Do they want “story”? Really?

You can’t go anywhere online these days, it seems, without reading something about the current woes facing the Disney company — their traditionally animated movies keep faltering, while the Pixar movies keep packing in the business. Michael Eisner’s management of the company is falling apart, obviously, and he’s got rebellions going all over the place. But there’s one meme I keep encountering in all of this, and it’s that Disney has forgotten story and Pixar hasn’t. Disney’s 2D animated films tell lackluster stories, which is why they’ve been box-office disappointments for some years now. (Two examples: Oliver Willis, and this AICN article with requisite teeth-gnashing in the Talkbacks.)

But I’m just not sure if the whole “story” excuse works. It sounds nice, and at first glance it seems to fit, because the Pixar movies really do tend to feature superb and witty writing. But there have been plenty of traditional, 2D-animated movies in recent years that told good stories, not just Disney’s, and they all tanked at the box office. The Iron Giant is the biggest example. Lilo and Stitch deserved a better fate, and so did The Emperor’s New Groove, which in my mind if the most unjustly-ignored movie of the last five years. I’ve heard good things about this year’s Sinbad movie (which I didn’t see). The only one that was a real hit was Tarzan. There have been clunkers, to be sure — I enjoyed Atlantis, but I’ve read a lot of bad reviews of it, and Treasure Planet was pretty lame — but I really don’t think the idea that Disney movies have abandoned good storytelling really holds up.

So what’s the difference? Why are the Pixar movies doing so well? I actually do suspect that the novelty of the computer animation has something to do with it, but I don’t know, really — and I don’t think that anyone does. When a movie with a great story succeeds, everyone says “See, the public still likes great stories!” But there are still movies with great stories that fail, and movies with bad stories that succeed. I don’t know what people want, and I don’t think anyone else does, either. Someone on the AICN talkback I link above says that “The success of anime proves that 2D animation isn’t dead!” Well, maybe — but how many people actually did see Spirited Away last year? How big is the anime community, really? It’s growing, certainly, but it’s nowhere near a mainstream thing yet.

I suspect that sometimes the public decides it’s in the mood for a great story, and at other times, they don’t care. And there’s no predicting when that’s going to happen, any more than I can predict when I’m going to get the hankering for a nice, juicy steak. (This probably ties into my growing suspicion these days that marketing is a completely bogus enterprise, but my thoughts on that aren’t even half-baked right now, so I’ll leave off.)

Share This Post

“Why can’t it be over?”

That is the plaintive cry heard emanating from Rush Limbaugh’s bathroom after just about every Eagles game these days.

I really don’t have a good feel for the upcoming NFC Championship Game. The Eagles looked flat for most of the game yesterday, and they won for two main reasons, a case of good news and bad news. The good news was Donovan McNabb; in the playoffs, you want the player who is the “heart and soul” of your team to step it up, and McNabb basically willed the Eagles back into that game. The bad news is that the Eagles defense looked suspect to me, and that had the Packers not undergone a mysterious bit of “Screw the fundamentals and forget the rulebook!” toward the end and in OT, the Eagles might well have lost.

As for the Colts, well, I didn’t see much of that game, but it played out pretty much as I expected: a high-scoring affair with the Chiefs’ defensive holes being exposed. But of those two teams, I think the Colts have a much better chance of going into Foxboro and achieving the crucial mission of beating the Stupid Patriots, and that’s why I rooted for them.

Go Colts, and Go Eagles (although if the Panthers win, I won’t be heartbroken — that’s a pretty good team over there).

Share This Post

Too friggin’ early….

In the Syracuse apartment complex where we lived last winter, when it snowed the snow-blower guys would be out in force at five in the morning, which was a bit of an impediment to sleeping, since our bedroom window overlooked the front walk. Well, now that we’re back in Buffalo, our window doesn’t overlook our front walk, but it does overlook the front walk of the next building over. However, the news isn’t all bad — the guys here do their blowing around six. Oh well.

(Even worse is that I can’t even make coffee yet, since I’m the only one up and I’m one of those anal coffee lovers who grinds the beans fresh each time out. I could have tea, I suppose, but I’ve never found tea to be much of a “waking” beverage.)

So, I like it when I get up really early, start noodling around Blogistan, and find funny stuff:

:: Some folks have decided to wage a stealth war on….a font. I can’t say I’d given it much thought, but I actually don’t like that font, come to think of it. I have something like 500 fonts on this machine, and I use about six of them. (via Angie McKaig)

:: Beavis lives. No, really. (via Dead Parrot Society)

Share This Post

Hmmmm, not done….am I supposed to turn the oven “on” to bake stuff?

Fans of George R.R. Martin’s Song of Ice and Fire fantasy series may wish to note that he has altered his “Where’s the next book?” bulletin on his website.

Basically, he still isn’t done with A Feast for Crows, but he’s somewhat less “not done” than he was before. Or something like that.

I’ve avoided Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series because I didn’t want to fall into the trap of waiting basically forever for a series to reach its end. (Well, Jordan’s crappy writing helps in that regard.) But now, Martin’s got me in that trap anyway. Yeesh.

Share This Post

More “West Wing” thoughts

I’ve been watching old first-season episodes of The West Wing recently: our local WB affiliate runs one each Saturday night at 10:00, and this week I discovered that my library has the complete first season on DVD. Having now watched most of the latter half of the first season again, many of these episodes for the first time since their first airing, I wonder once again: What, exactly, ever became of the Moira Kelly character (who was also supremely annoying)?

And in watching just a moment or two of the commentaries, I caught Aaron Sorkin saying something like, “I view the whole show as a novel, and each episode as a single chapter.” Which made me think, “Geez, Sorkin must be a pretty bad novelist then.” Plotlines are introduced and then disappear, entire characters disappear, et cetera.

And once again, I write an entire blog post with no point whatsoever. Go figure.

Share This Post

Give that boy some smelling salts.

Sean continues his delusional attachment to the New England Stupid Patriots. It’s really sad to see, really. He wasn’t this way in college….must be the sleep-deprivation from raising twins. I’m sure he’ll come around eventually.

And since I brought up football, I might as well join in the head-shaking over Rams coach Mike Martz, who has now managed to cost his team both a Super Bowl win and a berth in the NFC Championship Game in the space of three years by making dumb-assed decisions. Thirty seconds left, with one timeout at his disposal, and he makes no effort to go for the end zone and the win. Instead, he decides to play for overtime, which almost worked out, but ultimately didn’t.

I wonder if Rams fans wake up in the middle of the night, cold and sweaty, as they realize what might have been, had Dick Vermeil not been dumped in Martz’s favor.

Share This Post

Ahhhhhhh, that’s the stuff….

One of the nice things about not being a “political blogger” — I comment on politics when I feel like it, and that’s not terribly often — is that I don’t have any desire, inclination, or incentive to watch those crappy Sunday morning talk shows. Instead, I spend my Sunday mornings listening to classical music. Right now I’m playing “Fantasy on Osaka Folk Tunes” by Hiroshi Ohguri (1918-1982), and I suspect I’m having a much better time than the poor bloggers out there who, out of habit or necessity or because they just can’t help it, are watching George Will act thoughtful or Chris Matthews act interesting or Tim Russert acting like a journalist.

Share This Post

Additions! We got yet additions here! (and some stuff about space)

Check out A Voyage to Arcturus, a blog that seems to be largely about science and space policy, by Jay Manifold (whose name sounds, in my ears, exactly like the name of one of those “super-competent everyman” types you used to find as protagonists in Heinlein and Asimov stories — and I mean that as a compliment!).

He seems fairly sceptical about the recent/impending Big Space Policy Announcement by the Bush Administration, and I tend to agree: this strikes me as a big dollop of pork to the aerospace industry (big in Southern states), as well as a mildly transparent attempt to get the “vision thing” out there. The timing also interests me: they seem to have sat on this announcement until the initial results of the Spirit Rover mission were in (I wonder if this would have come out if the mission had failed), and there is political timing as well: the Iowa Caucuses are right around the corner, so this gives something of a positive to the President as the Democratic infighting rises to fever-pitch, and it also means that the announcement will probably be a bit of a distant memory when the fall campaign rolls around.

I want to see some specifics, but in a time when the country’s fiscal outlook is a giant disaster, in an election year, and coming from a President in whose scientific interest and acumen I have little faith, I’m really feeling that skepticism is the way to go.

Share This Post

Why Blogging is way cooler than posting to Newsgroups, part XXVII.

An old friend of mine from my Usenet days recently e-mailed this to me, and I found it quite funny. (It’s even funnier if you’re familiar with Gilbert and Sullivan, specifically The Pirates of Penzance.) I thought about changing it about to refer to bloggers as opposed to newsgroup people, but it still seems to me that blogging is much less given to endless flamewars than the newsgroups are, by virtue of the fact that blog posts inevitably sink farther on the main page and, ultimately, into the Archives. Plus, blog posts that are part of a larger debate — even a cantankerous one — still tend to exists side-by-side with other posts about other things, which is not really true of the newsgroups. Anyway, here it is:

“I am the very model of a Newsgroup Personality

I intersperse obscenity with tedious banality.

Addresses I have plenty of, both genuine and ghosted to,

On all the countless newsgroups that my drivel is cross-posted to.

Your bandwidth I will fritter with my whining and my snivelling,

And you’re the one who pays the bill downloading all my drivelling.

My enemies are numerous, and no one would be blaming you

For thinking me a dickhead after I’ve been rudely flaming you.

I hate to lose an argument (by now I should be used to it).

I wouldn’t know a valid point if I was introduced to it.

My learning is extensive but consists of mindless trivia,

Designed to fan my ego, which is larger than Bolivia.

The comments that I vomit forth, disguised as jest and drollery,

Are really just an exercise in unremitting trollery.

I say I’m frank and forthright, but that’s merely lies and vanity,

The gibberings of one who’s at the limit of his sanity.

If only I could get a life, as many people tell me to;

If only mum could find a circus freak-show she could sell me to;

If I go off to Zanzibar to paint the local scenery;

If I lose all my fingers in a mishap with machinery;

If I survive to forty, which is somewhat problematical;

If what I post was more mature, or slightly more grammatical;

If I could learn to spell a bit, and maybe even punctuate;

Would I still be the loathsome and objectionable prat you hate?

But while I have this tiresome urge to prance around and show my face,

It’s simply isn’t safe for normal people here in cyberspace.

To stick me in Old Sparky and turn on the electricity

Would be a fitting punishment for my egocentricity.

I always have the last word; so, with utmost finality,

That’s all from me, the model of a Newsgroup Personality!”

(I don’t know who the author is, because several searches turned this thing up in a number of very disparate newsgroups.)

Share This Post

ForgottenStars.net

The official site of Kelly Sedinger: Reader, writer, photographer, and dreamer

Skip to content ↓