A thought experiment

I see that William Bennett, one of our nation’s self-appointed Ministers of Virtue, has resigned from some position he holds because of the unfair politicization and taking-out-of-context of something stupid that he said. Well, that’s the expected response, I suppose; and anyway, what I found objectionable wasn’t that Bennett would frame an outrageous thought experiment, since there’s nothing inherently wrong with such stuff, but the underlying assumptions behind the thought experiment he framed.

And speaking of thought experiments, here’s one: What would the reaction of the Right be if, say, Howard Dean were to publicly say:

I do know that it’s true that if you wanted to increase school test scores, you could — if that were your sole purpose, you could abort every baby in Arkansas, Texas, Kansas and Georgia, and your test scores would go up. That would be an impossible, ridiculous, and morally reprehensible thing to do, but your test scores would go up. So these far-out, these far-reaching, extensive extrapolations are, I think, tricky.

Hmmm. I wonder if those “You’re taking me out of context” defense would fly. Probably not, and rightly so.

(And before anyone gets uppity, I just made this example up off the top of my head and tried to pick a stereotype that everybody knows to be utterly false.)

Share This Post

Sentential Links #19

A roundup of good stuff from Blogistan. Click for context:

:: I finished “The Unbearable Lightness of Being” last night. And cried like a little baby. (Hmmm…been a while since I found a book that made me cry. Maybe I should look this one up.)

:: Let me tell you about my history with Tommy. (That is, Tommy of Tommy, the album by The Who. Which I’ve never heard. Is it true that if you play it with a candle burning, you will see your future? And I should have voted for Almost Famous, which I just freaking adore.)

:: Times change, people change, literature and popular culture change. But it’s always struck me as strange that in such a Bible-thumping, God-bothering country as this one, so many of us never learn who Ahab was, the original Ahab, who did more to provoke the LORD God of Israel to anger than all the kings before him, until we first sit down with a copy of Moby Dick or hear the story of Absolam, Amnon, and Tamar until we read Faulkner.

:: The difference being that the US is no longer looking to annex Canada by force (if at all). (Well, shit. Here’s me, thinking that being a launching point for our invasion of Canada will finally be the silver bullet that the Buffalo economy’s been looking for, lo these many years! Just found this blog last week, by the way.)

:: And by the way, we rented The Iron Giant to watch Saturday night. Never seen it before. I’m not giving anything away, but at the end, when the IG is flying and says, “I’m Superman…” I totally had to increase my rate of blinking by at least a factor of ten, lest my wife see an unwonted emotional outpouring. (Oh, screw that! Cry openly! The wimmen-folk love a guy who cries. I think I read that somewhere, anyway. Oh, and congrats on one year blogging.)

:: I think there’s something to this, and I also think that blogging has had the effect of liberating thousands of talented amateur writers whose particular gifts may not necessarily fit neatly into the pigeonholes of professional publication. (I think it’s amazing how nearly every time the thought crosses my mind that maybe I’m just wasting my time here, Terry Teachout posts something like this.)

:: There is, needless to say, quite a bit about the Bomb on the Internet. (No, really? But seriously, Mr. Ross has a collection of fascinating photos he took while touring the Trinity site, where the first atomic bomb was exploded. Fascinating stuff.)

:: You know, there is very little in the world that makes me more objectively terrified than the idea of George Bush and his den of incompetent hacks fiddling with the Posse Comitatus Act. Indeed, if you were to ask me what one thing would get me marching in the streets, this would be it. I’m entirely serious. (Actually, this is the entire post. I hope Mr. Scalzi doesn’t mind.)

:: Plus, I’m teaching myself to play the piano–the fruits of which are certainly worth a blog entry or two–plus I’ve been doing lots of reading, but haven’t had the energy to write much about it. (Well, crud. But hey, along the lines of self-taught pianists, perhaps I could send a book recommendation Will’s way, as opposed to the other way around.)

Enough for this week. Enjoy, and I’ll try to have this feature back on Sundays now, although, to be honest, I may keep it on Mondays, since I’m finding a heavy dose of blog-surfing nice and relaxing after a Monday at The Store.

Share This Post

Oh, they played yesterday? Really?

Well, I suppose I have to say something about the Buffalo Bills, who turned in yet another lackluster performance yesterday in losing to the New Orleans Saints (temporarily ensconced in San Antonio), 19-7. So here are some random thoughts on the soon-to-be-redubbed “Buffalo Shitty Bills”:

:: If the defense doesn’t blitz, they don’t get pressure on the opposing quarterback. It’s just that simple. And when they’re not blitzing, they’re terribly susceptible to the run. And Nate Clements just isn’t as good as he think he is, so next year I’m fine with using the money the Bills would need to re-sign him and instead use it to bolster the offensive line and get a real pass-rusher in here, either a linebacker or a defensive lineman.

:: Everybody thinks your running back is an offensive superstar in waiting. He starts off the game with a twenty-five yard run. For the game he averages five yards a carry. At no point in the game, except at about a minute left in the fourth quarter, are you behind in the score by more than ten points. So of course you’d only give him the ball sixteen times.

:: J.P. Losman’s throws looked better yesterday. He still isn’t hitting the receivers on the numbers consistently, but he’s putting the ball in places where they, if they’re really the great posse of NFL receivers we’ve been led to believe they are, should make the catches. But no: drops galore, and another 75-yard performance.

:: Benching Losman? Bad idea, especially when the offense is stalling due to stupid penalties on first downs and because of bad playcalling. Here’s something: I agree completely with Jerry Sullivan for once.

It’s not Losman who calls plays. It’s the offensive coordinator, Tom Clements, who loves to outthink himself. Clements had the Bills running against Atlanta instead of exploiting a ravaged secondary. In a noisy Alamodome, he had Willis McGahee carry just 16 times, even though he averaged 5.3 yards a pop. Is it against the rules to let McGahee carry on consecutive plays? Or to use him on third downs?

It’s not Losman who missed a field goal late in the first half. Rian Lindell is automatic – until a kick truly matters. With the Bills trailing, 10-7, he could have tied the game and given them a jolt of momentum. He missed a 45-yarder. The Saints got a 40-yarder from John Carney just before halftime. Huge six-point swing.

It’s not Losman who allowed the Saints to convert seven of 15 third downs and roll up 167 rushing yards. How many blitzes does Jerry Gray have to call before he realizes his guys aren’t getting there? Is it my imagination, or is Gray trying to blitz his way to a head coaching job?

It’s not Losman who committed 12 penalties for 79 yards. In fact, it was those heady veterans. Nate Clements, the self-proclaimed best cornerback in the game, had two. Moulds had one. So did Mark Campbell, Trey Teague and London Fletcher.

It’s not Losman who couldn’t contain the Saints’ four-man pass rush. The offensive line was wretched in pass protection, another reason why Clements should have run more. Mularkey was not pleased. He said it was too bad he didn’t have five new O-linemen to use for a spark.

The Bills need to stand up and say, “Look, fans: we’ve got to give this kid as many reps in games as humanly possible, which might mean that we’re missing the playoffs this year. But he’ll get better because of it.” Troy Aikman’s first year as starter? 1-15. Peyton Manning’s first year as starter? 3-13. Jim Kelly’s first year as starter? 4-12. There’s a reason why Kurt Warner and Ben Rothlissburgor (I think I spelled that wrong) were so electrifying in their debuts: it’s because they were amazing exceptions to an iron-clad rule. And if the Bills start Kelly Holcomb, it just postpones Losman’s development by one more year. If Losman’s a bust, or if he’s the next great Bills QB, it doesn’t change anything: we need to find out which one he is, and soon. Benching him yesterday was just stupid, and it’s going to mess with his head.

:: You’re down by nine points with four minutes to go in the game, which means that you need two scores to take the lead. It’s forth down. And you punt. Well, you might as well forfeit the game, then. (Readers of Gregg Easterbrook’s TMQ column, make a note of this. You will see the Bills’ Preposterous Punt from yesterday mentioned in tomorrow’s column.)

:: I bitch about the offensive line every week, but I don’t get how they can be reasonably average on run-blocking and suck so massively at pass-blocking. Or is it just that McGahee is good enough to excel even with shitty blocking? Kinda makes me wonder what he’d be like if we had a line of the Dallas or Washington caliber (circa 1980s for Washington, 1990s for Dallas).

Summing up where I am right now as a Bills fan: because of Losman’s youth and inexperience, I’m willing to write this year off. But if the Bills fail to make the playoffs in 2006, it’ll be time for Tom Donahoe to be shown the door.

Other football notes:

:: As much as I think Terrell Owens is a gigantic jerk, man, does he back it up on the field or what. It’s like he says to himself, every time he does something outrageous, “Holy shit, I gotta make up for this one in the game.” And then he does. The guy’s amazing, and I don’t think he gets the respect he should for being at the absolute top of the NFL.

:: Hmmmm…the New England Stupid Patriots have already lost two games, and their defense looks distinctly ordinary against the run. And their next game has them visiting Atlanta, the NFL’s best team at running the ball. The StuPats could well be under .500 for the first time in quite a while after this coming Sunday. And it can’t be encouraging to Bill Belichick, the fans in Boston, or all those sad people nationwide who have been serving StuPat Kool-Aid at every meal for the last four years that the StuPats have given up more points than anyone else in the AFC after four games (and all but three teams in the NFC). Call me crazy, but two-time defending champs or no, a team that’s on pace to give up over 400 points this season has cause to be worried a bit.

Of course, if it means that the StuPats are experiencing a stumble-in-progress, then I for one welcome our new alien overlords!

:: Now that most of the league has played four games, it’s a little bit meaningful to take a gander at the current standings, versus my predictions before the season. So here’s how things shape up right now, with my predictions in parentheses after the current leaders:

AFC East: Miami Dolphins (New England Stupid Patriots)
AFC North: Cincinnati Bengals (Cincinnati Bengals)
AFC South: Indianapolis Colts (Indianapolis Colts)
AFC West: Denver Broncos (San Diego Chargers)
AFC Wildcards: New York Jets, Pittsburgh Steelers

NFC East: Washington Redskins (Philadelphia Eagles)
NFC North: Chicago Bears (Minnesota Vikings)
NFC South: Tampa Bay Buccaneers (Atlanta Falcons)
NFC West: Seattle Seahawks (Arizona Cardinals)
NFC Wildcards: Seattle Seahawks, Carolina Panthers

Well, I only have two teams that I picked to win divisions actually leading their divisions, but I think I’m safe on a few others — does anybody think that the Dolphins are for real, much less that they can hold off the StuPats in a surprisingly weak AFC East? or the Redskins? I also find the Vikings’ dismal start very surprising, but the NFC North appears to be a diaster of a division. (And the less said about the fact that I picked the Cardinals to win a division title, the better, thank you very much.) I’m not bothering to figure out who’d be the wildcard teams if the season ended right now, either, but as of now nobody I picked to be in the playoffs, with the exception of the Panthers, is more than a game or two out of first place.

That’s it for this week. Next week, J.P. Losman gets his first look at the Dolphins, a team that Jim Kelly made his bitch for much of his time here. That would be a worthy opponent for him to start turning it around against. (My God, that may have been the worst sentence I’ve ever written. Ending with a preposition? Ha! I ended with two!)

Appy polly loggies to Sean for the cheap humor. But I’m sure he’ll get me back in due course.

Share This Post

Excellence? What’s that?

Empty Suits

Look, Ma: Two empty suits of blue.

The more plausible complaint about Miers, from the point of view of conservatives, is that she won’t have the intellectual prowess to pick the court up and move it, to persuade other justices with the power of her ideas. For moderates and liberals, the complaint is that Bush had plenty of opportunity to pick a woman without picking the one whose best qualification is that she’s his friend.

Good God, does George W. Bush have any pretensions toward excellence at all? I mean, good God. Can we please fast forward to January 20, 2009 right now? It’s not like this is a conservative’s wet dream of a Presidency; this is a Presidency whose main modus operandi all along has been to act like a conservative’s wet dream of a Presidency, and hope that they’ll be out of office and collecting their handsome pensions for government service before the conservatives figure out that the hand which has been stroking them has, in fact, been nothing more than a big inflatable glove at the end of a stick, while the real hand has been busy plucking their wallets dry.

And if I, as a liberal Democrat, gotta suffer through a conservative Presidency, I’d at least like to sit through a conservative Presidency whose approach to policy isn’t the governance equivalent of a monkey tossing its feces about in random fashion.

“Soft bigotry of low expectations”? Well, even the guy with low expectations has some expectations to start with. When these people die, they’ll likely be greeted at the Pearly Gates by Antonio Salieri, the Patron Saint of Mediocrities, where he will absolve them. Maybe. If he feels like it. Like as not, he’ll just sit at his harpsichord and plink out his forgotten melodies, one at a time, one for each middling figure advanced by other mediocrities as Lincoln’s heirs.

It’ll take Saint Salieri hours, I wager.

UPDATE: Kevin Drum helpfully collates conservative reaction from around Blogistan. It’s kind of reminding me of that scene in Pinnocchio when the boys on Pleasure Island realize just what’s about to happen to them.

UPDATE II: Photo added.

Matthew Yglesias:

This sounds more like Miers was an opportunist than a convert. When conservative Democrats ran Texas, she was a conservative Democrat. She gave money to prominent Texas Democrats (Lloyd Bentsen) and to national Democrats who tried to move the party in a more conservative direction (1988-vintage Al Gore). Then, when Republicans came to dominate Texas, she became a Republican….As Kieran Healy points out, it’s very unlikely that a woman born in 1945 would manage to have such a successful career in competitive fields while simultaneously being some kind of lightweight. But she’s clearly not a heavyweight legal thinker. She’s a heavyweight networker, climber, bottom-kisser, and careerist. What, exactly, that implies for her likely service on the Court I couldn’t say.

You know, I don’t have a problem with the Democrats who voted to confirm John Roberts, on the basis that even if they didn’t agree with his ideology, they could at least grant that a President of the opposite ideology as themselves is going to make his court appointments accordingly, and that this guy was qualified. But this pick? Nosiree, Bob.

Say, I wonder if this might fall under the “extreme circumstances” exception in that “No filibustering judges” compromise of a few months back?

Share This Post

Tweak, tweak, tweak….

Well, never let it be said that Lynn Sislo doesn’t go whole-hog when she redesigns her blog, because she just finished a redesign and now the thing sports a whole new URL and a whole new name, which means that I have to go an re-alphabetize the Master Blogroll. I oughta reverse my colors and change my URL to reflect the new blog name, “The Beaches of Constantinople” or some such thing.

Oh well, it’s the same old good content and linkage we’ve all come to expect, but with some…orange. Quite a lot of orange. Reminds me of my college days, actually (our colors were orange and black, which made for some vision-induced headaches at the football games).

And now I’ll go re-do the Master Blogroll. Harumph.

(Oh, her new blog is called A Sweet, Familiar Dissonance, and her new URL is http://www.lynnspace.com/b2/.)

Share This Post

Chapters! We got yer chapters here!

We’re entering the home-stretch on The Promised King, Book One: The Welcomer, folks. I’ve just posted Chapter Nineteen, in which the Siege of Bedwyn ends and the Battle of Bedwyn begins, and in which another unexpected battle takes shape at the Giants’ Dance. The climax of Book One will play out in the two chapters that are slated to appear in November, with the closing Epilogue to arrive in December. And with that, Book One will draw to a close.

I’m sad to report that my original plan of sliding right into posting the chapters of Book Two come January 2006 will, in all likelihood, not work out as such, as I have not completed the rough draft of Book Two yet, much less started the polishing work. But I’m getting back into that, this week: first I’ll be re-reading the entire story up to my current point of stoppage (kind of a refresher course for myself), and then I plan to start writing again. It’s been too damned long.

Anyway, go have a look at Chapter Nineteen, and also catch up on the previous chapters that you may have missed — they’re all there, linked in all their glory in the sidebar.

(And as always, I am anchoring this post at the top of this page for the duration of Sunday. Scroll down for newer content.)

UPDATE: It’s a really nice “Indian Summer” kind of day, and there’s other stuff I want to do, so look for Sentential Links and the Image of the Week tomorrow evening. (Both of those features tend to be time-consuming by way of the amount of surfing the Interweb involved, and I’d rather read the paper and the like.)

Share This Post

Sunday Burst of Weirdness Coolness

I’m not sure what provoked him to do this, but filmmaker Kevin Smith has decided to respond to some of the weirdos of the AICN TalkBack section, here.

A few representative responses (naughty language alert, and it’s even worse if you click through and read the ones I’m not cherry-picking):

TalkBacker: I’m finally starting to believe that the 90’s are over.

Kevin Smith: They can’t be, sir. With your post, you’ve proven that the former-fandom-turned-cynicism which was the identifying hallmark of said decade still reigns supreme. As long as there are garage band fans (“Nirvana was good when I was the only one who liked them. Now they suck.”), the 90’s will never die.

TalkBacker: The fucker talks way, way too much, and talk is cheap.

Kevin Smith: Thank Christ. It’s why I get away with making movies, sir: because I make talky movies and talk, as you’ve said, is cheap. Cheap movies that earn mean I get to work another day.

TalkBacker: I love listening to Kevin Smith talk about movies and filmmakers until I see any of his movies and realize he’s a fanboy in writer/director clothing.

Kevin Smith: Finally! Somebody who gets me!

TalkBacker: Hey, Kev.: instead of lampooning yourself for doing bad work, why don’t you fucking learn how to make a film or at the very least hire an editor?

Kevin Smith: Because I’ve been doing what I’m doing for, like I wrote above, twelve years now, and shit seems to be working out for me. Even the folks who’re like “His movies are remotely funny” join up for at least the commentary tracks. Not saying there’s still not much, much more to learn, but if it’s not broke, why fix it?

TalkBacker: The most solid thing you ever did was the “Clerks” cartoon and that’s because you had less influence than on your movies.

Kevin Smith: Yes – so solid that it was my least successful endeavor of the last twelve years. I’m gonna fire my agent and hire you, bro. You’ve got your finger on the pulse.

It goes on like that. Of course, arguing with these weirdos is an exercise in futility — I mean, we’re talking about a form of Interweb life that, on the evolutionary scale, is just below your garden-variety blogger — but it’s still entertaining to read.

UPDATE: OK, I posted this link before I read through the entire thread. I’m still linking it, mind you, because it’s utterly hilarious, but I feel that I should put in a NOT SAFE FOR WORK warning. Because it isn’t. At all. Seriously. (About halfway through, a couple AICN mouthbreathers decide to take after Smith’s wife, which goes over about as well as you might think it would.)

Share This Post

Sunday Shuffle

I haven’t done one of these in a while, so here’s a randomizing of the MP3 library:

1. “Farewell and End Title” from Dances With Wolves. One of my favorite scores, and one of my favorite films.

2. “Children In Chains”, from Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom. I liked this movie at first, then I hated it, and then I liked it again. I dunno. I’m weird that way. The last score of John Williams’s “golden” period, when nearly everything he wrote was terrific.

3. “May Angels Fly Thee Home”, from Merlin. A very good fantasy score by Trevor Jones. (I liked the TV movie a great deal, too. If you see it, make sure to watch the complete DVD version, as opposed to the heavily-edited VHS version.)

4. “Domestic Experiences”, from Little Women. I’m coming to very much love Thomas Newman’s writing.

5. “An Architect’s Dream”, from The Towering Inferno. I’ve never seen the movie. It’s an early, pre-Star Wars score by John Williams. I only bought it because the FSM CD was close to selling out, and a year or two later when I really needed money, I pawned it on eBay. In truth, I’ve never listened to it all the way through. This particular track is pretty good, on first hearing. Lots of the familiar Williams pathos.

6. “Cheek to Cheek”, from Top Hat. Fred Astaire, singing to Ginger Rogers. What can I say about this? It’s one of the best performances ever of one of the best songs ever.

7. “Porco e Bella” from Porco Rosso. I haven’t listened to this score all the way through in detail yet, but as the score plays in the film, I like it a lot. Joe Hisaishi has a real feel for Hayao Miyazaki’s tendency to tell stories from any time and setting he wants. (Porco Rosso takes place in the post-World War I Mediterranean. It wouldn’t even be fantasy if the hero hadn’t been subject to a curse that gave him the features of a pig.)

8. “Enter Lord Vader”, from Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. Again, not much that I can say about this one. I just love John Williams. That is all.

9. “Remembering”, from Total Recall. As far as I am concerned, this score marked the end of Jerry Goldsmith’s most fruitful years. He continued to compose music for over a decade after Total Recall came out, but with few exceptions I find most of his output during the 1990s to be lackluster and, occasionally, even boring.

10. “The Matrix Revolutions”, from The Matrix Revolutions. I only made it through about a half hour of The Matrix Reloaded before I fell asleep, and I never bothered watching Revolutions. But Don Davis’s score is a keeper. Davis created one of the more distinct sound worlds for this series.

Well, that was fun. Or not.

Share This Post

A stupid observation

I like to fill out the gaps in my DVD collection with the cheap-o DVDs I find on sale at places like Target or The Store. Not the super-cheap DVDs — you know, the Westerns where the hero is played by “Jonn Wayne” — but the regular movies that are on DVDs that sell for around eight bucks a pop. Lots of times, these are movies that are available (or soon will be available) on double-disc special editions with lots of extras and whatnot; but since I’m generally not one to spend lots of time looking at DVD extras (I have yet to watch any of the documentaries accompanying the Lord of the Rings extended editions), I’m fine with picking up the cheap-o DVDs.

What’s funny is that a lot of these DVDs date from the late 1990s, when the format was just picking up steam. Yesterday I bought a DVD of As Good As It Gets, and I laughed when the back cover touted as a selling point “Interactive Menus!”. It’s sort of like how every so often the people who make Tic-Tacs will re-emphasize the Retsin stuff in the mints.

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓