lacking confidence). Maybe a family member walks in, or maybe the patient freaks out and yanks out the IV and bleeds all over the place, or maybe if it’s a multiple trauma a family member’s on the exam table in the next room over and sees their loved one in Trauma One and starts shrieking their name. Maybe a surgical consult is taken, or maybe the patient goes into defib. Maybe the arrogant doc gets the patient’s heart beating again, or maybe the doc — who could be anyone — becomes so emotionally invested that they continue CPR compressions for a period long past when braindeath has occurred. And then someone says softly, “Luka…” or “Pratt…” or “Abby…” and they stop compressions, sigh, give the time of death and then angrily strip off their latex gloves. The medical portions of the show are almost as dependent upon formula as Law and Order. So, at this point, for me the show has to be about characters, and they just don’t hold my interest anymore.

But that is all neither here nor there. What I really disagree with in John’s post is his assumption as to what’s behind my current dislike of ER:

Many, Jaquandor included, took in last week’s episode, which centered around a pregnancy in crisis, and immediately compared it, unfavorably, to the infamous “Dr. Greene loses a pregnant mother episode” from an early season. I’m always suspicious when you hear the refrain “it was better then.” Memory has a way of coloring our experiences heavily; how many people insist that their favorite band’s best work was done–how coincidentally–when they first got into them?

Echoing John, to this I say, “Feh.”

First off, it’s worth noting that I haven’t been down on ER completely for the seven or eight years or whatever it’s been since the original cast started defecting; in fact, I thought it had a brilliant episode just two short years ago. Beyond that, I thought the episode in which the ER learned of Dr. Greene’s death is one of the very best the show has had, and I thought last year’s two-parter with Dr. Gallant returning briefly from Iraq was good as well.

(John also lumps me in, several times, with lots of other people who are ripping on the show. I wouldn’t know who those are, since it’s not like I participate in any way in ER fandom, if it exists. And I certainly haven’t noticed any search engine hits along the lines of “ER sucks”, so maybe John could share a link or two. My comments on ER are mine alone, and certainly not meant to be any kind of “received wisdom”.)

But going deeper, I find John’s dismissal of my opinion as mere nostalgia rather convenient; it’s as if he simply wants to disqualify in advance any belief I may hold that Drs. Ross and Greene were more interesting than the Shane West character or Dr. Morris or whomever. “Ah, that’s just nostalgia,” goes the refrain — which means that the question of whether or not the show’s stories really are as good as ever can be safely set aside. This is baffling to me, and I’m troubled to think of an instance where I really think that some cultural artifact was at its best at the time that I first got into it. The X-Files? Nope — I started watching faithfully in Season Three, and I thought it was at its best in Seasons Five and Six. Millennium? Season Two. Star Trek? I watched the Original Series all the time as a kid — but I think that Deep Space Nine was its most consistently good incarnation. I watched NYPDBlue from the series premiere until its series finale last year, and its best work came in its fourth and fifth years, when Jimmy Smits was on board and the chemistry between him and Dennis Franz had been worked out. I watched Frasier from the first year, and loved it until near its end (in fact, I stopped watching it not because I didn’t like it anymore but because it was up against 24, and I faithfully watched the last half of its last season, finding it brilliant again), and I think its best work came when the writers stopped playing games with Niles and Daphne. The Simpsons? I don’t know, since I haven’t watched it regularly in a year either, but I think the recent work that I have watched is often very good indeed. James Bond? I first saw him in action in Moonraker, but my persistent belief is that the best Bond movie was made two years before I was born. My first Van Halen album was 1984, but my favorite album of theirs is still 5150, three years and one lead singer later. And I’ve never been one to cry about the lack of a Han Solo character in the Star Wars prequels. I could go on.

The problem with a show like ER is that it’s clearly designed to be an “interchangeable ensemble” show, which is nothing new. ER actually replaced one such show, in LA Law, which incidentally didn’t do its best stuff in the first years I watched it, either. But it fell victim to the same kind of thing that I think now afflicts ER: storytelling paralysis coupled with boring and, occasionally, just plain bad characterization. When the ER producers started bringing in new characters, some were hits (Kerry Weaver, Abby, Elizabeth Korday), others were misses (whatever that woman’s name Peter Benton went off with, “Dr. Dave”, Lucy Knight). They had it going pretty well again just a couple of years ago, but then I started to feel the chemistry going again, and now I think the chemistry’s pretty much nonexistent in the current roster. Ultimately, I don’t think John’s charge of nostalgia goes anywhere. We’re just left, then, with a difference of opinion: I’m bored by the show as it is now, and I am therefore changing my channel. I’m not lobbying for its cancellation or anything (my call for cancellation in the last post on the subject was meant to echo the show’s recurrent theme of government budget cuts threatening County Hospital’s existence), and since I think I’m quite capable of rising above any feelings of “nostalgia” I may have for the early seasons, we still have a mere difference of opinion. John thinks that the show is still great, can go on for an indeterminate number of years, and would be well-received if it premiered this year, as it is. I disagree.

Which is why this Thursday at ten he’ll be watching ER, and I’ll be reading a book. Who’s better off? No one, really: he still has a show he likes, and I’m free of a show I don’t like anymore. Sounds like we both win.

Share This Post

I called it!

In my football summation post from yesterday, I noted the absurdity of the Bills punting with four minutes left and trailing by more than two scores, and I predicted that today Gregg Easterbrook would mention it in his TMQ column, Well, can I call ’em or what?

Why Are You Punting???????????: Trailing 16-7 with 4:21 remaining, Buffalo faced fourth-and-5 on its 35; in came the punting unit. Sure fourth-and-5 is a tough down, but you trail by two scores with the sun setting on the game: all New Orleans had to do was go three-and-out and the clock situation would become impossible. It took the Saints only four snaps to get past the point where they would have been had the Bills gone for it and missed anyway. Two weeks ago, the Bills trailing by 13 on the final play of the third quarter, coach Mike Mularkey ordered a punt from the opposition 39, signaling his players it was okay to quit on the game — that the priority was containing the margin of defeat. Again this week Mularkey seemed more concerned with containing the margin of defeat, thus deflecting criticism from himself, then trying all-out to win. Tuesday Morning Quarterback asks: if Bill Belichick is trailing 16-7 with 4:21 remaining and facing fourth-and-5, is there even one chance in a million he sends in the punt unit?

And I also noted that the Bills really need to find some new blood for the offensive line — in fact, it’s my belief that this is the greatest reason why the Bills are in an 0-5 playoff drought the last five seasons (and likely to go 0-6). Here’s what Easterbrook had to say on that subject:

Worst Blocks: In my preseason preview, I noted Buffalo management’s strange indifference to the team’s need for offensive linemen. During the past five drafts, the Bills have invested eight No. 1 and No. 2 picks in the glamour positions of quarterback, running back and wide receiver; against only one first- or second-round pick invested in blockers. It’s showing, as the Bills so far have a cover-your-eyes-awful offensive line. With the score close in Week 3, Buffalo failed to convert a fourth-quarter fourth-and-1 in opposition territory; the Bills offensive line got zero push. In a close game on Sunday, Buffalo failed to convert a fourth-quarter fourth-and-1 in opposition territory; five Saints hit the runner in the backfield! These were the decisive plays in Buffalo’s past two losses, and on both the offensive line might as well have brought out pillows since it lay down on the field. To add insult to incompetency, on the snap before the failed fourth-and-1 against New Orleans, Buffalo failed on third-and-1 — as the Bills offensive line got zero push. The Bills have only three touchdowns, and some blame the poor performance of new quarterback J.P. Losman. But pass-blocking is so consistently bad, Losman has to start scrambling on the count of “one thousand two.” The Buffalo offensive line is going neck-and-neck with the Houston line for the dubious distinction of worst in the league — but unlike the Texans, this season the Bills expected to go somewhere other than back to the drawing board.

Actually, it’s worse than that: the Bills have only spent a first-round pick on an offensive lineman twice since 1995 (when they drafted Ruben Brown). Meantime, they’ve basically spent three first-round picks in that period on quarterbacks: they traded a first-rounder to Jacksonville for Rob Johnson in 1998; they traded another first-rounder to New England in 2002 for Drew Bledsoe; and they picked J.P. Losman in 2004. (Using, I might add, an extra first-round pick that they had acquired by trading their first-rounder in 2005 to do so.) And don’t forget the second-round pick used on Todd Collins in 1995. Four QBs, only one of whom is still here, versus two linemen, only one of whom is still here (2002 first-rounder Mike Williams). Ouch. Now, no one expects them to build their line entirely through the draft, but picking up other teams’ castoffs and shoehorning them out of position into the line here (Trey Teague’s not a natural center, and boy, does it show when defensive tackles are past him before he’s even finished snapping the ball) is not the road to offensive line success.

Man, I oughta be blogging for NFL.com.

Share This Post

IMAGE OF THE WEEK

Eloise

Eloise and Nanny, from the Eloise books.

Tonight the Daughter chose Eloise for one of her bedtime stories, which made me happy, as the Eloise books are just a joy to read aloud. Author Kay Thompson writes in exactly the way a breathless, over-sugared, over-pampered rich six-year-old would talk: lots of run-on sentences or sentences that simply stop in mid-thought; sudden jolts from one topic to another; subtle alliterations and wordplay; and even the occasional phonetic hint of a snooty British accent. And Hilary Knight’s illustrations are also a delight, with surprises lurking around every page — such as an early page where, as Eloise recounts the way she rides an elevator to the fifth floor and then gets out and skips up the stairs to the seventh floor so she can ride the same elevator again to the fifteenth floor before taking the stairs up yet again and so forth, the opposite page turns out to have a “gatefold” picture depicting Eloise’s elevator journey up and down the hotel.

What was most fun this time was that, in the books, Eloise is six, and so’s The Daughter. So Eloise is, in a way, in her peer-group. Cool!

An informative website on all matters Eloise can be found here.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓