1 Comment

  1. Yeah. I just… yeah. At risk of sounding like those d-bags we've been defending the prequels against for nigh on 20 years, this sequel trilogy just isn't Star Wars, man. I can't get past my certainty that good ol' JJ did the same thing to this franchise that he did with Star Trek: utterly failed to understand what it was actually about, focusing instead on superficial surface things. I simply cannot accept that Luke Skywalker, the guy who walked into the lion's den to confront Vader and the Emperor, certain that he could do what everyone was telling him was impossible — bring back Anakin Skywalker from the Dark Side — that guy would not run away and hide for a decade or whatever, no matter what the motivation. It just feels wrong.

    And of course you hit the nail on the head with the idea that all our original trilogy heroes' struggles and victories evidently amounted to nothing, and that really irks me. Obviously something had to go wrong or we wouldn't have any conflict — they really couldn't live happily ever after — but to see them all living so unhappily… it's just a drag. And Star Wars isn't supposed to be a drag. I fear the grimdark has gotten to even our beloved galaxy far, far away.

    I have a friend who believes the trailer is deliberately misleading us, that Luke's final line in the trailer isn't what it seems. Perhaps. I hope so. But the movie has got to do a lot of heavy lifting to make the mess that JJ established into something… well something good.

    I'd really like to know what George had in mind for VII, VIII and IX.

Comments are closed.