I read this article with interest. It’s on the topic of DNFing books. What does that mean? It means Did Not Finish. For some people, DNFing a book is a simple matter, but for many there’s almost an honor code among readers that you have to finish a book when you start it.

Dear reader, you can.

I’ve tried to force myself at times to join Team Finish What You Started, but in honesty, I’ve always been on Team DNF. Many times I’ve found myself simply not enjoying a book that much, not “clicking” with it. I’m not the type of reader who needs the all-night page-turning experience, and I am not the type of reader who insists that the first page has to GRAB GRAB GRAB me. Of all the books I’ve read and loved over the years, I honestly can’t think of very many at all where I can say “Wow, this book had me hooked from the very first paragraph!”

I know there are readers like that, because I’ve encountered them, but giving a book the first page or just the first few pages is like buying a ticket to a movie and walking out during the opening credits. It makes no sense to me at all.

So when do I DNF a book? Generally, if I find myself reaching the halfway point and I’m just not enjoying it, that’s a sign. If I get that far and I open it up to read and I have to think a bit about what the plot is, or even backtrack a bit to remind myself what’s going on, that’s a bad sign. More often, though, I’ll DNF something if I get roughly a quarter or a third of the way in and the book just isn’t clicking with me. Life’s too short and there are too many books I want to read! Why spend the effort on something I’m not enjoying?

However! There are a couple of caveats to this:

First, I almost never indicate on Goodreads that I DNFed a book. I will only do this once in a great while (I think that at this point I have only listed four books as DNF over there.) This is why my reviews almost entirely skew positive: While I’m fine with not finishing a book, I am not fine with reviewing a book I did not finish. So, by definition, my Goodreads books are books I finished, and therefore I enjoyed just about all of them.

And second, I never hold a DNF against a book, really. All I’ll say is that at the time I tried reading it, a book just didn’t click with me, for whatever reason. Did you ever have a pizza for dinner that you weren’t really in the mood for, and you ended up having it because it was easy and it was there and hey, you gotta eat something? The pizza doesn’t suck, it’s just not doing it for you. Same thing with books, and there are a lot of books that are beloved to me that I DNFed the first time around. Hell, my very first attempt to read Guy Gavriel Kay, who has since become my favorite living author, ended in a DNF.

How do you all approach your reading? Are you DNFers, or are you Finish Or Die types?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to DNF

  1. Annehueser says:

    I'm on Team DNF too and have created a DNF shelf on Goodreads so the books I have DNF'd go there and I don't have to deal with them anymore. I don't post ratings or reviews for books I didn't finish. I do give books 2 stars on occasion but mostly my ratings are 3 stars or above because these are the books worth finishing.

  2. Michael May says:

    Great post. I love your analogies about movies and pizza.

    I'm also on Team DNF, but it took me a long time to get there.

    I use Goodreads mostly as a journal to remind myself what I thought about what I've read, so I record DNFs, but I usually give them a couple of stars as a concession to the possibility that the book improved after the point where I gave up. I reserve one-star reviews for books I actively hate (which is super rare). But I always try to record something (as politely as possible) about why the book wasn't working for me.

  3. Roger Owen Green says:

    Definitely on DNF. I look at my bookshelf and I can even tell you how far I got in each book. It's usually a matter of busyness rather than not liking the book. That said, most books I read within a week or not at all.

Comments are closed.